Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/502/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/502/2006 AI generated

Notice Requirement for Limitation of Liability Despite Invalid Contract

Case Number ATAS/502/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed the legal effect of a statutory provision requiring specific notices regarding limitations on liability when a contract governing the relationship between the parties was invalid or unenforceable, specifically considering whether such a provision could still be effective despite the overall contract failure. The court reasoned that the notice requirement, designed to protect the party receiving the service, was a mandatory condition precedent to any limitation of liability, and its effectiveness was not contingent upon the underlying contract being fully enforceable; therefore, because the required notice was not properly given, the limitation of liability clause could not be enforced.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Notice Requirement for Limitation of Liability Despite Invalid Contract: The court reasoned that the notice requirement, designed to protect the party receiving the service, was a mandatory condition precedent to any limitation of liability, and its effectiveness was not contingent upon the underlying contract being fully enforceable; therefore, because the required notice was not properly given, the limitation of liability clause could not be enforced.

Keywords

AI generated
statutory requirement contracting party contractual liability notice period validity of fixed-term contract supplementary interpretation of contract

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive orders concerning court costs (Order 2).

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive orders concerning compensation for the respondent's costs (Order 2).

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



                !"" #$$%  "$# #$$%



& '&( ()(  &( )'

*+ ,  -$  #$$% 



 !"#$    %





%

&' ''    (   !%)!* %#$ " +,!+-./  0



           

   (.14(  

( .'

+5  !$+243!"#$67*!8%9%"" $"#"&'(%):(97;"9+ <*.//+!9=>?%""#"59%$9 8@"+=3//85

.5 9.//,!=$="$?7#%6!=8#%"*%$ " "$# 9 " #%8 $#A5  => "=%%%% "=88%"=%!'*"=(#":(97' ; 8#$9"+3<*.//B!A$%%"=$97" $%%#%5

,5 =$  =A%%% 9 "  %%!     %8$ " ##"#%"9C99#".//B!DA=$%%99$5 <%$=99%+.#.//35

B5 =$*%%<%$97" >"$"%".E#.//3!  % #9%#% 6 F% >$$ " 9#% " 9#5  $?%  %% 87 "88 % 8% * A   9$*C% A   8$"$ 9*% D9% " =(>?% % %$? " 95  9@% $?#% 6   "  9 =* ?$   "%%>?%!%9>%$"9C9#$"%8% "@D#%$"8"9%%!A9#D#" 8@5

35  F% " E "$#> .//3! %$  8 : ' +/421.//3;!  > " $  <%$  ! 99% A =$ =$%% 9  >$$8 "= "9 " =>?% " =88! A= $%% %< $ 97 "   9 = >?% "  "7  A= =*% 9 8 "=%%%% "=88%"=%%A=9!=*%9%%$#%% "9#.//B5

45 =$  =$%% 9 A%%$ "  9# "7 * .//3!     8% %8.-%>.//3!##"#%"9C!9%5/3.,-23, G88$%D%%"=*!#%<.//3!%4,385E/!9+//85" 8"99%##%5=$8#$99%B*#>.//35

E5  "$ " . "$#> .//3!    8#$ 6 =$ A= %%  "*#%%$#$9*"9%5

-5 +2"$#>.//3!=$8#$99%5*%$96#%*!   "A$ A=  9*%   9#% " #%% % "  9# #  !A= "9%9"*88%!A=>%"$<6



12331.//4  (,14(   "3//859#%A=*%"$#$" .//.59%99?#%"$<6*A$"9$$"% 9$"5

25 "$"+B8$*.//4!<%$=99%5

+/5   " +/ # .//4! 9%$  +, #! =$  %<%$ 5  %%  "$ "  ! 9% %#%  #F# #%8 A DA=*%*A$"9$"9$$"%5

++5 $9".,#.//4!%<%"!99% A=$>$$8$.//3"=9#$"%>"@D"= 8@"+=3//85%"$"%$5

+.5 *%$6"$%#!=$%# >!+,*.//4!9" "$99%%?5

+,5 'A!$%$?"$6<?5



( )'

+5 ?*H?%<":;$%$#"8$%%%$!"7 +I%.//,! >%"!#9$"3<?! "%9$"%%*(9$"%!399$%%+4<?:%5+%5 %34 ;5

'%6H%"H$%"+4<?!9 >8$"$ .E<*.//B: )+,/+/4;!" ?*"9%$!+,8$*!  "9%%%?%9#%%% >%"  " $?   6 % <? %%! ! " H%%% " H$%"*D<?5

.5 8#$#% 6 =%5 34 5 + %5  @5 B !  > % " J%%A"%%%9$*6H% 34 "   8$"$   9% ?$$ " "% "   " 4 %>.///: ;A%%*68$"$H(#"" +-#+22B: ;5

