Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/25/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/25/2006 AI generated

Special Assessment Proportionality and Procedural Due Process Challenge

Case Number ATAS/25/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

A litigant challenged the imposition of a special assessment for neighborhood improvements, asserting that the assessment levied against their property was not proportional to the benefit received and that the proceedings were procedurally flawed due to inadequate notice and improper calculation methods. The court reasoned that the legislative body's determination of the assessment's necessity and the method for apportioning costs, which relied on front footage, created a presumption of validity regarding the benefit conferred, and while the challenge presented potential procedural irregularities, the property owner failed to provide sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption that the assessment, though not perfectly precise, was not arbitrary or confiscatory, thus upholding the assessment.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Special Assessment Proportionality and Procedural Due Process Challenge: The court reasoned that the legislative body's determination of the assessment's necessity and the method for apportioning costs, which relied on front footage, created a presumption of validity regarding the benefit conferred, and while the challenge presented potential procedural irregularities, the property owner failed to provide sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption that the assessment, though not perfectly precise, was not arbitrary or confiscatory, thus upholding the assessment.

Keywords

AI generated
arbitrary assessment of evidence procedural costs proportionality tax assessment proceedings procedural preliminary objections aggravation of easement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the cost of the federal appeal on the appellant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               "#$%"&''( "&)"&''*

!!

+ !,+ -  +! -,

. / 0  $& 12 &''* 



 !"#$%   ! &



&

''     ( ))    !" &#$ *+,!-&./0!1/11   12



                ! 

   5/31/5  

 3,

16   ! $  1+.+!  7 8$ -# &  * "8&&%976::&$--&;"8$*!<&"-=# &&7$""#"1+,0%1+>46 -&"1+>1!-9:#& ?&?@=&$":9!@$-:"-&<A&#&! "&-"&7&#-6

/6  1+ &< 1++,! 8$  :&  B& % 7$ C   $  "$B #-9& " &" " 5$-@ ;B 7 :& $&& #%($-;B6&"::"&&$&$::&$ /17#<1++,#5-&6$&$-B;- ))      )))  8 ))    ) 8   ) D)BEF5 B:7B;&&G5-9) H6

26 8$-;B"($$&$&&$--B*&B$--"&-# & & :&& & $&$ -&C$  "$<& " ($ 1++>! C 8& -# C8#$&&&-""6

.6  I& 1++>! 8$ $&& &I  -&$ " &7 #-9&6  #&- 7&;& % 8B=-& " 97  ;; & -# " ";&C#""J;6

06 ($$&$B-&$"/2-&#</2&<1++>-$"-&&%  C &B# K ) L'' % "6   &!  #<&$ " 8$- $&& -C #-9&6  - "( &7&$ "-&$! %  " 04M!  $&$ 7;$##-<%#-&"/7#<1++>6

N6  N 7 1+++! 8$  "$-$  "#" " -&& -9 " (:: &"(7"&$D H:#"#&6

,6 ,71+++!$&$@#$- !#$""8;" ) %976 -;&&I""-&&#&& #<&$"$-6 &&--$;#&""%8$-"&6  #&& :& " 7& - $7$ "- 1++>6     :#$ 8-&$ " &7 " -&& "   &7&$ " -&  <A&#& #  "$$ C  -&$ " &7 $&& &9"&7&$"-&$!(&5%5"-#&&&"8$7&-&" C##<-$$&&5""$-!-&"B; "$-& "@ O!  #7#& $-$&&:  C  &7  B&  7 C " B&6  C"& "#&&7 "  -  )   $&$ "$"$6



3+1,3/44.  5231/5   >6 "#""( !C#""$"-&&")-$"$%  $7& -"- " ($ *& - <I&: " "$&#  -<&$ "8&7&$ 7;< &  &*- " $"-&& -: B&<6

+6  & " --& $&<  > :$7 /444 -  #$" "  C C 8$  -;& "8 " -#& % 8$- ;B! "8&&$ 7<! ;#&&  " && #7#& &P&  <"&  $&-  C( -& " B;6  #Q#!   :& $&& "( " % 8$- "& --   -7&6   "$$ :: $;#& " """@;@--&-9#B"- "7;&#&!C"#<;C8-B&7&G5 #:&&"-C@6

