Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1296/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1296/2007 AI generated

Securities Registration Violation in Bankruptcy Sale of Contractual Interests

Case Number ATAS/1296/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed an appeal involving the application of a statute concerning the registration of securities, where the central dispute revolved around whether certain complex contractual agreements qualified as "securities" subject to registration requirements, particularly concerning sales occurring within a specific period before the company's bankruptcy filing. The court reasoned that the agreements, which represented fractional interests in future profits tied to the enterprise's success, possessed the essential characteristics of an investment contract, thus classifying them as securities under the relevant law because purchasers were motivated by the expectation of profit derived from the efforts of others. Consequently, the failure to register these transactions rendered the sales violative of the statute, leading the court to uphold the imposition of statutory penalties against the responsible parties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 100 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Registration Violation in Bankruptcy Sale of Contractual Interests: The court reasoned that the agreements, which represented fractional interests in future profits tied to the enterprise's success, possessed the essential characteristics of an investment contract, thus classifying them as securities under the relevant law because purchasers were motivated by the expectation of profit derived from the efforts of others. Consequently, the failure to register these transactions rendered the sales violative of the statute, leading the court to uphold the imposition of statutory penalties against the responsible parties.

Keywords

AI generated
transactions in securities contract of sale registration of a company enterprise law contractual default interest prospectus liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 100 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (order 6) in relation to the cost assessment (Art. 100 BGG).

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (order 6) concerning the allocation of procedural costs.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (order 6) regarding the imposition of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



            !"!!  #"$"!!

%%

&' %()'* * * & '%* (

+,  -  "" .+,  "!! 



  !"#$"%%  " &$"%%'"( 

"

((     & )) *      " $ %+,- 

                

   *1.20*  

* /(

23   $  "4 2,56 % ""$ !7 8 % !9%$!$%"%269$#100:% %%!""!; %&99"%&#%"$< =#>"!"% 99%""%&$!7?#%" "@ 10063

13 "7$!& % !+%&$%>$>%#" $$1001#%5@&26293

63  2-  100:    !$" (A  $% "  9 $%7"%!"" ">%99%""%&$! 7? " """$ %& "" !"$ % "#3  $%  B"$ > &"#"$ !9 C$ B>& &$"" ! C74  >& #?  !#" ""% % D$ >& C  " "#"$ ""  !"%?%! !""%$!7?3

:3    ?9 % > %B" % %$!" " % ?7 % AE!"C#"%;#<A=9"$""%%1:B 100: %& $7;  $" %  + !" "7 % ""  7">&"" !" 9"3   "$ "" 9" #" F ,0G H 7?  9C <" 2@0G H %"= ,0G  4%" H 7? <" 2@0G H %"= " 60G  "" C" H 7? <"50GH%"=3 $%$ &!>!%& $"% %4I" "$""!# 44% 7! "$""!$#43

53  % % &$  $"$      !$" (A  "?!$%%)# $%$7<)=3" $>%"#"$ %!"$ C  "" 9" % &$! 7? &$ #" #$ !"$%"#";"!"?7!#" "3

/3 %$%60J"1005 ))  )))D ))    )D  )<)?KL?9#?7""M*!; ) =9C$%7$%&#%"$%&$H60N3) "> ! $%&$$""H O %&C"#"$$7;%"% &%" H %" %  ! C % # " $!$""9 %  4 !$ 7?  # % &$!  % # " %&$$#"  %&4%"!$H,0%7$M""#"$"C74""B$ " ! """ H &$ % $   %&# :&000 93 !  >  !$H#"$%5&-0093! <26; =%" H!"%7%60N<!;6- =3 ""%$""$93

-3   % % % &  &$  9" &4B" %&  %&"" !93"%&"$7"!9< =%!!"



