Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/211/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/211/2006 AI generated

Appellate Review of Evidentiary Rulings and Jury Instructions

Case Number ATAS/211/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute concerned various legal challenges and procedural matters arising from a case, including challenges to the admissibility of evidence, jury instructions, and the application of specific statutes or legal principles across multiple appeals and cross-appeals. The court consistently reasoned by meticulously reviewing the record, statutes, and prior rulings to determine whether the lower court abused its discretion or erred on matters of law, ultimately affirming, reversing, or vacating judgments based on whether the challenged actions were supported by the controlling legal standards or factual findings.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appellate Review of Evidentiary Rulings and Jury Instructions: The court consistently reasoned by meticulously reviewing the record, statutes, and prior rulings to determine whether the lower court abused its discretion or erred on matters of law, ultimately affirming, reversing, or vacating judgments based on whether the challenged actions were supported by the controlling legal standards or factual findings.

Keywords

AI generated
procedural review matter in dispute rulings providing an interpretation evidentiary grounds appealability of interlocutory decision limits of judicial review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to rule on court costs for the appeal.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                !"## "$$"##!



% &%' '('  %'  ( &

)*+  $ * "##! 



 !!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'%((# % )'%((*% 



%

+ " ++    +++ ) ++    + %#' )   +" ,#%%%-".//0  

            

   301-/3  

' ,&

-4  05 # 0//6"  !!!!!!!!!!" '  -767"  %  &% ($(8,((%(%%'%99:(% (%&4

04  -7 & 0//6"   %'  % !!!!!!!!!!" $'%  ,8 %,$'(9"9(8%9'%8&(,&8,"( $$%(.#0//64%$''9)%'')%'( $%((%();(<#'%3#'=%4$8% () ( ()$$ %   ( %4  #>% (  9 %< '%%(4

54 :'  '%'  $%' %% ( %& ( -7 &  0 # 0//6" $ ? 2/@A9:0BA0//64

64 +  $$% #'( ( -B A 0//6 ( % !!!!!!!!!!" :' $'%  (% (  ,& 8, & (', $% ( :$'&$%%(%#'%%4(  %( $' (#% %#%"  ? :$$ = ( 2<# #'%% $%% %  (  3% % ( :$'& $% 8#%%4$%%>%$'8<#%?#,4

24 +  $$% ( -6 A% 0//6 ( #'( (:(#% (   %(:(%C3$<D+ E"9$,8% ( :'&'#% #%'" :' FF (: $'&% $%  '$'8,4+#G#$$%"('#%(:'&'#% % :'&% $8& ( ("  9  %> (39 $#% (?$%,8F##%%('8''%&(%:'&'#%(05 #0//6"9'%'9F'(>":'%'9$#<#F%%4

.4 +>($$%"+ #F?$%%&FF%##'(%" $('(0/A%0//64

H4 +$$%(:'"+ F#'--%>0//6%%('"  ('% 9 :'&'#%  9%  A% #F%#% $  I(J#$%#%8$%%4

B4 :'" $ :%#'( (  "  %A%'  % %% ('" $ % ( -/ A& 0//2"  % $'>#% ?  9: =$% #'( $  #'(3%,$'(% FK% (' % $$#% ? :% (  (' ( -- %> 0//64  :$$ (  ("   %##%$(%$((% !!!!!!!!!!(0B%>0//6" 9,(%>$$("9:':$'"$



12.10//2  351-/3   $&9  ' ( F $% & (:F##% ( 8 ('4  #'(  %#' 9:  $&% $ (: ('#$% (: '%% %' $'=%%" $9  $%% :&% $&% A# FF% (  $( % 9 :=% (: '$ '  FF% $ ? FF#  $'(:$%,8F##%J#$%#%9$'>4

74 :%#'    A% ( " %#% 9  % !!!!!!!!!! :$$%%  8#% #'( $%> ( #%%  (%  $%4 +:%#'":&(#'((:(#%"%!!!!!!!!!!" '%% #$%#% F#' $  ( % !!!!!!!!!! ( +& ( ,8 %,$'(9 % ( %#%8 ( :$$ #% ( LI$%= &%(<&CLE(--K%0//6"9(''&>$ %' $< ( %  :'&% % ( :FF%"  :> (:8#%  F& (: ' 8& (  ,& % ( $( %  :#$%(:#%F%$$%#4