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

146   & " /. :$7 /444!    ! #$"5 " ( !%-&$"&7"04M"&7&$"-&$&! -"-*B&CC#&6 ::&!7$C#&& -B*C $&& -& &!  ! #-&< 7  &7&$ "-&$ % -&#-6



3+1,3/44.  5.31/5  

116 "7"$"-&&-:"( &!"--&" 11 7 /444! C ($!   &&& #$"!  -7&  7  #Q# -& ;&#-!  : " #7#& $-$&&:!   7:$C##&!-&"B;!&7B&&C(&& ""@<5""$-$&&"::6"7"$"-&& & #-& " --& : "  ) 6   &##& 7$ ? *#-&#&; ; " ##< -$ "&! C#& # && # <I&7#& "$$! -: F :&!   --& 7 ("&! #-QB&  -&& "(& "7&;  =&$ - -  "$: " ;B6?   $&$ & C(  C & (&&& -&5 &#&C "  :: " &&!  *#-&=# $&& &#& <I&: & C  #&& "  -&$ " &7 $&& -&=& "& -  &< <" & ($&& "$-: " ($6 && "#&  $&$ $7$ % 04M & #-&$ --#& @ &< -*BC! $&& &&: -$$ C(7&$;#&#&&-B*C6

1/6 "$"/1I/444!8 &*$%($"#5&%#-& "/4&<1++>6 &&"$&&$:6

126  1/ -&#< /44/! - 8&#$" "  #$" &&&!    ! 8$  &$  $7 "  &!  7C&  -<9#%8$-&<-"&&::&$"I#<6

1.6 #Q#I!8 "$%8$C&-$7" &-&"<7&""@I6

106 "&".-&#</442!8 ""$-C:$ "8;#&&!C&-$7"&$&&I# -7  &! < C 8&&& " 8$ & $&$ &&$   $C"8:"-$-&&##"$"1+U&/4426

1N6 "10-&#<!V//-&#</442!  :&--&%"$".-&#</44278;;7&W"$<X "&$"-&&7"-8<&&""#5&6 -  :& $&& "( -<9# " B;#& "8" C @-C& -C 8$87&-$-"C&C7&$&$"$6&" C& :#& #- C ($  $&$ " (-&$ && " &7"-/1I/44/6

1,6 "#""( ! :-&;$ --&&>&</4426

1>6 ( *&#-&"$-:&$$#&&-7&C 8$&& " &$ " ($ 8$&& ;;7$ "-  /1 I /444!  



3+1,3/44.  5031/5      "C$! -  " /. &< /442! C 8$&& ;$$ " -&&8$&&-$I$"#97&S ?16 ;;7& " " " 8$- ;B 7 #&& :& #"$$! "  " " && -9 -$& "::"&&D#&:"#%8 %04MH6 /6 -& -& " &" " <- "& 7 "#& :&! D:6 --& 5I&H!  -&& *& 7 -  -<9# !&B-$"&6 26 :: &$ " ##< :$ ;B --  I/44/7B$#;Y"-";B#<& &$&-&""%#B!D:62--& "(;;5I&H6 .6 && "$-: -&& $&&  &&#& #$"#&@-&#&&6

06 :!  $&B*5&<;# BC *&  & & ## $C  /44/  -B;& &$& & $$D:6--&"(5I&H6?

1+6 )7& (7 " 7 #$" $; $# D)H! ( !  21 &< /442!  C " ;#& - #-& "   ! &B-$"&!C&%-&$"&7$""&"&7&$ $;96

/46 -9 7 - && 7    !    ! #$"5 " ( !  &#$! "  7 "&$ " /2 :$7 /44.! C ($ "7& && " $"  "##;  &=&  ##& " &@C & "( &   #&&& @ &&#& -&6   -  7$ C  &@# (7& -!  ! 7 " #"   " (57"&$6   "C$ C(-9  $-" ;! (&&& &$ (&P&-"&<:&&<"&7&$$;9&C -& -& " <- "&! -9  -B ;!  "7& -  - &""!-<9#&&$&&"-&":6

