Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/155/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/155/2007 AI generated

Standard of Review for Post-Appeal Pleading Amendment

Case Number ATAS/155/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns the appropriate appellate review standard for a trial court's decision to permit a party to amend its pleading following the expiration of the deadline, where the amendment related to an issue that had been previously litigated and decided by the appellate court in a prior appeal. The court reasoned that because the trial court's decision to allow the amendment was discretionary and occurred after the initial appellate ruling, the standard of review for the amendment itself was abuse of discretion, not the less deferential standard applied to the underlying substantive issue in the prior appeal, as the amendment introduced a new factual predicate that the trial court had the latitude to allow or deny based on fairness and prejudice considerations at that later stage.

Legislator headnote

Official

; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE ET SURVIVANTS ; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; RESPONSABILITÉ DE L'EMPLOYEUR(AVS) ; DOMMAGE ; CAUSALITÉ ; RUPTURE DU LIEN DE CAUSALITÉ ; NÉGLIGENCE GRAVE ; INFRACTION ; CARACTÈRE EXTRAORDINAIRE | LAVS52

Keywords

AI generated
substantive reasoning examination of procedural pleas amendment of the claim revision of a judgment appealability of interlocutory decision limits of judicial review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in order 1 for the allocation of court costs.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This provision is cited in order 1 regarding the allocation of costs for the respondent.

Art. 93 LTF

This provision is cited in order 2 to dismiss the appeal as inadmissible.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           "#$%"&$$# '"())"&$$*

!!'

 '!  +'  !+ + 

+,-  &  .$ /0 &$$* 



 !"#$#% &'" ' ()*+ "'",- 



'

.  #/01# -'*23#$## ## '!"

 !"#$23-  45+ 55"  

             ! 

   *$4#$*  

 1 '

#1  "'" , -  6*57  "'"8  "'" '  +'  !!  '  79  '  :/ ;9 #223 9 !! <'  5 5&'' =5>'"5''('' 5&'1  "'' >>" 5  5 " 57     !5' .  #/01#6*5781

$1   6*57  '8  "'"  +"'   "'" 9 +'  9  7  5' ' ;&( :/ '< $//$1 - 5'"'" "$;9$//:16*57(55"  8  "'" (" 55   "'" '' (<  9    559+' 9  5! >"9$//$1

:1 -  9"  !5'     #: ; $//:     ''  ! >"9$//$(5"'""+"''5 ! !$//$?;$//:' >9  03($2#>1#@1

%1 "'""'" "">'5;+!'  < 5!7' $25'!<$//:'("'' '"'"5<" ' $%!$//%1  ' #%>"9$//@A )'  ">' <1

@1  " $@9$//@"!""5'  !!+? (55"   ( 5' 5  !''  @%(%3: >1 2/ '  ' (' 5' 5  !''  $3(B2$ >1 2@ 5 ' ) '' ')> 55"  !?5'!<$//$1

01 -  '  >' 55' ? '' "  '  $@ ! $//$1  )5& 9 '!' 5"  5' 5   9 ? (55"  &"''(!' "'"1 *9'';"& =+"''5C"'&(('5A&5!(9' 5 "'" 5'"   "!"   ! '  +"'1 - (55"  =+"''9'5'> "'"1&( '""5="?(>> >'! (9$//@5D'''  "'" &"&'>9' 51('+ (55" >!"&*9'&''"-5(5+9!=' ' "'"1

B1  "  55'  #3 ;9 $//0    >!"  5<'"  '  !'> &(  "'"  + >!   "'" '  +'  !! ' !! ' 5<  5!'  '' 1 '   "'' =!" ?    59" E  "'" C 9' " !1  "''   '  *5!'  '' ' ' F 5  '' ! 5  "+1  "'" 



40/%4$//0  *:4#$*   +!'"5($/// '&(!$//$!5"!' F G' >'" 5 $//#  &  59&"  >>'" 5  5!'  '' ' $//$1  '' & +"' !5'<  >!'   !<' 9 57!= >>1

