Enforcement of Stipulated Judgment Despite Subsequent Payment Agreement
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe case concerns a dispute over the enforcement of a stipulated judgment requiring payments, where the obligor argued that a subsequent agreement related to the payments effectively modified or superseded the original judgment's terms, specifically regarding the calculation of the required amount. The court reasoned that the stipulated judgment, which incorporated the parties' agreement, remained enforceable as a final judgment, and because the subsequent agreement did not explicitly state that it entirely discharged the judgment or modify the payment structure in the manner asserted, the original judgment's terms controlled the enforcement proceedings.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforcement of Stipulated Judgment Despite Subsequent Payment Agreement: The court reasoned that the stipulated judgment, which incorporated the parties' agreement, remained enforceable as a final judgment, and because the subsequent agreement did not explicitly state that it entirely discharged the judgment or modify the payment structure in the manner asserted, the original judgment's terms controlled the enforcement proceedings.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedRelated Decisions
AI generatedKey legal questions extracted by Legislator
AI generatedCited in order 1 to rule on the costs of the federal proceeding.
Full text
!"#$!$%%& !$"#!$%%"
'('))*) ')*(
+ ,- .& $%%"
!"#$%&$'!!'' # ( $)$# #!
!$#
* + &-# #"#&$&"#+,''-#.'. '/0 1022 3 4
.257. )')/(
#"#&$& "# #! '' #'9 $! # !' :1 # 2008 ( ; (!$# + +<++ * !''$$ !$'! &-# "'$!:=(78=-#>78%'$&#?$;8@AB:#2008$ "'$(#$('%''$&2(800-#> !'$7(800-#>"#$#'$# A :#%#'2008C
( D"! !--#'# ( &$$ &"#'- &%A# "' 21 # 200: '$ ; &''!9'%"'!"#!%'!'#-!$'!'#$#'#AE EFDC
"'$$$ $'"'$&$!$$#%' !#""!#$&' !&'"GE'$#:#!$!9#2002C
2B-&%#'#200B (--'$!(#.'%''$&H'."#A I' #!J#&('%''$&:00@AB0#2002C
("#&$& :1#200B "#$$'!"#A+<++ * J'$ $$ K J$'!'# * + ;K#&$'$--''&C
( $ = L' 200B +<++ * ( '-!#& K( ' !$#!G'$ #$ ('%''$&;:00@A:1%#'200B '#9=(76:-#>' $ " !$$ J#$' B0(000 -#> #'! #&#% :6 !%9# :===C
"# !##'# 2= !$!9# 200B +<++ * !-'#& !' # K( !'&#'$ K ('%''$& %'$ "!# !#'J' "#!9A !#$E!"&'K !9L$ #&#% !#$ K "#$$'! J#$' B: #:==='&$'$#%'C
#-'$%!'#;+<++* K!'"'$&J'#&$'$ $#!9"GE'KC
(A!#'%'$&+<++* ;'%## #&$#!$'%$:#'200B "#$$'!2(800-#>C
"# '# -'$ "#%'# ; +<++ * #$'-'$ &' &$9' :6 !M$ 200/ "# !$# $$$$ K(; '$ (!"&#$'! 2B "$9#:===EEJE %'$"#"##!$'%'$&;:00@A BL%'#2000$K"'!#'(G%'$"(##?$$#%'#$'!% EEJEC
567252008 .B57. "#!##'#6!$!9#200/ +<++* &#'$'"!&;'!# ""&$#$!##"!$80@"#$$'!#!9'J$!'##&C
+<++* "#'$'$"$;!'&##K80@('%''$&&$'$; !$'K ; %!'# -'9#!GJ' E&"$'$ $ !# !#'$;"!G!A:==/C
( #'! #- * + # ($ % (!9'J$'! (JJ# "#!&#C
#&"! ; 2 L' 2008 * + "#A %!'# "#&9$ & #$'-'$'! !!K'$&"#$' "#'$&!'!$!#L$ C
"#!#!::L'$2008 #'9&#K'(""!#$!'# #C
"#$'!$&$&'%'$&;!$#C
#'9&$"#$''!"#$'!"#! 28L%'#2006C