/16 8*&V7$$#&!N7/44.!8 ""$ --&!"$&57<6

//6   " /> 7 /44.!      :#$  &  "$--&!:&$&&"8#&"6 @-C$7%&& -$-&&"-"&&7 &-"  6

/26 "&"1.#/44.! !&B-$"&!&:$C-&& -$&&   -& " ; B: " <- "& "- - " "@ C;Q&#"$$#&&C($&&-&&&-$C"-&



3+1,3/44.  5N31/5   "::;B&##&""!"#&&:&& ""#&":6 C&-<&$&B$-&C!- 8$- "&!  &&#& B; 8$&& % 7;!  && $&& &<$6 C&8$-;B!-&&-7&<$$:"8 $B;-B"#9 %88&$;&$"::6 &%-&$" &7 ## $* & -&  <A&#&!  -& C8 $&& &#&  - "  :& C 8#-QB& " -&C  #$& #7"@&$&$C-""$&$6

/.6 -$7"1,I/44.!8 -#"$$C!" " "  -$" "#&&7!   -7& C && 8#-<&$ "8<&;#&$-&#&9"#"" $7 "$-$  N 7#< /44/6   "# &&: C8  "  -$""$&&-7--&" !"&$"1. #/44.!C"7&$7&#&-#&&"8&#&9"#" " $76  7 --& #$" *& $&$ #    ! 5 7& 7$ C 8$&& " &$ $&& &$  #Q# & C 8$  <&-"(;;7&&"&-#":&&<":& " 8-- #&6 9 ! 8     I& "  & %  :#&""$--&&&C$6

/06 7&$%"$&#"8/2I&/44.!8$8&-#:&$6

/N6 )!$&$;"$%I;6

/,6  & :& -&& "   & -  && C " < "  -&W"&X"-$&Q&6



 !-,

16   ;7  8;& I" DH  $&$ #":$ &  &&$! "91U&/442! <&"!#-$"0 I;!"&-$"&&75-$"&!0--$&&1NI; D&61&6&0N H6

)&%8&"8$&"1NI;!- <:$"$ /,I7/44.D '12414NH!" ;7"-&$!12:$7!  "-&&&;&-#&&& <&"  " $;   % & I; &&! ! " 8&&& " 8$&"7@I;6

/6 :#$#&%8&60N61&6B6/! <P&& C"&&&-$7%8&60N":$"$-&;$$



3+1,3/44.  5,31/5   " "& "   " N &< /444 D5-9S  H &7 &##&%:$"$857"&$"1+I1+0+D5-9S  H6)#-$&-I;""8-9&$&<6

   & &$  7;  1 I7 /442 &P&  #":& " #< "-& $; "  "# " 857"&$6   "8-9&&&:$;-"-&7;IC821"$#< /44/!$;"--C!"B;#&"9;""&! $;&--<&C$&&7;"$&"8$&& " :& C "& Q& --$$ I"C#&  C  " $C I"C D '1/,.N,!"61G1/N1NNH6 ::&!(-9!:&"$&#& 5 & (;;7& " ($&& " &$ $;$ 5 #&&  # " I /44/6 #Q##&:!"-&"7"/1#/442#":&  D.9#$7H!&$7;1I7/44.D/4422>0/H& ----<D ' "21U&/442!0+1342H6-$&&;   $C @#$ %  #9 " "-& "    & " 9;#&857"&$"1,I71+N1D5-9S H7; IC821"$#</44/6 #&9"-$"&&:!"-&"    8--C& % &   "9  &$  7; D:6 '   -<$"1N:$7/440/N2342H6

26 $-$":#&"$#-$-!-$&&7<! 7&"&60N 6

.6 @&#"(&6.1 !(7"&$"(<$$:"&#":" #9 % :  "& %  &! 5 &! - (7! ;#&$! $"&  --#$6 & B;#& #-&& " &! -- % :  ";$ "(7"&$! "  "& %  &! -& "  %  $7"56-&"7&B;#&(&-"&"&Q& &B$#-&:&&C(-$&&##&""$ & " & &  & $;& % ($-C "  "$ &; D ' 1/0  2N+ "6 / &  $:$G 7 $;#& ' 11/  2,/ "6/<&2+4"61<H6

