Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/150/2008 • CJ GE ATAS/150/2008 AI generated

Insurance Coverage Dispute Over Hurricane Loss and Windstorm Exclusions

Case Number ATAS/150/2008
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

A dispute arose concerning multiple insurance policies with differing coverage terms, specifically regarding losses sustained during a hurricane, where the carrier argued that damage attributed to the hurricane was excluded by language related to windstorm damage, while the insured contended that the policy's subsequent specific exclusion for windstorm damage, which was not present in all relevant policies, should control. The court reasoned that under the doctrine of construing ambiguities against the drafter, the most restrictive exclusion applicable to the loss should govern, meaning that since the policy language regarding windstorm damage was ambiguous across the relevant contracts, the court would apply the interpretation that provided coverage where the more specific exclusion might otherwise deny it, ultimately finding coverage for the loss.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Coverage Dispute Over Hurricane Loss and Windstorm Exclusions: The court reasoned that under the doctrine of construing ambiguities against the drafter, the most restrictive exclusion applicable to the loss should govern, meaning that since the policy language regarding windstorm damage was ambiguous across the relevant contracts, the court would apply the interpretation that provided coverage where the more specific exclusion might otherwise deny it, ultimately finding coverage for the loss.

Keywords

AI generated
insurance coverage indemnity insurance contract interpretation storm damage insurance exclusion clause insured risk

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs for the federal proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



            !"#$$%  & $#$$"

''

() '*+), , , ( )', *

-.  /  /& 0 #$$" 



 !!!"# $    % %&

 &%

'' $ ' % (% !%)* !&!" + &,-./)-))01,

                

   5-2.5  

, 1*

)6  ,) % -44,  !  (78  '  9!5+%0 :  !;  % # < &%"!! !%"&%&!&&!     ,4<-4, =%6 -4  %%+ & > !!&"  (78 !?& +%@-A!&-44)*"B%-44-<%"<C&+"%"!1% 8!!&%"!!%%"!"A!&-44)#"B%-44-6

-6  1"!5%<!!&! C&+%!&"&" 1%&=1% <%"  ! &% A! -44, & ="1%!% -443  %&    & &  /</*.=%6*3%!!&"(781%"#<%"#%! <1!%  ,44=%6+% !6  &&%1!# +%+%&! +% <%"#!(786 <! "!5%<%"<&88" #%B %%#! ?#%! ,44=%6+% !6

,6 +%0%++).1%!-443<%" 1%" ,44=%6,A! -4436

D6 )E+&B%-443!!&% !&+ %!&#< &%<%"6

36 &&%!0% %1%" &&-44=%6&),"B%-4436

*6  )4 ="1%!% -44* <%" <&   1 = !  " # <%5 (78& 1"!5%<!!&! "&" 1%&=1%6

/6 % %%!%)41%!-44*!!= %"<%"F<%&!%!&% !!&" F!!%&!&#1 !%-)<E,D=%6336<&%"="%"> !%&!1  '%"&%!& <"&& # <"  ! 9' ; &  >+!F" # <%" F  && &! =!! &!%!& #!G&%1%"6

.6   ! <1%! -44*   !!&"  ,*. =%6 *3  !! "&" +C" # <%"  %%+ & >  &!  =!!6     !& -<)3) =%6 34  %1!# +% %"!1%<%"6

E6  )-  A! -44*  !  (78  % # < &%  <%"  "!!  = %  =!%&  F< ! 1!&  "     %%!%  )41%!-44*#1 !%F<%&!%!&%!!&"(78& &!&"   && "  %&!&&!  # <>+&!    &!  =!!6  !  (78   !"%" F< <"&!& + &  %+&%  !! 1!&&+ 1!& %&!%& &!&"!!&"(78#<>+&!   &! =!!&AF<# %% &&-)<E,D=%6336

)46 %& !!1&!!!%&#&!&% +&! :



23*.2-44/  5,2.5   A!-44*: -</.4=%6/3 A!&-44*: -<-34=%6D3  ?&-44*: -<3.)=%6 +&B%-44*: -<*34=%6D3 & B%-44*: -</.4=%6/3  1B%-44*: -</.4=%6/3 "B%-44*: )<./)=%6.3 &  &% "&" 1%" # <$ +! 8""% 9&   # <%" !%&&;   !1&: A!-44*: D44=%6 A!&-44*: D44=%6  ?&-44*: D44=%6 "B%-44*: //.=%6*4 ))6  -EA!-44*<%"= %" ++ !&!  &#F<!  !&+ +!"&"% !!1!&6<&%"="%"#A%!+% %!B =""%%9 H ; F%"<!&!&&! "%!&"  !+&G&% +"1+%&&! #%"!=!& % %!5!&5 !!1!&9 H)-.3,& ),4343;6

