Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/47/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/47/2005 AI generated

Contract Breach and Damages Award

Case Number ATAS/47/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns a dispute over contract performance and subsequent liability for damages, where one party alleged the other failed to meet specified obligations regarding the scope or quality of services rendered or goods delivered. The court, after reviewing the evidence presented, including documentary submissions and testimony, reasoned that the contract terms were unambiguous and that the complaining party had demonstrated a material breach by the defendant. Accordingly, the court determined that the breaching party was liable to compensate the non-breaching party for the resulting financial harm, establishing the quantum of damages based on the established contractual framework and applicable legal principles regarding expectation interests.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Breach and Damages Award: The court, after reviewing the evidence presented, including documentary submissions and testimony, reasoned that the contract terms were unambiguous and that the complaining party had demonstrated a material breach by the defendant. Accordingly, the court determined that the breaching party was liable to compensate the non-breaching party for the resulting financial harm, establishing the quantum of damages based on the established contractual framework and applicable legal principles regarding expectation interests.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual damages framework contract services rendered characterisation of contract breach of duty obligation to contract

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the court costs on the appellant.

Art. 64 LTF

Ordered that the costs of the respondent be reimbursed from the general fund (legal aid).

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               %&'(%())* %*&%())+



, -, !  ,! !

'.  !/ 0 # (* 12 ())+ 



# -3333333333     -3333333333 



4 5 #6   7 66  !"#$### ''() %&

               !  "#$

   ."*%#.  

 4

%/  " !(0 "##$  )!1 2222222222 )  !(0 %3,+  2222222222 )  ( %3+"  4)) 5  6 78  (4'  '49'(4':&+;'.!<=>?>!!''4>)@  AB ! 7/ 2222222222 4 4  4 1 @(0  5  C ;(0'D'E4(B'?!7(222222222244 41@(05C/FF'B')')!G4>1 '(4%-@'"#H"##$!<4()4'@AI' ;'.!<=()4'?!(43"&!!/

' @' 41 ' 4  2222222222  72222222222 '' J>44()4'(!(4$%$(47/ 2222222222    !  ( 4 "33   ( 4 7( 2222222222/

 ) '4'J' J 7/ 2222222222 )' ')  K' !   222222222222222222227(2222222222!/2222222222/

"/ %"@B'"##-42222222222)('4(4>) >1'4>E4((0.)G'J4(0'D'4'4> E4( 4 )!G) B' G'J  4> E4( !4 G)'J/

$/  $ F)B'"##-> F)4(01)!12222222222 F('('FJ>)'D)D<J) B'!F'4'(D)4(4/>!!''! '!J>'>D''4>4>D/

-/  %+F)B'"##- )!!)54)''BJ>' B'))B''(4>''DL4FF'4'FF'/

&/  %# ( "##- >  @) >!!''  ('F J  B)'F'' 4 !'()4'!2222222222''(!'0/

,/ %$B'"##-)!<4 '04 ' 5 > 4  4)''/  FF'  41 4> E4( B'.)!G)  4> E4( (0 G'J/  @' "##$ ' )' !'  B  AB  !E 4>'D'  )' 'B) M( 0J)N/   2222222222 B' 0' 'F') J>' >D'' 4  4>D/   0D B !<  BED )' (G( !!((!'0/

 '0  4  '  D')     ()4 *+,"*"##- *+,$*"##-/



*+,"*"##-  .$*%#.   +/ %$('"##->@4/

O/   4(4 4 '0  4  '    ('  "# @' "##-  4' FF'' 4 41 ' 4  2222222222  2222222222 4  ()4'/  41 '  )) 4'4('<'B=

? 7)4'4)G0''' M@AI'N :4('-" 6'4'

!'2222222222)!(0%3,+4(''')5B@LB' K'))'D)!<44%-/#+/"##$"#H"##$/

'D'=;F/'D'?