31  #0>"9$//0' &!'55'1  )5& &  "'" 5'  <)   !G! !!< & * !G!955<D')''1 >>'59'G'59"5'"!1  (9' &' ?   7  <  ?  <D' ) ''1  >' >?(55"&9'5! "+=+' 9'!'"'  "<'&>'&'' 59' G' "+"1 ; (=  5 & (55"   9' '" (+'"5"'"5<5'(=' (!  5+  $//:1  "'" 5" '  != 5 9  @/(/// >1 ;&(?  >'1 '  "'" !5'" 5 (55"  1  !=  '9'  "5H' "'">' (>> >'&(5 ;+"' !''!="'"1

21 "5 $#!$//0 &!' ! !'> &!G!=!! 5'5<  !!+;5    .II - -- -6*57 . 81

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



40/%4$//0  *%4#$*    ( '5" 1    &'  ''   >+' ( '?!'9'1  ( &"+!'&!<"+""& 9'G'' 5  '  0 ! (' "'" "+7!' ' ! ! '1  5   57*9<)119'!'"57 9  9  !5' ?  ! 5  !  1  5 &(   575'51   5" & ! H  !'' ? ("'<!'   !5'<'"   !(55'' 5 (>>'5!';595"&'5 >) 5'"?)*M1  J( ( 5 ' 57*9<) (!<"+"" "'"  " '   9'" ? > 5'   "'!'   :/ F' $//01 ##1    $% F' $//0     &" !'  "  55'1 "&(55"'55' *5!'  ''  '  '' 5   < >  '    75 '&5<'"'++"15=!&  9   &   9!'  ''  ('' 5&("9'&''""'" >'&(55"+"' !='1

#$1  5  % 5'!< $//0  '  '!  !' '"1 .+'!!' 57*9< (!<")' ':/ '<$//$ "! '1

#:1 ' !5'5 5'('':'<$//01J ''' ""&'K

L(+' '  "<'&;(5 ';()5&&'') "''+""5"'(5'"+7!' 55("=" "''?;1(+&'!! !' 5C&'"'"'>"1- ;(5 "5" 5'5"'19'>'(' & ; (9 5  59   "'!'1 7  5'!5 $//$ ; !  '" !9'!;(9 '1>'' !95 ) (5''9>>'"='"''  &'" !"  <5  '= 9' G' >' '"!' 61118 (' 5'  !&  & '" '!' " ) +!'  1 1  !5'<'" "'' "'< 5 '!'1    5 ;&(? & ';(5"'< "!5'  61118M1

 5"''    (' ' (  ()!  5<'"  '(+  '"' ('5' =+ >'



40/%4$//0  *@4#$*   5> "!<$//#95!''9:;'$//$ !  (+!' >F'$//$'>!' "!?>'< $//$1

#%1     : '< $//0  <   " (55    1 '!'''5755 5"  ' >)' ":/9!<$//05 "'!1

#@1 "' $B'<$//0 &"!'5'1'  '' ' ! >"9$//#'5' !  "!< $//#   '  ('   !5'  '  &( ;' $//$ 5<<!''? "&' 5' ;$//$1 ' >>'9!' '957 ;'$//$59 (+!'1 ' '(9'5N (>+' "'"(5' 55!' !5'<'"'(9'5+'57 <& (7 ?  <D' ) ''  5  >' > ? (55"  1 <;'9!'5 '5<'"'++"9&'" +"' 

- 1-(9'9" 557+' "'" !!+'5 G'"9'"1

#01 57'! ''"''55 #@ "!<$//0 "'"+ "?;+1



 ! '

