Sanctions for Undisclosed Evidence Withholding
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court considered whether a party's failure to disclose certain evidence, known to be in its possession, warranted a specific sanction, namely the exclusion of related testimony and the striking of responsive pleadings, despite the evidence being available to the opposing party through other means. The court reasoned that the purpose of discovery rules is not only to provide information to the adversary but also to ensure orderly trial preparation and adherence to procedural mandates, thus upholding the trial court's discretionary decision to impose the exclusionary sanction for the deliberate and unjustified withholding of discoverable material, even though the undisclosed evidence was ultimately presented through other avenues.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sanctions for Undisclosed Evidence Withholding: The court reasoned that the purpose of discovery rules is not only to provide information to the adversary but also to ensure orderly trial preparation and adherence to procedural mandates, thus upholding the trial court's discretionary decision to impose the exclusionary sanction for the deliberate and unjustified withholding of discoverable material, even though the undisclosed evidence was ultimately presented through other avenues.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedRelated Decisions
AI generatedKey legal questions extracted by Legislator
AI generatedCited in the dispositive for ordering the losing party to pay the costs of the appeal.
Full text
#$%&#'&&( )#*+$+#'&&(
)
) !) ! !
!,-. / '% 0-. '&&(
! "# $#%&" '(
!"
/-)%*/
1 )
%0 1/23 4 5( 6 7( #3 8 -,,- 95: # (( 23 # 5;< 2 = 7"2#=#297((0
-0 >%8-,,?"5'2<((#77@@''(#2 #(<0
>0 > 2'= -,,?" 5( #(2( #'# #5#'( # 5/ $A': 23 # # 1/23 4 60 < #9( 95 5BC2#@#:0
?0 5((:#''1/234 69# #! !! D E 1/234! ((6" 7 : #7#" #2 * 8 -,,>0 (( 2 =" ''" 5B2 #5 : # (( #57: 27("2#29#='=''=" 7(#2#@#7"#5'"7# '7(<70
*0 B:(#5(## 2F#G #'(#$A':0
&0 %, 2'= -,,?" 5( @'( H " #' # ! #2 * 8 -,,>" 95 #(' 7 @@ ''(# # @ # # # (( #'#( # @ (2I#(# #392=0
.0 #%,2'=-,,?"H "# # " @( 9 @# # ! 9 #357(($@@#5@@#2##(9 5(572C('(9##((0
+0 %?2'=-,,?"5(((#(# 0
J0 (#'(#$A':#>2'=-,,?->' -,,&0
%,0 -*@(7-,,*"5(#7(( 9## ! 7:#7#0