./-0.100-  *6.20*   %" % 2/  100/3  !!" " > %  "#"$ %!"$ &$ !"""%%% "!?% H!" !3 '" %"7"" $>!"$!?+>%&$$"" !"4# "#"$ $7;C""#C93"B"$>!>  % " " C!"4 %  " $ >  !$% %&%!"" " % $"' " " $3  "  $"$ 4#$ ">&!%"!$"$  !"%& >%&77 "3

)  '" % "7 &"" %#"  9 %  "   ! &$ &+" !  !4"$ % # %  "?$>3   $"$ #$> !" ""&77 "#"$"$4%""7"> &$#" "$!"$H&"$7% *!93 >&$!!>&H"#%&C$""$"$#$>& ""%7%9"%!4949 $3

$"$7$>&$!$%"P%J99"%"#C $  "; !% " """ % % " !? %    " %C "7  "! "  $"$ 7$3  !   "" >&%  %" "$7 #%% "%-0N#77 " >9$%43%"">&#H&$"4#4% "H 50N#77 ">9$!& !+%&99"3&$C!>$ "" "!9  ! % % "" & !O?" % #  %<!;:1 =3

@3  % % &$   $"$   H  %# % $%!"" !9 % &  > %  !!" % 1,  100/   H  %7$%&#%"$%1,N39 !$#>&$" ! $  """ H   "$  100: " /@&:-6 93 H  >& " ! "?$> "4"C8""#"$ !"$!$""# O $ "  !" " %& 4"" " % 25N  :@&/-0 93 <:&5@@3* !  ! :0 ?3. 3Q:&--13*! !:2/?3. 3Q5-&15@*3*!#"$%"% 25N=3 )&7" % # # #%"$  %# % $%!"" !9  !$$ > &$  9 " &C! " %99 "  98  !#" C >& "#"$ %!"$ C  "" 9" %  $! 7? < >  !>" %&$#" "" "# *% % &?L"!"%?7!$H20R # "$!$""9 9  *% % &$"4 #   4 !$ 7?= " >&  $""$#%"% "%%4%% " %&$<!:6 =3

,3  %$ % 20 # 100/ &   B"$  % % %  " % &$3



./-0.100-  *:.20*  

203 %%$%"$% O B$7 "$%"H "%&#%"$3

223 @ 100/&$&"!$"$HS%" !S%& H>  %$$  ! ?" 4$$9 %& %  ! " "  ! O"  ??%& !37$>&&$""%&!"?E 73

213 %2- 100/&$9 $!!"C%C%$%20 # 100/  $7" O" % &!"$ "" %&C  !9 % 83   !  B"$ >& %#" !% % $% " " &$!!3

263 %%&$$"$ #9)3  #$ > &$ #" 99"$ %"  "7 % "I? P   4 !$ 7? #" $"$ "$3 )&7" % "I? $7;   " $ >& !#"% ""4%% "%10NH15N!" !"%9" >  7" "  !% " >& !" # 4 % ! !7$3

2:3 "7$ ! &   )   !$$ # "   %&#% % :&00093! 4%>%!"%!"< M !+$%&   !+$  ? 4 4? ""+ % #"  !+$ % !%"=3

253 %#%$%!""!9&"#$H#$#"% %7$ %&#%"$3   9    !$  # > &$ " ! $"""H"$100:"/@&:-693H>&"!4" %  "#"$  ! " $!$""#  O  $  ""  !" %& % " % % " % 15N   !!>  $%" !!$ " <:1&,:: 93=3    4" H  %7$ %&#%"$ % 6-6N <!/1 =3

2/3 %$!!"%62B#100-& 9 $%$% 9 % " " % 9 %  " !93   !%" !$$ H &$ >& !" 4$$9 %  # % ! " ! "" >&  9% % "#$3

)&7" % %7$ %&#%"$ % &$ &   !!$ >  "7 %&4#" !9 &" ! 9" > %  !$"  %$ $%  C " ;" " % >  &$ " H O  % ""#!"$%"#"%7 ?$%"#"%  4 $%%&%3)&7"%% "4#$ % "7  "! &   '" >& " $   "#"$ !!$ 7>&&% ! > '"%"7" " $>% "%#"O"!?% !" !



