Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/432/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/432/2006 AI generated

Property Distribution Dispute (1770-1777)

Case Number ATAS/432/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involves a dispute over the rightful distribution of property interests among various claimants stemming from transactions occurring between 1770 and 1777, with the court reviewing numerous deeds, land division records, and historical documents spanning those years. The court's reasoning focused on interpreting these complex property instruments, often referencing statutory provisions and established property law principles to determine the validity of successive conveyances and the precise boundaries or shares each party was entitled to under the historical context of the grants, ultimately resolving the chain of title issues presented by the evidence.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Distribution Dispute (1770-1777): The court's reasoning focused on interpreting these complex property instruments, often referencing statutory provisions and established property law principles to determine the validity of successive conveyances and the precise boundaries or shares each party was entitled to under the historical context of the grants, ultimately resolving the chain of title issues presented by the evidence.

Keywords

AI generated
land law division of property legacy of property of another matter in dispute devolution of estate determination of rent

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           %&'(%)& +%',)%)&

+

 +!  +"     " 

-. ( $ /* . )& 



 !"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"!  ( )*!%



"!

++   & (( ,   ! %"%$ -./ "0123133 34



           !" #$

   ,1531,  

 0+

38 $1.9%"3.20"!#%$!%!% !: ;!"%"$$ <%"%:!=%":<>(?(( 8(%"  $ "  @  "" "! !% = (%  "!"  "!#%  $"$ !$%%$ !43%17748

18  %  3! % 1771  "  !!A"  "!#% "  B$$;%%$  %%"$ 9!%:!  &! !"  C%    -! "  !$ @%#8

48 ( &""""%  12 #B! 1771   "!  &%"$!$ ;;! & ;%B!-C% # ! !"%%! "%  D% " "" "B%%$ ! "!%"" "%,%;"%! " <-%"<$! %8  !$"$C"$""$ !%;"B%%$ !"!%""%""%, $ !!"@%-"%D8"!B$$;%%&"%"&%#% -<%"!%D !  "! 8 ;%  " ""%" & <- "<-!E%B$$;%&B"%""%<!8

08 (  !"%;%" $%  16 #B! 1771  "!   "%" !$"  $ % $ !%; -8  "  "%,$ !! " @%-"%D8  B$$;%% $C" & "!%"" <- "%D     B"%""%&<!"<-!E%8(% %"$"!#%""" % 0  "B! 1771 "  $"" &"   "%B #  ! !% &"%#%"$ !;%8

28 !  !F  47 #!% 1774 ! &;;% "  &!,%#%%"$ G%, !: H  I &%"$!$  !D%  !""% &%#%%"$  #  &B""%&!"8

68     &! !"  C%    -!  ;%" &B9" . 9#%!1774&@$% !"! $%%" -<%"!% " -<"<$! %8 ,% %C"%D  ""  !:  <- "<-!E%  $ % $ !%; - D !!%" A"! "!" !  "!B "%D  "<-!E "  "!B  =  $ 8 ( "" !"%% &!$ ;;! $C"  ;%B!-C% "  %;%"% "$ !%" !$%%#"8  "  "!%"" -<"<$! "%D " $%"@8 &% %"$  "!#% " "" %  !"%&$%!"% %"$"!#%";#!B8"! "%%%D& !!%"A"!C"$=27J% =#%!8



560251776  ,4531,   /8 (! !"$%12#!%1774"! $%%" $% %"! " !<"C% &!$ ;;! & ;%B!-C%8  @" @ !$""$$";#!&!<"%%;"%!8

K8   ! !"  47  "B! 1774 = &"""%  &   "!  9"  %C"%  ;%B!-C% % &$"" $ !%;8  "% $C"  <- "<-!E%  "" D %C"%  !$ !% ! %"$"!#%8&@=! !"$%A"% " D&% -   %%"%  !"  17 = 47J " D &"%#%"$ @!$ 9D&= !$""!@%C%B8

.8 (  ! !" $%  32 "B! 1774  "!  &!$ ;;! "" & ! !""% !"  "!B  &<! !C%D & <- "<-!E% B"%"$ & ;%B!-C% "  "!B  !<%!#%8(% %"$"!#%"377J %3!%1771 ! !$%$"!%$8

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

338 (  ! !" $%  37 #B! 1770   "!  &$"""$&!$"""%%!"% %"$"!#%""8 "" !"%%  $C" """$ D  - "M D  "%" !$" "" " %D" %$ =  $"" $ !%; "    =  <- "<-!E%  B% "<-!E% $"" """ !!%C$ !  B"%""% <!8

318 (& !$%"%$%(6$B!1770 %"$"!#% ""%:!&"%#%"$<B%"&!$#%%"%!"



