Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/560/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/560/2004 AI generated

Application for New Trial Based on Allegedly Newly Discovered Evidence Denied Due to Lack of Diligence

Case Number ATAS/560/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute concerns an application for a new trial following a prior judgment, where the applicant argued that newly discovered evidence, specifically relating to the credibility of an adverse witness, was not available during the initial proceedings despite the exercise of due diligence. The court reasoned that the standard for granting a new trial based on newly discovered evidence requires a showing that the evidence is material, was not discoverable before trial through reasonable diligence, and would likely change the outcome of the case. Finding that the applicant failed to satisfy the diligence requirement, as the potential impeachment material regarding the witness's prior statements was ascertainable with reasonable inquiry at the time, the court denied the motion for a new trial.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Application for New Trial Based on Allegedly Newly Discovered Evidence Denied Due to Lack of Diligence: The court reasoned that the standard for granting a new trial based on newly discovered evidence requires a showing that the evidence is material, was not discoverable before trial through reasonable diligence, and would likely change the outcome of the case. Finding that the applicant failed to satisfy the diligence requirement, as the potential impeachment material regarding the witness's prior statements was ascertainable with reasonable inquiry at the time, the court denied the motion for a new trial.

Keywords

AI generated
newly discovered evidence lack of witness credibility related proceedings belatedly submitted evidence new application failure to prove deterioration

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the losing party to pay the procedural costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               %&&&%'(() %*+(%'(()

!!

, !-,   ,!  

+.  / 0 # 1' 2# '(() 



# 3333333333 





       ! ++,- " #$%&'()*



                ! "#$

   0&.10  

 4

%2  "-++  33++ " %1 *+ &''!  +  4*+ " ,3+ 5+03)  6  7+,-  "-++ " & 7-*+ &''! 3 8  -,+ 9 ::2 :;;;;;;;;;;  :;;;;;;;;;;  -3+ " ",,4 -8+* < ++ = +,3>- 3  - %/// 9 &''% 3,"72&?@1@2' 202

&2 %&,+&''!:2:;;;;;;;;;; +A" +5+03) =69B""-++2

C2 %'D+&''!+""-+7+<-9  3-3"0 +  +7,-  = 8B E+ 9  3-+ 9 B-4" " 2 +D++"-3  ",$,D+7+ 3"++2

 !

%2 6+4*+B4++D"+++56--,"+7+-++- ")  % F &''C  +A  "  + 52 % 2  62

$"C',&''!3" +A",+++75+03) 6 -"B77++-"B2%2+"-8 =*+-- --*++"B2%C%" ++4*+0  02

A6 G  "  8  +  + +  +A " - <,+7+*H

0 7+43""+3++7"B$2"+3++7"BD4, 3 8-+ B+- "  # D4-    ,+72 B+- "  # D4-  B-" 9 <0+ 8 "  , I  "+3++7 > *+ <3-,  I +  33 9  8+ ++4+ 5 G /1  &/ J K33 -+ " "+ ",+++7 !), -"++ %//% 32 &!( J LA#+" "+D"+++3+*-+%/(%32C%C262

0 B+-"#D4-*8+8B++83,>8 +A3*+<,+572K3332+232& %62+33MB3) "<8 "*+,$,3*+9B+"B+D- 3*++""+3++8$-" +"B 7+< ""B-+"D4  =N+++- "+++D+"++2

0  + +++  + $ "-- 2 = B 3+  33++ " 0+  A 572 0GE+ A

  .///.&''!  0C.10   "# " =#O+P *2  %//% 32 %@(  !C'62  *+  3 " * 8B +A  "+  )4 4-- "B4+ *  33++),8-8"B+A*+ -4+,D+"+85 G%%&C%C62 ,+7,++") 8+"-3+8"B$" *+9+B<+"B D+"++8+7+"3+%F&''C"-D9"D4++ ++8D433----4+),-2

6  =<,+"B77+,3-J*B$" "C',&''! +D8B9<++-4,9*-+7+7,+-9B2%C%   "+B++2

 =   D+"++ ",+++* 3-+    8B + " ",+3++"+2>+"338B2 @ "  + 7-"-   3+ 4-- " "+ "  + 0 0 -  *+4  % D*+ &''C #8  ++  +A "  8+   + +8    "  ",+ " +2 "+3++-47-"-A+4943 +<"+,$,++<D89 -3+9)*"+*,,++" 2 B ++3-3"9B<+43-3+7-"-8-4+4*+ -- =2

