Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/270/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/270/2005 AI generated

Contractual Damages Causation Dispute

Case Number ATAS/270/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant sought to recover property damages arising from a contractual dispute, arguing that the appellee breached an agreement by failing to perform required work, resulting in financial harm. The court reasoned that the evidence presented by the appellant was insufficient to definitively establish a direct causal link between the alleged breach and the specific damages claimed, noting that the contractual terms regarding performance standards and remedies for non-performance were ambiguous or not strictly adhered to by the appellant in their proof. Therefore, the court affirmed the judgment in favor of the appellee, concluding that the appellant failed to meet the burden of proof for both breach and resulting quantifiable loss.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Damages Causation Dispute: The court reasoned that the evidence presented by the appellant was insufficient to definitively establish a direct causal link between the alleged breach and the specific damages claimed, noting that the contractual terms regarding performance standards and remedies for non-performance were ambiguous or not strictly adhered to by the appellant in their proof. Therefore, the court affirmed the judgment in favor of the appellee, concluding that the appellant failed to meet the burden of proof for both breach and resulting quantifiable loss.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual damages proof of causation settlement of dispute financial loss the term 'judgment' breach of maintenance obligation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the losing party to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

   

!""!#$$% &!#'$!#$$%

&

( &) ( &*  ( *)

+, -. /  % 0 #$$%

  

1* &)* &) 2* &  + 3(  12( ( *   !"# $% & '( ) *

"+

455555555556,  -+

              % '.1 %

 1)&

2#   " 34444444444!)+ 5%6+7  ! " 8 6 6+ 6+#  ! " 9" --   2+ "$+ 2//:  "7+  6+7   ;       <   9 !!   ;     !  5%6+7  ;"8# %  + )  ! "  """"  6+ => ) 9""  ?@ 6+ +   @9 " 66 A """" "= B "   6"  ""#

'#  ! "  9" 6 -+  )  $&"  6>+  """  ""  "  "+"  6+ =>, ) " & @9 22 - =++ '00',  6" A "  6+ B 6+ ""   C  1D'// -+# E0, > 6+  " +F" G@9 H2 + '00'#

H# !" )  + "   ;",  +66+" 9--" =  ! "  6+ -  'I - =++ '00'#

E#  'H + '00E, + + @"   ;", D--  6+" "  -" 5%6+7 D--8  "- )  ! "  "  6>+ J 0E 2HH120  6+  ""  (DEI0 -+# 10 = " +F" ) E,1K 7  'E

- =++ '00E, 6 E' -+# /1 ) ""+ 9" +F"  2+ G=+ '00'  'H - =++ '00E#   $"+  -" 66"  "  6>+#

1#  2H G=+ '001,  ;"    +$    D   +  +", @ +" L6+ " " 66"#    )  "  D" +   6"  ED1(2 -+# /0 &"  " +F"    2+ G=+ '00'  'H - =++ '00E  E' -+# /1, 6 " +F" ) E,1K +  +   6" 7  'E - =++ '00E,  @  -+  6+" " 9"  100 -+# 6+ = 6+  +7&" +  -+, 6+" " &+"  "+" 9--"#

(# "+ "+ ",   6+"  "  6>+ "- , 9L"+"

 6" A "  6+ B,  "+" 9--" " 9+  @   6"  "" 6+    2//: ) '00', 9"""" "=  2+ G=+ '00' "  ""+  + "#

:#  ! "  " ="  )   "++  2: G=+, 6  / + '001#   9" 6 -" #

I# !+ @,    " &+  ) G&+#

.//.'001 % H.1 %

 *)&

2#   &= + 9+&" G+ 58  " -  "  "" , 7  2+ C" '00H,  +$ "  + , 6  1 G&, "  6+ " "  =%6+ ", 1 66 " " 2( G& + 5+"# 2 "# + " 1( 8#

!" ) 9"  9 "  2( G& +, 6+  +$ -  +  ': G=+ '00E 5 ; 2H0  20(8,  +  &=  6" ,  2H

- =++,  6" "+"+ +&" 6+"""  +$ "  +    &+  + ) "+ G& ""+, ,  9"""  9 "  =L G& +#

'# -+ " ) D+"# 1(  # 2 "# $ ,  +$ "  +  M"  " @  """ +"= )  6+ => 6+- 66" """  6+ =>, 6>+ " >" +", > 6+    =+,  @9L 6+ ""  +6$" 5+" HH2 )

HH2    $&" N +" 1', 1(,   2, " +" :H   

-  + +  6+ => 6+-, =, +==" " ="  '1 G 2/I' %  N +" 2E'  =8#

! 6 " 6+ G&+   967 "  "$#

 6  ="  G+" 6 "",   " +=$ 5+"# 1( ""#  8#

H#   ""  + & 9+ $&"+  +  5+"# ' # 2 8#

E# ?@ "  &  "+$ @ M",  +7+ " ",  """ 66" """  6+ =>, 6>+ " >"%+"