%%0 @(7 -,,*" 5(2 # 5( (( ::( 2 ! 9 ( K95G @ ' -,,&" # G 9 (( ( 2 # =#:(0
)*+,)-,,. />)%*/ %-0 #52$A':#5(2#5("%7-,,&" ( 9 5( ( ( '' # # ! 7 :#7#0
%>0 #-+7-,,&#(G "7# ;" #' # ! #2 %+ 7 -,,&" ( 9 5( 72#(("955(2("9557 27 # (( 95 57 2@ # B # ! 7 (2 # 2(# #57( # /0 B29( 9 5( ( :( 2 # 2@ B9'39(G'K(=0
%?0 <(#G5#'(#$A':#5(2#5( '@ 9 # ( # # ! 7 : #7#" 5(((#(# 22#'#".K-,,&"22'G (2#=((@#2#5/$A':0
%*0 #(#?8-,,&" (##5(B2# 5/$A':#-*@(7-,,*.K-,,&('( ##'(7(#-*@(7-,,*->'-,,&2(' # ?*5&>J @0 -*0 #(( 9 52 # 5( 9 ##! (':#5@:G#5'2<# 9527@#'3#('#(#((0
%&0 %,7'=-,,&"5(((( 9##! 7:#7#0
%.0 #( 22 # %& K7 -,,." (7 G 522 # %%2'= -,,&" @'( 2 #(( 9 5( 5722((('70
%+0 #%*@(7-,,."5(##(22 23 # = # (0 G 5 #5#'( # $A': # -*@(7-,,*->'-,,&G##B#'( #$A':0(:(95( 9## ! 7 : #7# 'I' 95 57 ' @ # 52 # 5( 2 (0 B2( 9 272=#@7#5'22 #( # 2 ( # 7 '# =0 2$( G 5'( # 2 7 '2 # '( #5: #:" #('" # 2 7 B'( 3 2 B' 5(# # 27 # #(0 (:( 95 57 2 2 @ 2 # #( # 52" 295 57 " 27 # 52 # 5( 2 5< # ('9" 7'2<(079(=#'7##(
)*+,)-,,. /?)%*/ 9G@#'2#232#7## #5I#'@95'(7((##(# 7#0
%J0 = # ( '2 #( G 5'( %& ' -,,. 2 @ 27(2#"2"#75#5'("2:( #(*7-,,.0
-,0 %, 7 -,,." 5'( 5 =( G 7< 23 9 @#( #(0
-%0 =#(2(#(G'22#29 >,'-,,.05'(522((0
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
)*+,)-,,. /*)%*/ 23# 2' # # 2 '0 7 ' 7#((#'#27(05(=#('2#' 9 K57 G 5 0 $A': '57 # 9 K #7 I #( # 227$#'(#$A':0 23"2:$ '5#9K27@9K705:95<7 #B#'(@#5I 0'"9K$ "572#5'20P 9"#2(#(((7(0 --0 >, ' -,,." = # ( ''9( 23/7= # #G5'(0
->0 =#(7#9I0#5##%%K-,,.G 95'(522((" ;#((4@' I #' # (( ! G 37" =((@ #5 : #7#0 5( ( # ((0 2" ! '2<#B0 5'/'I'9::08-,,&"7 # @3 # ((" K5 #8 #5I (0 7$( #'#(("#5#K'0 #22(0 7#95 23#2#37"#'#="K#'#(##7 ##(("952(0'(="(: :7#5=G"':#@2#'0 5B29 9 = $ (: 7 2 9 2722#((0'"K225=0 52$(#07#((9'2 (:02(G(:#9((5K'#B0 #'( $Q " %-" $0 #@/0 52$(#''"572 :(#05B299("K5::(#Q#5B 2 # ' # #(0 9" K5#9 9 F2B9"G' 0 52 2 # 9 " # 9 7 G @3#((0 ##'9#''2( 1N60@''#7(2'2#((" 9(#(2#G2'20 5'957::(0 9" K5#9 9 2 9 (( #'( $Q @95(2@2'9 27 #' $Q " 29 @'' @ 9 (0 (( 5 2 '< # 2< # B1N60B952#9#(2 7( #522 #5@@0 2 # #( 7 @'#(("K20"@''"K '(@39'G! 0P0
)*+,)-,,. /&)%*/ 2"#'#((4L@'7((::(2 ;"#'#((! ''("@(7 -,,*1N60((! #'($Q'0'52#"# '" # ' # @@" # @B0 ' 2 2( # #('2 # # B ::( 2 ;0 1N60 2( @ 9 ' ' 5 27 # ((" 5 2 2C#0((''#295#'=B 7 # 2 3 $ 27 # </0 5#' 2'9522"5::''@B0'$:( # '#(:7#2=@##($ 0 5 @ 2 #(0 5 2 $( # '' 2 7(0 9 K 7" K 7 # 9'# ;P0
