Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/538/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/538/2005 AI generated

Appellant v. State: Refusal of Duress Instruction Upheld

Case Number ATAS/538/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant, having been convicted for criminal offenses including drug distribution, challenged the trial court's refusal to grant a requested jury instruction regarding the defense of duress, arguing that the evidence presented supported a finding that a co-defendant coerced their participation through threats of violence against the appellant and their family. The court reasoned that while some testimony suggested pressure, the evidence did not meet the stringent legal threshold required to warrant a specific duress instruction, as the appellant failed to demonstrate a continuous threat leaving no reasonable opportunity to escape the coercive influence, and therefore affirmed the conviction, finding the refusal to instruct was not an abuse of discretion given the factual record.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appellant v. State: Refusal of Duress Instruction Upheld: The court reasoned that while some testimony suggested pressure, the evidence did not meet the stringent legal threshold required to warrant a specific duress instruction, as the appellant failed to demonstrate a continuous threat leaving no reasonable opportunity to escape the coercive influence, and therefore affirmed the conviction, finding the refusal to instruct was not an abuse of discretion given the factual record.

Keywords

AI generated
duress by threat unlawful drug possession requested state criminal record proof of criminal intent indictment decision

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was used to regulate the distribution of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               '()*')++, ',*-')++,

##

 # "   "  #  "

*.  /0  % 12 $% )++, 



% 3333333333    !" #     )  $%&'(( &)*((

) 

44   "  "5#   6" ( (* &+),-) ./01/11   12

       

        !"# $%&

   5/3.5  

 !  

")(#6666666666 *($7(&8 &8(9(&( 1,,:;

  /. <9( /440 877(  ) & 85(9(&(  =(5>  ?  *( *9* &  ;

&(()))( ()&2*/4408 )7(*&(();

)(&/1*/4408( < ))  &(() 7(  9)('8 *() ()&)  & ) ( &&)*  *&(%;

8(9(  @  ))    9 & A*  ) 8   )( & /<( /440  (&('  ($ &  '8( 8 (  (9 @  )9 %* & &)( '8())( 8&*(()&);

8)'(AA&&)9))(('8)9 &(() $( &)( @  (>;

#     

8 9  &  B 1  B    0: B 1  B   &  )( A9)(  8)A( () <&(((=? ($ )&)(  ( (' )     )   ()  (9 @  )( 7&  85(9(&(  = ?;

)* & ($& &>) $(;

( )8( (*))8&*(()&&(;

)8 B02B2&)(7& (A&&)( & )( = ? 8   )(&  &(()  ))( () )  ') 7)*<'8@89)(&)9(;

7) &>)&)  '( (A&9( )$< ;

  )  '( )$ (  A( &   &)(   *$)*  &  7(   &(('&%&)*& ( *C*)')&  )$<  )    '  D & > & )>  < (7(  = ! 114  0- )(&B/; 1,E,B21E)(&B/$?;

  8>&>)'8( (*))8&*(()&);





3-/23/440  523.5  

#  4 " # "   "  #  "

%

7/8   9  :   5& 12) ";<

  8 

1B )9$;

% 8

/B 8&* ;

2B &(()&877( )&85(9(&( &  &/.<9( 2*/440;

.B 9)(   @ 8  @ DA )  &( & &  )9 &(() $( &)( @  (>;

0B )&* 8  @ 9  )   ) & 0445 7B @ (  &  (( ()@7( &;

:B 7)*   ( &  '8 9  7)* ) )     C  &  &( & 24 <) &>  ) (7( ()  ( )& &  ($ 7& &  #DF(GD)7'( : :44.     )( %*(B  &(    C  ))AB  **)( &)( H ? (&(' % * '&(()) &()$ (( &&(()  '; $? %) ) ' *) (7 (  (* )9)( &*&     &((); ? )   (A  )  & )   B #(  **)(  ) (    )( *  * )   ? $?   ? (5&  ($7&&) * (>)'8( &9&(9$B**)(&)* ())*)+ & 9 '( )  <)(  (( '  &(()  '   89) & ' %&() = B12/14: 14E?B    A77(>H (& H     (!! I(# I 



3-/23/440  5.3.5   )()7)*& C  ) (7(% ((('8@877(7& &)(A77



3-/23/440