Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/539/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/539/2005 AI generated

Installment Sale Treatment for Contingent Property Transaction

Case Number ATAS/539/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed whether a particular transaction, involving an agreement to sell property with a complex payment structure over time, constituted a sale under tax law provisions concerning installment obligations, despite the contract being contingent on future conditions relating to development and financing. The court reasoned that the arrangement satisfied the definition of an installment sale because there was a clear agreement for the transfer of property in exchange for a promise to pay in the future, evidenced by a promissory note and security agreements, even though the total price and exact payment schedule were subject to future contingencies, thus subjecting the transaction to installment treatment rules.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Installment Sale Treatment for Contingent Property Transaction: The court reasoned that the arrangement satisfied the definition of an installment sale because there was a clear agreement for the transfer of property in exchange for a promise to pay in the future, evidenced by a promissory note and security agreements, even though the total price and exact payment schedule were subject to future contingencies, thus subjecting the transaction to installment treatment rules.

Keywords

AI generated
contract of sale installment payments property transfer tax tax provisions transactions in securities law of obligations

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs to the appellant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               '()*'*++,  ',-.'*++,

##

 # "   "  #  "

/  - % 0) $% *++, 



  !"!#$#"!%$!& & '!! !

('!& !"!#$#"!%$! ) '

($!

&&   && "($*+,, -../   #0!

&&   &&  & -../  

       

       !"# $%&

  ,  



 1



/3 ! 45$  ,* 46'! ,..+   !'7  "!'8! '$   #"7'9$$(86'("!'6(!!'5($!$# ,/ 4'$ ,... "!    #   $ ('! &3

,3 :'00!*'"('$'045$"!#'$#  !'7"!'8!'$ (!(#  "!$5 "! ('$'# $!  #"(;  ! 6('!  "!#6(< "!(0'(#!$!'53 45$'6(!$$!# 0(!/,!,..+3

-3 !''9#=$!$'$'!>("$'7!"5(6!$"!8  &&   &&?'@"!8A B3

C3 $D! (#=$!$'$'!>0("!#6(< "!8 &&   &&  & 3 "!('$#("$ $#  /E 6!' ,..+  ($ ' !(!$ 9  "!$$'(  (!$' D "!$5!  -/!,..+>#86D*FE-G0!3

+3 &((!!'! ,26!',..+ "!$$'('7! "5 9'"!!>#869$D '$#!=$("!' D//F.,+0!3*+3 #$#"!#'#9"!$$'('7!"5($!'5H'$#!=$ ("!'H#$'$,F--20!32.3

23 ($($#$#$!';"!$'$,.',..+3 ($#$# '0(!#9>D#0$>(7!6$'(!"!$ !'$5!#D45!3

 #



/3 F!$3 ,+   (' 0##! !  '7! "5   "!#6(< "!(0'( 6'' !6'6$$'6''$#/*#7!/GG-?IB  $!#6'5!/!46'!,... !85"!(#!'6(!3(!9 (4('$($">(!!"!$$'((!$'D"!$5!?!$3/,,$ /,- ( '6' @ B   45  '  '6(! ("#$$    F!$3 *- 3/('0##!!"!#6(<"!(0'(,+4'/GE,?B 

    1*2,1,..+ -  



('$D86 !'7$(!('"'/!(J$,..-  ('$  "!8 9 F00'! '  #$# $!' ?!$3 /C, B  ;#$! F(00'  "!$5!7#!#"!$'$'(#$!'#"!45'6(!.

,3 &(F!$3,, I?(6$!6'5!"'/!46'!,...B  '6(! "!$$'((!$'9'!$!'5($"!$5# (0(!#$;!$3/,, /,- /C/$/C, K!$3-D+IF""'9$ "!(5'($$D$!0#!!?3/B3(!:9(4('$ "!$$'( (!$'D"!$5!(!!"(D'00#!$!"!$$'((!$' 5$#  6('!  '7! "5 ;'$$ #6$$  ($  '6(!  $  "!$$'(  (!$'  5$#  6('!  '7! "5 ;'$$ #6$$($('(!'5?03!$3,CIB3(!  (4($D"!$$'((!$'$DF6('!'7!"5;'$$ ($   ('(  !'5  '$#!=$   ($  '6(! ? I/,E,-.K I/,GCCCB3

-3  >"8   45  "!'8! '$  (!(#  "!$5 "! ('$'#  6('!"!#6(<3$"!$'$($ >"!$ !'5  ,/ 4'$ ,...  >$! "!$  /, ! ,..+  $ D 9  45$  '6(!$6;#$('!3

&(  ($ "!('$   "!$$'( 9' "$  !'5 "!  !$EF2EG3/+0!3?//F.,+3*+H,>--232.B$'99'"!  ! $  *FE-G 0!3   '$#!=$ <$ #4D #$# # "!  '$'$$'(  "!#6(< #0!3 ''  ! ('$ D ( ;@ #"(($$C,+3/.0!3?CF-CC32.0!3@-FG/G3+.0!3B3

C3 (0(!#$ D  4!'"!  "'  4(! #$!'$ "(!  "!$5 49F ($  $!0!$   "!$$'(  (!$' (   !   (4('$ '6(!# 7##0'''!  $$ "!$$'(  !('$ D  '$#!=$ ("$('! !  ($$  @'3  '$#!=$ ($ #  $; '' #5 ( F!$3 /,  F(!( !  "!#6(< "!(0'( 6''  !6'6$ $ '6''$#  /E 6!' /GEC ? ,B ( (  $; !#5$'!  ' '@' $ "#!'! ? I ( "7'#  -21.,  /E 4'$ ,..-B

+3 #($!"!L "!(#!#$$5!$'$?!$3*-3,$ EGM3/('!"!(#!''$!$'6/,"$7!/GE+B3

NNN



    1*2,1,..+ C  



#   1 " # "   "  #  "

%

234  5  6     7 & 0)* "89

/3 6'$  &&     &&  D $!0#!!   ("$  ('! &   (  C,+3/.0!3 D  &&     &&     & 06!  #3

,3 6'$  &&     &&  D 6!!   "   ($$   '$#!=$ ("$('!    ('#!$  8  /- ! ,..+ 49F ($$!0!$3

-3 ><($$97('3

C3 '$9"!(#!$5!$'$3

+3 0(!  "!$'   9F "6$ 0(!! !(! ($!  "!#$ !!=$   #'  -. 4(! 8  ($'0'$'( "! "' !(# !#  !'7 0##!  !  &:O'P!:(09' 2  2..C     $!(' ;"'!3  #'  "$ =$! "!((5#3  #('! ('$ A B ''9! ;$$ 9 #''(  !(!$ #'! (7$'!  ' $ "   #''($$9#K7B;"(!"(!9($'0'$'"(6('!!$$ $!#''(KB"(!$!'5$!((!"!#$$3&'#('!  ($'$ "  $!(' ##$ ##!# ( $$! B 7B $ B '@   !'70##!!"(!!"$!!$'8!!!(!9F' 6!#!!'!!673#('!!(!$'(!(!(<  "!6  9' !($ 4('$  '' 9  #''( $$9# $ F6(""  9#$#;"#'#!(!$?!$3/-, /.2$/.EB3  5!00'8!  !#'$A     'II Q!'& Q 

("'(0(!"!#$!!=$$($'0'#;"!$'''9>D>00'0##! !('"!5!00

    1*2,1,..+