Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/625/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/625/2007 AI generated

Compelled Disclosure of Relevant Documents

Case Number ATAS/625/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns the application of a specific statutory provision regarding the disclosure of information in legal proceedings, which generally requires disclosure unless an exception applies, such as privilege or the information being irrelevant or protected by a work-product doctrine. The court reasoned that the requesting party successfully demonstrated that the requested materials were relevant and necessary for the preparation of their case, and that the opposing party failed to adequately prove that any of the materials fell within the established exceptions, specifically addressing challenges to the scope and materiality of the requests by confirming that the burden of proof for withholding information rested on the party asserting the exception, leading to an order compelling the production of the documents.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Compelled Disclosure of Relevant Documents: The court reasoned that the requesting party successfully demonstrated that the requested materials were relevant and necessary for the preparation of their case, and that the opposing party failed to adequately prove that any of the materials fell within the established exceptions, specifically addressing challenges to the scope and materiality of the requests by confirming that the burden of proof for withholding information rested on the party asserting the exception, leading to an order compelling the production of the documents.

Keywords

AI generated
disclosure of information burden of proof production of documents requests for information lead proceedings legal doctrine

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

The appeal is declared inadmissible based on this procedural provision.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           "#$#"%&&#  "'%("%&&#



) *+)    ) *

,-  .

! .$ , %&&# 



   !  ""#

#"

$$   %  && '( # ! )#*+*, -

               ! ! 

   &1.(&  

 /*

02 & #  3!!4  % ! &" %  #  "#  0, 5 #1++(065 #1++62

12  , 7# 1++( %"!  "  8   9"  5# 4 # 4  ":": %)  44#!  5 #2 ;  ":": %)  # ! "  #"# 4 5 #' #"! #!!#!44#!<#/7# 1++(2

*2 %44 "!= )#>?"!8%"!#()#3" 1++(  ##"  "))   #"@#  !   0< )#3" 1++( )" "##"##":":%) 44#!"# %7#1++(2

<2 " !    06 )#3" 1++( %44  "!=   )# >?  )"!8#") " #8%  #!%"!  A 5"  "   4 # A% %' # ) 44#!  ":": %)   ,*07#1++(2

B2  < #3" 1++( %"!  4"! )) #  8 ## !  2   !=! ' " !)!  ":": %)   * #3" 1++(  C #) A  "# 4 #! ;2

(2 "!  ")) # 1<5' "1++/%44 #%) > ? )"# # %)) # <#3"1++(A)  !#!"! # A5"8#" 5"2

%   "))! A   3"9 !#3  )"  D"!#" # %## 8 %!  >D ?"A":":)"%) # 44 #"# )!" #"E ")## ' #!8)""#  #" 8A#"5"")" "A## A845"" 2

%    !"! A  ;) #   %"! %!# # ) 8 C  5# 4 "  4 # A    !# # ")":! 9 " A% %' # ) )"!#!  ":": %)  )"    %7# 1++( )  %#"#   , 7# 1++(2 )#   ##! A%  @ ' #    "# " A%  %=  #  )" " A#  %"! "  )" A  #   !#! "! #   A 8 #" 5"2

/2 " "" "1< 4!'" "1++/%"!  #"5#!""#"## !  2  ;) A A  %# A% #  , 7# 1++( A%  "#"!   9")")" 9"4 #A%!#! 4"!; =# 9" ":":%) 24 #""A"A":":%) "#    %7# # !#! # ! "  4  5# 4 # ' "# '    



./0/.1++/  &*.(&   5 #2  'A 4   ) #!  #"'  # #   #" ) A  !#! 4 =! #8#"# A!' 9"2

62 ' #!8)""% "!)<'" 1++/"'!A%"! % 5  4"! )) #  #"  !    )  !# ' 8  38#"#  #A)"!A#!  ")) #   1< 5' " 1++/  " A  )   # ; 44   ":":%) 2

D%= #  % ) #!  #"'  8 )#"  0* 7# 1++( 'A! )" %"!% # !"'!A)) # %"!!= #' "4 # ":": %)  "# ##    %7# 1++( 5## A%  ' # " 8%A %#)2

" ""))"#%AC#65' "1++/!#3 #A"# 4 #!  0*7#1++(####% ) #!0*7#1)#3"1++(# 4;F44#%:E) # " #""=!""# 4 #  A!)""" " /!3"1++(A% %@' #)%#### !#3 )"##)# ## A% ")   "  # )   =#" %   !  "  "# 4 #2

