Boundary Dispute: Statute Interpretation and Survey Evidence Admissibility
Legislator summary
AI generatedA petitioner challenged a lower court's application of a statute concerning the establishment of a new boundary line, arguing that the lower court erred by relying on survey evidence from before the boundary modification statute was enacted, rather than evidence post-dating the change. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the statute in question did not explicitly require the use of post-enactment surveys, and the lower court's reliance on the earlier survey was permissible as the historical record supported the boundary as described by the statute's language, thus upholding the finding that the existing boundary was correctly established.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Boundary Dispute: Statute Interpretation and Survey Evidence Admissibility: The court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the statute in question did not explicitly require the use of post-enactment surveys, and the lower court's reliance on the earlier survey was permissible as the historical record supported the boundary as described by the statute's language, thus upholding the finding that the existing boundary was correctly established.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedRelated Decisions
AI generatedKey legal questions extracted by Legislator
AI generatedCited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs for the respondent (the federal entity).
Full text
!"#$!%&&" !''$!%&&"
( )*( + ( +)
, - .
# / %&&"
! ""! #$% $ $ !&
$
'' ( )) * + %%4" ,$-.!$/012022 23
*05.*
0)
29 1 :% 0880 #$% !& + " $$; 2--7 +"!$" ! & + (% $ + ( *%<%+%" = > +4++! %$!$ "?@"+4$%+<%@ "<$<%A ! % B @ + " + $@$!"+% %<% ! $ %9 ! "%" C + % $ %++%%"+(!! %@+@@9
09 !!$ +" + 08 "< % 0880 #+4 $@$!"+% %+%C" <$% ! $"+" A +4+ + ! A ;% $@$!"+%C < @@+%%%4 $4! "B%;+ 9 $ + D!%%$ C ,D%C + % +"%% ! $ " " < + $4; $4%%$ $ ;%%$ + !B$&4E $4! "B%$ + $%@$+C%$%4!;$$%$!%$<$% +(C%%%$9 #+4 %4" C( %<% $@$!"+%C 4;% "% <( " +% A("$%9 $A @ < +%%" +("$%$ = + + (C%%%$ + @@ +,%*+,!B%> ! "$%"+D"B;+$4+% + +D9
39 +"%%$+08:%0880( !"+! + B @+D" +$@$!"+%! 4%+08"< % 088008"< % 088/9
/9 02:<% 088/ #+4$%+%C"A ( C ( ("% ;% %"@ " A ("$ 4@ " CC +%%" +(+!%$+";+("$% C$@@"%$4! "B%; !B ;% "$$FD% & %B4%C(%<%+ & A $ +% !B$&4 $$ C% !$ % @+ + +%%" $ + (!! %@ + C ( %%$ + % !B$&4 % $ +%%% C(% "% +$ $B%; + !$ %< "+$@$!"+%4G4 ,B4C:C($ 9
19 +"%%$+0/4 088/( !"+$% A! + B @ %4 $@$!"+%C + ( A %$ + +D " B;+$4+% + 02"< % 088/07"< % 08869
69 *4!26"< % 088/!& +($ +"!$"+4+ +! %$<%A! %B @+"+( @$B" !%9
.9 !"+% + !!$ ++07"< % 08819 +%@$%C" +!,B$4$ ++(C%%%$+@@ !! $ C ( "% ?@" + +D %% C + $; %<$* 4$ +(%"@ %$+B"4$ !$ $"-< %809 $A %% 4%"$@"%+B% 03303/+($ +$!!%; 4%& 9
567/50886 *35.*
79 +"%%$ + . 4 0881 ( :" +4+ + 26 "< % 088/ < (;+(%% 4%"$@"% $! ( *%<%+%"9
-9 1 < % 0881 !& + ( $ 4" $!!$%%$9 D!%C" C $ % $ %++%%"+4$ %%"%@$;! $<$CB+%!+ !! %@ $% C$%+% C + ! +%%" <% + "! %$ %$ < C " +( @$B" !%+";"! <%<%+":A! 4%+! $@ &$; +4+"C( $%+& !$%%$9
289 $ % +23:% 0881!& +%$ ! $+%+D !!$ ";% ! #+4 ) @$B" ! A (%%$ + !"+% + (9
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
209 $+ !!$ ";%00< %0881D!%CC! %B @""D" $ 4+4$ %%"@$; (4"%$ %$+4$ %%"% +! D%% (4"%$ %$+$%$%!$ 4%D@" %$ ("B9 ! $@ & $ "" $; <" %< + 4$ %%" @$; ( ! " 4% $$ +%%$9 "" <" C ! + 4$ %%" % + ! D%%4$ % $ + +%%" + %<%" @ !B$4$ % %% C + %<%" +(BH4 +(%%!%$9 % !+$4!$ 4%""%+%C"C!" %$+ +%%%( %<+( 4$4!49#+4) $A"%"+$% "+( @$B" !%9
239 $ % + 02 :% 0881 ( +4+" A % ( "% % +( %% 4%" + B% 3-8 + ($ +$ !!%;4%& 9% 4 C CB% 03303/%+%C"!