./-0.100-  *5.20*   "%"#"$%!"$!; ""!"!$% %$%!""3

& &"$9$$H&$#"%&#%"$H>&"#$) " 7$>!!$#""$""> "%">3B"$> >>&" O "" !"%&#%)%2/B100/"C %&#%"$&"""!:0N3

)&7" %&$#"  %&% !9 &   " $ >&  " !9  """ !    ! " %$>"3  99" &$  %! %& 9 " "9$  " & C$ > &"#"$% 8 >9"!$9> %!#$)3 %!!%9"$%&!!"7%!4H  !%&9 ""?$>3& ">"""H "$ &$ " # 44 " !# &C %&"#"$  ! 4  9 " !9  !;" %  " % 4I" "  ! >  %  ! "  !7$ $#" " %&   "  "!   4 O"    ! %$>" ! "&$%!%&"#"$"#%!"$H$""%"$3 )!"& #$>&$&!%"%$ "$#"$ %$$7"%!"$HC %"#"$"#% ">& %! "!%& 4$#$H&$?3

2-3 %129$#100-&$"B"$"""%$3 "H&"%&% *"%&#%"$ H !"%@ 100:3 % % >& $%" %  """> % 10N   " !$$ !" !"%9">"#"$$7;" 4$ $$% ""$$"7;"%I73

2@3 #"$H!& %$!%21 100-B" % 3   !!$ > &    "  "C %&#%"$ % 60N %%$%60J"1005"$93

2,3 %-#100-&$ "!"3;#>&  %! ;%$%20#100/#"!$%$%%%7$ %&#%"$ H  $%" % 25N3  &$" %;  > %  % %$ &  " $ H !!>  O  $%"3  % % >& $%"%""">%& 10N"!!>$!" !" %""$%% "%98"% > %9 "3

103 %11 100-&  "!"3C!>>& !$%$ H  4"" " % 25N %  ! ; $#" &" ! >& %$">&$4"% "%% "%% O  %& "#"$ %!"$3    9" # > &$ >% 4



./-0.100-  */.20*   O "%%99"$7">$%)%!!%10 #!  ""#$H!" !3"& ""> % "%% "%15N% !)!!'""!7$$ &  $9; C !; $% " !9 97"  % "" % " % % " &" #4 > ! " "#"$3 ) &  !!>$%"!!$ "#%"H" !"%4 "%  "" !?+> % &$3 9 &   $!;" >  )   %   "C%&#%"$%60N">%$""$93

123 %1: 100-&$ "!"3



* &%(

23 9 $ " H &"3 5/ 3 2 "3  ?3 1 %   7#  &7" B% <=  4 " %   '"  " > % """ !$# H D" 5/ %   9$%$   !" 7$$%%"%%/"41000< ="#H  9$%$D*#%"$%2,B2,5,< =3) !$"! B7%%D!;"$"43

13   9$%$ % 2/ %$ 4 1005 %9"   9$%$  &* #%"$ " "$  #7  2 B" 100/ <100/ 1006= !!"" % %9">"" "!$%%"%#" 4 "%<"3515@"/2"3 =3!$""  #%"%  ">%%"% ""9$"$9 $!; 2B"100/<?3"3%%!""""#H %9" %2/%$ 41005=3

63 "B"$%9 "%$!$#!"#4<"35/H /0 =3

:3  &!;  %  "7  >" % %" H  " !>  ""!H&"% !93)!%;   >" %  % %7$ %&#%"$ % &"$$3  99" ! ! &"""H"$* O >$!!"$%"#% &$"""$3#"%;%&C &B"9%&!!> $%"!!$ "%10N#%&#%>% % "3

53 )B!%#%&#%%"O"$#$#"""9" %  "" !9 ;" % &"$$3  &4 %& # 99"# " $$ * " > &$ !;  # % &""" H  "$ & ! ! %&"#"$    "#"$ %!"$   "



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

/3 &&" $&"#$H! %%7$%&#%"$  100/>4$%$"%20#100/3 >" %!"9"!!>$$%"%25N!" !"% 9" > &$ $""  9 " &C! " %99 " " %#" $#"  " 4% # "3 9"&" $4"H%7$%&#%"$ %1,N3%" !"H&!!"9 $!"&" $ &"#$H%%>%$$>&$!" "# >&H " ! !" " H -5N  ! "  !" % 9" >  7" "  !% " >& !" # 4 % ! !7$3 &" $  $ H !!>  $%" !!$ "    """>"4"%7$%&#%"$%6-6N3

