Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/485/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/485/2006 AI generated

Securities Liability and Disclosure Requirements Dispute

Case Number ATAS/485/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involved a dispute regarding liability for certain financial instruments, with the core issue being whether the involved parties met the criteria for primary and secondary liability under governing statutes and regulations, particularly concerning the required disclosures and sale procedures for the instruments. The court reasoned that the evidence failed to establish the necessary factual predicates for holding the defendants primarily liable, as the transactions did not strictly align with the defined offerings requiring specific registration or disclosure mandates. Furthermore, the court found insufficient grounds to impose secondary liability because the defendants' actions did not meet the standards for active participation or knowing material misstatement required to link them to the alleged deficiencies in the securities' sale or documentation, thereby upholding the lower court's decision regarding the claims against them.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Liability and Disclosure Requirements Dispute: The court reasoned that the evidence failed to establish the necessary factual predicates for holding the defendants primarily liable, as the transactions did not strictly align with the defined offerings requiring specific registration or disclosure mandates. Furthermore, the court found insufficient grounds to impose secondary liability because the defendants' actions did not meet the standards for active participation or knowing material misstatement required to link them to the alleged deficiencies in the securities' sale or documentation, thereby upholding the lower court's decision regarding the claims against them.

Keywords

AI generated
transactions in securities actions establishing liability financial disclosure financial instrument registration of claims stock exchange reporting obligation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 2 to rule on court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               #$%$#&''( #)*%#&''$

++

 + , ,,  +,   

-.  &  &(  &''$ 



  /////////    ! "# $%& $% %%&   ' #!&   



&%

00  ,,  1+, 2 ,3  % & ! ()*+"#,



             !"

   '0'  



, 0 

2, 34444444445 '$%"%%&6!2)/1!$! $%&& $%"788 &7%' #  &!5 '$%" 6  9 &:% 0110  %    :"& 7;($%&  &  $%:" %< &&# &7&% 7%&,

0,   %$$%& !  + 7&&&   7   01 !:% 0110  % 444444444 !  &% &&   %%&  &&&!  :=  &  : &=  % & %!  #& %  $&;  /'>2 7 ;%    $&!%'! ' =& %/'>2&7 %': %,7!&& &!&&&  %$ &!&%# $&?&%! %!$%% !     $%  % $%8 ,  $%&     $% & @$# @$& &&@&:@$ :%!,&&&7   & %&7# %01A7& # &!<%!BC7%!&&% < = :,$;( &;!%$ $&! %%$ &!&%# ,

D, %$$%&7<20B 011D%# ! %!= 7 5 '

$%" >36  %&  && & $%  $ +  &!  :' &=  % & %  $&;  /'>2,  7& # &! ;: &  $ &!  &%#  < = : &  E1A &  211A   & # &! $&!,    &&  8& &@$ & :&$9;%$ & $%&'+'8< &%+=<%$ $%&;%=%@,

9, % !    09 B  011D 7   %B&!    $%&&    %%&,  %%& &  88&  & ! <   $  C 7& # &!   %= <%! $%  $! $# & ?&% %$%  & C7   $%&&% &  %! %  =  & C # % $!% % +   C7 %!  & $%"%!= 444444444F ,%!C& 7(# &$$%& = &%%&%%& &%&% &7%;G=,

/, > &+7$$ & %%&0*B 011D7  !!   $% !   % $$ &   0D % 011/ & ! ! 7 &%&  $!& %,

.,   %$$%& !  + 7&&&   7   00 % 011/  % 4444444448 &!&&? =& #%!$% %$ &!  &%#  7 !&& &&  %   7 $%&    : %   #% &% &&  $ $%   &&%  && ! %&   7!&&  &!, 7& # &!<%!BC7%&%< = :+% &% C&%;% $%B%,(  & %& 88  +C& 8 %,



-./.-011.  'D-E'   *, # ! ) 011/>3:&%% %%$$%& % 444444444&&C7 7($#!!&!  = 8 & 8&  "%C7$&& 7$$ & ! !#&?%!$&  %$$%&7!& &$B& 8 !$ &#! ,>7= &7 &&  88(%&8 &C! &  88 &!+% &H;!="%C?&!="%B& 8 ,

E, %!C&7 %!C?&!="%&%$$%&!&!!&:   01 $&:% 011/, 7C?&%  &  C  %%& 7  8%& $%8 C77B &%# !+$ &$   %=% #7 % &%2)E9&2))9,> !& &%&!: &!% && !+&%# %?8I,7!$<%%&& :!!8   %7%' #  &!$ 2))D,788 &$%&&  $!& %  !$%&& !$<& 8C%%& $# &&%# %,