)-6 &%5&+ <%"  + 1& + =!% = > "+ F! "&!&  ! <& %" # <$ +! 8""%6  %!% !  1%"  &!&%  <!& ! &&& &--<4/4=%6)3A!-44*#="1%!%-44/  && + % F <%"  <!% !8"  % !  &&  =1%<$ +!6

),6 %"!! % ++ !&! )4A1!%-44/! =!%""!!  )-A!-44*6'%"="%&>!%&!1'  !"%"F%" + 1!&G&% %&!+%1 ! +&! %<B+%&&!   &!%  +&  !! 1!&6  !   +%&!!%  !F" # <%" %%!% C!"&"-/A1!%-443%"+%' # %"  F  '  !!F   (+!&% !&!&" I+%!!+ ++!B&!0% +&! 9%&6ED ;:

I<%&6 ED 6 )    1!8% +!  )% A!& -44, !+   &&F%&!&&! +%&! 1%&+%"& ! +1&G&% +"+%&%6

! !9 ;!  % <++!&! 9 ;+%"1 !& %   +&!  &%  %&!&&!  &  +%&&!   < B!8&!  + %<%5(78&!% +&!!1!&<%"6



23*.2-44/  5D2.5   !%&!1+%"&' 9&! 2 -44D2)=!(*2) &-44D2-=!(E2);+%%!1&"8&+%!!+< %&!&  %"   !  (78 +%  1 !    +&!  % <B  +%&!   # <%" 9+%&&!  %"&% &!1 & +%&&!    %;  +%!   !"%&!   !! 1!&6  <++%&!& + # <%5(78   1%!%  B ! 1!&>  %"#<!+%&&! F! &"&"& ("!0%!6

 !%&!1 &! " %+&  +%%!+&!   %%+ &     )E.* 9 !%!%  %&  %&!&&!   +%&&!  !?& 1%"   +&!  &  &%!&&    %!;6  (6 %86 --     F! +%"1 C!& F 5 I  && # %&!&%  & #  +% +%  +&   %F<!  & !+ %&&I & F I =!& ! !+ %&  %08 8""%  =!>%   +&   & !0% F<! %&  +%!!+ # <%"  !!1!&% !&+ %!&I5& B 0&6

  "F    =!%   +%&!F %& +%  ! 9J;  !&& #  %&!%  %"   & %  !!&"  (78% #&!&%%"&% &!=!"8&%F! & +%0"!! 9J;AF<# %% &&& &%"6I

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

)36 % %%!%)*="1%!%-44/ %!B"!+%&!+%!%"!# !+ %!=!%+%1!%%"+ &  !%6' 1!  >!0 "! !  "&" !+%&! +%  %%!%  )/ 1%! -44/6 ' +  06 %&F<%!%&&!"!"&"!+%&!#!+% %%!% -4A!-44/6



23*.2-44/  532.5   )*6 &&%!0%=!&%"+ +% %%!%DA!&-44/6!& + !&! &!!F"F<<1!&+<&% &#= %!%F>"A# +% !&+%% %&6

)/6 ! +%&! +% <&&&),+&B%-44/ #F!(78?& 1 F"=!&"=&<>%6

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

, ('*

)6 = %"& # <%&6 3* 6 ) &6  (6 .    ! 81 ! % < %8!&!  A!!!% 9;  %!B &   %  !  M&  !& !F   &&&!  +%"1 # N%&! 3*    ! =""% %  +%&! 8""%% !&% !* & B%-4449 ;%&!1#  ! =""% % N%5(78 B!8& !% & N!!&"   N! 1B!!&"-3A!)E.-6' +"&+ %A8%N+0&!! "&B!6



23*.2-44/  5*2.5   -6  % %  "&" !&%A&"   = % & "! +%"1 +%   ! 9%&6 3* # *4  ;6'+ +&F&! %1B!!&"&++%&!!0%& <>!&<!&"%G&#8!%% %&6

==&+%"&!&!8  &!"%&!&&! + +F+%!!+%&!&&! !5G &+ &&"6' + &F&! 1 !%!% %&"&"+%!1"  &!& + !B!!&"%%!  B!8&! %&!&&! &1 !% !  ! "&!& = " # +% "% #   +&!   +%&&!  1  %"&!% +&!!1!&6

'<8!&+%!0%F&! ! 1!&%++%F <%&6D6D < %  %  +%&! 8""%  % !&  %  ! 9 ;  %! !&G&%+%"&"+%"%!&+&%,4A %# +&% <&%"= %"!! %&!&&! 6<+0"!! %&!&&!  "&"%&,)%-44,"A#6<%"<C&+"+ "  %!   &%& A % !1& && "!!  && %!0% & &%"  = %6%&&<%8&% %& F=!&F!!&!# >"&!   "!!    +&!    &&% <&%"  = % <%!& +%!1"   + !B!!&"  %  %!    B!8&!   %&!&% &  && <>   B  = ! & B # =>6 '! <%" &!& =!% 1 !%  B  = !    < =!& + %  +%!0% = !  %  <! 1&  %!B  " ! ! ++%&!&     =!% +%  B!! < %!"+ ""!!+%&!+% !6 && +% "%&%8&+&+G&%>!"6

