Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/386/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/386/2007 AI generated

Appeal on Statutory Disclosure Liability Based on Deceptive Impression

Case Number ATAS/386/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns an appeal challenging the application of a statute imposing liability for damages resulting from the failure to disclose certain information during a transaction, where the lower court found liability based on the misleading nature of the disclosure, even though all specific required elements were technically provided. The court reasoned that the statute's purpose is to prevent transactions induced by fraudulent or incomplete presentations, and thus the finding of liability was justified because the overall effect of the disclosure was deceptive, violating the spirit and intent of the law, despite a literal reading potentially suggesting compliance.

Legislator headnote

Official

; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-ACCIDENTS ; ACCIDENT ANODIN ; ACCIDENT DE PEU DE GRAVITÉ ; AA ; DOMMAGE MATÉRIEL ; TRAITEMENT DES SUITES D'UN ACCIDENT ; SOINS MÉDICAUX ; LUNETTES ; REMBOURSEMENT DE FRAIS(ASSURANCE) ; CONSULTATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) | LAA12

Keywords

AI generated
disclosure of information liability of statutory auditor misleading or deceptive marks fraudulent causing of financial loss tort liability nature of the infringement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs to the appellant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           "#$%&#&''$ ""#()*#&''$

"

  +", "++",  ""+  ",

-.  & ! %' / &''$ 



 !"# $%&$'( )



)

*    *+    * )"# +  * ,)'-./")))$ 0&&%   



              !   !

   3%143  

"+ + " 

   536'  )7 #))  8##9 !+!")# :'!/;"- )!#<))8-)"))!))  "! 69 6' !  *     * +    *+  *536'* 7 =+9)/)< 6)!)!$>("8%&&0?

  9) /")   ) + 8 < ))  = ! 8 69  - )  ! -/ ! ) =+ ))") + #)# # "=+<)))))#)#!""-#?

+!)!%>("8%&&0+99)!+"69)6(<*  !#)!+!)8-)?

+ )  ! !  *  !)# ! @& ("8 %&&0  A6= =  '  6") ! )  )##6/# < !A 6 <  *  6 (36()6!/-B)!))"-#9)=+ ))")+()#)## =)<=* #6!6#-)(?

+  ) #-") =  )  6)# !  !"! )  !'  )#"#!!)=8)?

 6 !# ! %2 !#"8 %&&0   *   9"# =+  6() 6 6!  /-  ( ! ))    )) /C  "#! ! %D ("8%&&0?

 ) < +66) ! )   *   9"#  !#  %E :( %&&2   ")9 =  "6") ! )) <  /- !  *  =  ! #6#))))") =+)6?

!!%@9#(%&&2 )(!=6/-!  9 ) !') =+ ) !"8 =  *  A-  )) "#!)?

!#6!>"%&&2 * ):)!))) =6#()))"6")66/-!9?

#)#)")$%"%&&2 )6)9"#= #))-!#<:-?







12$%1%&&2  3@143   + "+ +  

9"#")<+)FE0F$)F /FE!-(G-) :! ! %% ("8 $>4$ 57   8 ) !   H) )= !)))6#(<+)FE0!9#!# 6) -## ! !) !   ! 0 )8 %&&& 5 7 = ) )(<9#!#G3!)!%&"$>D$5 7?

"6#)6:-!!G6')#)8?

6)-##!!)!536' 7 )# (-$:(%&&@ )668+6'?

 ):)#!9")!#6#(6 )(8?

+A)"! 6))!+!+!))))") "#!   ", A   !""- ")#   9 ! )6)   !")# :'   ) !+(!)# ) ! (()  )  !")# 6 )))<+)#-)#=)6"6))?

/!6))+)(=+<)!)?

+6)!""-")#)!"#=+)#6  !) A 8:) = "6)  "6/-=")  9)")   6) ! 6  ) =  9 ! "6") ! ))  66 )= ) 6)/' !)  ) 6  /- =   # 6 #)  ))")5)$% 7?

+ ) ") !  )A) !  =  8) !    +) 6  "6")!+8:)!""-# )=+6()I)"6#=+!) )!+)"6) 6)!+(##6#)) ))")?

+<+#(!)+6#)# )=+"6)!'6=))  +) 6 )#  "#!  )) )) +#)) 6 99)   6 (!)!#!""-")!))?

+99)!#-)-)))#6 #)) ))")?

6#=):)#F

F







12$%1%&&2  34143  

"  0  ,  +", "++",  ""+  ",

!

"  1.

$F #(8F

"! 1

%F :))F

@F )=6#!)-))F

4F 9"  6) !  =G 6() 9"  )  6#) I) !  !# ! @& : !'  )9) 6' ! 8 9#!# 5*/JC/9=0 0&&4  7 6(!")'!!) 68 9"#")A)FD%!9#!# 89#!#!$2 : %&&E 5 .7?  "#" !  !) !=    ")9 ) ",!6()6)-)!)!"!)?!) I) !#  8 9#!# 6 ( 6)  6 ( #)= A !) ! +)F 4%  .F  6#) I) )  6'  6 ! ) (=#""",!6( !()I):)<+(F  -99'  #!)N             KL M 8*     

69"!6#)I)))9#A6)=G<G999#!# !)#68=6-99





12$%1%&&2