560251776  ,0531,    17J 9"%;%$ !  !"%" -<"!8  ( !"%" $C" D  ;%B!-C% &"   C$ & !B%%"$ -<%"!%D %C%;%"%#     9!% !8 (   !$%"%   %"$  "!#%"/2J8

348 ! $%%  33 % 1772 &  !; = &!$  !%" =  !" &%#%%"$8

308 31%1772%%!;$C"! !;%8

328   !"%;%"  K 9% 1772  "!  ;%!  %C"% !$$" $$8   "%   %C"% &$ % $ !%;8

368 ""!3/9%1772"! ;%!"%! &!$%C"% !$$"$%8

3/8 12%1772&!$;! %"%8 :",% !!!%!  "%!  13 9% 1772  %C"  !"%%! D  "!   %  % %"$  "!#% ""8 ,%  $"$ $C" ! ! &!! !"  C%8 ! %!  "!   ;%!$D& !$"%"$""$ !%;$#:!D&" !"%# &<- "<-!E%"&% %"$"!#%""-$"%#8&!$" %% = &"%  $%%  33 "  31 % 1772  &  %% D&= &"!%&!"&%#%%"$"%:!B%%%!"! !;%8

3K8 (&#%$%169%"1772(!"%;%"$%K9%1772 "! ;%!%C"%8(!:#D !%!$%!"%"D"!B&<!!C%D"  $ !%9!8!($9=" " "<C% -<%"!%D !%"B%!"12J"""%#%"$8 "  %C"%   "!  % " %;%!$ "" !  "! D !"!+8D%!! !"   "!  %,% "  9#%! 1774 " &"  &"%"$(8"!&B!B%%"$ -<%"!%D& %"$"&!$% !""!":!%#%" "A"!!=  ;%B!-C%8  ( "% $C" D  D"%  % "! &<- "<-!E% " &""%" -<%"!%D "  %%   ! N D D %" &!%C%  "!B -<%"!%D % &C!"   %#%%"$ $!%!=12J8

3.8 ! $%% !  %"%  14 9#%! 1776 &  !9"" ,%   ;"!&@ !"%"!+8



560251776  ,2531,  

178 ! "  13 ;$#!%! 1776 &!$ !!" "! "" $%% ! &%"!$%%!   %  " !$B" =  %  O#! & @ !"% -<%"!%D 9%%%! " !%% " = &"%   $%% !  %"% " &"!% & !" &%#%%"$ "%:!  %"  $ 8  ! !  !C""% "$!%! " %C "" D  #% $%@  %! " "!%"%!8  $""  "% $%! &!!@ !"%$%"!8

138  14 ;$#!%! 1776  !!" %D  !%B  $  %   ""!   "!   11 ;$#!%! 1776 =  "%!8 ( ""%%#!!";;!&$""$ !%;$#:! %1771! "%C"%D$ ! %! !"%%"""" !"%%""! %%D !$%,%&! !"C%8 &%#%%"$ "%"&" B$!;%B!-C%%! $""$ !%;$#:!8"! $!$C"D&%"%"$   ;%B!-C% " " D  D%"$  #%   !!" " """ %%$8C"% "D %! !""<!<!;%! %%%  !"!"!:%;;%%8 B% D%"$#%CC!# "<C% !%%!%"&$""$ !%;$#:!8 "" !"%%%"%"D&% %"$"!#%"""8"&#%D& #@ !"% -<%"!%D"!"$%!8

118 17!1776&%"%$$"!%!!!"=!9"" !$;$!" !"%#"%=$%%! %"%8 "=& !$%"% $% @ !%$ !  "!    ""!  14 ;$#!%! 1776 % !:# D&% " %;%!$ !  "!  %% D  "!+8