#1 +9O+'; 68"'"! >"'''" 7 #F'$//: <' !5" @;+ '5" ''9*5" '@55"''#0;+6'1#'1 '@0 81

-'?O' O"' #0;+5 <>" " $B;9$//%6 .#:/#/08  +9 5'"#:>"9  5'''+'5!''' <'    "+   ? ' ;+ ''   O'''  O"' 9);+1

$1 >!"!' ? ('1 @0  1 # '1  =1#   < '  D''& '''5"9?O' @0 &''9?>" "O*9'99' $/ "!<#2%01

-!5"'5;+  O57'"'<1



40/%4$//0  *04#$*   :1   >" "   5' +""  '    6*57  8 0'<$///''"9+#;9$//:19 5' "+ ' '!!' !5"  5"    "  !''99 (55' (' "5'  !!+ 6 '1 3#  -8 5  5"   "  "  55''   ' !''>6'1@$1$ - ' 9+ 5  # ;9 $//: '1 @$ ' @0  81 O' '' 9 5" &'55<(57 7& "''9+ !!'E"!""5'  !!+6>1 .#:/#81

 9= O' ('1 @$ 1 #  - ' &( 9+ ;&( :# "!< $//$'9'1@$ -! >"#;9$//:&O55&? O)! 5<'" ' 7&;5   =+!' 7+  ''(< "+!''''  '  9+  !!' E  >' ; &!' "'!'  ' 5 ' ' 5'' 6 . #$B  %0B  1 #81  !' ('1 @$ 1 #  -  9+ 5  # ;9 $//: 5  ( '1 @$  - &!'! >'1'!L !5'M'!5" 5 LM 6 !  K !5!'  L +=PM 5 L=+MQ  ' K 55  L  !5NM8  &  'D  =+!' &' )  '   5<'"  (!5C 6>1 . #$2  #: 91  1 :1@ ' G'  5<"  < >" " 6*57 . 8 :/9!<$//%R4204/:81

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



40/%4$//0  *B4#$*   ; >'Q;!&"+!'  " "5' '  ' ? 5'  & '  "  @  6 . #$2  #2@  1$1$#$:#0 1@81&!!'   !!+ >'9=;5 ''+""!'   "5H' ("'' ' 5<' & '  >'>' ('>6 .#$2#2@91 1$1:81  O57>'"'"5"$25'!<$//:O"'' ' "'"5<"$%!$//%' "  '' $@9$//@  '&5'"'' " $& @1 @1 -O'1@$  "59'G'''&" '';5 9 O55'57 & 1

 O57  " ' "'" '>" 5 5 !! "  $@ 9 $//@1 O55'  "'" >'   " "+1    '    <  "  '  #0 >"9 $//0 '   '' ; 7  '>'   "  55'  #3 ;9 $//0  ' &  '9<6'1@0'0/ 81

01 )'! ('@$ -(!5C '9 !!+&("  9'  55' ''!'  5 "++ +91     55 & (' @$  - '  5' 5" 6>1   #232 5+ ##B81

8(57 !!+'5' " ''< 5  (9<'" "'"5!'' $3(B2$ >1 2@5"''  ''5' -4 4 4  5  !  ! ? 5'!< $//$ C !5  '"G' !' >  5''') !!'1

<8('#%"# -"'9':%'9' - 5'(<+'5(!5C  " =&''  "' 9 *? !5'955''1  !5C 9' 9C )  5" &!'  57 !5'<'9"?" !7?& ''5'5'G'"'>(<;'  "1

(<+'  5C  '' '  >  "!5' ' 5 (!5C  'T=  ' 5< 5' 5  1  ' "+   .   ""?"'""5&5<'" (!5C (' @$ -'"'''  '5<6 .##$#@@ 1@Q #23B 5+$$/81 (!5C &(&''5  '''T= !!'9' 55' ('@$ -&'D5(<+'



40/%4$//0  *34#$*    "5 '7!'  !!+  " 6 . ###  #B:  1 $Q #3/#30 1##2$ 1$Q #23@5+0%0 1:81

 . >>!")5"!'&(<+'"+ "5 !!+ ' G'  &    E  !!+ ' F ?  9' ''5"+++95(!5C 55'"+' ( -6 #2B35+$@2Q #2B$5+03B81 !5'& ''&(< !!+5' *<9' 55' 5' !''&(!5C9"*''!' !5 "++ +9   ! E  ()' 5 (  >'  ?  "+'!'"   !5'!'  ? (< ( >' 6>1 .   $3 ; #23$ #23:5+#/#81