9" =#(<(B2#(>%K-,,.2 @2#(7=7239I0
-?0 2 5 2 2(( #5=7 " %* 8 -,,." = # (@'(95:#GK:0
)
%0 @'(' G 50 *& 0 % 0 $0 + # :7 5: K# 16" = # F 9 # 2(7 G R *& # @(#( 2 :(( # # # # & = -,,, 1 6 9 7G@(#(R/$A':=:R#'( #R7=(#-*K%J+-1 60
'2(2K:##R23(=0
-0 "(7:%K7-,,>"#'I'9'#@# #--'-,,-1>3'(76#5 #-+'-,,>"( 7:%K-,,>"22=523#39#'## 22(%K-,,>1@0 S%>,??�%"%-J ?#0%0-60 ("22#(722(K952 K2#'3##G5#'(#$A':#5 2 (( '#@( 2 5( 7: # # >3' (7 # 17 S%>,>?>#0>60
>0 (( @'( '2 " %* @(7 -,,." # #( # K 10&,0% 6 # %J K7 '# %. @(7 -,,." 27'#%J@(7-,,.1@00>+0%> M0%.0>#
)*+,)-,,. /.)%*/ :7 2(# #'7 # %-2'= %J+* 1 670%&0%0= 0 K(# @' #(2(72"7=10*& 60
?0 :25=:##''#?*5&>J@0-* #5#'( 7( G # -* @(7 -,,* -> ' -,,&0 7$"#G5#'(#$A':2(###5=K # 2( " #('( 2 #( # :" = 95 5< 2 #5 '3 # < 7 1@0 S %-* ?%? #0 %" %%J = >& #0 %= (@( (60 *0 7#R+0%0 "5(#G5#'(#$A':2 "''"9R'2#7G2(## 9R=((0
K2#" 7 9 K #5 2@ '2=G#5'2<52#G5#'(#$A':9" =9(@''22"#@B#( # 5'2< #5@ / # '3 #('0 "@@"#(2=#5#25#'(# $A':(:''3#5#'(#(##5$ # 7" 2 50 >% 0 > 0 0 #2 (:" 5 2 # G 5#'( 2 9 @B #( 9 2# 5'2</27@#(='/9(#5("# ''= #5 : #: # 52 # #( #5 22 @3 G 52M 7 # 'I' # K # 2" 9 2( # 520 " B ( 2('5#'(#(##5$#7#G 5#'(#$A':1 S%->->?60
= # 50 >% 0 > # 2(7 = 95/#(7 # ( G 5#' # (# # 5$ # 7" @ # '2" 3 A= # 2 # 7 (" '' /#( /2=( # '$ # @@ 2$Q7<22#(( 22 @3 # @ #: 1@0 S %-> ->? #0 .=)==" S%-,*-%M= ) -,,>)?@$?)%60 525=7(( '' 9 K2# # " ' 9 #5= 9 2( 7' #5#'( G 7 K #5 '2=G #5'2<1 S 2=(#%? 7-,,>" J-),-"#0?60
7$ #@@( 9# (" 7 # 2 '= G #5 '2<" 9 #(@7' 52
)*+,)-,,. /+)%*/ # @' # /M 2 " 2 #5 '2'7G(#07#'I'9#52 #5B ' 9 (" 2 # ( # " '2 #(@7'7((0''#5"5(( 2222(#G##'(#$A':1 S%->->?#0 .=)==M -,,% T%?220?%/?-#0-M -,,>T--20-?%#0 -60
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�%=(@(60''=# #5#'"#B22IB95(# #(' 2 3' 2=( 95 B # ((1@0 S%---.>#0>M -,,?T-%20%J+#0>0-60
927"K:#@##("@ #2 # " @ 9" @ #5I (= # '3
)*+,)-,,. /J)%*/ (@="22''27'=="5/G/#92( #:(#7'=2(2#(0@@#295@2I #(('''$<2$32=0'(('#@ (:( 7:=" K: #" ($(" B 9 222==1 S%-&>&,#0*="%-*%J*#0- (@(M @0 S %>, >-? #0 >0- >0>60 5B// 2" # # " 22 9 5#' K: #7"##"@7#5(1 S%-&>--#0*60
&0 # #5I # G @ 7 G 5 # 2(#@(#2"2272("#22 2(##(93K#91 S%-?%+,#0 %60K2#''#(####5I#"#(#50 -J0- 0"#2K=#5B29795#( 2G#('"#@#279B@#G@ # #(" #57 3 #" # 22 G 5#' # 27" #5 2# # #(' G 22"5=:25(#'7#("@95((2 '2#" 59 ' 5 < 9 5( # 2 B A0 1 S %-& %& #0 -)" %-? %+% #0 %" >.* #0 >= (@(60 # #5I # : #3@'"#7#F5# #( 9(" #(2#'' # $ # 3 # @#1 S%-.?>.#0>#)"%-&%>-#0-=I(60