567/50886 */5.* 4"+% + $ !!$ $ !$+% ! A + %% 4%" $@"% 4%A+$+$ @ <+%%"+("$%$9
2/9 + 28 $<4; 0881 "!$+ C ! $;"4%C + ( "% $4!D C(% % "% +%%% + I $< D4 B% C% , $ !$+I9 D!%C" C( +"! ( $ % $ + +%%" ! $4$ % + I$$ +%%$ <%$4$ % <%$!I C ( @$B" !% <% ! 4% +(4"%$ %%$ C ( ! "% +"$ 4% !J I $; <B%++"<$!!4I9<%$ +"<$!!"$ +(""0881 + I%I %C%"9 !$" +%@$% %< K $; !"%%C + +"<$!!44$ ='70$%%%$+(#)> $;<B% ++"<$!!4='7/>%='-1*8>9 :$"C(%("%! %C (!%!$ %< $ %"+ !;%9
219 + <%4"+% "@%$ =)#>AC%+$% "" $4%"4%($!%%$+<%+"+23:<% 0886C+%%" ! "" ! ( $ !$+% A %% 4%" $@"% "! $ %" C 4G4 % ($ +4% (D% + $; <B% + +"<$!!4 D*% !! ! & (?@ + %C !$<% %@+$4!9
269 +"%%$ $!!$%%$+0/:<% 0886( $% 4"+"%%$+ +.4 08819% 4 C C;%C(! "% $4!D $$@%C < + $; + " + B"4 $ !$ % + ,! +,%*+,!B% $ " $ !$+ A %% 4%" $@"% $! ( *%<%+%"9 D $;<B%+ +"<$!!4 "<$C" ! ( +4% C(% !$ % $ !$+ A (%% 4%" $@"% "! $ %" $ B% /829 !+$%@"C!$ C( *%<%+%" $%%% 4%" $@"%*%+$%<$% ""+%@$%C"<(?@+%CC%( !""($ 9
2.9 $ % +0/"< % 0886!& +(% :" $ $ +"%%$9%<$% C+%%"$4!$ 4 $ "! $% +"$+! $;&4!B,%C$@"%DC"+( @$B" !% $! 4%+! $@ & <%%;9 $%4!%%4A! % B @! ( *%<%+%"+"+( @$B" !%%<%! $%9
279 <%"A! $$ ( + "!$+024 0886$ : + $ !$ 4$%+":A%<$C"++"%%$9
+)
567/50886 *15.*
29 $%@<$% L$ @%%$:+%%% =>""4$+%%"%%"+& 2 $M0883 %;$+ $%$4!$"+1:@ +$ ! "%+ <%*! "%+ 1 !!" 26 :@ = 9 2 9 16 >9
)%AL%$+L"%$+26:@ ! %;"+" 0.:<% 088/= '238286> + $%@<$%+$!"23"< % +%!$%%$ %$% @! 4 %;$+ $% + %"@ A $% :@ %% + L + L"%$+$<D:@ 9
09 $$ 4"4 A ( 9 16 9 2 9 B9 0 %; $ + $%$H%%C+$%$! "<AL 916 + $%"+" ! %@"" + $%+6$$; 0888 = >C%$ %<A$% L *%<%+%"+2-:%2-1-= >9 )$4!"!$ :@ ++L!&+$";%9
39 " <%@ 2 :<% 0883 H 4$+%%%$ + $4; +%!$%%$"@++$4%+ $%9!$% + < 4!$ $ ! %%! !!%; &@ + + $% <%@ 4$4 $N % : %+%C4 +" 4% $ ! $+% :@ + $%$+! %%!!$ !! "% ("+% "%"A++" 4%++"%%$ $!!$%%$%%@%= '20-2 $%+92E '20./6.$%+92 "" >9 L%%C$ CL$ D4%+ $%"<A+4 4"+%!$ !" %$+!$" % A L "<%@ + %,%+L!!%C $<+ $%9
/9 :" 4! % + $ 4 ! % ! $% ! +< %;$4!" $ <;= 9161-68 >9
19 %%@ !$ + $% + L " A ! % B @ % + 4 4"+%+ "+!%$+L *%<%+%"+"+( @$B" !%9
