Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/310/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/310/2007 AI generated

Contractual Waiver and Statute of Limitations in Breach of Fiduciary Duty Case

Case Number ATAS/310/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellate court addressed a dispute stemming from transactions occurring in the 1990s, specifically concerning the validity of a contractual waiver of rights regarding subsequent legal actions and the application of statutes of limitation to claims for breach of contract and fiduciary duty. The court reasoned that the language in the waiver agreement, which purported to cover future claims, was sufficiently clear and unequivocal to bar the litigation, especially since the parties were sophisticated entities aware of the transaction's nature. Furthermore, the court determined that the applicable statutes of limitation began to run when the underlying breach or harm occurred, as the injured party was either aware or reasonably should have been aware of the claim, thereby upholding the dismissal of the time-barred claims while affirming the lower court's findings on other aspects of the case.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Waiver and Statute of Limitations in Breach of Fiduciary Duty Case: The court reasoned that the language in the waiver agreement, which purported to cover future claims, was sufficiently clear and unequivocal to bar the litigation, especially since the parties were sophisticated entities aware of the transaction's nature. Furthermore, the court determined that the applicable statutes of limitation began to run when the underlying breach or harm occurred, as the injured party was either aware or reasonably should have been aware of the claim, thereby upholding the dismissal of the time-barred claims while affirming the lower court's findings on other aspects of the case.

Keywords

AI generated
statutes of limitations fiduciary contract breach of duty waiver of right contractual damages legal entity

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               "#$%"&''$ "()'"&''*



 +, ++,  +   ,

-. / ! &) . &''* 



 !"#$%&$''" $ (&$'')$*+  



$

,,     ( --  *  ! $"& './0!   



            !

   *4166*  

+ 0

67  8*#9:(&;!&%6/26!'(<#$<! $%  - '# 6/==  >$& ' "?% # ' "@ '  AB$"$#9'($#C - 7

47  ($ $%&  #$& $$ ' $% '9  6= D$ 4554!   ' %< &'%$! #&$ '# 4555! ' &#E&! ' AE< '$ $ "A<!    ! E"$< $ "&'* $$$'(&7 *(##'($%$&#F'#7

G7 ''(#$'<#"#.!(&&$& "HI#$"&'&&63F&%455G# ! E<7 *  '<$>& ' ' $&*$ $ ".F '#4555!F$$H&#'.$#B$&'''$!>(&$$ '&#F7 (<<%$ ' '  4554  $)&  #$& $$ ' $% '9 D$ 45547 -  "&'!  #$$ ##$ $ $$ #.E>"$>#E.>"$!%#$$ <$$9 "$&! '(#$ F$! (I#"$ 'FF"$  F@7 (I" >  "$& '&'$"$%'"$<&&!.#E%*'$   "A!  "$$ F$ <F$%7  #$ ' FA".< &$$ #$F7  '<#E '   "A  &%&$#'J$$$ '&<&&$%<F$%$ 'K%455G "$$$&%'>('9$$E$*##E.#$& G* 3$ 3* L7 (#$& ' $%  "A$ K$F& "  ##$ ' $$  ##'"$#A&$&<$'"''$%!'$%$& &<9$'#$&!%(''(*%'$&7

37 (&  '&#& #9 ' (FF $ ' (*%'$& 8*#9 : ( ;'"''$'(%'$&'$'6GK455G7

L7    EF ' > 'K$  '&#$"$ '  > $ '"$<  '>&! '  ##$ "&' ' 4 K$ 455G! %  #$$ '#  62 '&"A 45547   $$&  '"$ '("#$' ' E % H <E! ' "A$ %! &#! EE '!  > (I" > H  %I &$$ "7 (I" <>  #&$$ # '("$&! H (I#$ '( E.#$E&%'F$&''$7-! #$>&  / K% 455G  % ' E % "$$  '9$ $E ##E. #$&!  < ' E '  " '&A7('(&#'$'46"455G"$$$&%'"" $'#$E'*&#I$$E"*%'9$7A >#&$$<"#$$%'E%$"A! '$ $$ "A$ '7  ##$ (M$ ' $$"$



