Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/217/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/217/2007 AI generated

Governmental Entity v. Contractor: Recovery of Liquidated Damages

Case Number ATAS/217/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

A governmental entity initiated an action to recover funds disbursed under two different contracts, arguing that the receiving party failed to meet certain performance metrics, resulting in the imposition of liquidated damages. The court determined that the statutory provisions governing the contracts did not authorize the imposition of liquidated damages, but instead permitted recovery of actual damages resulting from the breach. Since the entity sought to enforce a specific contract clause that was legally invalid, the court concluded that the entity was not entitled to recover the specific liquidated amounts, and therefore, the decision to deny recovery was affirmed based on the lack of statutory or contractual authority for the claimed damages.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Governmental Entity v. Contractor: Recovery of Liquidated Damages: The court determined that the statutory provisions governing the contracts did not authorize the imposition of liquidated damages, but instead permitted recovery of actual damages resulting from the breach. Since the entity sought to enforce a specific contract clause that was legally invalid, the court concluded that the entity was not entitled to recover the specific liquidated amounts, and therefore, the decision to deny recovery was affirmed based on the lack of statutory or contractual authority for the claimed damages.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual damages contractor state recovery claim administrative contract misappropriation of assets actions establishing liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



                

 

  !" #!!"   !#  # " 

#$%   &  %  



  !"""# $%&' "() )!)*





!*)

++       +    +   "*"# ,*!"(-)!* ./0& $%12   



       

   4%354  

  #""! ) !66!"*"!  & 78") %11'  6) 9  "  !:")#  #""!)"*#)/*!)*!")2!8;)%11<=

)!)$178")%11'=

  )#6!   "  %$ :#8)") %11'  !6!)**  6)!6!"*"! *)*"! > 8!")  8)* 6)  )!)* ? !** ?"*#)/* !)*!")  +@) 01AB1 6!)  6#)"! %111 C "  +@) $55A&0D  *  "*" ? "*#)/* !)*!")  +@) $10 10 6!)  6#)"! %11$  !"*  ! E  +@) $00AB0=

F!))!)* !:")#6)!!))")0)%11'=

 9?" !8"* ?*#)") ?!) "*)8 *)  6)*"  9" * :"  "*"-=

 #  ' ( "  !" #!!"   !#  # " 

& )+   ,

-*+.+%% / )0 12 3 "45

$A ! * >  "   9  ! E > *"*) ?"*#)/* !)*!") 6!)  6#)"!%111*6#)"!%11$*)#"*>$00:)AB0A

%A F,!**9;!"A

5A !*> !!) *!--*>)#-) !A

&A F,!**9;!"A

0A 8"*  >8))!**$00:)AB0>"?""> :"!")%11'6*)A

<A "*96)!#)*-)*"*A

'A 66"*"!F)*A01 ":!)6)*"9F68*:!)) )!)!*)6)#*))/*#"517!)(!*":"*"!6)6" )!#)# )";:##)) +.G"H).!:9"< <11&



32'3%11'  45354     *)!"I6")A#"6*/*)6)!!-#A#!")!"*J D""9)I**9#""!)!)*#")!;*")"*6 #""!9#=;DI6!)6!)9!*":"*"6!8!")) *)#""!=D6!)*)"-*)!!)6)#**A+"#!") !*"* 6  *)!" ##* ##)# ! ) D ;D * D "4   )";:##))6!))6*))*"()))!)9F" 8)#))"))8;A#!"))!)*"!)!)!,  6)8  9" )!* 7!"*  "" 9  #""! 9# * F8!66  9#*#I6#"#)!)*C)*A$5% $1<*$12DA    -)::"()J )#"*J       KL M ;+

!6"!:!)6)#*))/**!*":"#I6)*"*>?::"6)-)::





32'3%11'