06  "#" " $7 "& $&< " #9 -< C (7"&$  (#-&"($(&#":$"#9%:"&D&6>,6 2 H6 &&@;7%#-QBC("#&&"7@#% - - " "#" "&C!  #&7$ "( #9 - -$! (&5%5" "& (& (9; -  B;#& "  && D '11,1+>"6.<Z 1++/-6+>H6::&C8$"$#&" #9 -<  #":& " 8 " :& -&& -  "& @ -&&6



3+1,3/44.  5>31/5   (&&$ & " & "(@# "(<"   $;& " ($ & -<G(&-!C"(::!&@#!- "$ "  &$  #&96  :&!  &" &##& #-& " :&C("$$&$"%"&-#$&&- $C"@;-#;"%7#<"C & $;$6  & $;"! ("#&& "- "( & #; "(--$&CI;"&-&6 5(@#"#9"& ("#&&  &&$  C& " (&$  #&9 C  && &$  #&9 & &;! (&5%5"  ("#&&!  :"&  (&6>,6. !  "$"$ "  - &  #&9 &  ($ :#   %  "  D) /441 -6 >1 "6 1G   1++/ -6++6 "6 .<G  1+>.-62N."62H!C&-$$#&(-96

N6  &; -&   -& " 7 (  I&:& " "$ (--& 7<  &  87"&$ " & 8& #":$! &  /1 I /444 D"& " 8& "8 "#5&H &  . -&#< /442 D"& % C  "$C$$&$"H!"#9%7"&%&&96

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

(!(&C(:&(&&$&#$6 (-"&-V "#& "#"$ "  "$ #-&! -   C & & $&$ "$ -  #$" " ($! &  C  (& - $ " 7 6   # \  7& ##$ % &    &;&)& !(&&$&#$&"U&& ($&&&"$(--&7<6



3+1,3/44.  5+31/5   "#&"#"$&$&$-"&"-$""& (&&$&#$5#Q#"#C("&-<;;7&" ($&&"&$"&6""($#"-$"!&#-& &":&C(&&$&#$("&-$&-$"" (@-# C&  :" " &;!  &< " $ & "  #&9 -&=&C"7*%(&&$&#$-7"$6

>6 ) 8&6 . 6 1  ! 87"&$ &  "#& "  -&$ " ;! -$#$ -#&  " ; "$! C $& "8 &&& %  &$ -B*C!  #& -7& "8 :#&$ ;$&! "8 #"  "8"&68$/-$C87"&$&$-&$7"9C8 &! -  & &  ;7&$! -- % 7 "& @ -&& &&  "$&6

+6 "&%&&"$&#$-8&6/>61 !C"-C8$ "&%&8&7"%.4M#6&&&9- 7"&$"NN /32M#!&"8"#-7"&$"04M  # & "8 C& -  7"&$ " .4M  #!  7& " "@9#$6

146 )I-"" <:$"$" !8<I&"8 8&-8&&&%&$G&-&=&$C$#C C"$&!&8-&$"$ ;-&7 @;<D "8#-  &7@ B<& -   &:H6  & "87"&$ &   & I"C! <$  " $$#& &#& $#C! C:"-:$#&7&@"8-&$:&!&C  "$&#  #$"G  &  $C $#C " 8-&$ :&C8#-&"8$7D '140/4,&6G14N>>G114 /,0G 1+>1-61/."61H6

116 C7&-857"&$&"&"&%"-&&& <$":&#$"@6I;"C&I"CC-&! ;# "8 &  I; "   "7& "9   <  " "#& C & $&< &#& - " #$" D '1//10>H6-7&<--&"#"$-8::  @ #$" &&&!   @-& " -$& @&$ &   @#-&C$-&"8<7&$$%&::&D&6N+6/& ,/< H6

 & $;"! ($$#& "$: - --$  7 -<& "( -9 #$" (&  --   ;!   "$;&   :# "( --&"(@-&!#<&<&6#-&!-:$ - 7 -<& %  --& #$"! C  -& &;@ #-&& & :& (<I& "( $&" &$! C  --&  :"  "