-/4 $%%$%'($'%$%&(- &%5#0//24

--4 %(#$%$(%(BA0//2"%('' 9: '%% (( &% ( %%  A ( :'&'#% ( 05 # 0//6"  (F%9%''$,F=(&&%'"%9:&%# $'$(8,$%%'%%%#>'I%'8,4A#G#(% '&'#%"&% J' ($((M3&,M#'("< $(%4

-04  > ( '  ##9' = $%  B A 0//2 9: &% :%%(#%%;&=$%#'(A(%(F % !!!!!!!!!" %%   (%  ( 9% ? $ ? )=$%"9$>%'(#$'%%($,=( :=$%4

-54 :%#' :% $$' ?  9  % !!!!!!!!! % ('8'  %% 9:=$%"$(05A0//24

-64  >('$$'=$%(F#(%% !!!!!!!!!9&%'%'88''$:%#'"9%$%'4 $%:%$$$F%(#9$%<9%=9% ?$?:=$%4

-24  ( ( 2 A% 0//2"  > ( '  ('  =$% #'(A(%##?%%F(#'(4

-.4   $$% ()=$% ( -- &#> 0//2"  % !!!!!!!!!  &'$#9)=$%'&%$$%'((8$,FF%'



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

-H4   ('%#% ( 0- &#> 0//2" )%#'  $%' (  "   F(%  )=$% ( % !!!!!!!!! 9 F#% %%%(#'(()(#%4

-B4 -.A&0//."%)%('%#')=$%$'%'488'' ()%$  % !!!!!!!!!!   #%%% $ ( $$% ()=$%(% !!!!!!!!!"(#N(&%%#'9 % !!!!!!!!!!)%$(#G#$$%)&%'%'F#' ( #<#$<%( %%4$"% #$%#% #%(4 )$$(3"=$9'9) &% %'  % L!!!!!!!!! (  ( () $><#  %,$'(9" $ 9  (M3& &% '%' F=' '8<#%4 %% %%)&%(<?&&$><#(,&8,% )'%%9)F(%%9)&%F%'%%(("$ 9  #'( )&% $' (  ( ?  (84   %%' & (9' ?  % L!!!!!!!!! 9  ( #%% ?  # $&%"(<9))'%%$$9()'&'#%(05# 0//64   '8#% &' 9"  (  %% &% $< (  %L!!!!!!!!!"&%>'%'9%(%(%4

-74 )$$(("%$(%$((-/A&0//.(  % L!!!!!!!!! ?  #(%" $ 9 3  ##9



12.10//2  321-/3   %F8%((#'($(%%(0.#% (-7&0//64%(3%&%D

        

%F%I(884

+%%<&=%$(#%#'(#%OP

Q"FL'#8>'&'#L'#%%#4

$ - # ( $( 8,  & ( % ##   '$'%%((4

+%%D

>$'%4

88,D'$'R

%%%( D O $( 8, D $%% '$ I%' 8, # ('  !!!!!!!!!S

        

S   1  !!!!!!!!!  (3J  !!!!!!!!! $ ( (M3&&%A4 )$%''$,'%FFA9)?$'%3T  F==4

 054/54/6" )$<3#(  ((% ( %%" )% %(  $( 8,4$"(,&8,U%4

$=$$%')(%PS



' (&

-4 8&:8%A(CE'%'#(F'%%%'"(< -K%0//5" >%("#$'(2A8" (%$'(%%&3$'(%"2$$'%%-.A8C%4-%4 %2. E4

+%?:%(:'%(-.A8"$ >F'(' 0HA&0//6C -5/-/.E"( 8&($%'"-5F'&"  ($%%%8%$#%%% >%(



12.10//2  3.1-/3    ( '8   ? % A8 %%" " ( :%%% ( :'%(&=A84

04 F#'#% ? )%4 2.  4 - %4  ,4 2 "  > % ( *%%9(%%%$'&?:%42. ($%8''((%((.%>0/// C E 9 % %& ?   F'('  :3(% ( 0/# -7B-C E4

+#$'%$A8((:$<%'%>4

54  %8 $%    ( %' % % ('9% % )$'&% $%(%%%%%%%)'&'#%(05#0//64$% '8#%  $  9% ( &  % '&'#% $% G% 9F' ()(%()%46 4 %F"%%9%$%%&%" &(9%4