=B2%C%2%  Q+-A+"+A<3,3D4    +*+  3-J   )4  ,A B4++  D+"++   ,3-R2  "  -+ "   %/@%  "+3++ ++--,3--3+-&+A-,,+HQ+A ",+++7++-3""+",+++7" I+3-*+R2

 ++B+3),$,3++38+"++2 )4"B+3-+3,D4""-44"B"+3++ H  "+ 3 + 9  +3-+ +- #++8 --4+8>-,+8",2 D4"*3+3+++," <+"+2 "$"C',&''!+"--8< "B2%C%2&  ++3"33"B+A<    " "+ ",+++7J +  +3-- Q +AR ,, +4+7+ Q  +AR2  B2 %C% 2 &    3-+ 8  +A ",+++7  ++- Q"   I  +  3-*+R2 B "+ 8 -+,   " +< ",+++7 )* "B D+"++2 ++ B+3-+ +- 3, 9   "  8  , QR "+$8+7+-4,,+,"B++"-,+-2

  .///.&''!  0!.10     >  "  7+,- 3  +3-+ #++8  --4+82  - " *< 3-3+ 5:-,+ " " + S : 0%/@'32 !268-4+%/@'"+-<N-" D+"++ +*+  3- <+ 3-* 9 B2 %C% 2 %     +A ",+++7 +"-3" " 3*+ <-+72  +A -+ "+- 9 ,3+-S +"B ,,++"T8+ *+ 9 M "    "-++ " "-3,2  B-+ 3" 3 8+ 8  ,3, + 4-- + 3 8  +AB-+*"-",3-"B+A+2-+-*+"8+ ,,++3-+"*+A+,,+",3++ 3++) 5,3++ 3++ <3T62 =  :-,+ " " + 32 @ Q"  >), *+4-    + "B    ,,++3-++-",++--"-+"-+" D+"++ ",+++* "++  +"-3"  8  -3+,3-R2

)  % D*+ &'''    -- ,+  A--7+ "B  4-- " ,3-2   ++ "*  D+"++ ",+++* 3-+ " "+ ,, 52 1  62  *  ,++ " ,,++ "  3-+--<3-,-77+,-5: %//@32/!C'62+++-" D+"++B"3D,+--,++3 G+3 G 2   *+ 3 "  "++  8+ + ,3$#-  -4+ 88 -3""7+,3-,+)"B+D8 9"-*9,,++"9D+"++",+++*3-+  =B2

=+ B "*+ +* B+3-+ "  "  $ " C' , &''!  ,  = ,+ -4,    ,,++ "  3-+ > ,3+  #-   +0,$, + +++2 B,+7,3--A*+-3-4+2

 * "  8+ 3-)"  -+ " =  33++ "     7,9 ++4*+2

B-+ " D4  > 3 + -- - 3  +A 7-"-"$"&@D*+&''!" +4*+"3- %C 7-*+ &''!  "+3++ ++ 3,  = " +-4   9 + D4 ++  " B " B-+ " *< 2

&2 D-  ,3 + "*  D+"++ ,3-    *A 52 12%2#2%1' 62

  .///.&''!  0 .10   C2 <,"B2 C2C D8B9B*+"3-*+9B+-" B3+"-"-++33++8 --7,-2

!2 B3)  7+4"7-E%'D+&''!9 3-+9B-4""2

2 -8B3"BAD>-"N2

  .///.&''!  01.10  

!  4  !-,   ,!  

#

567   8  9   :$ 1+' ";

  7 

%2 -*A2

# 7

%2 "-AD2

&2 >"N2

C2 7,  3+ "  8B 3* 7,    3- $ "  "-+ " C' D ")  +7++ 3 3+ ,,"- "-  +A 7-"- "  =#O+P#78+ 1 1''!     + <,3+2  "-+  3 $ 34-2  ,-,+ "+H 6 +"+8 <,8"-++"-+A++3""-++ 8-J A6 <3 3 8 ,+7 + +, 3*+ ","   "-++J 6 3  +4   "  3-2 =+  ,-,+  + 3  + --, -,--   6 A6  6 +0"  +A7-"-"33,+)8B+ "*"-+*A2,-,+",+,> " 3* 8+  D+ ++ 8  "-++ 8-  B*33 " 8--<3-"+-52%C&%'1%'(62  477+)H  3-+"H   >= -+:    3+7,"3-$+7+-<3+++8B9B77+7-"- "+3477



  .///.&''!