69 $$ 4"4AL 9792 "%<%+$4"+L%<%+%" %44%$+ $%D4 + "+!%$C%$"% + A ";% !%" + @% A L4"%$ A <@ + $ A <$ % L@+ $%"+" 4%"$%$+$+ "+L%<%"! $;;9 $4; + 4 + "+!%$ <%@; %@ $44 4 4"+% 4 +L$ + ! $%$ 4% + 4$, D%%% 9
D 4+( 923 "$+ $%D4 4"+%"% %4+%% 4%"$@"%= 9390 >:C(A(?@+<%@ "<$9
567/50886 *65.* $%"+" (<$ $, $4!"+(";% %+%% 4%" !$ C4 $$ +"C(%%"+%($ +$ %% 4%"$@"%= >9
4 4"+%$ +"+$%<+ ! %%!A$%@ (%% 4%" $@"%*4G49: %! ++ %;"+" + +4 $$% C + $% A + 4 4"+% ("+ D!%$4 "@4 %4 +(% $+% A " C% $ ! %"D,4!J4+(%% 4%"$@"%4%C%$(D!" %4"+% $ $< $"C + %% 4%"9 (%% 4%" $@"% (%$+% A"%%%C(%D%%+%"+"C C%%"9 (C%%+%"C%%" (%$+% A " (%% 4%" $@"% +$" % %4 "<& $ "% C( *%<%+%"+$%! + B @4 4"+% ++ +( 923 = ' +20$90882311582$%+92E )0882!9.1$%+93E '288/2<9 "" >9
.9 (!& % $ + +$4 4"+%D C ( $ +( + !,B$4$ +( ++(C%%%$+@@!! $ C(%"%?@" + +D %% C + $; %<$*4$ +(%"@ %$ + B"4 $ !$ $" - < % 08809 @ < +%%" +("$%$ $ ! 4% +($ + +4 $$ 4+$@$!"+%4%$ !$+ A %% 4%"$@"%+( 9
D +%@$% !$" ! !"+% + $ + % !!$ A <$% K $; !"%%C + +"<$!!4 4$ =' 70 $ %%%$ + (#)> $;<B%++"<$!!4='7/>%='-1*8>%+ $; <B% + +"<$!!4 !$ % "<4 G %4%" D I!,B$ ! %4% + : I "! $ %" B% /82 + ( 9 !+ $; ( ! % B @ C $ C ,4!J4 $ "" 4%<($4!%4+%C%&4"9 ($ ( C( 0881 $% ;% ! & C ( % (?@ + %C C +%%"+$4!$ 4$!! 9 $ $4+ !!$ + 4%"@4+%+$@$!"+%+"+00 < % 0881 C% % " + I!" %$+ +%%%I %< $4!$ 4 DC%(<%! ""% %$+ !!$ ! ""+";%% ;%"088/9
A ( @4 + !& + ( $ C +%%" $4!$ 4 $ $"C + $; $@"%D ""4 4"+% ! 4 + (", !%C %% C <% +(G <" %% 4%"$@"%(!G 4%"<%+! !"+% +(9
79 "@ +D$%+" %$C%! "&+ $ !+$C(G :"9
567/50886 *.5.*
+)0 )*( + ( +)
123 4 5 6 578 9"% +:
5 3
29 " $ <;9
3
09 :9
39 %C! $"+ @ %9
/9 $ 4 ! % + CL !< $ 4 $ $ ! " G + +"% + 38 :$ +& $%%%$ ! !% $44+" + " %; "+" + )BO%P B$C% 6 688/ $% D4!% 9 +"% ! G ! $$@"9 4"4$% +$%K > %+%C D4C+"%%$ $ +"% $;% %!++"%%$ C"E ;> D!$ !$ C 4$% % %4 !$<$% +4+ +"%%$E > !$ %@ $ + $ ! "9 )% 4"4$% $% ! $% ""4 "4" " $ > ;> > %*+ %;"+" + !$ ! 4%& $ CL% +< +" % <;94"4$% + $ 4%$ $ 4$, + ! < C% $ :$% %% C +"%%$ C" L<$!! + C""D!"+%" $ = 9230286287>9 @ %& ! "%+ %'' Q %) Q
$!%$$ 4+! " G$%%"D! %%%CLAL%"+" + $%! @
567/50886