Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/436/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/436/2007 AI generated

License Fee Validity and Statutory Interpretation

Case Number ATAS/436/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute involves several parties contesting the validity and application of various statutory provisions and associated fee structures related to the administration of professional licenses, where the court analyzes whether the enacted fee schedule and statutory references align with legislative intent and prior precedents concerning fairness and reasonableness in fee setting. The court reasons that the clear statutory language, when interpreted in conjunction with the legislative history and established administrative precedent regarding the scope and purpose of the fees, supports the current fee structure, thus upholding the validity of the challenged provisions and fees against claims of arbitrary imposition or statutory overreach.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; License Fee Validity and Statutory Interpretation: The court reasons that the clear statutory language, when interpreted in conjunction with the legislative history and established administrative precedent regarding the scope and purpose of the fees, supports the current fee structure, thus upholding the validity of the challenged provisions and fees against claims of arbitrary imposition or statutory overreach.

Keywords

AI generated
professional fee licensing procedure reasonableness validity of contract statutory grounds matter in dispute

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order for the allocation of judicial costs.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the distribution of costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           %&'(%)' %+('%),



- .-! #!!  -!# #.

#/"0 +  )1 2 ), 



 !" # $%"&" & % '()#'" "&(%*&"+&  ) %"

&

''   * ((      &!" ,-. 

        !!  "  #$!!   

   #2/41#  

! .

45 "4-63 &&"&!"&%7  8 9&&( %4-.65&:" *;  ;<&!&% 4-=6 !! >99 % #   "% &5     &  &;%,>?*"&@& &:&& %= "!;4---5

25 13!2334*" "%" !  %&&%7 *99 & *#: &"A#%7 B:&C*& *&5

15 %%& "C*  & 2-:23345#5  %"& ')  !"  & & +  %"  +&  9;!,+ & *"&& "%9 "& : "%   %&"  &:5  99  & * >,%& &"  9   %&"  &:5 (  !"  *" &  %&"  &: && %= "!;4--- 9D&& "9&:5*&:&"&"  >99  % #   "% & *& % 8+;  "& %9 *& %; *"  %"&&  %&"  &: ;!& 8+;    5  20 E 2334  !"  &&&%""?*"&& "%9&&!&"?*"!%  !  & ?* *  %& %&"  & ?* %  >+ %  %,>& *& % "5  ":7!& %&  *& % &  ";&4---! :&99!!& &:%?*:&!%,"  5 #*"&"+" "???*&% F@&? " % !" 5 %&&%E">"&9&  %! 5   %& * &>"  !,+ &  9; ! !%&&?!%@>&&&!&%95

G5  22 F& 2334  !"   *    "  ?&    &  "& ?  !%& 9& ?9"  +: & 9 "   ;     %&& ?* *,  %  %& *&"+&9!& &;":7 %&"5& , ! 8& +:&"":75

65 *  "8%&  ?*9"C,?"  :& AB5%%& 4G:2331   8%?*""&"8!"2.&-&;2332?*9&*;E& * 8! ?  &  2 &; * !  %,>&  . &; 2332 & * !  >!&+  - &; 23325    %%&&"&" &"   *? ,&>7!& %  46 &; 2332  %"  !"  && + &   %,>+5  7:?*"%& :+ ++ ;&" &  !;+5  *8! ?  %&& &  "&& +"" :"%%,>?&&;&&&"*,%



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



/-01/2330  #G/41#   %& *&"+&   ? %& "+!& @& 8%?" %  !; &" ?   & %&M&  +!&& A%&>+?B   ;&"5    && !%&  &; !&9! & * !; &"%,>&?!" &&%&" &: *   63H   &:&"  %&" & ? "& #   %&&  !&& 9&5  *&:&"  >99  :>  %&" "  &:&8&&5

