Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/459/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/459/2005 AI generated

Stipulation Governing Asset Distribution Affirmed Over Subsequent Agreements

Case Number ATAS/459/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The litigant challenged a ruling concerning the recovery of certain funds, arguing that prior stipulations related to the resolution of a complex, multi-party financial dispute entitled them to a specified distribution, despite subsequent agreements to which they were not a direct party. The court reasoned that the initial, comprehensive agreement established an overriding scheme for asset distribution that was not nullified by the subsequent, narrower agreements, which only bound the signing parties; therefore, the initial agreement dictated the parties' respective entitlements, leading to the affirmation of the original judgment granting the recovery sought by the litigant.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Stipulation Governing Asset Distribution Affirmed Over Subsequent Agreements: The court reasoned that the initial, comprehensive agreement established an overriding scheme for asset distribution that was not nullified by the subsequent, narrower agreements, which only bound the signing parties; therefore, the initial agreement dictated the parties' respective entitlements, leading to the affirmation of the original judgment granting the recovery sought by the litigant.

Keywords

AI generated
asset recovery settlement of dispute possessory agreement concurrence of liabilities restitution of unjust enrichment separation of property

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive to regulate court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive concerning the granting of legal aid.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$$%#&%%$ #'$(#&%%$

))

* ) *   *)  

+,  -. /  0(  &%%$ 



1 23333333333 



4         !"  () #$$%$ &'

        

         !"

   "-*."  

 5 

$/  %, 0  -,,- 1  23333333333 )  -4 (  $567  88  ) # 9 : ;  !   #< !    ==   (#   ##   !9 # 9 ! :     8)!)  9 (!  ! $4 ( $557 > 1?/  ##     0  )) ( @!(!# (!  !A=> "#<B ?  )   ) C) -,,- D ##   !9E/ 9 ))  ! F) F9  &   F 9 # 88  $ G  -,,- >@  F  (     )) : 88) # 9 # H (#) #  $G0 -,,%?/  ##    ))  ;)  ! ! %,0 -,,-  I#)! )@ F 9J-( -,,-># <$ ?/

-/  !%,0 -,,-9)# )  ==   !(!)!)  !<$G -,,-># <- ?/

%/  !-7( -,,- 8 ()@9)F!(!)  #) !<  $ G0  -,,%  F9   8  #0  #& (   8 !9(#;)!8!# (-,,%># <% ?/

7/ = @##!# (!)!$%G -,,%9)!) @  !!-%G -,,%/K ! F F8(  & ) #   #-,,%># <7 ?/

+/    ! 4 G  -,,%     ) )#  !  (  0   8() 9) F9 9#  ! #)! @ 9  !  !9 F9@   !   F9    8 #0     ! ! #!) 0)#0 !9(! @<0/9 0 9# )!9F !# (!># <+ ?/

6/  !$.#(:-,,%9)08 #)#<!        I# F) F   !9 F9  0  )    F   ! 9) -,,-/       G   !( @ 9"H ! A  L  =   1 M )! ;)  &   ># < 6  ?/

./    ! $7 : -,,%    9 !)) ! 9 (# :  ) ! !  9  F    0  )) (    ! F) @ 9) F #  F9  9;  !9   !9 0:  0  !  (  0  ! 9 (!  ! <0 F   &;  ! !) 0  ! # F @ 9: ;  !    (!   = ># <. ?/



*++,*-,,+  "%*."   4/  #( < )F    ! #   )) !) #    @ 988  ! #  ! <0  ! ! $% 0(: -,,%/  $5 !)(: -,,%  ((!(!#K)) 8 )@9)F K8 ##  / "  )) 0) #     -. G0  -,,7 !)   8 ()  ##    %(-,,7# #  :! 6( -,,+/

5/ #<  ((  !9;   )F    ! #    # ( ! (  ! G  @ N -,,7 >   ( ! L/ .%%/7,   K (# 8 !9 (?))!)#)# $+:-,,7/

$,/  ((!( ! #K  ))  8 )  ! ! $- 0(: -,,7 >O,7-+64-+?F9)8 ##  /

$$/ !)  !$-G0 -,,+ 0)9##  /

$-/    ! 7 8)0  -,,+ 9)  8  ##    ## F9 #)! )  !)G@ #!   :  !      0F;(!)G@( )@ /

$%/ !)  ##  !$,8)0 -,,+ ( !)  ! $- G0  -,,+   # I !  #  O ,7 -+64-+  #)  # ( ! G  @ N -,,7   I ! ((   )) 9##  8()@# / 0)F9)0  ;) !(! !9!(   #< !9  F9    0  (   #   4G -,,%!)G@F!(   )=  ) ( @9: ;  !    F 9  !9 F9   0  (  9  # H ! PF9  ## !9: !0 !9(! ! !<0! #!F 9) G#/

$7/    ! 4 ( -,,+ 1  23333333333  G)   !)  /I# F0 )#9)-,,%#< ! A L  =   1 M F    # ;!  ! & 0 09#<! <;# H &Q(; !( )/

$+/ 0 ) @  #    !  )# ! -% ( -,,+  !#)  (H( F !#)!#))!@0 G! 8!! #!9!#9 )(#)/



*++,*-,,+  "7*."  