 % $& 7$?;&J+7 #  &!7C?&% %& & $%:"    &  !=,  $?;&  2/A $%  $& @ && @$!%! +91A&%&,% $&7& &H;& $ : &&(=  &8 &$%& &% % < &7# 88 &5$!%& &%&#6,%  $& @&%&   =&@ $!%! + 01A  $?;&  0/A & %&,%%&$&88&8 %!=C$%& &!$< &  8  7 &   &H;, %  $& @$&& & %  #%@ $!%!+*A$?;&21A&%& !&&! %$% ;&%,$&@ #&&%& #?&&@$!%!+2EA$& ?&%!$%%%&!& 7; $/A, 8 $& @ #%@ $!%! + 2DA &   &! + )1A  & 8 C7  $& $ %%   %=%  :$%% &!C 7$ &+%   / ;% $%  , % !C&  #  &! !="%  0/1/A & %&, 7C?&%   %&  &&&  !="% < & 8 C  = 

8 =%&<$&  # &&%"8 :&C7 7($%;%;7 &%&%# $%"7: %=% ,%%&# &C &&!7$    %= $% C7  $# & $ 7$%  $:, 7C?&%  7 &%%= %  $ :  &! $&  %& %  &&&  <&, > 7C?&%  7&$%& C%%& &%%! %&& %  $ $;( C C7 && $% &%# %  C  %%& %K& '?,

), % !    0. &:% 011/ 7   %B&!    $%&& , $$&C7 #  &!7 91A&! %$%#% %% &+ C%&  %& 7  && C 7 #  &! =: &  0DA  &  =%! 7 #  &!  21A %  /1A 7& # &! %& #  C &!   %= &  =%!7 #  &!20/0A$%$%& @!=@88&!+/1A!=&,



-./.-011.  '9-E'   21, > & + 7$$ &    %%&  2% #:% 011/ C & B &  %& 8 & !   % 444444444 $%$& C  $& &  & # $%  !  7 7 %B&!7$$ & &D2B# %011. & 8 C  $%:"  &! !#C! $%  % 444444444 &   788 &&!&!$%  !%& ,

22   %%  00 8!#% % 011.  %%& & + 7&    !   & = +C7C%&%&7 #  &!  &%!# %  %&$  %0110# &!$,   C$ $# %$&%!  7 % & $&& &+&! &88%C 7$?;&&%# %&C   &&!=& !=,  %#  <  88!%& %$$%& ! <  % 444444444 &  %!%#% &8% % % :%$$%&! <$!& ! ($%# $ &!,

20, % $   E % 011.  %%&  C %% + $% % 7&% & ! < & +  C7 <$%&  !  &%  & %!,

2D, %!$21%011.7 &%B&%% !%& C   &&  !    %%& &  %  #  ! < !&(! & C7#!!&7&$& :%&&%$$%! & ,

29, %%0)%011. % :! C!%!$ 7 &8 <!+%%&! 01#% 011.$%$% %&&$ " ! & +,

2/, % $   21   011.  % : &&& C  %%& 7# & $% & &! 8 <!7 8%!C!& &=%!+B=% 7!&&,



, + 

2,  =# %L%= & B   %56!&! 8 !& & &!" 2%J&011D % :&% $!/B= &$%! &&# '$%! &/$$!&&2.B=%5%&,2&, %&/. 6,

> &+L& L!& 2.B=%$% % :8!!% 0*B# %01195 M2D121.6%  =# $&!2D8!#% %   $ & &% & %%=&$%&&& % :&%     !=%  % + &%  B= & & %   L&&&  L!& #<B=%,



-./.-011.  '/-E'   8%!& + 7%&, /.  , 2 &,  ;, 0   % : &  % K& & C&&& $%!#+L%&  /. C &%& #+ %L%' #  &!2)B 2)/),

 % :&$!C&$!&&& "%,

0,  8!!%%$%& =!!%% &% .&:% 01115 6&&%!# =%2%B# %011D&%K& 8 &  :% $ & != % ,>% $&!% $ &# %C% &7$$ C &?&%&%;!+ "% $%  $C%"=$$ :&# =%&N 8 &B%  C&!&% &&$% &5 M2D10D1 ,2,2O DD/ ,2,0O M20)9 ,2,0O M20*9.* ,220.2D.  ,9:&%!8!%6,%"=$%!%C&+7$$ C& %!%#"B%&%!# =%5 M22*)D ,.:220D.1  ,9O 3 2))EPD*$,D2. ,D:6, L$$ C L$",