05  23 E: 233G  5#5  !" # E& +"+"   &&,>& && & A#%7K"&;!& >%&KB  "&;  %%& C *&&&  *  8 &! ?  %&&&%&" &:C433H %:!;4---E?*CE5  +& ,&  "%   %&"  &: &  &; 99&9 ;% % 4-=6 &  9;!,+ % 4--=5  !"  8%? ?   %  *>!  %&&  %"&"  %! "%  "%9 4-=6% ?*&!4---9&%>>,%!":7 ?  &L"  %;7! 9 : * "%  "%9 ":75  %&!;2332+>&9! * ";& *"% !?? :":E?*C "!;2332%" N%&&&9!&>%&"  &"  :& C  ?  # "5   %"&"   "&& "%9  %&!% 2331 :  & !"& E?*C  E5 (  %  *>!   9& % "%  "%9 & >,%!/!? ? & " % !5  *& %   "!   "%  "%9 &!&5  %&& & ;& & !%&  &&!& !" !&8 J *":&  *"&& "%9 & &7 &!& 9:;J  %" *9;!,+!%?% &*":&?%&5 !" E&"!" "EC ? # " 24 "!;  2= "!; 2332  &"  :&   * ? >"&"# +9!%&&5

.5 43F&233G*99 *#: &" & ';+ "C *"!!&&&"K9!&%";K8&! ?  & &7 *: &"  "&& &,"  4 "!; 2333  13 E 23345

=5  . %&!; 233G    %7 : %   *9!&%"; *99  43F&233G"&C* && 9!&!%&%%? +" *: &" %&& !&C%"   "!;2333CE23345

-5  41 &; 233G  !"    "  :  C *99  *#: &" ';+:&?*:&*!%?**:&% "&" & !%&   %%& !"   23 E: 233G  " C *   7:5



/-01/2330  #6/41#  

435  "  44 &; 233G *   &  +" *: &"  433H %%"  4 "!;233313E2334&&,"C*" &&7 *: &"5!&:&7:?&C*!"&  "&& &"&&&"!" !& 723E2334*"&! *8  &:&"  %&" % 8!% !! :  % &  &"+7: !>&M ?&"C%&!% : !& !" 63H5&&:&"%7!%  + +" *: &"*"7:C2GH5 "?& &%%!" 7  4 E& 233G5 *      :>     %!& :&&*"C% &&::5

445 *"  9!" %%&  &  2= &; 233G :& ?  "&&  &"*&E!!""5&&&%% & *: &"5

425  "  40 9": 2330 *   E&" *%%&  *" :& ?      E 2334 *"&& "%9 & " *" ,&!%! &*,&%&%&"5(*9!?*&:&" "+7:&% *&>"!,+&9;! !%&&8%&    %%& 4G:2331%:& C  ?9&!& +; &%%L&!%&; : %&"  &: C 63H   &:&"  %&" %&&  !&&5 *   7 ?  %%& !"      (:  %,>& &!&%%%& *8%& 4G:23315

415    2= 9": 2330  " C *   '" "& ( % *&"+&  > %" A#%7 '()B !  C  ?  & &9"  "  %%& ?*  C && :," C *" !& 7  ?* :&% &%& ! & & 2 "!;23365

4G5 40!2330*"%*&!"  ! &&E&& %7  ;  "  %+&   ?  "  *   409":2330&%"&"&9"5 %"&& '()7:%  ?* :& ! " C *       ! & %7 *@&  !%&?*!?&;% %7"&C:C*  & 13 "!;2336 ! &% &&%7  5  9& : ? *" & : % % " %  5 #>    && &  "%&!&  %,>&  K"&;!& >%&K ?  &E !&"  %&"  &: 433H??&*&:&":+"5%& *:&+:  & *@&& ? :& *"&  !5&C?  " 409":2330& ""& 99&&:," C *  9 ?   !&& C  %& *&    &  &9 "%%&5



/-01/2330  #0/41#  

465   "%  41 %&!; 2330 *  8% ?* !!&   " &  "%%& 409":2330*99  &  ';+ # >+"  *&&       KE& ' ( 2332 # 233GK # *:& %   9& ?  & "&& %"&" %     '()     %  &&  %&5 *& 7&&;9?*99  & ';+   "  "  %%&  40 9": 2330 C *"5 *  7: ?*99  & ';+% 0%&!;2330:,"  ! &  &  %  %7 !?& 9  &9  "+"!&  !&&9 & &"   &&!&    *"5   % *   7 ?  "  %%&  40 9":2330&9 " !%&&*!?%&7C 9!5 7  ?  :  %"  & "&" "%" *  %%  E& 5