1/2314552  *G166*   #E.$E&#$>"#$'$$"$$<>!$$# ' ,$! N.#I $ -$7 - ! (&$$ ' #$$ &$$ $$ $  #$&'$%&$$#$A'("&$#'""&'! #& >! "  # ' " #F7  #$ '&#'$H%&$$"$'(&$$'&#F'(&$'&%$7  I" "#&"$  "A$ &7    $ #&& >( '&"A4554!#$$(%$#%OAK$F'OIPQ#$I %$'9%!'.'"'&#F7

27   ##$ ' = K$ 455G!    ! < $ "&'*$$$ ' (&!  '<$>& ' $A '&<&&$F ' E '#>$>(&$$'&#F&%9'#K4554!<<%&# '&9 ' #9 ' (&  K 4554! % ' ' $$  ' "A$##$'&#E&>$'$$A$$"$ $<>7 '>&>$$"$-$$,$$%$5!L!H $$ ' '&$$$ $ # F$  ""! (%$ #" >( &<9 '"$'&#E&7(&%$##.E$E&##9'  !"&$(&$$7

07 6#$"A455G! !#.E$'(&#$#$<!  #&  '<$ '(&#' '&#F ". 8, G476;  > ' %AE<'$'#4555!%<<%$45547#$' (& $$  "I ' $M$! ' H   % $ "A! I A! $""$ '$! % $ ' F""$ $ H  K"A '$!  >( E" $$ $ <&7  "&'  $$& AK$%"$  #$$ $! #$ # '  &"$! (&%$ F"$! % # F&>$##$%'!>(">'F! F$<A$&$$'#''$M$7(%&$A '  #$&   #$$& "#$"$ ' $ ! $F">K$Q''&#!"<7 -!'&9'A*#9$'#9'#$$4554$<<%&(&$$ '&#F7F"&$$#$&'$%'$&$$7

=7  '& ' 6 $A 455G! (   " (&  A&&F '( $$#F#'&$"#A$&'&$7

/7 ##$$"&''46"4553' F"&(&$$' $& $$ ' (& '# D$ 45547  $$"$ $$ '$> H $&#&&'""$7 #.E$ ##&$<' $' (*%'$& F 'J##$  &# # & H  >$ ' &>'($$$H$&#$&'$%7

657  ##$ "&' $"&' ' = K 4553 '      F"& (&$$ $$ ' (&!  "'F$ ' $$"$7 



1/2314552  *3166*   (%<$####$$'($%$&#F$&! ''&%>&#$A'"$%$7 %$ &<"$ER(&(A'")$'<F@$# ""7 &%$>$'($$%$&'#$&7

667 -$ H  ##$ ' % ' &'#$$ #F $ ' , ! (   '<$&  I#$ $'# E"$<> $ #.E$> #9 ' $ '(I#$ "&' H 9% 8*#9 :  ;! '  42 K% 455L7   (! E"$<!  $$&>(&#&$$''E>'E$'> H&<"A%'$''""A#&$ F& '$7 (I" > $ <> ( #'$ # "  &%'"$$F$AK$%7 %#.E$>!  !#.E$!F"&'<$'(&#''&#F".% .'""$>8,G4766;!'#"'I7 "!I#$ $ $ > (& %$  #$& ' $% ' L5S! ' ($%$& I& K>(  ' $$ $ $%$&!  > #'$ H I E #K%'"$''"$'GGS%!'9D$45547$ #Q&   "  # '( &$ #F! > #"$$  A"$ ' I< ' #'$ #$Q$ >( &'$ ' $"# ' #&!>(%'"'#$&H(&$$'&#F'(&!I"#$ '$!"$$$?%##$<F'&I%"$#$>7

