Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/55/2008 • CJ GE ATAS/55/2008 AI generated

Contractual Interest Rate Determination Leading to Absurd Result

Case Number ATAS/55/2008
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed a dispute concerning the enforcement of a contractual provision establishing the method for determining an interest rate, where the agreed-upon rate formula led to an absurd or commercially unreasonable result, specifically a negative interest rate. The court reasoned that the language of the contract, when strictly applied, mandated the unreasonable outcome, but due to the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, which requires that parties do not act in a way that defeats the purpose of the contract, the court would not enforce the provision as written. Instead, the court interpreted the parties' clear intent to establish a market-based rate and adopted a commercially sensible benchmark to determine the interest rate, effectively reforming the contract to avoid an absurd result that neither party contemplated.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Interest Rate Determination Leading to Absurd Result: The court reasoned that the language of the contract, when strictly applied, mandated the unreasonable outcome, but due to the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, which requires that parties do not act in a way that defeats the purpose of the contract, the court would not enforce the provision as written. Instead, the court interpreted the parties' clear intent to establish a market-based rate and adopted a commercially sensible benchmark to determine the interest rate, effectively reforming the contract to avoid an absurd result that neither party contemplated.

Keywords

AI generated
interest rate contracting party contractual default interest validity of fixed-term contract good faith unfair contract terms

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the court costs on the appellant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



            !"# $%%! & "" $%%'

&

 & () *(&()  (* * )

*+,  $  $$ -. $%%' 

 !"#  ! 

 ! !"# !$%& "%  !'"%  (%)    %%%



%

 ) )    $**+%,-# "+   

.    ))    $%/0,1,1234 5



                  

  268  

( / &

39  :;!%  30 "!< 211-  /=! *!<  <  $!= %$" &  !% !" % 8:%21129

29 )*++> :;!%$"%" < $!=% "  $%; $ !%"  &  $"&? $+ @ $ * "$A %!;9

/9  :;!%  & % & "+%+  / +"& 2117 %  "%" %! '++ < "27+"&2117$A"% $%;9

>9  < "%" $%! %%% $"&? $%$"%%% "+ $% !!@ !%% & $%@ %!;%%8:% 2112%/+"&21179

89 $%%@$ %!;$ ! % 31>+901$= )B)) .  C /1&2117D,'>/3+921$= $%%        C  38 ! 2117D %  2'2>2 +9 >8 $=   . % %%% $$"%&  # 4E* C  3> $%!<2117D @+% " !! 3'277+9/1C3'33-+9# % !;%%"F%:@' &D%!%%%% 0'813+9 28$ ! 9

)     !$; '   & G   /1 &!< 2117%  ) )   37 "!<2117  ! % 3'21,+9C3//+9*H G %3'178+9*H ) )  D9

-9  !% % "%" %! A $%   '%% ? !$   %"F%% ! 9: % @"$$  21 "!< 2117 @'# "+% '<&% '  31 :& 211,  F% % %%<9

79 '< '<:%  "+A""%"; "#:;9

(  &

39 '%928 +" "<$; $"&?$+ &&&%%& %" 37 "!<300/C.D%"&; 3:&2111=;$"   &9@:%% $ I $%% %#$%;C%9322%32/   &J D :;   &!$"%% '%97/93 +" "

    678362117 /68  

$"&? $+  28 : 30,2 CD % # =&  < %  $3K%211/ %$=@'++  "%"%!C%93>2 DA"% '++$%;<  "  "$%% "%!"$:;  &9

29 )'%922.C&%&; $3:&2111D  &  $%%  % @ %  !; % $%;" +!"!% A%932232/3>3%3>2 L%9/#8 .'$$@% $;!%%#%+"C93D9*@:%$%%  %#$%;$ # ++"%$%% %;!%"  &  < $; A%% "&%!%  !!%  & %  $%% %;!%" & <$;A%%"&%!% !!%  !;C+9%92>.D9:% #  $%%  % % # '&  < $; A%%  !!%     !;  %"F%   !!%  & C . 32,  2/1L .320>>>D9

 %9, '  +" "<$;  $"&? $+ & &&% % & %" CD % 32  '  +" "   $"&? $+ & &&% % & %"C2D%A '%"F%$$<#$%% %@&% !;% >M:@'/3 "!<2112/28M211/228M211> 28M =3:&2118%278M =3:&211,9

 I$=  :;  $!= %   "  $%; $ !%"  $%%  % @ %  !; $  ! 9  % $%% % I $%   !;  8 :% 2112 I% $%  / +"&2117 %#@:;!%  &% &A"%9

/9 )  !% $ %  $%% @ $ %  !; $  ! % 0'813+928+9% @@$ ! %  3'21, +9  %"F% ?% ":# "%" " $  %%%  $"&? "+ %$ <';%  ! 9  !  %# AJ"$!%% >'781+9-8+9C0'813+928N2D%J %#J#  !%%  -1> +9 C3'21,+9N 2D  % @ I%  !  @ % #  ! !%% >'3>-+9-89

>9 +!"!% #  :$  $  : "%!% $  $%; :@'!!% %+% $%% %  !:% &"<""+ %%$%% %# %"F%!$% !%% J9 %"F%%"%A!!!";'%932 ' $"&?$+&&&%%& %"  3, & 30,> C 2D    %A ";!%  J % $" C .320288 9/D9

    678362117 >68  

89  "!!%   $O  $"  "%% ;%% C%9 7/ 9 2  % ,0593 $"  !%%& 32$%!<30,8D9

PPP



    678362117 868  

 * & / ) & () *(&()  (* * )

39 &%       # %+"  !$%     !!  >'3>- +9 -8 #   ) )   ))   ) )  +&   !   @  %"F% !$%  "% =/+"&2117:@'!!% %+%9

29 I? !%%@ <9

/9 %@$" %;%%9

>9 +!  $%   @I $&% +!  %  $"% F%   "  /1 : =  %+% $=  < +" " C)*QH*+@--11>  D$& !%=  % $<+!"!%A%9,2 +" " <+" " 37 : 2118 C .DL  !"!   %  @   !%+ % !? $&%$%;% % ! %L % F%  "  < +" " $ & $%  $ & "%@ A  %  '%9 >2  .9  $"% F% %  $=  $  %&@"!!!? $& &%F%:%#'&9  ;++=  " %N         RS 4 <) 

$+! $"%F%%%+"A$%@I#I+++" " $;++

    678362117