"$9;H& ( -1:.1001%"">&!" " !"%&9"%$%"%10N""">!% % "%% " $% """"$3 "%%&!;> 9"&4B"%"O"<%3:3131=&$4$$9$%&$%"%10N "9 ! >  "#"$ $7; "   ! H " ! !" "  ;7 7$$ 4$ $$3#"""9%#> ( & &" ! $"$ % "" $"?% %     % !# %&!!$" % &% ""&! #$>&"$%"$""S4#"S



./-0.100-  *@.20*   %">&!"%$BH>&%$%"%10N!9"% %#H%"#C%""! !""3

#? ( 9$%&!!>$%"!!$ "%5N! "  !" %  94 !%"#"$ % &$3   %$$ >  9" > &$!"!99"%"#C%#"$"$! !"% %%&$#"%!"$$%%"#<"#"$%"$7; C$H" !!"=%">% "%% "+"%$BH$"$ !%$"%&!!$"%!"$$%%"#&+ #" !  %  %$  % 9 %  % % &$#" % #%&#%"">9"%$%"%""">3

#% O %!$"F&" $" !"%9"> "#"$$7;"%$ !4"""#"$%"$7;3     !  %$"  % " % % " %  " " % 7" % &$ " H  "!" % !  "" % "%" !%"#%15N3;"!!> # $%"    """> %  ?93  79 % " %" %O"$"$3

&O"!$"$ ( !!!$>!""%&* #%"$  !" &!"$ % 7 $"" %& """ H  "$ % $ "  " # H  4  $#"    7"> % "$$3  % " %   !$"   %  >  9" &4B" % &O"  >" 9 " % "" >  %99"$ 7"> % &$  &" !  !O?$ %&C H "9"  "#"$ !9  ) !%" ! % >L 3  &+  % !  %&!!>$%"!!$ "%?9!3

-3 >&">9" >&" $!!%&9 "$% "%&#%"$%"%H9C!!! O """H "$ O "C%&#%"$<93 (21/1@@  1002G:20!3-6=3 %$!>) 9C$%7$%&#%"$%&$H60N %" % 60 J" 1005 %" ! $>" O" %$$    % %& !!$" 94 " ! # % $> !   !" "$ " %!%%$!%C; && 3  %%"!!!$ !"%&C""%%&$#"% &#%"$99"$3!!$"%#7"%*!""#>&H "" C!" "  " & C" % "9 99"3  " $7%   99"!>&!!$"%#7"""4# O $>#"3 #"#?""% "999"9">&"$#" !    % %"    !!$" "4   >& $" %&  ! ""  # &$3   "9 % %#7 %$BH  "$ " !  B!%  9" B" %



./-0.100-  *,.20*   %&""C"O  " "$"!9>&$#" ! % "" #"  "?$ %&4B"#"$3  C !  (   %$$   "4  !!$" % 7 % &* #%"$  "9 >& &$"" 7 " % &$#" % &* %">!"% $%#""  !"$ % "# " &"#"$ C74  >    ! % # " " 99"$ < ( 21/  1@@ %3 1%M ( 22,  :-: %3:M#  1000G:0/!3:013%361002G:20!3 -63%36MO" 3%26B#100:U5/:.01V"33%1: 100:U 1@@.06V=3

( " % "" >& &  &C"  "9 !#" B"9 > & &$" % &!!$" H > &" #$  )  %" %$ &%&!$"$""$!&$3

@3 $7%C%$">!$;%""%B"$3



./-0.100-  *20.20*  

%  0 (/  %()'* * * & '%*( 

  1. +

23 $#43

 1.

13 B""3

63 "$  "%10093H?7%"3

:3 9   !" %  >D !#" 9   "  !$" O" %  %$ % 60 B %;  "9" !; % 4 9$%$ <)?KL?9>//00:  =!#% ";%%" !49 $ "C"3@1%9$%$ 49$%$%2- B 1005 < (=M  $  %  %" %>   "9 " +%!#"!"7"%"% %"M%" O" %$  4 9$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"> C %" % &"3 :1  (3  !$" O" "  !;  ! % "#>$  +%!#%#"O"B"H&#3  799;  !$%"         (( W)  W



!9 %!$"O"""9$C!">DHD999$%$ %!799



./-0.100-