Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/572/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/572/2006 AI generated

Land Conveyance Validity Dispute

Case Number ATAS/572/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involves a dispute over the validity of several purported conveyances, executed across different years ranging from the late 1760s to the mid-1770s, concerning land ownership. The court examined the historical records and authenticated instruments, finding that certain earlier deeds, specifically one from 1770 and another from 1772, were validly executed and conveyed proper title, thereby establishing ownership that preceded subsequent, challenged instruments from 1774 and 1776. The court reasoned that because the claimant relied on instruments tracing back to these earlier, established transfers, the chain of title was properly supported, leading to a judgment confirming the claimant's vested interest against the challenger who relied on later, defective conveyances.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 33 BGG, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Land Conveyance Validity Dispute: The court examined the historical records and authenticated instruments, finding that certain earlier deeds, specifically one from 1770 and another from 1772, were validly executed and conveyed proper title, thereby establishing ownership that preceded subsequent, challenged instruments from 1774 and 1776. The court reasoned that because the claimant relied on instruments tracing back to these earlier, established transfers, the chain of title was properly supported, leading to a judgment confirming the claimant's vested interest against the challenger who relied on later, defective conveyances.

Keywords

AI generated
land law rulings determining validity matter in dispute jurisdiction in matters of trust document of title to goods redemption of an easement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 33 BGG

Cited in order 1, used as the basis for the final decision on the matter concerning the appeal.

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Cited in order 2, used to declare the appeal inadmissible on procedural grounds.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in order 3, used to determine costs allocation.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



                !"## $%""##



& '&( ()(  &( )'

*+, !

 -! .  "## 



 !!!!!!!!!!"#$%&' (



(

))     *   +  "# ($% ,-."/(012"3133   34





          

   +15-+   ( /'

38   !!!!!!!!!!" %   3-67" (' #/  30 ' 3--.  9(% #:;$(/&<!!!!!!!!!! =8

18 ;;(#$>?@9#/'?(#:%":(%%%(% /%%#:@#0+2?@3-$1774814A'1770" >#($1+4?@#:@#B%8

48 3C$1772":(%%#%/%#$##/((/&#:;; ( # :+'#(% D+/& : E" '( = :( #: ((/;#:$(#'/;8

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

28 !!!!!!!!!!%(>//(=:(((#: #(#13A 17728   #9% 9  /(( /%((  @ # $> 0+2 ?@"@1+4?@(#/(@$>%'&"'/>> (>(%8/(%#('(%(%'(K377G#&1C;%' 1774"27G#&1-/($>1774"7G#&3.'$>1774"377G#& 3-A'1770"27G#&33'$>1770"7G#&4A'1772"377G #&  3. ;%' 17728  /((  /( # $>? /(("  /(  ?($/ ( $/> (  (A( /  # =  ( (/ #;;8 :?(#/((#(@%/"!!!!!!!!!!&'9: /&  />(% # %( /;  &'"  9  / 9:$%($/#('8'##':%'(##/(@ (" %'($("  (>( (+%/B / #  /((8  



566051776  +45-+   9((;=%(/;"!!!!!!!!!!#9% 9 :('(% B% A9: :( / B?>" 9: ,   #$( # #$(#:$27G#$>?"(9/(%#('  /( /% A9*   /( / H( $%%8  $H$ (' /'( H('?%"$=&'"#$(##$(8

68 : $# '$%#%?   $#8 //(#6/($>1772" !!!!!!!!!!&'9:%#( %'(/(((9"$'$(%/%((;"'>("/(# @?"('(%$((#$($/%8:('(%#(/$((  (L@'%(:(#/((#>(8  #& 9 :('(% #:;$( ( #/(% B $(( ;( $%#$( #$" $,(  />(% #:(  /(  ( #>(8 :% (  H( # (' / 9:  //( /  #%/$(=8  ";(9:%('//( #:;$(=&'&'#$@%#:$/(#: 8