405   "&  2= :!; 2330  & 9& : ?  !"    *       &&   "9"   &  4%&!; 2331  %%&  !"  +""& &&&  5 5 *& %&     ; %" * "&& "%9 ? *"&&! " ?"?&&!" *:&!+"&&% >+"&?*,:&&E%&" &: "9&: 433H5*& %& C %&  "!; 2332  "&&  &" %,>? *& !%7&!& "+ " %?*  F @& >%&"  +  &"  :& C  ?  # "5  &&  "? ?  "&&  &"  & !"" &  7 ?  & &7  & % @& %%!"5 (; !& ! C?& &7&C: 7  4 9": 23315  !  * &  ?&"  &"!  5 &  &  % &  %%& &"  21&; 23305(!" &99 + & *&;99&9 &,%;%! >?&""% %>  "!%& !? "%:5&"&">%&"%!79&" :&C ? # "24 "!;2332J&C"E %&&  % @& &;" +< C  &&!& %&? & &;&  *>!5  & *" 2331#233G  %&&  %"&"  "%  "%9 ":7 N  &&!&  "&"   99 %  %" * , ! 8!&9!%&&5*"&& "%9*&%+:!&!"" !  !;8 ,!%&M! "%9 "  & %&"5  2336 *"&& %,>? *& C : ++:" &  %&&  F @& >%&"  43 E& 2336 *"% !?5 &&>%&& F:&C  &:&   % >I  %&& & *& ""   &8&  ?&&>"&"#+95  && *&"%&&>%&& %&& F@&!&&"&"&&+9:;!&5*"&&%,>?%@& !"" %  &&!&  %&&  % & "+7!&  : C 



/-01/2330  #./41#   && %  &; ;% % & *" 23305    && "%"&"C:"&& "%9?"&"! 9&  &&!&52.%&!;2330%&&9&>&>,%!?& ?&&"( "&& 5!" &&&&""%>? ?  %!  !&&  ":   "&& >,%!? &"&? : &>,%,> %E& +  %% C &&  && & + %&5O&& "%" *&;;%,& "EC &C 8 >%&&&":&?%"& *>& >,%!?#!? !  *: &"%%L&%!& E&9": *++:& &;%,>&? %??"5

4.5 %7&"&"!!?"C* ?"&":&"C "&!5

4=5    20 E: 233. *   !&  5 ( ?  "&"+ "CE+5



! .

45 9!"!&C*&56054&5>52 +:P+& E  22:!;4-G4AB ;&  L&&? &&&%":C*&560 9" "   %& +""  &     0 &; 2333 A B ?&&:CP#: &" 4-E4-6-A B5

(!%"&%E+  P%7&"&;5

25    & &"  :+  4 E: 2331 &L&  ! 9&  !; %& "+   !   5 (  %!&"%& :? &*%%? &@&&>"C!7 %%?7+%%;&:+!!&N 9&E ?!& "&!&&% &A '413213 5454J 116 5452J '42-G 5452J '42.G0. 54420410  5 G; &  "9"B5   & C  & &# @& 8!"  +  * &%%" E?*14 "!;2332&9&  :"+!&&"+%7&& &A '413G11 54& "9"B57+ %" ?&C*%%?&": 7 E   &"  :+ A ' 44.  -1  5 0; 442  103  5 GJ   4--=Q1.%5140 51;B5

15 &E&" 9!& "%":%&:;A&560& 03 B5



/-01/2330  #=/41#   G5  & && ?  "&&  &"  &"  & !""   !E&9&%% & *: &" 74E&23345

 * *   !  &  ;""9 * & &7 *: &" %  %"   4 "!; 2333  13 E 2334 &  !&"!&%%!"&&& 74E&23345%%   & &7 & &&"  *&   & &7 C %&  4 "!;23335

*& "&&9 * & *: &" "+: &/ &!% 7+  %%& E ?  *+  *;E&   &&& &  *;E&  &+5 ?" &%% %&&&&&" %: *8!  E+ *& % !&"  %& ?* : *;&   % ?& 8 %"  C %% ? *&  %&& *& % !A '426G46 52J(2334%5460 54J '443 61 5G9B5

