Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/653/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/653/2007 AI generated

Breach of Contract for Failure to Meet Performance Metrics

Case Number ATAS/653/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involved a dispute concerning an agreement where one party claimed breach of contract due to the other's alleged failure to meet specified performance metrics related to service delivery, leading to financial damages. The court reasoned that the contractual language clearly defined the necessary performance standards, and the evidence demonstrated that the defendant did not meet these objective benchmarks, thus constituting a material breach, regardless of any purported mitigating circumstances or interpretations of intent, thereby affirming liability for the claimed damages.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract for Failure to Meet Performance Metrics: The court reasoned that the contractual language clearly defined the necessary performance standards, and the evidence demonstrated that the defendant did not meet these objective benchmarks, thus constituting a material breach, regardless of any purported mitigating circumstances or interpretations of intent, thereby affirming liability for the claimed damages.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual damages service contract breach of employment obligations contractual gap contract interpretation contracting party

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           !"#$!#%%& !'()!#%%&



*+ ,-+  * +   ,

./0 (  ' 1 #%%& 



   







  !"#$%"&'()*  &&+,

              

   (.-0(  

 ,

"%  ',+1 ' "/ ',+2 .##$    (             !  ( (  ! "#$%" 3&(14 5  &6  7&8,  && 1&& ' 1   3&(145&,,1&611,&''9+2.##$ +'.#:;;$7%/#%7&'&<',&'1&+.)',+2 .##$  +&  1=4 <  ',& : 1 ',+& 1  &,>+&%

.%  &,,  ', :' ' 1?  &&   +1 2&  ,, ',2&,'+'(&''.*',+2.##$%

@%  +1 '  &  ,, ,'&, '  ++ ' .#:;;$ 7% /#  ' ' @ A9&.##0%

/% '"#A9&.##0&&7+,&,,<&&1 1,&''9+2.##$,,,'&,+1@A9&.##0 &  ,+, ' &,> +& ' )/ 7% .;  11&& ' '&1&& ,B%

;%  & ' ") A9& .##0  &,,  &'&<, C  & 9& 77,  9+    .* ',+2 .##$ & '  ',& &+1&  &  +&1&':9&'',2&2&?&7%

$% &,1'..A9&.##0<&,>+&,&'+>+ ':&'7&9':77&&,2&B&+1D&&:9& 1 D  1&+ ' && ' 1  1,&'  '  @# A <& &9&  1,&' ' 1&+  8  ' ;E% & ',+&'C<&9&1&+'&&% && &'':,2&+'7&',&'1&+&'&<,(&  7&& 7&%  && ,& ,1, 1?, <: &9& C  & ' +1&  <: ,& ,'&,   +1  11&&':%/.%"'4B+:(9&&9&9' @" 2 ")/0 3 6%   :  9& D  1&+  @ A9& & @@ A 14  + '  1,&' 1 <  && ,&'%

0%  & ' .) A9& .##0  &,, : 11,  1&+ ' &,> +&%

*% ',&&'@"A9&.##0&A,11&&,1, 81&&'&'..A9&.##0%



-*./-.##0  (@-0(   )% &'.07,9&.##0&,,&& &2',':   ',&&   &+1&&+ C  &%  & ' +&9&'?81&':9&'',2&'2<&7 9+'&&&&B&&&<',=B'&9 &CA%

"#% ,1'.;9&.##0:&&+,A'%&'&< 1+&&<&'@"A9&.##0'&>&',,++ ',&&  11&& '4  <    7+, 11&&   ',&&':&,>+&1&'.)A9&.##0%1 1'+&71,,'++&9<,%

""% ,,B',CAB%





-*./-.##0  (/-0(  

 *,

"% 7+,+ C :% ;$  % " %  =%"   &2  ' &F&&<'&1,9CG%;$ '&7,',1&B,,''&'&'$2 .### 3 6 <&  &9 C  & 7,',  G(9&&  9&9'.#',+2")/$%