64 4(%?($%%('%(:(%'$$(:>("% :'&'#%(##8>(%<(%%:%%%?%'"( %'%4 %%=8(%'%%#$9)J  ()(#%% 9"  % '&'#% (%"  (##8   % $ $(% ( %%"  9)  % $ & (  #G# #<4  )% $ '"  &," 9 )(% %   9  ##'(% ( )%%% ?  %'V  F% %  FF% 9 )'&'#% (##8>" ' '&%#% ? ()% F%" % $&9' )%%% ?  %' $,J9  $J,9()'")%3?3(9)$'%##(%9 (34

+&  )'&'#% ' % )%%% ?  %' % ' $  $$% ( %'%%9%(F%"9)(#%%"','%"  A8 =#   F(% %#%  ( 8#% ()( #'(" % 9 (% G% %,'   F#% ?  <8 ( (8' ( &#>$'$('%"$$9'8''#%?)$$'%($& ( ) 4 " 9 )=% () $$% (  ? FF% % )(% %  (##8 $*% $>" # 9)  $% $ G% 9F'($>>($%"(%?($%%F(' )(%'(%G%'C -07-B-(454-"6/.(46454-V  --755H(4-"--B0B7(4->%'F'E4

>4   ( %' ('9% %  &,  9% ( (% 9) $$%%?)(#%%%"("A8(%,4%' %('9%"()$<((,%)=$'(&"F% ('' '%% $$ ? %*  FF% ( 8 (  9 )% $(%"  & (  '%% $% ( FW 8'' F&' $  %



12.10//2  3H1-/3   %C -07-B-(4540"6/2(4040"-026.-(42% 'F'"--26/2(46E4

4 + ) $% (#%% 9) (% ) F% 9 (',  $ 9 %(%%FW&%'&'#%"(%'%% J#$%I#$'%'$)'%)(%(%G%'9)'%%#(F %'%&%(N%&%&%)(%C%%9%E) %$&%(()'&%9)%%%%)(%C%% 9V    -770   -60 $4 H2" (4 6>V '(" )3(% >8%"  +,XM, (&X%8,% Y+Z" +M +,,%"  -6-E4  $$"  =#  )%%% ?  %' %  #$%> ? )(%   )% $ C%% 9 %  %% 9 E   %< (  &#> $'$('%"   #%< ( $& (  (#(C -0.5./(42>"-02-72(40V   0///5.5$46.V $>'00/1/0(.K%0//5(4 045E4

24 G%(-6A-777C -0252-E" >F'('( $''A$(%&?)$$'%($&%##%( (# #'(4 +  $$ (  > $$'% ( $&" 9 )$$9  >  $'( (#%%& 9) $'( (  ( (%(#%%FC%46/ '%&)%4-7 V%47240 &%4--5%-50E")(#%%A8$$'>#% $&"G%'$(<8F#"$'(%?$$'% #$<% % 8 ( $&4 < "  A8 (% =# ( #< >A%&%#J($&"99)%$&"$('(  (#% ? ($% $#%%% ( $%  A8#% &>   (% %8=4+$$%#'(=%%(%"$%%,)FF $$')#>($&%(9$9 F($#'(%$%4

)''#% ('%#% $  & $>% () %F% #'( )%   8('8%F#()$$%()=$%"#>% >%4  % '8("#$%9$%%8=#$%%% F%)>A%()'%(F'"9$$%F((=##$%" 9)$'8#%('%$%=$#'"9)%'%''%> $  ( ( C#<E" 9  ($% ( %F' #'(%%F9()=$%%>#%&'4

+ #%%    $$ (  > $$'% ( $&"  A$(  $' ( 8 (%   9   #< ()$$'%%J$()=$%($$%#'(=49" %( ($'((#%%&"=$%F'?#'(('$(%% '%> $  $'% "   > ()>&% $$F( %



12.10//2  3B1-/3   ()&%8% #$<%"  9) $  ( (" % 9 )=$% >%% ? ( '%% &%"  A8  %  '%  8%#$9)(%$#%((%(>3F('4

A8)'%$$$$#%F#$'%F( ()=$%#'(A("%[,()=$%'%%$''#%(#%%   $' ?  ($% (  A% F ( )'   $%#'(=()'%%(F%('4%%%()'%( )=$% A(  F% 9 3 %% ( %(%"  9) =$% (' $  %>  F#   ( #< &%4