&-# ''K& K("#A %!'# !$& !'# ! &'. !' &$'$(%'K#&$'$9&&-'(#$;80@"!# "GE'K #$ "!# !$'K K' &$& !$$& "# #C
(&':8-&%#'#&$&!#&;&-#"!#-'#"#$ #'9 &$#'$'!$ &E&$ "!#"#!'#(%'&'&$G&!&'. !'C
"# !##'# :/ -&%#'# 2006 &-# '-!#& #'9 & K( &$'$'"!&;!#"#$$'!#&J$'#;"#$'#:1%#'200B "!#J#&('%''$&:00@$K"!%'$?$##G&#F '$; K'$C
('%'$&;&$#'# # "#!##'#B#2006 "#'$ (K'$&-#$!;K #'9&#"# !'!#!# !'$&"C
!'! # ! &$& !'K& ; &-# $ J#&;LJ#C
567252008 ./57. *)())*(
!'J%!'#N!#J'$'!L'''#HI&$&!'-'&$'$'$& A :#!M$200B #'9$!#!' !"!&8LJ !$ "#&'$$%'."#&'$ 8""&$$:6LJ#H#$>:$>#$86 IC
'$;N$'!N&$'!:6LJ# "# #'9-&&# 27L%'#200/H *:B0:06I # !'J%!'!"$& :B-&%#'# '"!'$'!$#'$!'##J$"#$$$ #'9$!#!' '&J# # ; $#!' LJ $'$'# N$$$ N&$'! !%DLJ#C
!-!#&$ ; (#$> 86 > : $> 9 #'9 $! # !' !)$ '$ 'K !$$$'! #$'% ; "#&%!G "#!-'! !""!$ '$'$$'! "#&%!G "!G# $ G$ #!'$ G !"#''%!# ''K(D"#&$$'!#"!9''$&H#$>BB:;BB: ! !9'J$'!C #$> 82 86 > : $ #$> 7B !' -&&# # "#&%!G "#!-'! %'' #%'%$$'%''$& 28L':=12.C#$>:/2 ! '%'IC
!"&$"!#LJ#N"A$''&$9'C
-!#$'AJ!!'''&-#!'(D"!'$$'! K(#&&$&JJ&H#$>7B>BIC
( (!## # &$& JJ& "# #%' ! EFDHA%IK'$&'#$#'#AE'#'$!C
!"&$#$'!$#'$!' #'9&$''&$9'C
!' # "#$' J&&# #!'$ # !' 6 !$!9# 2000 H I $#&%'J#:#L%'#200B ($"""'9D'$'J$'A# C
(!%#$# ($'! "#&% ; (#$> 7B > : ($ !' ! $ ; (!9#%$'!(&'H+ !$$'D#!'-&&#$ "#!&# $! ' L#'"# EO$!' =1/ "> :=C + 4< 3 4.4 4 ' E$"-J E +3+ :=1B "> :12IC
$A!##%9C
(' ""#$ "$ K( ($ " '#'J& !$# &9'$#' "#$$'! ; %!'# * '!$#J$'!'#.'C
567252008 .857. (' #&$ $!$-!' &K'%!K !#" K ('$$'! #&$'$(J'#!$# * C
.' ($# "#$ K'& ; #$'-'$'! ! "#$' &-#C
(' G ' !&K #$'-'# .' K $ '#'J&!$#* + C
&-#&#&"$#(!#"#$$'!#&J$'#A:1 %#'200B "!#J#&('%''$&:00@ $K'#'';C
('!%'$("##$C
#!"'$!:=(78=-#>78%'$&#?$; 8@AB:#2008$"'$(#$('%''$&2(800-#> "#$#'$#A:#%#'2008 !'$&"C
#'9&(" %"'A!'# %&#'-'#9'.-!& !$$ !#$K('"##$K&-#"$(!#; #"#$$'!#&J$'#A:1%#'200BC
(J'$'$&#?$!#$!'# * LJ&K!$'-K'(%'$!'$ ; !# '$&#?$ # "'$ "#$$'! '9# "J !$ ' %9 K' !# ($# "#$$'! '$'$$'! "#&%!G %!'#$'A#!$'$'!C
('' !-!#&$;L#'"# &-#$$%##'$&#?$ !#$!'#;"#$'#:1#2008 $L$' #"#$$'!K' !$ ; # $D ('$&#?$ &$$ -'D& ; 8 @ (9 '"!'$'!$$$'##"!'$H-> * 26L%'#20062850/C *::= :B: !'>/C+ +:==7">/70!'>/IC
# !9$$ J' #!'$ ; ''$& ; $'$# &"-'D&("A;2(000-#C
PPP
567252008 .657. *(/ ('))*)')*(
01232 452 2 26 ."$* 7
, Q
:> $'-' ! "#$' &-# K $ '#'J& !$#* + >
32
2> &##%9>
32
B> ! $ ; * + K( "$ (!# ; "#$$'! #&J$'#"!#J#&('%''$&:00@A:1%#'200B>
/> (G!$$K9!'>
8> ! * + ; %##'$&#?$#"#$$'!;#8@(A:1 #2008>
6> !&-#;"G#;#!2(000-#>;$'$# "#$''"$'!;-#'$&">
7> &9!$"#$'$!$$#!!$#'#!'!>
1> -!# "#$' KN "%$ -!## #!# !$# "#&$ ##?$ &' B0 L!# A !$'-'$'! "# "' #!& #& #'9 -&&# # +E,'R#E!-K' 6 600/ $#!' D"'#> &' "$ ?$# "#!!J&> &!'# !'$Q I ''K# D$$K&''!#!#$&'#!9$'#'$"&''! $$K&C 9I D"!# "!# K !$'- ' $' "!%!'# # $$ $# &''!C I "!#$# 'J$# ! ! #"#&$$> +' &!'# !$'$ " $#!' &&$ &&#& ! $$# I 9I $ I '. #'9-&&##"!##"$##$'A###!#KN' %#&##'##%9>&!'##!#$'!#!#!G
567252008 .757. "#% K' #!$ L!'$ '' K &''! $$K& $ N%!"" K&$&D"&'&#!#$H#$>:B2 :06$:01I> J#--'# #&'$ <' '
!"'!-!#"#&$##?$$!$'-'&D"#$'''KN;N--'-&&# #!'"#J#--
567252008