+1,1AB'':14&&,2&%

.% A,'',&7+1&1&923%;$  6%

@%  &&B&8  :14  1&+ ':&,> +&   && 1&&'111,&''9+2.##$%

/% :% @; % "   1& < 1' :,  +1?   ' 91,&'&<+'+1'&&%7&8&'+1 &'+1&2+&122% =<7&<  +&9& &2+':, +1?'&9 &7+  & ' +1& 3% .6% & (&   B& <  1&+77,C+11&+1?C9 &':+1+8'&&':1,&''1&+3% @6%'&97&',+1'&'@#A<&&9 +'1,&''1&+11&&':%@$%.@ 

;% :%/"2&%"%C' &95

H&91?'&,>+&5

%  1  ' 1? ' &&   && <:91'@#AC+1'+' 1,&''1&+'4+'1,&''1&+I

2%  1  ' 1? ' &&   && &,,,+,1,,&'4"A9& <&&7&':,&9&1<&& 'I

% +1?&&1&&C1?2 '',+1<:&91'@#AC+1' 7&'47&1&'+1&I

'%  +1?   && C 1?   2 ' ',+1:&:1,2&2'7+'



-*./-.##0  (;-0(   @#AC+1'+'1,&''',+1'4" A9&<&&1,&''',+1%H

 &,>  <&7&, ' +& +& & :B&  ,&, 'G&,> +1&   A&1'% (& &'4  77 <:&   1& ' G9B 7&& <  ',2& 2&  G<& '&9+ ' && ,= 3  "#)  * &'% / I   ")). 1% "0* &'%/2,7,6%4',2''&,>& ',1''+&71<&&G1,,1?,CG,=,% ++ 1  & '  ' ' &&  ++  ',1' & ' G8& 'G ',&& & '  ' C <  '&4  ,, '% G2&B& ' 1? ' &,> +&   && &,,  1 &&',1''&'73 ")).1%"0*&'%/26%

&',&+2+'&'&+=A77&&+7,&,',& 1B,A<:1=&A923.##/1B.;*&'%.6%

:% /. % "   1& <  &&  ,1, 1?, <: 19&C&'+1&%9':%.''&1&& 8'&,>+&:,49C;E1%7&&,>,1 A+&&+1,++@#A:%/.%@ %

 C  2 ,B 1  11& ' &,> +1&   B&'1&"A9&.##@1:%.$%" <, ' && ,=  +& C  11& ':&,> +&   , ,=  && ' && &'J+ 9,  +&  9+':&,>,+,&%%

$% ::&&+,7&11&&':%/"2&%"% 1 11&'&,>+&%:B&':+1'&&1 ': 1&+ ' (&   2 ': ',+1  7D ' 7&  7+4B+%

',&,B'@#A1,9C:%/"%"% 81&,@#',+2 .##$% 1' '  + K  A  +2,   +'&  K  " A9&.##0A7,&,',&,,1,.A9&.##0%

 ', <  1&+ &&B&8 : 19 C :&&+, <: ' ' @ A9& .##0  &2 ' ,  1 <  <  ',& ,B  ,, ',1,%  ,<    ,B+   1&+ ' &,>+&+>+&',&'1&+:,,',1,<':A  +>+ :& 1 1F &,<&2 ' +  && C ' &,> +1&';E<&,>+1'',1L1&<,1  ,2&+ 2&  B+ &7,& C  8 ++ A':=&%9&7&'9<&'+1&



-*./-.##0  ($-0(   '1?'&,>,+,&+>+8K'&& &,,1?,12'+1%

0% 9'<&1,4'A,%









-*./-.##0  (0-0(  

  ,  ,-+  * +   ,



 2 3/

"% ,92%

 3

.% A%

@% &<1,'B&%

/% 7+  1& '  <G 19 7+    1, > '  ',& ' @# A '4  &7&& 14 ' &2 7,', 3=M&N=7<&$$##/  619&'+&4''& 12&7+,+8%*.'&7,', &27,','"0 A& .##; 3 6I  +,+& '  '& &'&<  & +&7  +?'191&B''+'&I&'& > ',  &2 7,', 1 9& 1  1 9& ,&< 8 '&& ' :% /.  %  1, >   1&4  1& ' &9<,+++?'19'&9>A&C:9&%  B77&4  ,&'5         & O   !?  !   



1&7+'1,>&7&,81&&&<GCG77&7,', '&1B77





-*./-.##0