'#9$%9<?""H97%$%>5

,5 %<%$"8#%"$9$*9!%*>:%534% 4/ ;5



12331.//4  (B14(   B5  >7*A%8%*"*9%%"  8 " =A%% " 9# "=(#"!  A  88% 97 " =%#$ % =>?% " 9C  9# A  "$  % $%$ ?#% D9$ % 8#$ 9  > " $ "  F% " 3 "$#>.//35

 % %%  88% A  %! "#$  '! % # 6 =>?%"8#$#%6=%5,5+ 5

H>?% " 9C  9# "$ " H%5 4+  K  %%  %9% " H>?% " H "H#  9  @? " $*$#% $5  %  $A <"A #9$%* " %% 88%97"H(#"%H$%"6%%"$"(:  +2-/95+4+K+2-+954+;59#"*%F%9C$6H*%99 %#:%52/5+"H"H(#"".-<+223 L  K 85 @88 E " "% ?$$ "H 9 H >?%"(  &';5

"*%*9$%%"$%">?%87 " H$ L 9#% " 9#   %5 4+   % " 9%9% 87  H%5 4B  ! " #F# A  $A "  ( D$%">?%L9*"HD$%8$ 9% :;  9  "  #9% :%5 2/ 5 ,  ;5  "$ %  "$  99% D$% A 9%% "#% 6 9C##"H?%68"I%$%#$D<?#% D$%H%5-/:%53B5. K )+.4.4-"5B%  $8$;5   !  8 "#%%8 % # 6  @? "  9$K88%!<9"!C8%"H$A! 9#9%#%!>?6""999HD@%6 9C%%: )+.3.E4!%5.EE"5.1K  .//+G +3+95++E;5

35  $% " 97 " " A  % H 9 9C$  9# 9  9$""+*.//3,/<.//3!#?$99%#"# "H%#$5

 > " $ %% A  9$" " *#%  $%$ ?#%9%$9H%#$%A%%"*## " 4,3 85 E/! 9 +// 85 " 8 " 99 % ##%!  A  8 " 9%5

$A%!!#8%#%8"$!<%$5

45 9$"%?%%99%:%54+%5 K%5-2&"  9$" "#%%* " +. 9%#> +2-3 L  ;5 %8! "



12331.//4  (314(   $##%"<%%8"9$"9*%F%#6@?" 9%A?%"#7%$#$%$#?"$?7%$5 88%!A >8$"$"H"#!9>%$"#%?%%$ "%<%$6$?7%99?$$"9$"9$*9 %%>@": )+.4+3+"5B>;5

'  <9"!   *$ 6 H$@  % F% #$ 6   9$%%  %7 " $?7%$  " %$#$%$ : ) +.B  .-3! %A ' +22- 95 +2B;5  8% AH $$#% L %A> L H<% ><%*#% 9%M  9% $ "% * %#$  9$" A" >#F#9*%%"#9%!%"H%%%AH 9*% >#% D? "H! A   $%% "$9* " @ "75

H97!9$%6%%#%7"$?7%$!6#% "%$#$%$!"#N?#%9A%H99 9#%"9#"H(#"%#F#AD*A$ 9$$"##% "*%  > " $5 !  %  $%$ %7#% "$>%$5

 > " $   H 6 "#  %  9#%"H$##%!#%%"H%"$<6%%%AH9F% "#$!8#$#%6H%5-2&5+ !6$##%%D"$> H9%6"*% >"$""88#>>% 9#F##%85







OOO















12331.//4  (414(     )'.  '&( ()(  &( )'

 

/0121 3  411 1  56 -%# ) 7

  21

+5 $*>5

 21

.5 <%%5

,5 %A9$"%?%%5

B5 8#  9% "  AH 9*% 8#  %  9$% F% "  "$ " ,/ < "7  %8% 9 9 ##"$ "$  > 8$"$ " ! '@PQ@8A 4! 4//B   !  % D#95  "$  9% F% 9?$5  #$# "%M ; "A D%#%A"$%"$>%%9""$ %%A$K >; D9 9 A #%8  %# 9* "#" %% % "$K ; 9%  ?%   "  9$%%5 '  #$#  %% 9  % $$#% $#$$  %% ; >; % ; ("!  >8$"$"99%#%7AH "*"$*>5#$#"#%#C " 9*! A % <%!  A  "$ %%A$ % H*99 " A$%$D9$"$%:%5+,.!+/4%+/-;5  ?88  $"%M       R"              

98#"9$%F%%%8$D9%AH6H888$"$ "%$9>A9?88



12331.//4