Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1287/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1287/2007 AI generated

Contract Dispute Over Financial Instruments and Security Interests

Case Number ATAS/1287/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The litigation involved disputes over various financial instruments and agreements, including the interpretation of contract language concerning security interests and payment obligations, with multiple parties alleging breaches, misrepresentations, and wrongful enforcement actions related to debt instruments and collateral. The court reasoned through the distinct claims by applying established principles of contract law, commercial statutes, and equitable considerations, ultimately determining the validity and scope of the underlying agreements, the proper characterization of the parties' respective rights and liabilities, and the resulting entitlement to relief, often focusing on the precise language negotiated by the parties and the applicability of preclusion doctrines.

Legislator headnote

Official

; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; PC ; VALEUR VÉNALE(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; PROPRIÉTÉ ; PROPRIÉTÉ FONCIÈRE ; PROPRIÉTAIRE ; FORTUNE ; FORTUNE IMMOBILIÈRE | Il faut considérer que la recourante, qui a acquis un appartement en France pour son frère et avec les deniers de ce dernier, est propriétaire dudit bien immobilier et à ce titre a le droit d'en disposer juridiquement même si elle s'impose pour des raisons morales de n'en rien faire. La valeur de ce bien fait donc partie intégrante de sa fortune et doit être à ce titre prise en compte dans le calcul des prestations complémentaires. | LPC3c

Keywords

AI generated
commercial contract financial instruments debt enforcement claim actions establishing liability payment of interest financial arbitration

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           !"##!$%%& '!($"&!$%%&

'

 ' ) )')  )  

*  $  (+ ,-*  $%%& 



   !"#$%  &&'

'&

((    ) ) ) *+)   &'  ' ! ,-./ 

                    

   3#0""3  

) . '

"4 !!5   &6&'6& 7  '!8 39&:  &&'; &< '  &9  9&''  9!' & 5!!& ' '9 9 &!4

#4  &6&!7   &655 '9&=>! 8 39&:  ;55'!&99&'6?-'.@ #$$A4&&'? &&''9 "BB#9&9& !' &699&''C) '3 (&  ' 6   6!' ' 9 5&!4  &&'  ''5   '! &  5 ' ?667 '95 !6,' D ?  99&' '&! '!C5&:& ? 7 7 '  &4 )  E9 '  7 '  9' &7   9&-'3 4

A4   && & '!  "A   #$$A   &< 9& 6    # @ '  &&'  9&! ! ?6 7 ' ?  ' 99&'' C ' '& 5   & 9&  9'   5&:& ?6  &7 & '  9  & ' C  ,!& ' &4   !>! 6&' &&7'> ! ?97 & 7&  &C ' &   6 !&  ?? 5< ?   '4 5    9&! ! ? ' 99&'' 7 ' !'! 9F! A..6$$$5&4 5&<   "BB#4   &7! ?   ' "  6   7 ' !'!    &'  ' ,' ' ?  G  ''    7 ' !>'!'! 5&!4 & :& 7 '!&!?699&''7 ' -'&!&!9&9& !' &&!6'3C3 &5&:&4

/4 "BH'#$$A9&6 '&!  & ''  &&'&!C6  9 &'I

36'7'699&'')'3  >!#/@ "BB#7'J'&  ' & C (&F3' & ?   ! >   ?!&&  D 4& &&' &!&!' &? K9& E9&!'?  ' !'!9F!  F & 99&'' 9&9&C!9KL

3  9  6 &   '' '!  #2 @  "BB# '  >! 9&  &&'57&5&:&4 '&'&&'&J' K7 & &<   5&:& 8M;    5& 5&<  A.$6$$$ 8M;  7 6,'&9& 99&''? '''&> '&!CC' '&

5   &4  !:   5&:& 699&'' &7 &  9  & ' C  ,!& ' &KL

3"# #$$AC !,!&5&:&&&' & @'! C     D   ' ?  &&' 7 ' &' &!  



01220#$$%  3A0""3   ! &9'):79&,'&99&''9& 9& &' &9&?6 7 '!6&> '&&CL

39 ? D-'&&&'&5&'A$6$$$N)9' 5&:&&&'&9'''& :&L

3  ''''   >!  #% @ ' #$$A 9&   ' "  ?   &' 5  7 & &  C  &&'''B$6$$$5&45&< 9&9'>& E

5  6,'  699&'' C )'3  ?   !'! ?  9&  9'  "  & '> '&5 &45      "  !'!  '!   '' '&' '9''! >&9& >'&4

.4 )&D 5&' 6  &9& 9&'' 9  "&5!7& &"BBB''9'C9&' &'''D  D  &4 ' &!  ?..6A"#5&47 '!'!7&!'&9C&&'9& 9!& "&5!7& &"BBBA"@7 &#$$/4