 "+

38 %C#%!P!C%"%9%%%!GI$"$%;%$"%"%"$: 3!Q"1774 !%B"!% $29C " !$%""#%, !$%"2 $""369C!G!"83"8 !"26 I8

(%"=P"%P$"%369C! ! !%B;$$! 1/9#%!1770G +347376I! %C#% "$34;$#!%!  % %"%"!%"%!!C" !""" !%B"! %  %$C!  ! = "!% 9C "%"%!   P"""  P$"%#@9C!8



560251776  ,6531,  

18 ;!$" = P!"8 26 8 3 "8  <8 1  !%B '"  %" %D"""% !$#=P!"826%! !"%C$$!!%"  ! %  6 "B! 1777 G I !"%# "" =  % ;$$!!P!,%#%%"$3.9%3.2.G%, !:H I8

( $" !9C!P :"%%$"B%8

48 I  % ;$$! !  !"% C$$!  !%"  ! %  6 "B! 1777 G I " "!$  #%C!  3! 9#%! 1774 "!'"  %;%"%  B! % %"% $C   %  ! %8 (!   "$!%  %"  #%! D !%" & %D %" A"! "!<$ =  %:!  !%%   D  !:C  %B "   #%C!"N;%"9!%%D"$"!%"" !%"G + 347147%8383R442%8381R +31.0%8381R +31/06/ %83316346%80B"!$;$!I8!:C !$!D"= & %D"!$!#:9!"!$#%C!G +33/.4 %8 6B 331  467 %8 0R    3..K * 4/ 8 436 %8 4BI8   P %DP :8

BI&!!!!""!!A""!#% %3!%17718( !%" $#" =  !" !!%"  '"!   "M"  3! % 17748 ! $D"    "  %B %% D  # % %"% $C %&!,%#%%"$8

08 "!9"$;! "$%$C@!!"!#BG!"8262."67  I8

28 " %"%C%  &!!  D"%  #%! %  !!" !$"  ""%"="$ " "!'"%#%%"$8

68 #!"!"8K83 "!"808 "!$ "$%#%%"$&% %"$ C%"" !"% !$$ !"C!$"!$""& %;%!%"$C$%"&%&%"8 "=&% %"$C% "$;%%=&!"8/ %%"%&B& !"%  %B%%"$C%&!$!!<$"!#%$D%%B!$D%"! %$!"% % "" %%"% !$" & ""%" =  "$ <-%D  " " D& !%"  !:  "!%"" "  !  !$ ""% @%C%B8

@"!P!"81K83 #%C!9D&439#%!1774P!$ !%"=!""%:!P%"%#%=66154J%=%,!"P% " %#% = 27 J  %  =  D!"  !" P% " %#% = 07 J  %R $%BP!$ "P !:P!"81K83B%  !$"! %,!"P%"%#%=07J%8



560251776  ,/531,   :3!9#%!1770&!$!%"=D!"!" !"@&%#%%"$ 07J%=%,!" !"@27J%"!%,D!" !" !"@67J"!""%:!= !"%!&"@&%#%%"$ /7J%8

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

K8 D%!D"% %"$"!#%& !""%" ;%B!-C% % #%" & %D! ! C%  !%%  $# $ !  9!% !"%:!"!B";!G + K;$#!%!1776  446570 %8 4 " 083 8 2 I8 "" 9!% ! " D  "!B #"  !"% %!" %! =  % %"$  "!#% G + 317  33. R    3..6   126 8 13/I8  "!"   "$C!%  ;;"% -<%D ! D  @ !"% -<%"!%D "  !%%  $%! D % &C%"   !! ! &% %"$  "!#% D&% "  "%B&"!'!G(1777 8367R +  831!1770 "%$ =  B%"%  6K4574I8  " "  %;;%"$  "%:!  !#=$"B%!&@%"!%  %"B9"%#&!$ ;;%"  !9"%;%!%#%%"$G"%:! !"%I8! &@  !%" @ !""%  &! % &$C"%  ! %" A"! ;%!$ !  B!#"% $% " = $;"  D%   !$%"%   !%" @ !""%  " A"! !$  %:! ;!=&$C%"$"!%""!$G!!A" 8 !$%"$%818181I8