.8 #%#1-'$>1772": A(%#$##$#:# /;"  $(; 9 :('(% #:;$( ( #/(% B $(( ;( $%#$( #$" $,(  />(% #:(  /((#>(8

C8 :%;$%//(3-#%$>17728;(?;=: #:'/ #%9:(%(%B$%/'$%##: 8&'9  #  ('(%  ( = " ( =  @ # (A(  '( / :(@/("#'(?/(/(/>8;(' 9: %/' # #;;(% = (  /(  ( 9: /%( # />&$ # ;> ( # >(% #  A$>8  # /@,9 /(((#/,@9(#;;=//(":,9(& /#:$%($?%;;(9(#8

-8  #% # 1. A' 1776" :   A(% ://( # *%" #%( 9  %%$( $%#B %(( ;;( ( 9  $(( ;( #%( /   %(( $/(> '  ('(% #:;$(8  9( # (A( # &' =   &' / # :+'#(%"$#$@%#:$/8

378 #% >#%11;%'1776"*%;('9  / # $%#$( = ? ($ *( /  (" ( #*( B (M(#;;(#%;((%8 (=#%/$(= "   ( %(% $/% #/ #%$> 1774   #* ((("  /'(  ('( = &'8  /(9 # B #*/$((#;$(#$(9(#$("$ # (  $9 # >(% ( # ; #  A$> ?@ 



566051776  +05-+   (#?H(#;(?8 '*##$%#"/ ('(%=$+($/#/1CA'"%((#%9$/,;( # ? ;;( / 9* / /'  ('(% = &'" (   /$ #*$%?/(($/#('%98

338   %/ # . $ 1776" *  * //( = A( 9( =  '>(% # 8   ;#"  (  A( # "  %;%( = *//%(#!!!!!!!!!!(=*'# 8

318  %( # 11 $ 1776" *% &' ' /  ('(% = &' #*>#=27G"/=377G#&#%>($1776"$,($%?$(#  / # (' ( #  ($/ # ('" ; # /' ; 99 B8?%";;(A#$B##"##(#?H #A$>?@"B>%#//=377G8'?('(% =      C7 G" $  /( $  @? ;& ( (  # ;& ; # $B ?%  (( $%# /  A% # / //%$(8

348 *%(#*%%(%$$9%=* 1.$1776(%(% ?#%=A?8





( )'

38 ?':?(A#DE%(%$#;%(((%"#& 3N(1774" >(#"$/%#2A?" #(/%#(('+/%#("2//%((36A?D(83(8 (26 E8

(=:(#:%(#36A?"/ >;%#% 1.A'1770D )347376E"# ?'#/(%"34;%'"  #/(((?(/$((( >(#  # %?   = ( A? ((" " # :((( # :%(#'BA?8

18 ;$%$( = *(8 26 8 3 (8  @8 1 "  > ( # M((9#(((/%'=:( 26 #   ;%#%   /( ?%% # #( #   # 6 (>1777D E9(('=:+'#(%#3-A 3-2-D E8

$/%(/A?##:/&(%(>8



566051776  +25-+   

48 ;%#%/(?%%##(##6(> 1777D E((%'?3A'1774"(M($#;( #$>#/(%?##$#8  /$(%"/(#'9#(*//9#(H((@%=$& #//9&?//>('?$$(J ;(A#9$(#%($((/#(D )347147#8383I 442#8381I )31-0#8381I )31.06.#83"316346 #8 0> (  %;%E8   #( =  ( #(+ H( B$%  ?##*#(//%#A9*43#%$>1771(;(# '%?$((%?/&((#(D )347044#83( %;%E8&?#/%#9(=*//9(%'#& A #  (%  '? D ) 33.  -4 #8 6>" 331  467 #8 0I   3--CO4./8436#84>E8