% = $$% '%> $  #'( %%%"  A8 $% % (% % #$%(F%9")=$'"#'(%%%%8''#%"   ( (%" ? $( $% $  $%%   (  % ( F9)%?(4 %F"#$F%9)%F%#'(% '%>?(#(()$%%$(%$(%$'(A%F$" "((%9%?&$>%4

.4  )"  % !!!!!!!!!! % !!!!!!!!! % # ? ('9)$'&%(%FF%)%$($$%( %'%&)'&'#%4F%?%'8((%9  $$% ()=$% (  ( #'( &G%  $ & $>%"  &% (  A$( $'%'4 )=$% A(   % $$%' ( &=''#%$)$$'%((%'4FF%('&% 9  % &% ('A? %'" #% % A $< )'&'#%  "%L!!!!!!!!!"9%'($$%%##%9  %8 8, &% ('>%' #'%9#% ('A? ($  #4 %"  % %% & F%  % ('% ?  #'(4  > ( ')$(%(#%%(%%$%(%% $%4%FF%8<=$>93$%()% ('%"  )& &'%>#% 4 )=$% A(  '8#% &' 9  % ) $ F% '%% () '&'#% (%  (  $#<%%(05#0//6(%L!!!!!!!!!4 )%9 (%%&%"-7&0//69)#%4

 %% '%% ( " #G#  % #$% ( % (  % L!!!!!!!!!"$$%9")=$%"#'#('%$%$% (FF#%=$9$><#()$'&%$%4)&( > ('"$%$$G%=9%(,&8,'%' $&9'  F% $  ( 8\" ( ? )'$ ' % )$'&%$%$'=%%"9%$'$($%4 &(%%(?%%%$(%8F9



12.10//2  371-/3   %%FF%%(?#&#%##*%'"##%N(% (((%%4

   ( 0B %> 0//6  #(% ( %"  % !!!!!!!!!!<&9)J%(%%($%($$% (%!!!!!!!!!!?$85((8$,9('#%%" ( #'(" S$ ()'$ ' '&(%S" % )$$'% (  #'("9(#%S$'&%$%'$' F#' $ )#8S4  J  %%F  ( 8 9  % !!!!!!!!!!#%($$%"%(8$,"9 (%8,%'#8%#%()'$'4+)FF%&#% (9'?$855<#$8$,"(<$,($$%"S$()'$ ''&(%S"%(%"9)$'%'%,'( )'&'#%  4 )%  ? %% 9  % !!!!!!!!!! &%  %(%?A%4

   $'%'"  ( $% (#% $  S9 )=% ()'$')%$F#%J#$%#%9S4'9%"#G#   % (&% & % $  $#< F  ( &%  ((%(%%(%(05#0//6"%%%$F#%  ( $   ( %' % % '&'#% %  J#$%#%8  4

 %88<(#%%$$%(% !!!!!!!!!% !!!!!!!!!!$&&4 $(%" ('%%#'(%%%"  & $$'%  % ( %% #< $ F#  ()=$%A("9F#%(*%( % !!!!!!!!!!4  '9%"  > ( ' %# $F ( (%?%%(#(()%%#$'#%(%4

H4 &(9$'<("A%'4





12.10//2  3-/1-/3     (&,  &%' '('  %'  ( &



-./0/** 1  2// /  34 $!" (5

  0/*

-4 '&>4

 0/

04 A%%4

54 %9$'(%8%%4

64 F#  $% (  9: $&% F#  %  $'% G% (  (' ( 5/ A (<  %F% $ $ ##(' ('  > F'(' ( " +,XM,F9 ." .//6   "  % =#$4  ('  $% G% $8'4  #'# (%D E (9 =%#%9('%('>%%$((' %%9'V >E =$ $ 9 #%F  %# $& (#( %% % ('V E $%  8%   (  $'%%4 +  #'#  %% $  % ''#% '#''  %% E >E % E 3("  >F'('($$%#%<9: (&('&>4#'#(#%#J ( $&" 9 % A%"  9  (' %%9' % :&$$ ( 9'%'=$'('%C%4-50"-/.%-/BE4  8FF<  '(%D             ]\ ^ J        

$F#($'%G%%%F'=$%9:?:FFF'(' (%'$>9$8FF



12.10//2