Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1386/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1386/2007 AI generated

Disability Onset Date Benefits Appeal

Case Number ATAS/1386/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant challenged a judgment that affirmed a decision to deny benefits, arguing that the finding that his claimed disability, starting prior to the statutory cutoff date, was unsupported by substantial evidence due to the administrative law judge's failure to properly consider all medical evidence, particularly regarding the onset date. The court reasoned that substantial evidence supported the administrative law judge's finding that the appellant's disability did not manifest until after the relevant date, as the evidence, including treating physician statements and consultative examinations, sufficiently supported the conclusion that the required period of disability had not been established by the time of the statutory cut-off.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Disability Onset Date Benefits Appeal: The court reasoned that substantial evidence supported the administrative law judge's finding that the appellant's disability did not manifest until after the relevant date, as the evidence, including treating physician statements and consultative examinations, sufficiently supported the conclusion that the required period of disability had not been established by the time of the statutory cut-off.

Keywords

AI generated
disability benefits medical evidence statement of claim social security litigation reasoned decision standing to appeal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal procedure.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           %&''%'(() *%+,&-%'(()

!*

 *  * ! !  !

.  '

$ / 0.  '(() 



  !"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"! ( ")%

"!

     & ++ ,    % ! %"%$ -./ 

              ! " #$   $

   ,201,  

! 1 *

45  6%, !7!!"8$9$#!%!4.:;"!#%$ <%"$  %!=  !7  %" >  +5 5  %  4! % 4... ?<&22$@!2334"A<$"$#%"%B%" %!"%6%%"$!#"!#$)%85 "%"B"$ ! !#%=%"@=%"$"$%#%B!!C""""!#% ! !" $% %%"%  4: ?#%! 2332 $"@% !  "!  $% !$%!-5

25    & ++ +  +++9%$" BD !"%"! $%%"*E!)"=%5 %,%   ! !"  43 ?#%! 233;  %="%<$  !#%=% )!%<  %<$$ )$% %"," !!-!=,-9"% !#% F, :"-!9%@!-=%<B)$%!  !%"  -! !D "9! !%""5   %=$ <B B@$%"%<$"!@B%" #%"D %<!A%  !%" ")=%!!)%%5+BD !"%B- #%"  B% %"$  "!#%  !"%  %"$ # B%"  22 $@!2334A !"%!4!?#%!233;5

;5 /%233;!!"$ $ !7B99%"B! %#%%"$6%, !7B 8 !""%""AB"!%B !"B%#%%"$5

F5  !!"  $"$ % A  D !"% -)%"!%< !$ !   =% B! "% %5   ! !"  24 % 233;  "!   $%%" *E  -)%"!%  %="%<$  -")-% <% B" <B $"" $ !%9 $=! "  "%@ #  "%#%"$ A 433G5 BD !"  !#$ <  #% % " 9%%   !!" $"%" !$!#$ "  < !   -)%<   !$"%"  "!@ ?"%9%"% %"$<<"!#%5

:5 #%$"$!<%+!#%$%!$=%6+85 4/9$#!%!233F D !""!%$D%D !"% -)%"!%<""%< !$%$ ! "B!%"5

H5 !$%%F!233FB !9$"" !""%5

/5 +%"A& %"%!!"& 9%!$!9 !$%%!  %"%4.#!%233F5

15 +%"!!$ $ !!!"4/%233F !%@$ !?"$  !! ! !!C"  2: ?#%! 233:5 !7 #%! !  %



01220233/  ,;01,   #! !@" D D !"% "%< " -)%"!%<  !%@  !" #D !"&@""""%"A"$!=%<@?"%#D,% $#<" !$9""!@"9!!D"!#!B$$" !"""  !"%!  $"" $ !%9  D%D $#7!   "!@   !%"$%9"5 %%BD%"B!@%"$ -)%"!%<"" B=   !$ <  B%"$ #%" C"! %$  C <  !$ $#" B"! !%"7! !""" B !$%!  !"7! %#%"  "!@"9!!D5

.5  %  ! 233:  !!"  "!%  #D " $%D A &  <%  #!"  !$!  #   !""%5

435 &  99"$D -)%"!%<!!"4:9$#!%!233H !&"!%+%" !%! 5 ,% !" %="%-")-%"-!!D"9! !%"" $<"!<" !%!! %"$"!#%!!"5 7!==!#"%&$"""$&$"$!"5