%%B "    @ "%  !":!  @%C%B & ;;!"  #"$  #  !"!  ! "   !$%"$C!"%   !  "!#%    <D  %"  !$ %;" &



560251776  ,K531,   !B%%"$ -<%"!%D & %"$ " & !$ % !"" %"   &"!!%":! !$""!"%%"%"$""8 !G3I ;;"%! !<!%D& !%;&$""! %! $!$%%!BG1I& !"&%"$C!"%%"" %;""%#%G4I&$"" -<%D!%"%$$#"% %B  "<$! "%D!D"%"$"&$<"%B$!"% ! !$"%;%" -<%DG !;%" !%%!"%!$%I;%G0I &$<"!%""B"%!""%%!;!@!:C&!" " ! !$<B%%""% $ %" "%#"%";;!" !!$ !!"!;;""!B";!!@ G(1777 8322%81R!!A" 8 !$%"$%818184%;%I8

: ! D& &B  !$"" !   "%D   %C"%  "!B ";! !@  ;;%"  ! 9"%;%!  !%" =  !""%&!%%%B=&@ !" -<%"!!!C @&%%D!=&%%"!"%G"9C%"%CI%" D!!$% !! -<%DD%,$C!$C" @ !%":! "%$ %, , % !"""  !"!  !8  &C%" ! % &$"B%!  %:! B9"%# %  " "   "%""% -<%D &!$ " @!!  "%#%"$ !  !<$  "!#% C!$  !D&%!"G;8!!A" 8 !$%"$%8181808"!!A"%"$I8

 !%  %"% $% !  "$ -<%D " !  !! " % &!$"%""!"B%% B !"!<!D"% G9!%%DI#%!%"D! "@%C!%,%D&%""  #!""#"$ !!"!!"!$%"$C!!  "!#%8   !   %B!  !$%"% " % % " G!"8 07  +  %%#&!"83. R!"8.281%%#334"341R(1773 8 37K%84I&%%"!"%"9CG%"%CI!%""";%% %C!!  """%  ;%"  $% % ;%! !  "%"% " %$%!"%#= %"$G!$%I"!#% !$!=  @ !$B  ! !"%  %"  #  !%"  ! %8  &%   !"%%! !D &@ !" """  %%""%    %"$  "!#% ;$ %D" !  %C"%  "!B ";! !@8"% !"%"@"!%"$%%"!"%#"9%%%! &@%! # ""  % $%! % &"%"% $%  &% %"$  "!#% !  %$!"% $C"  $$" $"!C! = &%#%%"$ G !"%%!;"! -<%@"%"!ID%"  !"%"  %"#!%G +31/1..%82R(1777 8 30. %84I%%%""%G !"%""I %"$"!#%" 9"%;%$ !  !%":! 9!%%D $"!%" $$!$ @ %8 %, G +  B%$479%1770243574I8



560251776  ,.531,   .8 ( !%% %B! !$%"% !#D%& %D%B% !$!%%"!"%#D& !$!!!!%"%%"!"%;G!"807  +!!$"%#&!"83. R!"8.281%%#!"8334" 341I&%%"!"%9C !$%%B!" !#A"!%$ !  !:C ;!  !$" =   !$%"%  :" " !%C!  !#8 : !  9C %" @%!  %:! B9"%# "  -  !#DD&%" !# %$%!%"=% %"% !"""  !"!  9C" #B !  !%" %"%C%@8 (%  ! !" $%@""!%"%!% ""!<!&;;%! !$%!&B  !#"%%D!!% !D%;! %% $%" !"!G +312423I8

&$$" $"!%" !  #! !B" & !"%;%" $% &" %  !%C%%$%C"%;!&! !"&@ !"%%B" B%"8  " $C!%% !"D %"%"%C%@% !""%" ;%"&B9"&$";%$D! !";!@ " D&% !$C"%$!"% %"@ !%$D&%%"$"$$"B% % %  %! G:I D  !% "%  %"!;$! $%%"%!";%D%&@ !"%"B%"%#$8