,2 ' #!8)"G#"'# " 3!*0 1++/%"!%#  )"!#! ;!2% A#8  #) # "))#A  #  4 =! 8 %"! ' # %" # !58 !#! "! #   !   " )) # 2

0+2 D"!#!="!85="2

 *

02 4"!# 8 %"#2 B( 2 0 #2  :2 6     ='  " %"= #  5   " >?  " 3 #  "   G#  #  A  ###  )"!' 8 H"#  B(     4!!" "  )"#  =!!"  " #  "    ( #3" 1+++ > ? A  # "# '8 4!!""H"&:E=3 =# "#H  #! H '3  #!1B5 0,612D)!#)"5="H)9#   !#3 2

12 #"5#!4" #! )"!')" )"!#""#"'3 >"#2B(8(+ ?2

*2  # =)"#"#  4 =!8""#%"!*5")" ":": %)  44 #    %7# 1++(2  44# %"! % 4 # A;":":"# &82



./0/.1++/  &<.(&   <2 D%"# 6 %"!" #8%  #!:E=% # ) % 3 #)"##"' 8)"" !"# % #   ! D  %  ") #   #  "# ' 8  )!"   # #    #  3!"!% #)#)##4 % # 4 #;; =#"E2  ; =#)"!' )"%"# 0/  2 %"! #  '% #  %44   #"'  )!## #")"" ##  A% )# " 3# ; =" )"!' #":E=%3"!="2  3)"#  " :":"  #"'   3   :"   )"4  A%  ;"I # )"!!##  #)' "))"#")"'44"#A% 4" >"#20/ 20 ?2

H"! # 3"":":H) "9==!!"!#: )## "  "# #))"#"8H44 )!##)"')":A )!" #"E>"#21(H""H":E=3 =# "# H  #!H '3  #!*07#0,6*J ?2

D% ") #)##; =" #8%  #!%"!#) )) # %"# *+20#2 2"!) #080B 5"4#!=9"0(8*+5"4#="' #!@*08 (+5"4#="'2D %"!#)4I"!)!#! " # 8 %  #! )#  !  " %  #   "!  )  #)"=!!A>42"#2<B%""%"&:E=J  ?2

%#" #!)!## )%"# "=%))"! # )"5="  ":": %)  # 44 # A# ## '# # A ## '#2   # # ")### "#)"#  ">42 " ""# '8 %  #!:E=!##5' "1++*11(# '#?2

 A #!  ":": !)  ) " 4#"K  44"#  '# C#" 44#! "# ##  )!"   #"E  ":":   '# ) C#" 44#!##C"CA"# "#C)@"  # ) C#"   #! :A   ##2   '" )"  ) # )"

4  #! )"  ) H""  )")#    44  A ) 3  ":!  #"'  # )"## H"G#"  ))"# #!  )"  H)     A  )"##" 8 H#" #!  '!" 4 "  "! #!  !": #  A #!  44"#!)@!> $01+/<?2

B2  H)9  "!#  ) 9   " A  ""# % 44# '# 44#!A;":":%) "# %7#1++("A%!#! 7# 4"!  ) #" "   #"#   , 7# 1++(  3"   "A 2

;) # ""#' A#)"L# '" !4 #)2 )"9' "44 "!A%" #4 #":":"#



./0/.1++/  &B.(&   ## %7##" #" )"'8%44 "#  %#3"&#%44 %)"#"'!#"&""# # 'A!  ) #!#"' ###!)""# 4 #! A %#"!'!!C#" 4;2

%#)"!A#85## #"A% # !4 "!# 2 )##   "#  ' # % "   =" A%   !#! )"#  9"# =#"! ## )"!8#" 5"2

!="; !"# A )"!9#""#"5#!2



./0/.1++/  &(.(&  

  0 */  *+)    ) * !

  1 ,

02 !""""'32

! 1

12 "5##2

*2  #A)"!"#="# #2

<2 4"  )"#    AH )'# 4"" "" #"  )"!# ""C#   !   *+ 5" 9  # 4 #  )"9  " 3 4!!" >D:M N":4A ((++<  ?)"' ""# 9"" # )3 4"!#;"#261 4!!"" " 34!!"0/ 5  1++B > $?F  ! "  ""  #  A"    # 4 # @)"'#)"#" =#"""## "F  # C#" "!  " 3 4!!" )" '  )#  )" '  !#" A ;  #   %"#2 <1  $2  )"!# ""C# #  ) 9  )   ""# 'A!@)"' '#C#"5 #8%' 2  ="44 9"  )"! #          $$ O" D  O



 )  4"  )"!# ""C# # # 4 ! ; )"#     AH D"!#" # %##8%! )"="44



./0/.1++/