647 $$'0%455L!( $$&($$$'(&A<$' '"'""<#$$"$'&>$$K$!%'(I#$ '  !'#'$$"$'&>$7

6G7 G6"60K455L!(&&$&%# $'$E&#A9%' $8*#9: ;!#$A'&#F&$!&#'$".  .'" "$> 8,GG765;7 - $$"$ "&'"$I  &$& "'F& #'IF$#"!P $ !&<9 "&$'."#$"$<'7

637 $$'4GD$455L! '"'&"&'* ' (  ' '&  # %$  $$ '  #$$7   $$& > (& $   $$"$ # $'&# FF$7 - !  "&'$ $'$ #   ( # $A& H "& (&$$ '&#F ' #$$7

6L7 ##$$"&''43$A4553! '>& >(&$$'#$$&$$$$'#D$4554!<<%$7 *  #&$$  $"$ #.E"$! ' 'FF$& '($$$ $ ' $$$$E."A&7#.E$F"$$$#$& '$%'$$$%$&7



1/2314552  *L166*  

627  '& ' = '&"A 455L! (   $.& H (&  '"*$ "# '(%'$& '9  6 D$ 455G!   F'$  (I#$ $'#'4553!$H(&#$&'$%' (''L5SA'$%$&$&>'$%$&'#$&7

607   ' 6/ '&"A 455L! (&  F$ ##$ H  $$ '&! '"'$ ($ '( $ $9!  "$F >( $$ ' ' #$$>(A<$HE<%$'#$!("#ME$'('  &# '  $BE >$' $  '$ " #$$ %  F$$"$&$A$7

(##'##$!K$$F$"&'I'   ' 0 %"A 455L! '     ' 6  '&"A 455L $ '   ' L '&"A 455L!  > $$$$ > (& $  $$ #$&'$%7

6=7 -$H'"''( '2K%4552! &$.& $F$ "&'! #&$ >  "$# I" "&'I #$>&  455G*4553  "$$$ #  &%' '  "&' "K!   .'"'&#F"K7(&$$'$&#.E>'#$$#"$$$#!  !  # ' $% "M" H $"# #$7   K$ H    ##$ ' ( $ ' &'#$$ #F H *&K %$  #&' ' 62 K$  66 %"A 455G! H  ' $ '"*K& # "7$<''FF$&'""$%(&!> ##F@!$##$!%'(FF$!'%'# (##$<'$$<7 (&$##$9$%$!$H"$$  "%"$! ' $ >  '"$ ( # M$ >$F&7 (&  &$& '&& "" #$  #"$ '  >> $%$& #F7

6/7 63F&%4552!( K$&(##$'(&$"$'& ' = '&"A 455L!  "$F >( (I$$  F$ % AK$F '# (I#$  7  $$  $ ' ##$ $" >  A$ (%$#&$&#$"7

457 $'&62"4552 A'&!"#&$&#&$'4L #$"A 4552! (&  $K$&  $ $$ '& $  H ($''&$#!%''H($"&#% $$$!A'"$!H($'($$9'(%'$&!$ ''&#79<>$F$"&'I##$##''( $%$& '$$ '  # &7 !   &$ #F #%$ #)$#A4554!$K'(E'%$$"$"#A!% '$F$"&'' $'##$'( $'&'#$$ #F'*-&K'455G7



1/2314552  *2166*  

467  &# ' 44 " 4552! (     K$ '  $ H  F"$''&$$>&7

447 '$'6%"A4552($$'%$ A'&' ' "#$ # ' #$7  $$ !  $  '>& >(%$$&#$<!"F@7%$F& ##& '  ' ' ( $ ' &'#$$ #F   ($"$ $!&$$'&KH"'H$$&#>7 $$%$&!$$> # E$  #! #F # "#<  &#  ""7   %$H/E!E$%44E$#$K&H<'$&&%7 %$'$"#H$%$''IAI*F9$97%$' "$<"H9%7  '>&> &#&$$  A&&F'($'(%'$&7