( !""!    !%%    %B!  !$%"%  !#  9!% !  $  %C %!"!%   D% !  %:! & !$%!!"%"- &@ !"%! !"$%@8!D "  !$!%%"!"%#@ !"%;%$=$%%$ "" $"B% !   $%%" ! !  B &B!#"%  !;% " &%#"%C"%  :" %% D& % %  %! " D &@ !" B"%" =  !$"" #%"  9C  !%"  $!"! % C" D&%%!" !""!!B%,;$8

"!9"! !"$"B% !$%"!%""9C ""%" "%!  "  ;%" D  &@ $!%  $% "!%"" " C$$!" %"= !! !"% ! "%"!%!"% ;%D%&%"=!%!G +312423%84B5BB"I8 ";% %  ;%" D& !"%;%" $% " $"B% =   & !"% " !%" " !$!9"%;% %"D"=#! !B"8 @ !"% !$"$ ! !"% "$C"#%!-  !#8  #!"  !%%  $$ !  9!% ! !" & !$%"% !#9C""";%"&@%!%" ! != ""!"! %"%"%C%@% !""& %%"% &@ !""$ !"!%B8 ""9!% !& %D%B%!D& !$"!""!-&@ !"% !%#$% &@ !"%$C$ !&!!,%" !;;% G +  B%$12"B!1771172570I8



560251776  ,37531,  

378 & :!!";%"&B9"&@ -<%"!%D !"!   (8 ! !"  ,% ! %"  !%":! 9!% !"% ! % !'"!  % #! !B"8 ";%  %  &@ !"%"""$ !"! 8!%!!" & !$%"%    %"$  "!#% ,%  "!#" $C"  "!%"%#&$#"%"! D%$!$D !!" !$"  % %"$  "!#% "" ! D  "!  &" D& %%"%  !"  &!!  17J8  "!  "% ! %! D  !!" ;;! & %#%%"$  !% & $ % $ !%; $#:! %$ "   ;%B!-C% %C"%D$8  #%" : ! &@%! %  #% "!%!  $% "!%""   !!" "  "! = %;%!!  = ""!  "%&@ -<%"!%D(8

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



560251776  ,33531,    $""  !%B  $ " #% !  %  &@ -<%"!%D !(""%D,%" %" ! $%"!%""!!"8

338 " =  ;%B!-C% % -  %  %$!! D  %"% 9!% !"% !$%"$" ! %& : !%!'"! !":! %#%"     %8  ;;"  !!"  ;;!  & !B%%"$ -<%"!%D&%"$"&!$% !""8 "@"! !%":! 9!% !"% % #%" !" &""! D& ;;! &;;"% ! ! <!%D " & ! %; &$"" ! %! $  !$%% !B " D  "!%"" B"%! " ""%%! ;! @ !:C  &!" " $<$8 $%  !%":!   !"  &%"$C!"%%""%;""%#%"&@%"&$"" -<%D!%"%$$#"% %B! "<$! "%D"  $8(@!%":!9!% !"%$""!$%$% "A"!%D ;%B!-C% !!%" A"!!"$& : !;;!"#"$8

318 #D% !$:!!!!9"$8

  "+0  +!  +"     " 

$

123.. 4  5   67 /&) "#8

  3.

38 $!!!!#BR

$ 3

18 !9""R

48 %"D !$!"C!"%"R

08 ;!  !"%   DP #" ;!! !! "!  !$" !!A"   $%  47 9! :  "%;%"% ! % !$ !$  !%B ;$$!  ! (<S%>!<;D% 6 6770     "!%



560251776  ,31531,   @ %!8  $%  " A"! !C$8  $%! %"H I %%D! @""D$%%!!"$%!B"%!%" $%% ""D$R BI @ ! ! D "%; % "% #%! ! "" "! $%%R I !"!  %C"!     ! !$""8 (%  $%!  "%"   "!% $$" $$!$  ""! I BI " I %,  !%B;$$!! !! "!!"%:!!!!DP% #!$!!%!!#B8$%!!!"%!!-  !# D% !" 9%" %% D  $%% ""D$ " P#   D$"$@ $%$!!"G!"8341376"37KI8  C!;;%:!   !$%"     TU V -     

 %;! !$"!!A"""%;%$@ !"%%%DP=P;;%;$$! !% !C!;;



560251776