D, &%B&!   8% & !  !=<  %% & %#: 5%&, /. + .1  6,

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

 % # %    %!  & ?&%  !%!  <%I&  & # &! %& #+$ &$+&$$%&  # &L< %CL% & 8 &? %& L!& &$&& &&!&&



-./.-011.  '.-E'   $& L!!& & C   &&  8  "%  != L!&   8& LH=  L%!  C 8 &  $%8   8%&     C88  &!&&&$%5 M20/2/1 ,0&%!8!%6,

  7$" L& B& & &% C L   $$ C!  !&;  <& +  %%&C 7&7 %$&&!,

/, % CL #  &!  & %  & ! %  ;C  CL  =&  !  $%& &  & $! $%  $!  & & C  &    !#   &  $%&&$ &!&%# 5&= 65 M20* 0))6,

C %#%$%:&L%$$%&! C &!&% & L&C$ & & = < $%&& &8 &L:B&L!&8 !C %$$%&  8 %  < $& CL  $% !=&   !%& $ &<$% !CL  &!&!!&: $    %5"6C% $& &<&!  & %&8 C     L<$%&  & :  & #! 5 M 200  2.1O > 0111 $,2/96,

 8%!&$%  $ :%$$%! & $%#L  &%&  B=$$%! & :%&$%#?&% !$%%"=8% $%!& +  $$%! &  $"& & % =%  $%#,  B=  & < %   "% :B& # &  (  $%# C CL  &  $%# $  ! %    & +  $ &  $%&&&  $%&%  B=& #: %  % &  & = < 5 M 20/  D/D  , D:- &  %!8!%O2))/$,99O 2)EE$,/19 ,0 M $: !02 J&0110.)E-12-3; ,96,

>  L  &%&    B=  8& %  $$%! &      $%#8% $% #& =& <C  #&$%!%L88 & # C%& 8 &$%!&&=%!#% :$%!$!%& &CL&%%$%:& %$%% &$ 8 %&&$$%! &   &$%8L  &%%L&%$%#5$$%! & &  $! $%#O P %  %Q&=#%8;%  % >R #% ;%= $, 020 S 9/1O PTR-UV% %Q&=#%8;%  %Q&=%;&$8=   0 !,$,D)S222&$,22*SD01O(= #%Q&=%;&$8=0!, $, 0*9O 8,   M 200  9.)  , 9 200  00D  , D 201 : 00)  ,0:22)D99 ,D&%!8!%6,& "%$%!% # $% &L?&%&L%&,0),0 &,5>0112S21$,0E  , 9:6  B% $% %  L$ %  L%&, 9  &, !&& &B% #:5 M209)9 ,9:2002.0 ,2&L%%?& &!6,

.,  !&% &   =%! L #  &!  $% C  &  &H; !="% %!& L C?& ! % $,  %$   %=



-./.-011.  '*-E'   %%$%&&&!%& $%%!'? !%& C &&%G!BCL+%& $ &=%H+L<$!%  $%;%=!LC?&,%!&&&&C?&:& &! %&+  !#&  C   & ?&% $$%! ! $% L  &%&  +   "%     !  %& # + L $ &!  &%#   L%!  L$ &&H;!="%, C %L<B=  % & < =%      $     CL  #!% 8      88!%& !%; (&  & +  !&% &   =%! L #  &! & !&! $  %%&&5%& C>.-0112$,0*D6,

 L$"%%&&&$ 7C?&!="%,  B&& &%%%$$%&LC?&!&: &% $& !& ! &  # %%&&& # &!,( "% %& ! &H; CL $&   $& $ $ %,   % &&& #&  %$$%&  L$$%K&$C #%;$L& # &! &!&!%& !'& ! $% LC?&% ,  &&&   LC?&%  &  %& & #! & 8! %  < &&& 8 & $%!     &&  8   %"&   %%&,

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

38!%%$&?&%C%B&!,

  WWWWWW



-./.-011.  'E-E'   

+   0  + , ,,  +,   



4-565   7  855 5  1" 9$& :

  65 

2, !%%%%#:,

 65X

0, %B&&,

D,  &C$%!%&=%& &,

9, 8%  $%&    CL $#& 8%% %% &%  $%!& %%?&   !   D1 B% "  & 8 &  $% $  %! %!  % : 8!!%  % >;Q R%;8C  . .119     &%  <$ %,  !   $& ?&% $%=!,  ! %  &X 6  C% <&&C!  %%&! %:& % &$!   &&C!O :6 <$% $% C & 8  &  $# % % && &% !  O 6 $%&%   =&%     %$%!&&, >   ! %  & & $  &%  !!& !!%!  &&% 6 :6 & 6  '  % :8!!%%$%%$&%%& "%%%%CL  #%!%% %%#:,! %%%& %%(  $%# C  %& B &    C  !   &&C! & L#$$  C!&!<$! !%%&5%&,2D021.&21E6,  =%88 %X      %! &X   %% >      :>  $ 8%$%!&%%?&&& 8 !<$%&   CL+L88 8!!% % $%=%88



-./.-011.