Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/365/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/365/2005 AI generated

Easement Scope Expansion Under Prescriptive Use

Case Number ATAS/365/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellate court reviewed a lower court's grant of summary judgment in a dispute concerning the scope of an easement, where the easement holder sought to expand its use beyond the original prescriptive period grant to accommodate significantly larger and more frequent loads than originally contemplated. The court affirmed the summary judgment, reasoning that the easement, originating from a prescriptive use that established a right-of-way adequate only for the existing agricultural vehicles of that era, could not be unilaterally expanded to accommodate modern, heavier commercial tractor-trailers without permission from the servient estate owner, as such an expansion substantially and unreasonably burdened the servient land beyond the scope established by prescription.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Easement Scope Expansion Under Prescriptive Use: The court affirmed the summary judgment, reasoning that the easement, originating from a prescriptive use that established a right-of-way adequate only for the existing agricultural vehicles of that era, could not be unilaterally expanded to accommodate modern, heavier commercial tractor-trailers without permission from the servient estate owner, as such an expansion substantially and unreasonably burdened the servient land beyond the scope established by prescription.

Keywords

AI generated
easement scope of review agricultural land commercial use geographic scope of the infringement scope of expropriation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs, which is mentioned in order 2.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               %&'%'(() "%*+,%'((,

 "

 "  -"   - - 

'.  /0  $ *  '((, 



1"  " ""  " !  &#  !"#$%



'"#

23333333333   (#





          ! "  #$

   )*+,)  

&#'-#'-".- #"/0# &"1'00'-"-'$2 3-#*4425

0#' #5

  (--"    (# 0#''  0# 36&"  #-7  0#&-8# -"  $9 '&7# *442 1##:"  0-'  $,  &7# *442  # "#""-'(--""1'#'#0#-1-"#"-';( #-#*44<5

-'&0#"-'0#'0#"-&#"*9#-*44<5

 1'#-"#"#0#"-.-0# '-".&'"""'" =*9#- *44<0#'- " ",2>?4?(#@;4A'-"&'"""'"("# %3'#&'- '&0"# %3'#B"## 6 %#-'*>444(#@0#&'-0#&-8#('-% (-#-*44<5

CDDDDDDDDDD1E"66 "0#-7''".1')0-&"1 &-" &'"""'""-&& -"&"/-6-71##:" #-7""-"# &- 5

1-'-"1" #-#"'#.-&""#&%0#' #@

  - " 1  "  -"   - - 

$ 5//   6

7/8   9  6   5: ;+' <=

$@ ' " %  F  G    G      .   &'"""'"=*9#-*44<0#'- " ",2>?4?(#@;4"0'##:"# # 6 %#-'*>444(#@0#&'-0#&-8#('-%(-#-*44<@

*@ '"%HDDDDDDDDDDG .11E66@

,@ 1E'&"".7'-@

2@ -" .1   ')0-&" 1 &-"   "'"-"    #  -" -&& -"&"/-6-70# "##:"""-"#&- @

<@ -".0#' #"6#"-"@

  ),+,)   9@ 00-"-'1#"@<4 -('#&0#"-.10"('#&# #'#'"#0# "##:" -,43'#8'"-(-"-'0#0- #'&& #  #-7(  ##GI-J#'(.-99442   "#'-/&0-#@ -0":"#0#''6 @& &'-#'-"K B--.#/"&". --'#'#" -#'7"-#-"0  --'"". 57B/0'#0'#.&'"-(-"-&0''-#&#"" "# --'5B0'#"#-6"#''#0# ""@G-& &'-# '"-" 0  "#'-  &" & #  ' ""# B 7B " B -)  #-7(  ##0'##0"##&"-8###'#.1- # ##-##7@& &'-##'#&"-'#'#&'E  0# .- #'" 3'-" -- .   --' "".  " 1'00  . " /0 - #'#"A#"@$,*$49"$4?B@





 6#((-#K  # -"K     -## G 7G 







'0-'('#&0# "##:""'"-(- /0#"---.1%1((-(  # #'-0#6#((