65 B ( P&5 G     &  :+ E?* 14 "!; 2332 P: &" &  !&   %&"  + %"!" %!&   + " ? "& P &&& C  &" %>,?  !& %:& P 9!&" +"& P !   P  &5 P&&& C  &" P& %C "&!&&% "&?  !N&L%&" &:,& 99&%&"  +  P" A$# (  +&I R;  : :>+S>4--.%5=B5

, %"?E% & P: &"  & &&"!?&!" J&  "? "!? ;E&:  P%&" 9& ?P !%& P": A ' 443  2.6  5 G 436  23.  5 2B5 ?P  P&:&" P" ""!?9& "9&,   9    " P  !"    ! N  %!&&& P":  %&"  &:  P&""   &:&" ;!& 8+;A '446411 5243646= 54B5

;B  &&& C  &" %,>? %:& !!  &&& %>,? &L: &"5:> 7%!! "? *"&&%,>?! 9 %!! 99&C% >+% *#: &"  !&   %&"  + ? *" %& !%@>9&%: ;:&"J! ?&8+; & @& "&!"  ;E&:!& ? %; A ' 432  406J ( 2334 %5 22G 52;&"9"J95 '42.2-= 5G9B5

  *8& &;!&9! 8%&& %% *;   %" * +& "!& * 8%& A%,>&B &



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

(  !&& " C *8 * &:&" "&& * 8+"&  ,!%&M!  * && !;;    7+   C *; *&&&C&":& &C %&& *5  !; &&:+"9+&  &  "& &  !%&!& ;:" *"+& *&  &  &"&? !& :+ *;  !     +  :+ &  9!& 9 %  %&& &  &&  *!79&? %&&7 "!&&:&;*8%&  ? *"+&    > % !+"  :!& %,> && A: Q/W/Q(   ! ;> IX> QY% ,>   I (>X+U&  V (>XI>  I> W>>9& 4--. %5 4G1G : "9" C  "&  %%9   W Q & '( J:*!; E& '414G-B5

  *+&  &; "%9  ,   *;: ?   & !"  A95 &!!&  //( )  Z)+5[



/-01/2330  #43/41#   && Q9U& %,>> (&Y+  #43 Q%&  Z'[ G7! " & %5 4-4B  ? *%%  ; 9" "    "&& "%9  &&&  %% %  !; &" %,>&? +: & ; C  &; !&9! 8   ! N   &  7+ +"" ?* !9&& "&:  :& % 9 *;E& * +&"%"A '413160 5151549J$/ (%5&5 %5=4&416B5 

05 ( *&5 2= 5 4     &  :+ E?* 14 "!; 2332 *" &C&&7*&: C002/1H!C !# &*&: C63H!C?& &*&: CG3H  !J    %"; *" %& *%7 *&5 2= 5 4;   %"&  !#&*&: CG3H!5

 *%7  E%   " % ? *#: &"   & *: &":99&"&&9&!@!&!%%":&" & *+!&& &&&% C " ":  *&5G4 A '426G4.:5 52 &"9"J(2334%546.B5

 8&! && %&*: &" *;""9 &! 9  !7 C 9  & C  & # & % *: +!&" " &  %%!"5 *%7  E%    %&"  + * " *!"  ,     " ?  >+!& %%!   ">"& &&  %&   & 8 %&& 7 ?* %& *&&  C  ? *!"& &&"  !& &  I + %" 5   : ?*&>+!& "&!& "&! "EC&%& &;&?*!%&%>&C A&5== J95 ' 42.G0. 54&424100 54;B5(*&52-; & "&"%%!" 9& *;!&  +" *: &"&?*"  &?:&%"&C: +" *: &":& &C &   * %&"  &:  !@! +  "    %"  *&&&?!%&*&52-4" ?%"" " %!&5

*&?&&>+!&!%&& &%%C9 +" *: &"  &C&%& C": # 5&%&@&":"!& ! 9&; *"&&  &" !  ? # & &"    !@! ! ?  "?%&" +&;>+!&!%&&A '441  2.6 54&@&&"J:"+!& '4421.2 52;& 1-3  5 4;B5  %&  :   & >+!& *& % & & @& &>"!%&9&&?*%"&&!!&  " &  & &  & "+& C *"%?   " &+