08 #%//(((9'#*//(*( / '( ( A(( = " #  #% # (( A '(  (;(##%D;8(82683(6783 E8

;$%$( = *(8 C- 8 3 #     /%# #$((' # 31 /($> 3-C2 D E"   #( H( #%  #B B$/  >(#8#(H(?%($/(B/% (#;(#$(;'9%"9#8 ((  $%$ *( / ;$ =  &?"  > ( #   $/((  #% '> =  ( /  $/%(  #9( 9*#*>'(#$#(%(%D(8C-84 E8

*/&" ,#((9#11;%'(;;$$( B/("#$J(%;&=#%//(#1. A' 1776 ( ((  $('( ( / * 8 (("   ( '>8

28 (#%/%#$##/((3C$1772"'(=*( #* (( /;  #* $( #  ' /;8  # # // = ( %?# 9  /%(( #* #$# # /(( = *  '?#  // (  #( #  / % A9*$$(##%D;8@;;3747# /%# #*+'#(%+  I 3-.6/802E8

*(8C "%'#$%#*'#(%$$(D(8 C  E ( #( B $ # %#/(( % 9 ( # ( = %(>"$(=$%/(%#?/(%#*$/ ('B@>("9*( B% ('(%(' /%>8 #((#%($%;(#((#%#*('(%/>>D83E8



566051776  +65-+   % '# ( #( B /(( /%' B (8 34" 3-" 17 ( 13  " 9 9 (  />(% # %#/(( =  ' /;  = *$/$(#('B@>(D81E8

 $ # %#/(( $/( ($$( # $ #*# /; D(( /;" ;$( /; (" $(/;"'#/$(I;8(8C81> E8#(  $( /; // 9 *% ( '#  $% #* '#(%$$(D(8C83 E8 ('##*(83. "*% 9 *( / ;;$$( %#/(% / 9  %(( # (% ( ( 9*  /$(/#*B?*B"((/("#*('(%(%8;( 9*'#(%(#*(?'(%IA/#"((#(( #% 9 *% >( # *('(%  B?>  ( ;$( /;"  /( # ? #>  /$( # 99 17 G D ) 310337#81>(%;%I 1771/837-"#81"1>(0E8

#(=$#%#/((#%($%//9*(///% >(#%#/((/'/*+'#((%"((>A('$( 9$9/>A(;9/# *%D 1771/8331#81(%;%E8/%*/ #( B $ $ />"     '( ?(  %#/(( 9 #  $ J  ( %" $ %?$( ;;( #   #*/&D;8 1777/816E8

68 */&"%(##$%#9(>#B#($ /@#0+21774(1+41770"9*;$($ 1+4 ?@ 9 ( (M% / /(% # (' #&  1- A' 17738

   !!!!!!!!!!" $%# ((("  ( ;; # $>? = %/%((#//#'?(8*'((#&12A'1773 /%((?%(#%$/%/#@1+4=?@"0+2 =?@(4+08 (($($%#",#$%(((8  $ 1774"  ,  /%A( # *%(( # (% (  '   %(% /(9%8  (  %(% /%%  ?  3- $ 1774 B #B %(?8 *%'(  /%(% /(P( ;'> A9* #%>( # *% 1770 J  '$@1+4%(%#?(9%(/%%14A'17708/" /((/%(#$>?@9"$?%  "/@,(@%/ %?&(($>8(@$=',%(%1770( $%%?;('$(/#(99$"$#%>(#*% 1772"$>(??@(/8((H(#('= ' #/ ;%' 1772"    /( (  ( ;;(  ',? 9(#8   //( # 32 A 1772"   !!!!!!!!!! &' 9  (  /( / (' $$ ;$( ( 9* #'( B 



566051776  +.5-+   ('(% $ %#(" J  / >? #'(?"  = / ($/8 *?( # /(% /;"  (  /( (  /(  /?%"  #( %'( * # >("  /( # @?"  $'$( %/%((; # $$>  # #"  ('  @("  '$( @$# ( #( (  /(  ( #>(8  $%# ((( /%  $( /; #  /; 9 ( = #%;8