8 & (!5C '  5 !  + "5 '  !'?''<   !!+"5*'!!'&  5!()'5!!'E5<'"'++"6>1  0//:  '9 (. -55' ''*Q .##% B2 1:Q##:$@0 1:Q #2335+#:0 1:Q .### #B: #23@5+0%2 1$181

 U+U  >' '  '' 5 5=C& & 5"'  5 !?()'"&5')> "9!5'!'  * 6>1  0//% 81 &( '    ( "'" C!  . ('';">""?('B@%#""'9('B@2 # "  1 >!"!' ?  ' ''  5 =+"  ( !'' +' 'H"5 '?("+  "'"  !G! &(9 =& '  "   !!+ &(    !&' ''!'  5 "++ ?  9 '  5 & "5 ' ( !G! !!+  ' '  !' 69 '1 .#/B:@: 1@Q .##$#23@'(G' $#9#233  Q.'!P'='='V'=P'$7!" 15+$/2 '81

-(+'   -   .   5"" &  +"' >! ( ' "'" &5&)' >'>' +"'!'9*?* 9     !5'  5<'" 5  !!+ "   *5!' ''!G!55&) & (55&' ?  "'" C!1  9=  !5 " (' 5 5<  'H    9   '1 -' !"  +"'!'5&')5"!'"'"!!"''& '6+>!8!&!' >'>' ( +"'1  >' 'C5&!' 5'  5 &  5  >   5' 5 )!5 (" !;'   +"' >!!' ++"



40/%4$//0  *24#$*    ''    '  >>   "'" 6>1 - $/// 51 $$B ' $//$51#B081

8  (57  ' "'' '  +'  !!  &'"  +"' 9 +'  9 1  9'   '<!'  &'" (+ "'"&('' !'51

B1  ;5  ''  .    &( C  "++ +9 & (!5C>!5?&5'G'<!')+" '' 55<  !' '' '&' !G! '6>1 #2B$5102/81! &(' ' ()+ ?'"+  ' G'"9" (57&(5' !'''  !'7 !5'<'"' +' (!5C !G!'"+& ('""1  >>"' !<< (!5 "+!' &( (+' (55"5<'"<  + (!5C6>1 .#/3 $/$  1 :Q   #23@ 51 @#  1 $ ' 51 0%3  1 :<81 &( (+' ("'"C!5'5555 )+"97& ('''&( ' 5' 55'6>1 #2B$ 5102/Q #2B351$0#81 "''!5C5'''!'  5";  ?    ''> 9  "5 ! &!' O ' 5!' ''5!''59 O 5  '" >> ' 5 '' &O '    " ' <;'9 5&O5'O&''  ''  "< 6>1 #22$51$0#';5 '"81

 5' "+!' ' !5'   " 5 ' &  '' ' '"!5C"5" "''9'7'O+ 5' G' 5" 6>1 - #220 51 $$381  '   9  >' &  5<'"  (!5C    ('1 @$  - 55  55'  '"  "&' '  9' ''  5 "++ +9  55' '  9  !!+ 6  -=VN= -N9=+=' 91  51 B/   '1 >Q W -  -= 'N5>='  <'+<   R '=7 X= #232 51 @34@2Q .I-   5<'"  (!5C 5  *5!'  '' ( ('1@$ -9- ( #23B51##81

31 O57'(5' "5!' ''5  !'> ") ' <;'>  &( (7+ ( 51  !G!  5'* ' &  " 5 ' &  '' ' "'" !5C" ' 5'7!' ' 5&( 5''  5' !1  9'  ' "+!' & !G!   ' ("'' 5 =+" (5"  5!' ' (9'5+'< 9'   ! ' +"''   >'  !5'<  ('5 ( &  ''  "''<5C"1'9&(5''9;'$//$''