445 !$%%2.?#%!233/& !9$"" !""%A!!" "%9<&%&-#%" &==!#"%&$"""$5

425   !!  4! ! 233/  !!" " !$@" A  D !"% $% !%% " A &"%   $%% %"%=% " A &"!% & !" "%7! &%#%%"$ # %"  $ 5  %7! < &==!#"%&$"""$"$"@%" !%"%#!! !"$%D !"%%!!!)"=" !=!$ !%  EI J  + +  + 6%, !7 E555 ! *85

4;5   !$   F % 233/ &  "  !?"  !!5  + 9%!#$!%9%"%9%"##D! !"$%D<&%&-  &==!#"%&$"""$5

4F5  !%@$!$&#!"!<C"" !$$A&%"%  ! * -)%"! A &%  24 K" 233/5 ,%  $!$  <% %" L M %    !=! $ !%  E %.$@!233:5!=$"!%"$$"$%#% !  !  "!  %  9$#!%! "   "@! 233H5  %="% $  $"$  $ % $ !%9 $#7!  - "N -)"%<5 =!$%#%%="%""?!&"%"$?!&)%5%!%< "%"&"?%!"%$""$ !%9&" !<& !   "!@ $ !%9 !$!!" <%    $"" $ !%9 %#% & !$%%%#%&!)"%5



01220233/  ,F01,   <%& !%%="%<!"$""$ !%9$#7!&"&$""%%<  "%"5  !%"7! %="% !" "  ")-% "!%"  D%$"$  )$%  ! % ! %  !"%" -)"! % !""  !"  "%#"%  "%"  $ %!  "!@  % # )! !"& $"%"%$%!5 ,%""?! !$" ?!&)%"? !$%< "%"$="%$%%%! $@!233H<%"?"%9%$) %"%"% !F:?!5%!%<   $#"% %"%#   "%" "  % ")$! "%< <% &" %"!$ ? % "!# $="  %   % !"!$ % ?&@!# !$99!5

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

&D %< <  !!" " !$%"" A "  "!%"" "! !% ?<&!&" ",C"! !<% -)%"!&#-$ %<  $%%$%5-99"%#" !"&%"$=!"% %5 ?!&)% "%" "!"%!"" C !9%! !5 &"""" $%"#%%""   9% %< "  "%",9%5   $! "?! "!#!  "!%"" 99%%!<"%?&%%<<&?!&)%&$"" -)%<"!%"%$ C%&=! %!5



01220233/  ,:01,   &D %< < !   "%<  !"% @!  $#!" " $"$ 9%"5 99!& =%"!"%%!<%! $!$ " "$"" !$%$<=%"! "#%!%9!&$""$ !%9Q 99!$="&=<%&" %#%"%%%%" %@%%"$"!%""Q ")=%%"!%7<%" !%!  "$%"A@!#"%9%" !!E!!!" !"<;)! !%"5%#"%="%9%" !?%233/&"  "!$ &""%" !# $!% )$!%<   9%@  @! %9$!%!!%"")- ")$%"$"$!$#$$! !=%<5

 !%D! !"$%D5&==$="A# !%! % ""99"$""=%#% !"!!#%5M5

4:5  !7,#!@&<C"%%<" !%""""99"$ " $"$ %  + !  !$%"%5   #%  : "@! 233/  + !"%"  $ % $ !%9 $#7! # % %""  % &$ 233H !7&D -)%"!%<99"$ !+9$#!%!233H%<% &" %%"$#&%"!#23345

4H5 !!!%!4/"@!233/ !%@$%"! $!!"! <"%"#%!&%#%" #<% !$7&"%!A &%% !+&==!#"%&$"""$!!"9%D$   !"  &$ 233H " =$$!"  "" % %"$  "!#% %" !"&%#%%"$"%7! %%!233/5

4/5 ! !!%!  44 #@! 233/  !!" %7! <   %"$  "!#%%"C"!9%D$.$@!233: "!A9%%?#%! 233H5

415 !7"!%%!!%!A& 4.#@!233/$"$ =!$A?=!5

!  *

45 9!$" A B!"5 :H  5 4 "5  )5 :   !%@ "  !%'"%"%<"""% !$#AB!":H %9$$!H"@!2333! !"%=$$!!%"! %6 8<%"!"%#A%9$$!!B!,%#%%"$4. ?%4.:.6 85

+ $" !?=!B 7"%%$"@%5

25 %9$$!! !"%=$$!!%"!%H"@! 23336 8"!$#%=!4!?#%!233;" %@& 75



01220233/  ,H01,   ;5 $ $9!"$%% $ !% !$"!!"!#@ 6!"%:HH3 85

F5 <"%%"%=%!$?!&)%A" !%&99""" % %"$  "!#% ! $<" A  " &"!$  #%=!  !%" A  !"   !!"5  +   99" %  #  # %7 !%" "  !7,#!@ &<C" <  !!" 99!%" & $ % $ !%9$#7!"<&%-#%"@%==!#"%&$"""$5+" !%   "  &D  + %,% )%" ""9% <  "" % %"$"!#%%"9%D$4!!233H5!!"&- # $!"% -)%"!"%7!<"A!"%!" %$@!233: "!9%%?#%!233H5