 ) 

$/  ;0 9;  G!   >?))(! 8 )  )!< $N-,,%  :! (#)!+G; !  #) !   0 "#) ! + ##)  $6 G;  >/ $ /+6 ?/

= @9 !9) !$6G;#  :8)!) -.G0 -,,7> L$%,$,6?!  ;0 !#)$%8)0   ! #    ;#(  :!   !  );   @   G;     ! 9 ! 9) !0IG;/

-/ 8()(@9/+6/$ =R  F!  #)0@9/+6! 8)!)# ;))!! !    ! 6 : -,,, > ?  0 @    8)!)  9"(!  ! $4 ( $557 > 1?/  (#) !  : ! ) ( #G;!!9#<  ): /

%/ G)  (#   !0  G !   (#)    0: >8//6, ?/

7/ 9 ! : #  #I !   1  ! ! 9 : ;  # 9(:!## = > L$-+-.$ !/+:?/  9/% /$ 1#"" #  #!9: ; !9#  !(! ##!(   )= ! ( F  0 # !!(   = /

= 9/ $ / $ ! 9!  9"(!  ! -. G  $55+ > 1?#!(   )= !/-%@-6!! 0      ! 9/ =    ! 9    ); F  ! # !9    ! )G   ! 9/ + !    8)!) ! -6 ( $5%$   )G  9): ( ! ); >= ? 0:(  ( >/$/-/ 1?/=((I#) ! 9: ;  ! 9  FH  # F   : ; ( )(! 0!! !9 0F 9I #! );(    !) (   ! 9: ;  ! 9 !  ( S 9G (@9  ; 8  !:&;# F9:))8  !90!9)F 0# ( = /FH! H(#;)!9 ) !9; ( ); (#) !    ;( )  >/ - /- 1?/



*++,*-,,+  "+*."   = 9/ 6 / $  1   0   # ! 9: ;  ! 9/9 )!) ;)#88  !988 #! 9 F  9 # !)   @  : ;   (#   >/ 6 /- 1?/

I(!9/7/$! !9##  ! 8)!) 9"(!  ! $+ !)(: $55. > 1?  0  ! 9"

(! Q988   !G /);(I# @ 9: ; !9>/+ 1?/0 !9"(! 88   !988 #( @9: ; !9F 8); ; !988  8()(@ 8)!)>/6/$!<;(?/

+/  9#<    F   !(   )  =   (  @ 9 : ;  8()( @ 9/ % / $  1  F9   8  # #  !  ! # I(#)/  9 # )  # F9   )  )  88    #< !    == /  <; #! F9  &  &;!9$G -,,-9#<!9  () F GF9@  8  ! 9) -,,-/  ) )  )    9 #  88 F9 %$!)(: -,,-  ##   ! ! #   );/  88 9/ . /$ 1 #)0  F 9) F  &  &; !9 !  9 0  #)0  !   (  #  8  !9 ( !9 )  0 /  )F  )    I#)! ) # 9)  %, 0  -,,- 9 ! # #! 88 F9@  8  ! 9)/ 9 #    F  88    @ A=))#)D);  ((D$G0 -,,%/(:#! F9)9 #(# : F9  ()  I#)( ! F) ! !-7( -,,-F9 9#)/ 9!@G   F    9  !)) (( 88  ) 0   ; !  ##   !9   8  F9 ! # ! 9: ;  !    =   )) 8)/

9;(  !  0  @ !(!  !)(   !      # )F !  8    ! K<( ! 988    : ;  @ 9 (!      H #) !  ( S   : ! )((  :8)!)!!9## F  8)!) >/$5$ P 8/ / $$% / %  / $$7:  /% ?/ 8   8  !9H  &Q(;  #( #    !9H I(#) ! # ( ! # ( !9"(! /0 0&F!)! !# (#0 H !) I ) ! !   )( F (! >/ 6+  1P /$,6 1?/

6/   ! 0 8  0   #)  !) ! : ; 

8  < ! 9) ># ( ! # (   / 6$/  1  ! #  # 9/67 1?#0 !9I) 8)  8)!)# #!8  !$$0 $445>?#



*++,*-,,+  "6*."   !  (#  >(; !   8)!)   )0   ! 9"(! !60(:$55$LL$55-$-7!/7?/

./  9#<    )  :(  !  ! # 0   #  ( ! # ( (#K)    F #  8  ! ((  > L$-+  -.6P / 4 ! !   !9 ! 9  ()  0 @ 9 10:!<$G0 -,,,?/

4/   ( !N  9   F  # )/  )F  #F9HG)/





*++,*-,,+  ".*."   )   5  ) *   *)   

6-171   8  911 1  :" 0;& <

  71 

$/ )0:P

 71

-/ GP

%/ !  ( 0) ! 9##    ((!( ! #K #  O,7-+64-+P

7/  F#)!; P

+/ 8(  #  !  F9 #0 8(    #) H !  !)  ! %, G !<   8   # #  ((!) !)   : 8)!) !  =&T '&8F  6 6,,7       I(# /  !)   # H #;)/  ()(  ! B ? ! F I(F!)  !) :  #!!)   F)P :? I# # F ( 8   ( #0  !(!   !)  P ? #   ;   !  #)/ =   ()(     #    ))( )())   ? :?  ?  "!   :8)!)!##( <F9  !0!) 0:/()( !( (K ! #0 F   G     F  !)   F)  90## ! F))I#)! )>/$%-$,6$,4?/  ;88 <B  #) !B      LL U = U      

# 8(!#)H 8 )I#   F9@988 8)!) !)#: F#;88



*++,*-,,+