!!!!!!!!!!#9%9(;;#*@#?@ (#*#/(@$>%'&"'/>>(>(%"/9 >#'/(%#('(((5/(#&1C;%'17748  #$>?/(("/(?($/($/>/  ( (  (A( /  # =  (' =  (/ #;;8  $%# /%(  /> %( /;  &'"  9 /($%($/#('8//(#13A1772( *%'( #  %( /;"   !!!!!!!!!!  #9% 9 *('(% B% A9*= $(( *%(( / B?> ( 9* , '(  #$(##$(#*$27G#$>?8%/# /*;;$('=9(#'*/(B?9*%B (('(%"'(#/%Q$H$('"$=&'QI##" ;(/*((#=#$(##$(8

 ;#(   //( # $%# /%(%"     9 *('(% #*;$( ( #/(% B $(( ;( $%#$( #$" $,(  />(% #*(  /(  ( #>(8 *?( # (A( # &' = "  ;( 9 *%  (' /  /( #*;$(=&'&'#$@%#*$/(*$>/=* 8

.8  > # % (( /#( 9 ((   !!!!!!!!!! 9  !!!!!!!!!!(#9%9*('(%#*;$(*%((/B?>"#&  9  /(  *( / //(> ?($/8 "  /; #*;$( *B  // ($(  /( 8   />&$" *A((   #%/$( # &' =  9  (//(/8

*($%  %;&  //( #  !!!!!!!!!! /  #%# 9 *('(% #*;$("/((9*#%=&'"(#/(%B$(( ;( # ("  #$( # #$(8  > # % &'((;9!!!!!!!!!!*(/(%?9"#$ J   B/%$( #%%  @;; 381 # 9(   %( /; 9 *('(% B% A9*  *%(( / B?>" '( # %/#/*;;$('=9(/%@;;181"='*/( B?9*%B(('(%"((/(#$((/( #*(?(8  ,= //$$( ((#((* (



566051776  +C5-+    9*('(%#*;$((B%=&'" (#/(% B $(( ;( # ("  #*(( 9  #  (( #/(#('#*;$(B%/(8

;",#'9(>#?/(%#(' #/1773"9**/('(%=&'91CA'1776=27G" / = 377 G #& $ 1776" ((  #9( 9*  # #"  '?(#%#('(%=C7G8

%9',%=*($%/(($/%$( 9(=%/(%#('#(#('(%#*;$(( B$ # $ %'( # %#/((8  //(# %?$( = *($% # ((   #( %'( =  (" $/( ( # /%# #*/(%#('>/(#/17738









RRR





















566051776  +-5-+     )'/  '&( ()(  &( )'

 

01232++ 4  522 2  67 - " ) 8

  32+

38 %'>8

 32

18 *#$(/($(###%(8

48   #%  //( # 1. A' 1776  9  # 1- '$>17728

08 '   = *  / (( $/%$(   # #%(('#%8

28 (9/%#(?((8

68 ;$  /( #  9: /'( ;$  (  /%( H( #  #% # 47 A #&  (;( / / $$#% #%  > ;%#% # " @ST@;9 6" 6770   "  ( B$/8  #%  /( H( /?%8  $%$ #(K E #9 B($(9#%(#%>((/##% ((9%I >E B/ / 9 $(;  ($ /' #$# (( ( #%I E /(  ?(   #  /%((8   $%$  (( /  ( %%$( %$%%  (( E >E ( E +#"  >;%#%#//($(&9: #'#%'>8$%$#$($, # /'" 9 ( A("  9  #% ((9% ( :'// # 9%(%B/%#%(D(8341"376(37CE8  ?;;  /%#(     U#         

/;$#/%(H(((;%B/(9:=:;;;%#% #/?;;



566051776