 !' > !))  D B 4 4  D( K '' J 4@(04'/4(()B'J4')''4 B'4('/

'(40)G)!'))FF'/))'))D(BGE4 I')' ) D)' G( !)4 1' ()4'1 (D ( 4  P 4  J   D( K/  '(= ;F/ 'D'?/

F'()4'1>)<B53"&/ 72222222222 !04   ;'D? /2222222222  ;'D?N

0? 7)4'4)G0''' M@AI'N :4('-% 6'4'

!'2222222222)(%3+"4(''')5B@LB' K'))'D)!<44%-/#+/"##$"#/#O/"##$/

'D'=;'41?'E4(B'.!GG/KE4( (0G/4('0'/

 !' > !))  D ' 5  DDB' 4 4  D(KJ'B0'(/ FF4!'JJ)4 4/



*+,"*"##-  .-*%#.    '( 4 0)G)!'  )) FF'/   )) ') )D( B GE4I')')D)'G(!)41'()4'1 (D (4P4JD(K/ '(=;' 41?/

F'()4'1>)<B53"&/ KG'B72222222222 !04   ;'D? /2222222222  ;'D?N

3/  $# H "##- >  (' 4 0B' ' 5  4' 4 !'< !)')/  ' 4 !'< J   B' FF)  '(40)G)!''0)'/()4' >)' !  F' 4 !'    ' F)4)  Q.(4' 4 %O ( %33- ; 7?    >B' ! )) 4) !  ()4'.'/   0)' >)' !  '( 4>D(''(!'F')/

%#/ 44"$!(0"##- '04' @' *+,$*"##-5 *+,"*"##-/

%%/  % B(0 "##-  '0 4 )    4' 4 (!' !4!'/>1)>!!))/

7/ 2222222222  4)) M (( !'  "O @' "##$  AB/  BED4"@/(('B)$#@'"##$!.C"3@' %@'/

>'4!0<(44@>'!)4F'4@>')D(F 0)5@(0J'(>'4F('J4@'D(!/

)'4)@5(4B4!'/F'4'(K'/

 'B  )'  0J)  ' 4 BED/   (( ! )  4 ' GP  ()4'  B !'  ()4'( J  !)4' 4)@5/  %- @' "##$   (( 4   4 )G0'''/7'2222222222J'()4'D))' 1(')')''J@AI'/

>''<(F'JAB!B!!/ !('<F'@>'4H'BG!)4'4K2222222222/  ) ( )!  F'  )@ 5 >8R!' 4 "% @ !  (C( ' ()4'/  (( 4!' "##- 5  7 '/  4(44(0(!4/



*+,"*"##-  .&*%#.     '' !   2222222222/    )' @(' F' 'D   ()4' 4 )G0'''/  D  AB 4  B'D5,#I'(< 4''/  ()4'5&I'(<4 B'D/7'B'44>D5''/'()J>' >)' ! )' J   4' 1 D 5 >8R!'/  )' !)F)04F''B()4'J4'('  !!!0<(((444@(0/

>B!4'2222222222J)'0J)4 J)''4B'4('/4'4'J) 4!!GF/

(F''D!''!(!2222222222D))')D( 5>8R!'/

 "##"   )' 4)@5 F' 'D   ()4' 4 )G0''' @AI'/>G!)4'J@>B')B'BE)(F(( ('4/EB)@)('D(!J>"##$/

 "##" > 6 78   (0)  )@/  "##$    !S)44AB!F''D/B'"##" (C('42222222222/'(H"&@)/

(()AB%('"##""('"##$/B @('J4!B54>44(;!!?/

>!(((T'D4(0' D5>)DJ'0'/

7 F((  ('  B  ) !0<( 4 )/   !B ! !E>'/

!)'J('>!)4'D)4!!()4'5>'4 ()4'/

 4) 4 )@   ()4' 4)!4 4  ) 4 )/ K' '.' >()')@('/B4!(0'4(! EN/

%"/  %" B(0 "##- >  4)!) 4 0B' ' 5 >4' !)')/ !<  BED  ) >)' ! )  4 ' GP  ()4'('41('!<(44)G0'''T' B'))@D)J>')'!)F)04'B'(40)G)!'4 ''J@AI'!RJ4444>D/>E B'4!4>D4>/$,/"44Q.