:5 ! !<B!"52154 "!#%=! %4! ?#%!233FB!$!%"A!""%7!B%"%#%A/3G% A"!%,<!"!"&%"%#%AH3G%A%,!"B% " %#% A :3G  %  A  <!"  !" B% " %#% A F3G  %5

! <B %#%%"$ %" ! % " $%!  )<  <B %="% !"%"%" $ ! $%%""<%"%$#% %%"%% !"" %"$"!#%6 *42/22.85

+&!"%2. !%"A!" !% "N"A"7 < &!$  !$"$  -  % %"$  "!#%  F3 G  % "  $  %"!! "% "@5  !" " $ 7  $@"%!<!%"A!" !%%5

!%!&!"54/ %"D&%#%%"$@$$9%%%!!" @%"%9%"%"@!""&99%!!$#%$ ! &#%!A#%!="$!$%"$<! !%$5

  <% !  #! !@" B ! !" $%  <% " $"!%"B"< %"%"%=%D% !""%"9%"B@?"B$" 9%$ <  ! !"  9 !  D  " <B% ! $="  %$!"%  %" D !%$ <B% %" $"$ $"@%  % %%! 678<!% "%"D"$%%" %! "9%< %BD !"%"@%"%#$6 *422 4H3Q+2333 54:F85

 9!$"  !%%    %@!  !$%"%  !# B%%"!"% ?= !$% !#C"!%$ !!7=9! !$" A   !$%"%  7" " !%=!  !#5  %" D%!  %7!@?"%#"- !#<<B%" !# % $%! %  " A % %"% !"""  !"!  ?=" #@



01220233/  ,/01,   !  !%" %"%=%D5 +%  ! !" $%D " "!%"%! %  " "!)! B99%!   !$%! B@  !# " %%<!  !% !<%9! %%$%" !"!6 *  @%$4!?%"233;4H/03;85

!!C"!$"6H:03/;453153/8 !%@9$$!! $<  ! !" &D %=$ !  !  #  "% M -)%"!*EM&#%"  %#! !@"" #%"!#%!7 !@A$"!%"%!%"D !""%5

H5  #   <% !$7 % -  %  9%D!  "   "" % %"$  "!#%4!$@! 233:" !$<" &#!"!!%"A!" "%7!  4! $@! 233H5 +   99" 9%!$ & !$%"%  $% -)%"!  #  %7 !%"5 %  !" 7 !  &$!"!    !$%"%5 ! !   ""%  . $@! 233:  %="%"%$$"$ $"""% %"$"!#%9%!$A &%"!   <  !$$" $% -)%"! #%" $?A 9%"5  !%"7! !"""  !"%!  !"7! %#%" D "!@ -)%< !"" 7!##!%@ !$ $!"6 *42H;H3%5:@42: 4.:%52"!$9$!Q95 *4;3;2F%5;52";5;8$@" %$@!233:""5

/5  !!" <% @"%" =%    !%" A &"!%  $  9%D$  & 7A2&3339!5





01220233/  ,101,  

 ! * 1 ! *  * ! !  !

$

  23.

45 $!!!!#@5

$ 23

25 &""$%%2.?#%!233/5

;5 %"<!!"%"C"!%@$$9%&!""%7!&%#%%"$# 99"4!$@!233H5

F5 #%%!A&  !#$%%%$!"5

:5 "$":339!5A)!=& 5

H5  &   #!" & %%"$  !$!  9#!   !!"2&3339!5

/5 9!  !"%   <B #" 9!! !! "!  !$" !!C"   $%  ;3 ?! 7  "%9%"%  !7  !%@ 9$$! 6+)R%O!)9<%HH33F  8 !#%!!"%7!!%" @%9!$"D!"512%9$$!! !%@9$$!4/ ?% 233: 6 *8Q  $%!  !! %" %%<!  % "%9 " - !#" !"!%="!!!""%!Q%%" C"! !$  !%@ 9$$! ! #% "  ! #% $"!%< D %"%  &!"5 F2  *5  !$" !!C" "  %7  %  !!"%#<$- !#%#"C"!?%"A&#%5  =!99%7!   !$%"         ST ( @+   

 %9! !$"!!C"""%9%$D !"%%%<BAB99%9$$! !% !=!99



01220233/