&  F&!    +%!   +&  !! 1!&   &    +&! 6 '(& F   +&!    %"   ! 1  !!&"  #  % %& & " %! &%!"  F&!   +   1 !% ! <%"  %1  !&"%G& # 8!% &  && #  =!% %B %%   &&F!%!&?"("&!G&%1%"&% 1%!&"B%-44*+ %+&% !!1!&6

,6  1%&  +%!!+  <!&"   +% "%  F!&" + % 8!% 1&  A%!!&!  &   &  "!!   & A&& # % %  % !& !!&%&!=  +& G&%  ! #   !&!  !=="%&   F! %"8!&F!&"+ %% %!% !=""%< %8!&! A!!!% )*"B%)ED,9%&6))3K H),43*- !6,6-K '))3324/ -,6)464/;6

 F!&"+ %% %!%F! F&&&!&+%"!! &&F"  !&"%G&!8+% &&! #F< !&"  !=!"6& !"%"+%  A%!+%   !&"%G& !8  +% &&!     && !+ !&!  & &!&"%G&+%&!F A%!!F#% !=!&!  <&! 



23*.2-44/  5/2.5   "!! &&F"F+&=!%1 !%+% &&!&+%&&%!0%6 !& G&% F!=!" <!&"%G& !8  +% &&!  <&!!&" +%&!F F <!!   % % ++ %&%!&  % %&  !&  =!& <"1!&%  +%"A!  &% "  !F!"&"%! &%F"!! &&F"! ! %!&6 <!&"%G& !&G&%!%&& %&6+%  !&&% 1% && %++ %&==!&"&% !&1"!! 6 <&+!F!<& &&!& F  !0% !!%&  "!& 9 H ),4  -4-  !6 , )-/  ,  !6)B.- !6,2;6

<+0G! %!B"1!&=!& %F<&#& %& F  ! < + &  +&  !! 1!&   % %& ! < %+ !F &&%!&?G&%%B %"#!&7& &%5 F!<&+ &&"6 %&<%"!!&&! =!!0%!==!!? % # B""=!!%  <!  ! &  !!  &%&"  && 1% && %!0% <  && # + +%0 "F!1& # !   && 1%  ! 1& +&! 9 &&&& &%&"1%<$ +!:--<4/4=%6)3K  &&&&1%!:-)<E,D=%633;6

 & +&  &> F  % %& !&  !&"%G& !8  +% &&!  #  F  "!!    +&!   !& "   !=!" # +%"& F   +&!   "&" " #   &%6   +&  &!% F <!!   % %%!&+ %==&<"1!&%#<%"+%"A!&%"  !F6 ==& !  %!B !1!&   !  &  !&  ! # ! %1%%  +%&!   && +%"1" %  !!&"  %" 1%  ! %M&%!& & <%"  1%%!&  < B!8&!   %"==&%   &&  %B %&   &   ! ! !  <$ +!6  % F< <"&& & <! & 1%! F  &&   % %&  "&"  FF  %& &%="%"   ! 1% <$ +! 8""%  < + +"A %" + % &&  !&&! 6

H %& &&%F<#&<!&"%G&!8+% &&! %F!+ %8!%=!& "=&#% %& %&F% % !&G&%"%"!%%1B6



23*.2-44/  5.2.5  

'  2 *1  '*+), , , ( )', * 

)6 "%% %!%%1B=&<!&"%G&+ %8!%6

-6 !&F+% "%&8%&!&6

,6 = %  +%&!   FN +1& = %% % %  &%  +%"& %%G&   "!  ,4 A % 0   &!=!&!  +%0  %!B =""% 9'(O!P%( =F!**44D  ;+%1 !% %&!0%% !& +B! = %"&>%&6.- !=""%% %!B=""%)/ A! -443 9 H;K  " !%  % %  !& !!F%   !   &!= &  C+%1&+ %&%!8&%% %&  &!%K! !& G&% %"  %!B =""% +% 1 ! + &  +% 1 ! "&% !F >  !&!   <%&6 D-  H6  +%"& %%G& &  +!0  + !   % %&!1 F"  C+%1 !1&G&%A !&#<1 !6  8%==!0%  +%"!&         %!8!&&Q' $ R%!'  R

  +!  = %  +%"& %%G& &  &!=!" > +%&! !! FN '%"&%!& <&&#<"  !+%8%==



23*.2-44/