4G7 -!&$&<'&HK<7

+ 

67 <%J<$K'8;&$&"'F&$$$&!'9 6D$455G! A$'!"#&'LK<! '$#&'$$%*#&'$!L##&$$62K<8$76$7 $L2 ;7

-$HJ$'J&$'62K<!# AF&'& 40K%45538 ,6G5652;!' <%'#$&!6GF&% %$!  '#$ $$ <$ #"$$$  A $ '   ' &<   H $ K< $$! ! ' J$$$'J&$'%IK<7

47 F"&"$ H ($7 L2  $7  E74 !  A $ '   )$  $ > ' $$$ #&% H ($7 L2 '   F&'&   #$ <&& ' '$ '   ' 2 $A 4555 8 ;>$$%H(*%'$&'6/K6/L/8 ;7

-"#&$#K<''J#9$&$A7



1/2314552  *0166*   !$K$&62"4552$'&##$'63F&% 4552!$%A>$HF"$I'&&<I8$7L2$25 ;7

G7 (AK$'$<#$(&%$'$H$$9'(%'$&F% '$!$#''"*$$.&#($"&7

37 $&#$&%'$&!(#$&'<$$#$#&"&#"$  ' < '&! &$$ '( F"$& <&$! '( "'  '( '$8$7=76 $376 ;7(#$&'<$'&F"" '"$'("A'(#$'#A$&'<'(& "E& ' $% &>A& > $  '&$!  $$ '"$ &$ '($$$H$&#E.>"$$>(#$#9$$"$ $  " ' &'#$$ I<A 8$7 0  ;7  &%  $I '(%'$&!  % > (& $ # A$ ( (&$$ # %' $ "#& %  >( #$ A$  I@$ ($%$& > #$ A"$ M$ I<& '  #9  $$"$ $  " ' &'#$$!"E&'$%&>A&8$762 $$74=74 ;7

 %$ ' J$7 4= 7 6   8'  % $&  6 K% 4553;! J&'$H$$9J$%'H2241GS"!H'"* $J$%'HL5S"!H>$'$J$%'H35S  "T '   #&A! J& #$! 'J#9 J$7 4= 7 6A  ! #&$' H  '"*$ J $ %' H 35S  "7 9  6 K% 4553!J&'$H$$9J$%'H05S"!H$* >$'$($%'H25S"!H'"*$J$%'H L5S"!H>$'$J$%'H35S"7

L7 $$$H$&#.E>#%$!""$$$#E.>!$)  %'$&   ' ($7 3   8  % ($7 =  ;7 -%$  EFF 6550 '   ' J, - $ J%'$& $ J"#$ ' J*%'$&8  ;!#'J$$$H$&"$#.E> >'!   'J F"$& <&$! 'J '$  'J "'!  I$  $A ' F$ "$! $$! <$%  &"$! #"$  ' < '&! > #$ "<&  " $E&#$>$ $)#$&'$%'A!#$$$7  '(I$'($$$H$&#.E>##'(A' #& '( '<$ &"$ '( I#$ 8#.E$; $ (##.$ < $   $9 '( .$9" ' F$  8 , 6G5  G/= 7 '7L7G $ '7 2;! >  $$ # H    A FF$ # H%'$&7'9#""'&>'(&$$ #.E> "'F! ' # "" ' FF$ H #'  E< # (*%'$&!  '"$ '  #$& ' < > (& #$ "#MEF$#%'A%$&T"'>$I<A'$



1/2314552  *=166*   M$'&$"&AK$%"$>#A8 ,65462LT-4556#7443 '74A$&F&TF7 ,6404/='73F;7

  >   '<$ ' '&#! %$ #& # ' * #.E$!$FF$#&%$'#$&'$%7$ FF$ & 'JAK$% J J<$ 'J &#' '&#F $$  'J $A FF$F <% 'A7  '$   #$ %  $$"$ ###&$'#A7

