Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/405/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/405/2006 AI generated

Sale vs. Loan Characterization of Repurchase Agreements

Case Number ATAS/405/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns a dispute over whether certain transactions constituted a sale or a loan, focusing on whether there was an immediate right to repurchase the property at a fixed price. The court determined that the primary indicator was the intent of the parties and the absence of an unconditional obligation to repay, concluding that the transactions were genuine sales where the seller retained an option to repurchase, rather than disguised loans, because the relevant agreements fixed the repurchase price irrespective of the initial consideration paid, thus distinguishing them from security interests intended to function as mortgages.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sale vs. Loan Characterization of Repurchase Agreements: The court determined that the primary indicator was the intent of the parties and the absence of an unconditional obligation to repay, concluding that the transactions were genuine sales where the seller retained an option to repurchase, rather than disguised loans, because the relevant agreements fixed the repurchase price irrespective of the initial consideration paid, thus distinguishing them from security interests intended to function as mortgages.

Keywords

AI generated
repurchase agreement loan agreement transactions in securities purchase of real property credit sale fixed price

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article was cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

   

#$%&#'((& #%()#'((&

 * 

+ "+ *  +* *

*, - .

! '  '((&

  

 !!!!!!!!!!" #$%    " &%'% & '

((( ( ( ' $&' ) %' # #$  * '# # +' # 

'

((      (  ,  "   '$% # '-' ./"  &' 0012" 3033    0

         ! "  !

7 042 7

!  / 0!  !!!!!!!!!!  #%&%  0/ #%$- 0//8  #$# #*#$'%   #*)-'% &9 #  ((      (  ,  :7&9  ;<

 & #% # 00 #%$- 0//8" 7 * =$% >* ?''  #$#  $'= >   @' # $$  %'' #' ) @' ') A #B #  C!!!!!!!!!!

  0D ?) 0//6" *'%%" &%'% & ((( ( ( "  =$% &&' A #' #%<

 & #%  &&' # 6 =%) 0//6"    =$%  #%<

 *'%%  '?'%   D $ 0//6<

    =$%  - # %"  . ) 0//6" >* # )' %'%  '  '' #  C!!!!!!!!!!' *'%%" &'' '$$'   9@$' #  % # < > #9 "  #  &)' #%$ & = )  #'  )$' #*#$'% #*)-'%<

 &  # 03 ) 0//6" *'%%  #%% '  <

*   0!   @)  E@' ?# :;  %'% $#=% '  ''%" #9  3 F' 0//2"  - ' #  " $&% # 8 ?@" #'  &%#' '  )7&%#'" 8 &&%' ' 36 ?@  :'G 3 'G  ' 86 ; <

 ' A E' # E%' # 36 ?@ " &  - =%#%  0D ?) 0//. : H 32/  3/6;"  #  @)  #&'%"  32 =%)"  #&' '' @' &$'''  - ' #   # %@   A ' ?@ ''" " # E''' # E%' # )B ?@  <

=$%$' A *'G 86  G 3 'G  IG 5 "  - ' #   +'  ' > # ''' &%) A E'G 86 #   =%#%   &' @%% # #' #   # 6 '- 0/// '%  )@  3 ?) 0//2 : ;" > ' ') A   =%#%  E7IJ$@ -@' ' E#$'%   #E)-'% # 08 ? 3150 : ;<

  $&%' & ?@ #  #E&9 '  %'- <

45.640//6

7 242 7

    %'% '% <

E )' #E &# ' ' # K   # J <

 * 1  "+ *  +* *

!

23/   4  5   67 .&'  8

  / 

3G %   )-G

! /

3G # ' # '' # G

0G K   # JG

2G ' >  &%# ' @''G

 @==9  %#' M

7  L    

 & =$ # &%' N' ' '=% B &'

45.640//6