40/%4$//0  *#/4#$*   "+!''99(55"!(''>' 5!  *  &( "'' )+<   5' &( 9"> &  5! "'' ' 69 5 )!5 .  R 034/@  #0 ! $//081 . ' 7   ''&'9"<+'"+'++"5<'" !!'''"+++91

21  ' ? )! 5 '  ('  ' '    '"  "&' 9  "'  !!+   1 -  ;5   '"' "&' (57  ='()5"  9  >'  "" "'' 55 ? 'D  >>'  +   & (' 5 '9 "''5' >A+"">9"5 ''6 .##3$2/ 1#'">"Q9 .##2 51%/B81

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

'G''' !'75"E .''&>'5  +5  P  (G'   < & &( '    '' 5  !5'!'  )'  " ' !5"9< &( 7+?(7*5'' >'&''<"?(97!' 



40/%4$//0  *##4#$*   "'' '  5'  >' !! 5 ('"" 6 . #$$  #B  1 $4<<81

>'&( !!+' ''>A9 'G'"'<9''   ?  >' +"  9!< 6>1 .  R $0B4/$ ' ">" '"K .'! 111 -1 #//  $B:Q >'+ -=VN1 R>'5>='='    %1 >1 XY= #2B@ -1 #$% >1Q W!  W'S' ! R>'5>='='K   N  =   ) X< #$:4#23B -1 :/%Q  $//: -1 #%0/ !' RV81 ('5 . &('!!'"+!' >'+9 E*!!' '5"!'"5"=<? ('  '   '!5' ' & ('  ()5' ' (!5"9<'E>' '55D'<!!>'5!  !!+6 . R034$//@ #0!$//081

   '" 5'  9= G' !5 & 5'"!' ?  >'+' *5(>>"'" ">'&(55D' &( !!+  ' 9 5    !5'   !!  < "(;+" G' #B!$//@6 -%#%4$//@81 '' >> (''   9'  >>' 5! ("'<  "'"" ' +9!&!'?5" !!5(>> >'     +'   >'   "'"  ' & ('  !!   9' 55'&9'" !!+ ?''55'   ' '4 !  ">   ''> 5<  "+++91

##1  (57!!()5&"''55&(!' "'"(55"<'"!= ('5'!"? @/(/// >1 9 57  >'  * ' ('    5+ E  ' '!' !"1'5 ='!'9!<<   +"  9!< 5"5 "' &   !    & (55"   9' 5"5"  >' ' "'"  (+'   "'" 5  < 5 5  <  ''+7! <1  ' (' '"   !+  5'!5 $//$ !  (9' 5 (""!' >>' 5 "5  5' 5"1   !5'!'5"!'"5"=< (55"'!5'!' 9& '5!5')5''!5"9<'"'" ' ? "+    5 ('  ' ' ? !5    '"  "&'1  '(9' >>'5 !C ()+9!'  ''   (C 5"  *!G!1   59' & "!  5' +"''(9'5&>>''' "!'59  ('  5"5'  5;'  (55"  1    "'!' 9!<<!' >>'" 5 (55"    !''  '' """!"''"'"9'59' !=1



40/%4$//0  *#$4#$*   

#$1 "&' !' "'+"1



! + 2' 1  '!  +'  !+ + 



345-- 6   7     89 (#& :

  5-

#1 "9<1

 5

$1 ( !'' " $@9$//@'#3;9$//01

:1 '&5" '+''1

%1 >!  5'   &O 59' >!  '  5"' G'   "  :/ ; 7  '>' 57  < >" " 6-=VN=>&00//%  859 !'7  ' 5<>!"!')'13$ >" " <>" " #B ; $//@ 6 .8Q  !"!   '  &   !'> ' !C 59'5'+' ' ! 'Q ' G'  "  < >" " 5 9 5'  5 9 "'& )  '  ('1 %$  .1  5"' G' '  57  5  '9&"!!!C 59 9'G';'?(91  +>>7  5" '       Z[ X <-   

5>! 5"'G'''>")5'&O?O>>>" " 5+>>



40/%4$//0