-K#'!F$#.EI$F<$# "A'$$$H$&#$A'J$)#$&'<  ' J$7 = 7 6   8F7 $7 3 7 6  ;7  >J %'$& $ !  $ &! ' E> ! >J A$$ "&' #$$! $%$  #$& ' $% 8$ ' <; ' "9 "#$$! $ "  &%' #  "&' #&&7  $ $$$ #.E>! > '$ M$ '$<&'F$$!$>'$'"9$"F #$& ' $%! $ &  '&F$% # > J # # 'J%'$&8 ,6404//'7LFT M$G=415G'46K%4553 '7G76;7 %E!HUJI#$9%#J$>'&&"$ > $%$  I#$ $   '  E"# $  #.E!J. #'J$$$H$&H$9%'$8-4555#7 6LL;7

27  (##&$ ' &&"$ "&'I!  A F&'& '   #&&8 ,64LGL6;>##'A##&$'#%! >(##>A#&''"$$%>(#&''' '$'"$$F8$735 ,&$%($76/ T$7/L74 %$766G$6G4;!('"$$K<##&A"$ #%!M$&#'9<F"!#&'$H##&$ "#9$$<'#%7(&&"$'&$"$#%#A$ '( $F$ "&' ($   <   '&<$   F" '( ##$'(I#$!"A$A$7 $&<'!"#$> #$$<I"#$$$F$(AK$'(&$'F&!>##$ F'  ' I" "#$! >( # &<"$  '&$  #$ I#"&! >( $ &$& &$A  #  ' ' 8"9;!>'#$'$F& "&'$$F> '(I#$$A"$%&7

-(<$ '  % #A$ ' ##$ &$A #  "&' $$$!  K<#$$'$$"#$'F$>!(I#&!"&'$$$$ <&&"$!''$!H#'#$##$$' $'F>($H'7 !K#''# '#'I$$$F$##&$>(H(##&$'(#$&



1/2314552  */166*   '$%#"&''F"8 ,64LGLG'7GA1$&F&! 6//L!#733T 6/==#7L53'74;7

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

,$'$$>$$I#$#"$'&$ #$'$!"&<"$"97$'D"$ "$%&! ' $ > $$ I#$ %M$  # % #A$7 -  '<$#&#I#$'$%I'"&'.$% $! $  ($ #   '  &> '  '&# 8,G4766;   #$& ' $% ' $7  $ &<'!  '%< $  #$& #$ ' $% $ #  I#$ $ ! I$$! $$& #  'FF&$ "&' %$  $  &$& 'D"$! $ ' F@ %$! I#>& #  #"7  $  FF$ "$ ' % "&'I ' ' > (#$& ' $% >( $ $ ER  $   #$ # F$ $$#.EI'$F&# I#$7 ! ' $ F$  #%$ F<  "A ' $$$ H  $& #$A 'J$)  #$& ' <   K#'7  %$



1/2314552  *65166*    ' % > #"   I#>$  'FF$& ' $ H &$&<"'#F$%">'"$%$!> #$ M$ $ ' (&%$ ' (#$& ' <   ' (* %'$&7  '& '  > #&9' > (I$ '( #$& ' $% #$!$>($"&#I#$!###&$'&>$' $$ ' $7 ($ ' H K$ $$ > ($"& ($ F'&  $$ I#$#F''&!>F"&# A7

=7 &$$!K$&7





1/2314552  *66166*     0 , +, ++,  +   ,

!

12343.. 5  633 3  78 )$& , 9

  43.

67 &%A7

! 43

47 K$$7

G7 $>#&'$<$$7

37 F"  #$ '  >J #%$ F"  $  #&$ M$ '  '& ' G5 K '9  $F$ #9 ' A F&'& 8-EVREF>2!2553  ;!#%'"$9''$ #A!F"&"$I$7=4'F&'& AF&'&'60 K 455L 8 ,;T  "&" '  '$ '>  ! "$F $ ".'#%$#$<$'$'"'$T'$ M$ '&  A F&'& # % #$  # % &$> I '$ ' ($7 34  ,7  #&$ M$ $  #9  # ' $!%>&""".'#%!'%$M$K$H(%7



   <FF  #&'$      P   - .         &$*K$:  -'   

#F"'#&$M$$$F&I#$>JHJFFF&'& '#<FF



1/2314552