5+"# :H # 2 8#

  9 6 "" , ) 9"+    -  + + 9+%  2I + 2//E 5 < O ! IH'#208,  6+ + 966" 6+ $  ++  "+$,  +" @  +$    6" M"+ +""

 966" -" 6+   $"+  "  6>+#

1# #     "+"  "+"= -  + 6+"" " )

6>+   9+&" " L "  6+  =   6+" 6+ "" "

",  - 6   -+,   )  G&" L "+    9+"# I0 # ' ?# '    -  + +  6+" 6+ "" "  -"  22 =+ 2II/ 5 O ! 'I2#2 N #%#  , "+   , 2/// 6# 2''( ?# E18#

$#   "  F    6   -+  "+"  "+"= " " +7+ " @ """,  96"  "*? 

.//.'001 % E.1 %

+" 6$ )  -  6+  -  +",  66"  +" -  +,  @  """ 6  -"="  =+"  +" -  + O "+" ", "    " 6"$ 9 ++ "+"- 6+7 9 "+" -  +  9 ++  +" "+"- 5  6# 2'': N #   , &"P Q$+ !?$"+$&  RS+, 2//: # +"# I0 6# H12 N # ! T , R"+ P &"P Q$+ !?$"+$&  RS+, 2/// 6# ('28# + "+"  "+"= -  + O " 6+ L" "+"  "+"= "  +7+ " %,  -"

"+  "+$L -  +L "  "+ "+"   +&"  6"  9"+" -  +  "" @9 """  96"  "*?  +" 6$ )  -  6+  -  +" 5+"# 2 # ' ""# $ "     -  + +  6+ + "+"=  '0  $+ 2/(I O  O ! 2:'#0'28#

#  +$ "  +  """  +7+ " " "  96"  "*?  +" 6$ 6",   @ 6+ 7, 6++  =   -"=, 6@, """  -,  "  6" "   )  G&" L "+# "" " " 9+   @  -" @   "7+ @ "   ++",  G&  + " --"="  G& ++  9+" :/  " @9  @" 6+ =+  66" )  6+"  """ +  - 5 ; 20/  128#

(#  967,  +$    "+ 6+ "$ @9  @" 96>+ 6"  + ,   -+ "" $&"+" +  6+  6+ => 6+-#

6" "  9$ ""  + "   ! " ,  ""+ @   6"   ;" " L" " @   -+ " $  =++    ED1(2 -+# /0 6  -+ "  " +F"#  +"  --" $- @  6 6="    $"+ 6F?  ;" 9&&+ "  "+  6+ +  +=+" - 9$"+  +   +"

5 ;" "+ # !)+  2:  $+ '00'8#

(# !9&"  -+  6+",  " 9-- 66+"  6+   $"+ +@,     967,  6+" $"" 5 2/:E  6# H' " /1 N # 

20 =$+ 2//I8#

:# 6" "   @ 6+ 7,   + #

I#   "+   ,   + 6 6+U 9 " 5+"# I/     +  6+ + "+"=  2' 6"$+ 2/I1 5 O 1 208#

.//.'001 % 1.1 %

  *&)1  &) ( &*  ( *)



7-8   6  9   3: +;# *<

  8 

2#  +   +=$#

 8

'#    " 34444444444!)+ ) 6>+ )  ;       <   9 !!   ;     !     ED1(2 -+# /06  -+ "  " +F"  @  " +F" ) E,1K +  +   6" 7  'E - =++ '00E,  -+  6+" " 9"  100 -+#

H# +  =   -"=  D66" -" 

E# "  6>+ 6+" J 0E 2HH120  )  ++#

1# " @D D" 6 6+U D "#

(# -+  6+"   @9 6=" -++ ++ "+  6+ " ++F"

     H0 G+ 7  "-" 6+ 6 + +  +$ -  +  +, !?VP+?-@ (, (00E   ,  "+ L6+#     6" F"+ 6+& #   + " W 8 @+ L"" @    ++"  + $"+   " 6     ""@ N $8 L6+ 6+ @ "-  " 6=+ + "" "+  N 8 6+"+  &"+     +6+ ""# !   +  "" 6  "+  "  +   ""+ 8 $8 " 8 %,  +$ -  +  +  6++ 6 "++  "7+ +  ++ @9 =+  ++ ++=$#   +  ++ "+ +  >  6+=, @ +" G",  @    ""@  " 9=66  @   " L6    ++" 5+"# 2H', 20( " 20I 8#

 &+--7+W  + " W

<+%  X + Y   

 6 -+  6+ " ++F" " "-  L 6+"  @9) 9-- -  +  +  6+  &+-- 

.//.'001