(4'4"+@'%33&; 7?/



*+,"*"##-  .,*%#.   %$/ K4(44 '04)>!)')"-B(0"##-!' "%4)(0"##-J>B'FF'B(!'GD)@ ()4'@AI'4)"##"!)'J)'  J  J' 4  4(4 4 '' 4 !' 1 ) ' B/  ' 4  ''J @  AI'   )@ 4 )"##">B'!))4'F(0)0 4 'F(' 4) !  ) 4  MJ''   (4')4)@5>)DN/

K  !'<  4'  )  )@) 4  ''J @  AI'7/22222222224%"%@'"##"!H4-," 7(22222222224%#"&@'!H4$-&/' ')D((0)$-+4()4'(/

 

%/ 'DB'>D''@4''';?))(4'F')'')4< %H"##$ '04'(!)4&@D 4!)'4B'.!)'4&!!)%,@D;/%/ &, ?/

K'5>'4>)'4%,@D! '0F)4) "+@B'"##-; 6%$#%#,?4 'DB'4!)%$F)B'  4'!''''D!( '04 ' 4 ')D   5 ' @D ''  4 > 4 >)'4B1@D/

K(!)!@D44>!<'')0'/

"/ @)  (! ' 4B  @'4'' (!)    B0 ;/&,/%/G/-U/,#4'F)4)!'D))4 4'4'4,0"###; ?/

$/ K>/"&/%"/0 7>0'D'4'!4  GD  H 4 !' J' B 5 4'D'J  5 '  (4')J;/%?/ !'(!=

/1('('4'!)F((0'4('' 4 !'  ('' G!''  ('.G!''  4  )0'( ()4'.'!=

%/ 4()4' "/ 4G'!'' $/ 4 ! F' 4 !'  !'!'   (4 ()4'U



*+,"*"##-  .+*%#.   0/E()4'((E!!'4'D'JG)!'J !'!()4'4'('F'1)! 'F)4)! G'!''U

/!''!'1F'40)'!'!()4';/"?/

K>D'4)0'(40)''4('>' !4)!(;/-#/% 7?/

-/ K >/ $- / %  "  7  ' 4 > 0'D' 4 '  !B!!4GD4>HJ14!' !)B 1 / "& 5 $$ ;/ %?/  ' F)4) ! 4)'4 4  !'  GD!>0'D'4'4H4!'!)B1 /"&/""3F'5>)D!4'()4'/!4)'D   T > 0'D' 4 ' !4  GD  H 4>G(5>)D!4'J()4'/!'(' !'GD4H4!'F'5>)D;/"?/

K >/ $, / "  7 > 0'D' 4 ' !4  GD  H4'(FF)4>D5>)D/EDJ >)J')@(!'(5>)D0'4>'(()4' J>K'>!!!!')/>E!4>DJ>) 45>)D404'B'(/

J'44)('>J>)'0'(0'4('< '(!)B4>'(5>)D/FJ4'()4'>!! 5!4'(J>K'!!''!!!'); D AIB'GD '= KGB'P'G 4B(DG VKW KP'K'G'!/OO:%+,U 6 4&H"##$A,&*#$?/

&/ >!<'('!''!(0)G)!'/ F'    !)4 ! B' FF)   0)'  4/"&/"/-# 7!'!()4'/>!!''4 '!)')>4!''D'/

  'BJ   4>D   4 >/ $, / "  7/ !4F4B4>''()! '04 )J>!/'B)AB1B' 4 4)0 @' "##$  <D B' FF 4<  'B) 4> 0D ((44HBED)''(4>D/> J%-@''%-@!4J>'4()4' J' 'B'  ' 4>D 'BJ)/  '   2222222222  )J7/2222222222>)'!))B44BB' J>')''4B'4('J'4! B4)'4/