(2# B B: # '7" @@ 9 5( '" ' =37'" '@ 9 5 :#( 9 @#( #(" # '3 G 9 5(( 2 # '2 # 2( # /59#0525=:#5B2 ##@"'<#27:@79(22"' 2 ' G B 9" =" 22 2 1 S %-> >% #0-M%--+#0-M%-%*?#0-M%%J-&?#0?#M%%.= &?#0?20+&605(##5=:#'7#(2##'2B(# GK:1 S%%%-#0?=60<2#7###5I #5(@2G#7'''#5B' 2=3'21 S%-&%,-#0-="%-?%+%"#0%"%--%? #0-(@(60 #'"@B2"5=#'7 3 # #( 5F 2 ( 1" #'@"70"-3'(#0"-,,-"T-0>"20>,*60
@"7###5I#/2952#5 :7(23/(2(92((2=(#5B2' #7 ( # K #5 2 27 #5B'0
)*+,)-,,. /%,)%*/ #'"(2#57(7#795B2'
1 S%-.?>.#0>#)"%-&.-"%-&%>-#0-=(@(60
.0 3:95527##(#((9 2 9#7:#7#2= # 2' 95 2 # : = 2 : 2#' '2( 7 $ # </0 79 7 # # #5I # '@ 9 5'( 5 2 '2 # :(2###955#(B2/ 9G@#2##(#0
2"5'(#39"#22 9 #" 2 #' # (( 2' #5@#'3#('#(#! 0
#( 9 79 7 # # #5I #" G 2(="<#5B':@0
523" # #( 22 # %& K7 -,,." 5'( 5 =( G 22 29 #'# # 2 #( 9 5( 522 ((' 7 # 220 27"##(#?8-,,&"@(##B 2#"5('#/'I'5#5#'0 2 # # # #(" #(( 9 52 (': # 52 2 5( # (( #5 @ : G #5'2<0(9"'2'"'(9 2K@#(92#2'# '#@20 95#"#(9((@("#((# '="B2#'3@@29#G##'( #$A':(((2#2(#:0#(#92(3#95 5< 2 # 7 # # G #( '7( 9 # #( C 2 ( @@ 2 2' #5 (7 2(#5B##G=0
" @ 9 5'( 5 2 # # 2# 2 7 # # #5I #" # #(#50-J0- 0'2#2##5I#' 1@0 S %-* -,J #0 J= 20 -%JM %-- ?&? #0 ? 20 ?&J6" #5=5##('1 S 2=(#-2'=-,,*"%.+),*" #0%0-60 @@" 5( 2 ' ' G 5 9 27#'(2'#@'79"2(##5 '3=G22(2(#279 22(" # 9 #3 2 5' G '#@
)*+,)-,,. /%%)%*/ 21@0 S%-*?%.#0.=" S%--?&J#0?"%-,=--J #0-="%%J>??#0(@(60
7$"##(#?8-,,&"##%&K7-,,." 5'( 5 B'( # # 50 -* ((" '' 2' #( (7 2(##50*>0%- 92(7# ##5I##29552(2=3'20 @@" '' 2 2(" 5=: # 22 K#5$ " @'(' G K2# # G 22 # 50 ?. 0 % # 50J* 1 S%-J%%,#0%0%"%-&->#0-="%---%#0 >" >&. #0 >" I (6 9 '2 # #5 #(#5(72(###(/@'/2 9 2 (( ( 1 S %>, >%J #0 *0-60 @" =#(#2#52:229# #5@@#92#52((:7''2'2 '0 (9" @ #' 9" # @C" 5 ( # #5I # # 2 I (2( 7 # '' 5#' K2#" G B2 1@0 S%-?%+,#0?60
+0 2(#9"=95( 9#7 :#7#"5727##(0
523" #523 " K # # (( 7 : #7#0 /G/7 # # 5/$A':" 22F K '' #: # (( $=( G 2(" #5 295K27#:#7#0 2' #(KG" G " #5B # # B #'( # $A':0 @@" 52 # 5( 1'' : # ((6 3('7(@='22#('2< 2 '= G #5 '2< # G 5#'( # $A':
1 S 2=(#-,K7-,,&" -,.),?"#0>0>60
"2(('2#(@7#$3#0 #5=#" 5 # %,2'= -,,? #9 9 ! 57 (( $@@#5@@#2(957$( 9##((('#@# :( 2 9 5( 9 5#' # ! 0"52 #5(29"5:#(7#(( ( S S 2 0(9"# 5# (' 5#( # 5: # (7 ( ' # @
