Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/372/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/372/2007 AI generated

Tax Assessment of Intangible Assets (Goodwill) Valuation Dispute

Case Number ATAS/372/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant challenged a judgment upholding a tax assessment, arguing that the taxing authority miscalculated the value of intangible assets, specifically goodwill, when valuing the business for property tax purposes, contending that the required use of a specific valuation method yielded an arbitrary and excessive result. The court reasoned that the taxing authority's method, which relied on capitalization of earnings to derive the intangible value, was a permissible, standard approach under the relevant statutes, and that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the resulting assessment was so excessive as to be illegal or that the methodology was applied arbitrarily or based on clear error, thus affirming the lower court's decision to uphold the assessment.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Assessment of Intangible Assets (Goodwill) Valuation Dispute: The court reasoned that the taxing authority's method, which relied on capitalization of earnings to derive the intangible value, was a permissible, standard approach under the relevant statutes, and that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the resulting assessment was so excessive as to be illegal or that the methodology was applied arbitrarily or based on clear error, thus affirming the lower court's decision to uphold the assessment.

Keywords

AI generated
valuation of business assets tax assessments intangible property goodwill value in dispute property tax

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs are imposed on the appellants as they lost the appeal.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           &'()&*++, &-.*&*++.



#  /#   #  

01  2 % - 3  *++.        !" # !    ! !" $ %& !'()"(  !*"(  +(         (   &&, &  "7  * &     &-  & *  &      .  / 0) &(%123   4  $  - ()  !56 &  

              ! "# $% % 

  58:  

 4 

<= >1!( 5;>)566;9?!@!0  0 '!?( .%'? /'" )  !" <9:6("<9A9!" ( 59><9B2=

5= &@77A  '(7 >1!('"("  "(C'( D*"(( * )'(1'!(" ) '")E '7D'@ "'C (!1=

2=  '"  ) ( ) "7(7  9 ! 566; (  >1!(  0 '!?("("(!<;!566; 0 " 'D%'?  !((F(7"=

A=  0 "(" '(! ((( '")E '('"((( "7 '( !!D !(( )D (!1((59><9B2( 9!566;=

A= *((!"' 0 "'! *"(07()(G

&    55 ! 566;   &&  ,   &   * &        & -  &  *  &          .  / ((( F D ! (77" '<>)<99A!(( ) !"'( <22*B237=A:("H(9!566;!'=

"( *C(( !'( )  (( &% (!' ( !'(D ! ()""'(!(  *(( '0D ' <9B2=  * ' ( ' "(" ! F (())77(""=

& !   0  "     '   <: )!0 566; '"")()"( *77(("( <>)<9B: 2< I( <9B: ( ) !0"  <B (0 <9B: F  !   '(( ( 9;27=9:!'( @?D'(=

 !  D( F   "(" 77" '?  ' 7 ( (  $ & $  J% . ) ==  .&&&/& D(7"")F-    &&  *&& D%!H!(7""C%'?  && & &     & & &&  #&=56>( 566;&4&&- "")K'(( 0'1   ' '"(" ( * "1!( (7"" '?  4  $

    89:38566; 28:  

   < >) 566; "(( '"" D *(' , &  .&&&/  )( 7"  '  @1   1(   '")E '7=

& <9>566;4  $  7!"D )  ! "(( 3A5*B;97=;:(( L<83<;658 ( <6*55:7<:' 0'1 L523A:6("H(9!566; !'=

B=  !(("("(!C'(> ( D"D*F "7( *0)( *5)566BH(( ((0=

:= *0 *0>(  "7C""("1 "F>1=



  

<= *(=5: 7" "0'1 '")E'7 )))(() (" <B "!0<992.-/(")1 <>)5666?1'"   )=D>(( ' M '(( (F'(1.(=<55(<52   )% / >1   )!'"(( *(=B2=< 7" " '")E '7  5: > <935 ./ ( F ?)  0 (  '<I(5662 ('?D*77  "("(!.(=<A5 /C"( *77'(10  "  "'(( "(!"'>1  )=

5= &*(=55-.)()1 '<>)5666/  )  '((  ( D (  !1 ( '(1" 7!"!( C(=<55<52<A<(<A5 N(=2F: -*''D( '1!((F(7".=</=@D>('((  (F'(1' F 77"('(( (1!("  )  0 '1 C(( ")(!(  !!(  ) (  '(( (1!(" ) 0'1C((")(!( !!(  !1.7=(=5A-/=>( F  '((  ( ( F *)  0 '1 C((  !!(     !1  ("H(   !!(  ) . - <53  526N -<59AAA/=

2=  M'?  >1  '!? (  " ( C '(   D* "(( * )'(1'!(" ) '")E'7 D ' @  "'C (  !1=  ( '(( ( M

    89:38566; A8:  

'( !159><9B2 M('(9!566; (FD >1!(  )( )C"(=

A= &  !( ' (  '(( D '  !  (  3:5*99A7=36.3A5*B;97=;:O<6*55:7=<:/= D' !  (  <22*B23 7= A:=  ("H( ( ">F "(" " '  (((  '")E "7 =  !  (FC%"'!((  A5;*A9B 7= A6 .3:5*99A 7=36 G5/ (  !   ( ;;*3;9 7= 56 .<22*B237=A: G 5/  ( D *(  !  D ( F  C%"'  !(( 2:9*;537=56=

:= 7!"!( F  >'  '  > "(!( '  '(1 >D*!!( (7( '(( (  !>( )"0""7 (('(( (F ("H(!'( !(( %= ("H(("(C!!!"1*(=<5 * '")E'7)))(() ("  <3 ) <93A . 5/    (C "1!(  % ( '" . -'0"2;865 <3>(5662/=

;=  "!!(   'K  '"  "(( 1(( .(= B2 = 5  ( 39$=< '"  !(() <5'(!0<93:/=

    89:38566; :8:  

  5 4   /#   #  

%

67 8 00 9  :        ; < 2,* $=

<= )(  4  $   F (7"  !'(   !! 2:9*;537=56F &&,  & * &     &-  &  *  &          .  /  7)   !   D  ("H( !'(     "( ?9!566;>D*!!( (7(=

5= ME !((D 0=

2= 7!  '(   DM ')( 7!  (  '"( H(   "  26 > ?  (7( '?  0 7" " .&@PQ@7D;;66A  /') !(?  ( '07!"!(C(=35 7" " 07" " <B > 566: . -/N  !"!   (  D   !(7 ( !E ')('(1( ( ! (N ( H(  "  0 7" " ' ) '(  ' ) "(D C  (  *(= A5  -=  '"( H( (  '?  '  ()D"!!!E ') )(H(>(F*)=  177?  " (G     % R 4  

'7! '"(H(((7"C'(DMFM777" " '177

    89:38566;