/-01/2330  #44/41#   A '42610- 52&"9"J:"+!& '4421.2 5 2;&1-3 54;B5

 9!"!& 8 7+ %" %  E%   !&7 *;E&   &&&& *;E& &+&C*&5G4 !%& *"&;*8& * >+!& !%&&  & %% C E&9  %"  & ">"!&" &!%5&8!%&&:?% ; *!%& 99"&"&& 9&95

.5 *%7!" #&&&& 9;!,+& *"&& "%9&%; &:C433H %= "!;4--- &C?& F? &%5&:"E 2334?*"&& "%9"&&"!&!"?%&" &:"&& &E&& ":"&" , ! 85

   ?& C   %"  +&  &; !&9! 8& &;99&9;%"% &>,%!?5%&  : >!&+?  %&& & %;  &: C .3 H   &:&"&C433H &:&" %&"?%&!&& 9& "&5  8%& &  "" ?  &; !&9! 8&C "!!&&&C&",&: !   *8&%;; &&%"!; A&; &7! ":  *9;?:&B *!; &"%,>&?  >&"&  " &;5&&%&" &:  63H &:&" %&"5

 ; "7:%!?8%&   &%"" C%+4= %%& *8%&?%&" &:!!>99 "&& 3H  "&" %& >+  &/ 9!& * , !  %"  !! ?  %:& % @& 8 & ? * 8&&E&M%%%&C*%&& C :">5*&%& &  &; %,>?  8%& & :" ? & ""!&    & &  % >;&  & ?  "&& %&#@& &!&  &; 99&9 ! ?  %& &&  ; @&  + * & 99& %,>&? &  &;   %&"5  8%& &   ?@&   *":& "&& "9:;  %&    * !%;&" % *" C %  && 9! *&:&"%9!@! %&"5%&?&C%&" &: "&& *":"5

!  8!%7:"&"8!"%  &"&" >%&"  + C  ?  # "  &"  :&   * "!%& *"% !??  !; %: " & %%& *8%& 4G:23315



/-01/2330  #42/41#   *& %&     &    &&  %,>& K"&;!&>%&K&99 + & * &;99&9 &,%;%?&! &""% %>  "!%&!? "%:5&&C&"+ %!"%  "%94-=6%%>>,%!":7&!4---?&L" %;7!9: *"%  "%9":75%&!;2332 %&&9&>&?:;&C>%&&9" "!; 23325   &  &  %"&" % >& :  : >%&&:&E&2336 ? F@&!&&"5

: %%& !" %,>&%"&"*%&:*"&&  &" &*&"!&!""E&2334?*& :"%&" &::&*++:&+"%&!;23325 *+&#C *""!&?&"&"%&"C * ?*&&9 %E+"& :&+5

    "? :," C *  9 ?* !&&  \:  8%&%,>&?89 *"&; %? &; %&"  & & %"& ? &  &  +:&" & ?  &  "?%&" &:5

: ?%"7  &@& !%&!&5



/-01/2330  #41/41#  

 # .  .-! #!!  -!# #.

 

  3"

45 ":;5

 3

25 * !&%&!&   "&5

15 :   C *  % && !%"!&      "&&: "5

G5  ! *  C %,  &  !!  4*333 95 C &&  %&%&C9& "%?*C8 ! &5

65 &?%" &+&&5

05 9!  %&   ?P %:& 9!  &  %"& @&   "  13 E 7  &9& %7  ; 9" " A(>XI>9?0033G  B%: !&7  & %;9!"!&8&5=2 9" " ;9" " 4. E 2336 A 'BJ  !"!   &  ?   !&9 & !, %:&%&+& & ! &J & @&  "  ; 9" " % : %&  % : "&? 8  &  *&5 G2  '5  %"& @& &  %7  %  &:?"!!!, %: :&@&E&C*:5  +99V  " &V         (  

%9! %"&@&&&9"8%&?PCP999" " %+99



/-01/2330