Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/296/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/296/2005 AI generated

Statutory Interpretation of Fund Recovery Prerequisites

Case Number ATAS/296/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerned a dispute over the application of statutory provisions regarding the recovery of certain funds, where the appellant argued that the lower court misinterpreted the scope of a governing statute, particularly concerning the timing and prerequisite conditions for filing a claim. The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute clearly dictated a specific procedural sequence and that the lower court's interpretation improperly expanded the scope of applicability beyond the explicit legislative intent regarding the relevant time limitations and required notices, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent as the lower court correctly applied the governing text.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Fund Recovery Prerequisites: The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute clearly dictated a specific procedural sequence and that the lower court's interpretation improperly expanded the scope of applicability beyond the explicit legislative intent regarding the relevant time limitations and required notices, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent as the lower court correctly applied the governing text.

Keywords

AI generated
interpretation of a judgment statute of limitations filing of a claim procedural limitations statutory right of pre-emption seizure of funds

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$%&#'%%& #'()#'%%&



 *+ +  * +

),  -  ! .. / '%%& 



   0000000000 

 !

1 ! !  2 ! '3  '%%4 '(

! 

* !5    55 "##   $ '( % !&

                !"

   -,&.-  

/0! 1211!!1(,31,45 &$6+&,,7 &+.8&,,! &8+3&,,9 ( !1 !   !12 !    :!!  ! 1

/ ?? !;  @!1A''(11!1A/ ;; 1!1 ( ';/' B !;C *$$4,664*$$.6$84%!*,$*.+3)7

/0! 12('',8:A1,.'!1A2  1!:!';/'>/ !/0! 1211!!1(;'1!'7

    'A11  D;  (1!  ABE  $3  ,+ 1!:!' ; /';F 12!  1! !>/!1  /0! 1211!!1(;'1!'7

!!   1! G   /!# )*    1   ; ' 11!!1A  $, ;!2 $8)+ 5 9 1 C  1 > 'A11   G   ((1 'H' ;  '11 '(11!1A1;;I!J

9 G/ 1 '1!'!21;; ';' / !1F 1(''11 7 29 G  (1!    C  ;A  AB ! 1; !! B1!! G   !; A1! I! 1A G; ';''!7 9G;1A!'11 !1!; ;!(1!1A G'!'!21; ;1F7 9 G  :11!1  / ; !!'  !1  1   ;!1  1F >  !!'1:!1( 7 9G:11!1 G1!!'/'!1!; ; '  1/   G 1; 1!1 '!1  !'!'A1 '7

/!#)$#$ ;'A 1!G'A11  1!0!';'1!> :11!1 G1'11 ! 1 1F' A! !1( 'A11 7

 /!#3, /! 1!' ;!1!!1 ;'2; '11   1!  !1A' '!    1(!! 1A2  :! 1(!!( '7

//;FG!1 A211!';!! A!F  G-1 1!! !(@ 0!:!'7

/((!/1A G(1! A/!#)*;'1!' F   G / ;!   2  > A G/ / @ >  :   B;1!1   (1!1 ''!G1;!!!> ?? /B1H    !  ;C   *$ $4,664  *$$.6$84 % ! *, $*.+3)  ! /!;!;'!;1F>/;;1G/A1!/;;GD21



&)*+&,+  -4&.-   1!0!;1 1'!1  !1!>G/((1' ?? A!  12E7

/>!'H;'!;G 1!21 !1!1!(1! A G/  ; A1!  I!  1A G   ; ' A!  12 11!!1(7

/! !'!!A1/-1!!!'),+

G /' /A1! ; @  21 ;  ,$ ' > G  '(F!  ; 1!1!1H15(# ?,+8&,+4*,+9#

/ 'G'A11 :!'7

/1:!1(1 !/1(1H>' !(#4#- !#6$!# 1('';!1H'' 1! 1 6 ! 2,5 9!)8K#$ 7





&)*+&,+  -.&.-  

*  6 + *+ +  * +

!

75828   9  :88 8  ;" .)' + <

$# :!!'A11 7

4# (   ;!1   G/ ;A! (     !  ;'! 0!   '1  4* :  F   !1(1!1  ; ;1  ' '  12 (''   ?LM1NL (G1 6 6.     ! 1 B;1#  '1  ;! 0! ;  H'#  ' 1  1!J 9 11G B!!G'11  !'1 2!11!;'11  !!G'7 29 B;  ;  G  !1( 1 !1 ; A 1  !! ! '11 7 9 ; !  1H!      ;'!!# ?1  ' 1   !1! ;  ! 1 ''! '''   !! 9 29 ! 9 1-  12(''; ;!!1F G/1 A'1A2#' 1 !1   C  ;A G1  ! : 1! 11 G  '11  !!G' ! /A ;;  G'!'B;'1' !5!#$4,$*6!$*)9#  H((1FJ  '1!J   C? '1%   

  ;1  (   ;'! 0! !  !1(1' B ;!1 > /((1 (''   !';21G11G/ 1211!!1(;H((



&)*+&,+