)*+,)-,,. /%-)%*/ #5#' # (7 2' # # @' # 7(( # @ (25#'0
" (':: # ; '2 # '= / 7(( 2' # # # (#=(0 " # # 2 =#("('#((957::(5(2#0" / 7( # (( # @(7 -,,* G @ ' -,,&" 9 ;5(2 #'#! 2955(( #@ 9%+7-,,&"G7@95(2 #7#(KG(((0"#5#-+7-,,&" ('@@'(9572@# B # (( 7 (2 # 2(# #57( # /" 2 ##"#((95(7#((9' #(:0"#2-*@(7-,,*"! #'(G'I' #9##95723=''5(2 # 2 B 7 G #' I / 2@ / 7 '" '' 7 # ((9'#(:29! 52#B' # #' # 5( # 9 # < 2( 2'2'#(:0"B2# ('9GK@##'#(($Q 2(#=0@@"#2%7-,,&"5(2#5(52 '2<( # (( # 95 7 2 29 ! (' #'( $Q G ' 9 / (2 @@'0
2" # # 2 = # (" ; 2(#957#'#(##7##((7 #952(#2#377'#=0" #(#252# 9# #! #*8-,,>%?2'=-,,?"2#-*@(7-,,*.K -,,&"9 ;5(( 95#' #! 9%+7-,,&"=23#B2'32# 0 (9 (' 5 2 2 #'# # #7 # # (( 295 5( #(KG0 " 7 2 29"#8I 9#9' # G 37 7 '# =0 @@" 2 57 2 = 9 # 2' : ''(# # 7 2 2 5=" 5#' 2 @ '2: 2#5(:9##7I 0(9"$3#"92 9 # ( 2' @7 (( @ #'# # (' 527'==0 "2#G2 9##((7(#'#
)*+,)-,,. /%>)%*/ 7((9#5@'(B2995# #5 : 2' # $ ''0 (9"52(=#:(#7'=2(2#(95 '27((1@0 S%->->?#0.=)==60 " ' # #' # (( #' # (2B (=9#KA'K#@'#! " 2 9 27 # #( # # # (( " 2'"52'27((0"(#( 279@32#(("="G ''" # 2# 2 7 # @'0 5(: 9 5 2 2C # 5 G (:# 2 #(7 1@0 S 2=(#-JK-,,?" &*)-,,?"#0>0*60
@" K2#" '2' #5 ( 9 (' # 2 # 2# I 2(( 22 # = @" 9 B2=(#7:#5##=7 #5@@#21 S%-J-&J#0."%-? -.,#0?"%-,%,+#0>"%,+++602#7"9( # G #B 2 2 $ # 2 # 5/ $A': 2' G (2 # 27 # #'(" 2 ( (2#'223 9##! " #'2'#0"#'(:3K #B=B2@#7:9252 9#7'#5#'(#$A':1@0 S 2=(#-J K-,,?"#(KG(#0>0-60
#(@7" 5'( G K 9 27 @ #(=' #( # (( 9 ''= #5 : #:#50>%0>0 95572#G5#'( #$A':#-*@(7-,,*.K-,,&0
J0 50-* "9750J*0% "2#8' $(#7I(10%"2'32$60
B ' # 50 *> " #( #( 22 @'' 2( @ ' G (7 5( 5 #(7 =(9'' # @ 7B '2 7 # 7B '<#27927I2#2710%6052 7 #( #( 22 @'' 2( @95'@'(9@7I'/ 2=10-60
2 #5'=( B 9 # #5 (7 2(# @ '2 # 20 @@" 9
)*+,)-,,. /%?)%*/ # # ! 2 @ 7 # '' 9 @'2=( 9/2=1 S%---.>#0?60 7$" 2' #5#'( # ' 2( 2 2((# '2< ( #5 #( '@' (0 @@" # '' 95 ( 9( # #" 5 #5 #'( # $A': 22F # (0 " @ # #( 1'(6 #5 # # 2 7I =''2=7#'1?*5&>J@0-*6"# 9##5#(#50*>0- # K2#"2#5"(0
%,0 '2#92(3#"K(02"2(# :10&%0 60
)*+,)-,,. /%*)%*/
! 2) 1 ) !) ! !
3-
%0 (7=0
3
-0 K0
>0 92(#:0
?0 @' 2 # 9R 27 @' 2( I # #( # >, K #3 @ 23 # = @(#(
1 $VQ$@9&"&,,? 6"27#'3## 2="@'('B0+-#@(#( =@(#(#%. K -,,* 1 S6M '(' # # #9 " '@ '<#272:##'#M# I #( = @(#( 2 7 2 2 7 (9 B # # 50 ?- S0 2( I 23 2 # "79('''<#27"#7IKG570 :@@3 2(# <7 ! ; (/K4 $22 E
2 @' # 2( I @( B 2 9R ( #5G5('2:@@
)*+,)-,,.