*+,"*"##-  .O*%#.   4'FF'(B'4>04!''(()4'(1  J' 1!'J' J>'   ' 4 J  %- @' "##$   ()4'/   )D4 ' <D B' )   2222222222 ' 4  J  ' ')   ()4'/  ' !!X J 0F'J2222222222B'4>D4>GR!' 4 '' '  '() J>' >)' ! )' 4>4   1 D (' J   B' !R 4> )@   ()4' !  '(40)G)!'/

 B 4  J' !)<4  '0 4 ) '4 J     !B)4''4>D()4'/K' ! 4 '( 4 0)G)!' 4  )0'( 4  0)'  )' !'0  4> J  '(  )) 'B' %- @ !<  4)044/

)D4 6 @D)J>)!))'4>F'0(5>) 41 @ !< B' )  ()4'  ' ' ! B'  K' (C( !  !! (E 4  ! 4 (! ; 6  4 & H "##$ A,&*#$?/

(C(('<>!<(C('4DDB)!< 'B)AB'>'4'JJ>'!!B%- @'"##$B'K'!!!(E/(0(4F' >4!@'F')04>/$,/" 7/

,/ ?51(''!B!)B'4!'4 0F'4<J>!'GD)BF'4 '( 4  ()4'   !  )@ 4 )  "##" ' >)!))4>)''D'/

0?4'5!'40F'!('E4Q1'DJQ') !!(JQ)B'44'/ '''D( 4)'')!B0'DQ4('''5'54('') BD'5''4''('B'B)'=

%/ ' F J Q') ' 'B 4  '' < 5 Q)D4 4 !4)(')U

"/JQ'D'')B'D'4'('4(!)U

$/ J Q4('') Q' !  4 (! '(()4'( 4 Q'1'4 4 'D(0U

-/ JQ'  ' F4)  '.' ! !4 4 4'!'' JQ'  ' (4'F'0'!)@4'U



*+,"*"##-  .3*%#.   &/ J  ' Q' ! GD) 4!'  (( T  'D(  )) 4) ; 6%"%,,'4/")F)?/

 !' 4  0 F'  !! ! @ Q1' 4Q 'D(  4Q 4)'' )/  4' 5  !' 4  0 F' !'C'BJ)B<!)'(!(4Q4Q (!( 4 Q4(''' !'0 4Q)B' GP Q4('')     !) )D''(/ 7' 4    Q)  ! F()( 5 Q/ $ / "   !)B' 4  0 F' ' 0  4 J' Q'(! '  (J) 4  4''D J' !  ' ((Q04B)'F''F('; 7 %333A3+!/&"& '4/-0)F)')U 6 A%-&*#%?/

+/ >!<''4)J>0'J>E(0) '("##"'(''5'4"##$'4!F'!''1 )J>'('5GJF'(0)4<J1.' 'BJ)'(D"##"(("##$J'4' C1(')4GJ!>/

O/ !J>C@)/



*+,"*"##-  .%#*%#.  

 ! 4  -, !  ,! !

869   :  ;   <$ ='( ">

  9 

%/ )B0/

# 9

"/ @/

$/ F(  !' 4  J> !B F(    !) C 4  4)' 4 $# @ 4<  'F'' ! !' ((4) 4)  '0 F)4) 4  KGY'PGFJ' , ,##-     ' 1(!'/  4)'  ! C !D)/  ()(' 4'= ? '4'J 1(J4)''4)'0''!44)'' J)U 0? 1! ! J ('F ' '( !B' 4(4   4)''U ? !  'D   4  !)/ K'  ()('  ' !  ' ))( )())   ? 0?  ? '.4  '0F)4)4!!('<J>' 4B4)'B0/()('4('(E 4 !B J'  @' '' J  4)'' J)  >B!! 4 J))1!)4');/%$"%#,%#O?/  DFF'<=  )'4=   EK )'7   

!'F(4!)C'F')1!'''J>5>FF'F)4) 4)!0'J!DFF



*+,"*"##-