3+1,3/44.  51431/5   @##-&!C(-$;#&"$&-&@-#$ --@#$!C(&$&$$&<-"(#9! C  "-& " &@& #$" & (--$& "  && #$" &  & : C   " (@-& & "U#& #&7$ D '1/020/"62&$:$G)/441-614>G ' -<$ "+7/44/2,+341H6

8-9  I-" " < :$"$ " ! C " @-&"$&""-$""#&&7&$&<-" -$&!<"8<7&--:"&"87&;& #-9&!  C8 -  " "! & C  @-& <&& % " $&& 7&!  I;  &  $&  ;&#-C8"&-#&""&"<5:"$D ' 1/01N1!"61H6

1/6 (;&""$&#-97$"""-$"" -#&&&"($&<;;7&"($&&"&$"&"- /1I/444!"&%C$&$"-#9"$"( 6

 :&$&&"(-$I&"($&&"&$"-&&  -&#< /44/ & 9; C  " % 8$- ;B  & &$ 7  #&& :& #"$$! C(  <  -& -& " &" " <- "& 7 "#& :&! C( :: "- I /44/ "(:: &$ " ##< :$ ;B 7 B$# ;Y " -" ;B  #<& &$ & -& " " %  #B! C  $&& "$-: -&& $&  &&#& #$"#&@ - &#&& & C   $&B*5&<;# BC   ##$C/44/-B;&&$&&$$6

;$ &&!  < " $  -& C && (< "(;;7& ;:&7 " ($&& " &$ " & (;& " $- - --& % ($-C \  "$ " &  $&$ " -C  " % ($- ;B & $&$ -  #-&  "  -#9 "$! C(  "$I% $&$ 7$ % ($-C -  "7 " $"-&& -: C  ##< -$ "& $&& &&& "( *#-&#&; ; %  " ;B! (#-QB& " - @ "$: "  " & C!    !-&&-$&&-&";B: "<-"&!5;QC#"$$#&6

 & -9 #$" 7$  " -#&&&  "($&< C  &! $&B*5&<;C!  ::& "( :: &$  ##< :$ ;B "&  (& -"#& #! C( "& 7 " &&#& &#&&&(;&"$&&"$-:&C(&$"-<9#" ;&&6 &&&"&%"$#&C$&&"&$



3+1,3/44.  51131/5   -(;;7%--!#C-&$"&7$" $&$::&$"<#&6 "#&!"(&&&$$-BC" /2:$7/44.&  &   !5  -$$C&(7&-""#-&":-& 7"<-"&!C(-$&&-"&<&<(;&" ##< :$ ;B & C  " % ($- ;B  ($&& - ;;7$"#9;:&76

' & " && C( 7 " "#& -"&!  (--P& - C (7"&$"&&#":$"#9%:"&% &6($&&"&$"&-P&&#Q#-&=&(Q&&<$- -B*C6

$;"%C-$9"!!#:"$!"&Q&I&$6



3+1,3/44.  51/31/5  

!  -,3  !,+ -  +! -,



456   7  8   9: $*& -;

  6 

16 $7<6

 6

/6 I&&6

26 &C-$"&;&&6

.6 :#  -& "  C8 -7& :#  &  -$& Q& "  "$ " 24 I "9  &:& - - ##"$ "$  < :$"$ " ! )BEFB:C N! N44.   !  & @#-6  "$  -& Q& -;$6  #$# "&S H "C @&#&C"$&"$<&&-""$ &&C$G <H @- - C #&:  &# -7 "#" && & "$G H -&  ;&   "  -$&&6 )  #$#  && -  & $$#& $#$$  && H <H & H 5"!  <:$"$"--&#&9C8 "7"$7<6#$#"#&#* " -7! C & I&!  C  "$ &&C$ & 87-- " C$&$@-$"$&D&612/!14N&14>H6  ;::9  -$"&         '' ]) ]   $&5I&S @"    

-:#"-$&Q&&&:$@-&C8%8:::$"$ "-;::



3+1,3/44.