24 #1@7 &#$$/7!  '!'!&&!'C &&'&D&'.26A"#5&4

%4  #. 5!7& & #$$/  &&'  5&! 99 '  '&  !    &9&'E9 ' 4

14 %@ '#$$/&&'!'!&<9& &)@& 'C 6  4  ''     9& 6'  &9&   &>' !799! 9&!!'4  & )    9&  9&' E9 ?! ?6  7 ' 7 &6O7 '6&>'? 7 '&7 C6,'699&''67& 5& 5&<  A..6$$$3 !? 7' C 1/6.#A5&4  4  &&'  & E9 ?! ? A$$$$ N ) 7 ' !'! '&5!&! &  9' 9&  5&:& ' ?6 &9     7 ' &  B$6$$$5&4 5&<   '  '' '' 67 & 2%6.$$5&4  4   ?'   7 & 6O 7 '  #$6$$$5&4&''&&'&!9?P& 7 '!"$6$$$5&4' ?  '& "$6$$$5&4 7 ' !'! 99&'! 9&  5&:& C 6    7& 7F>C:74

B4 "/@ '#$$/&&'&9& '9 &''

3'''' 5&:&'!"$@ '#$$/4''& :& 3   ?!?6 9& ' 3-,&>5& 699&'')'3 4

3  '& ''''   >!  "% @ ' #$$/ 9&   '&'& L '' & :& 5 & 7 & 9>!  &&' 9& 



01220#$$%  3/0""3   !&, 9&:  6   ' 7 & ''! ?   !' ' !@C&'?7 '99&''(&4

3''''  >!1@ '#$$/9&P&&&'L &&' ?''& :&'& !&&'C9&&"$6$$$5&4

"$4  & 6 '&'  '!!9, ?  #1 @ ' #$$/ 6    ! C  &&' 6  !' ' 9 D  '&5!&&  9&9& !'!     5&:& 9&: 6' &(&4&&'&!9?6!' '99 D9' 'H'69!&' 5&:&6F'9& &995 &5E5&   ! C 699&''4   ''5  E9 ?! ?6 '&5&'  9&9& !'! !' ' 7 >D6  E5 5&:&4

""4 &&& &"&9'D&#$$/6  &7!?E9 ' ! 9&&&'!' ''& ' 76''''  >!9&5&:&"$ @ ' #$$/  ?   ? ' ?6  9& '  ,&>  5&   699&''4

"#4 "29'D&#$$/6  &<&&'75&:&4&6'  E9 ' !@C!'!'!&9& 46  &9&9!6D' & ' & ?  6!' ' 9!   7'  ' &' 5 ' ?  5&:&   &&'!' '9&9& !' &&!D 4 &6'&' '!!9, ? #19'D&#$$/&&'''5   ?!C6  ?' &7 ' &5!! 7&&''4

"A4 !&' '!2&#$$25&:&&&'  ?!KC 6'''  E 7 ' 5 '   6  '&'  5  >7 K ?6  !' '  9&9& !' &  699&''4 6!9E   &&'  & @'!D'?6 5 & '9&'' '' ,& '' !&'  ?   !'! !9! '  >! ' !> ! 9&:  6  '&' 5 >7 4

"/4  # 5!7& & #$$% 6    &  !   & 99 '  5 &'  !    #1 @7 & #$$/ '  ''    &D&'  .26A"#5&4 6    &' ?6  &&' '  &'  6'  7' !'D  7'J'&#/@ "BB#?&&'!' '6?!&&D  ' ? >&! ''  &?-'  &&' 67 ' @  !'!  &  &''& C 6    ' 55   5&<  '''' ?6 67 ' 5 ' ? &7 &  9&-'3 C  5&:& ' ?  & & !' '  9&9& !' &  699&'')'3 4 6  ' &! ? &&'!' ' 55  '9&9& !' &4

".4 &  & 6> '  6!>'   ?  &&' & ' !@C 5&! 9&  9! E    D&'&   6E '  D  D  & 6    ''! 9&: 7!& 5 '    & ?  & & 



01220#$$%  3.0""3   ' '  ' C  @'4    ' &!    ?6  67 ' 9 !'! 5&!6E 'D 7'&99&'6?-'!'D .@ #$$A' ?6  67 '  9 !'! 5&! C '9  6E ' 6 D  D  &4 5   5&!&&'?6 9 '9 D  '!& & ''9&!& '''&'@& 7'6'&!5& !  &' '' 4

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

&&'5 '7 &?6'&5&'5&9&9& !'!699&'& '&  &O6  9&& ' !&&  '4& &  ' ' ?6 ' '&5&' & '  ' !'! 5&' H'E   !>' 9&''' 9&  !& '!   5&:& ?  7 '  &   &!>  '!&'4&&'9&99'?9&9& !'! ''&    6 ' &   & O  9&& '  5 & C  & H'4  :> 9&  & ?6  6F  9  '& '    5 ' ?  5&  6'&'   699&'' D' C  5&:&   ?  & & 6 9 9 &'  & & '9  & 9 '4   '  55' 9&7 & E D    E35   !9 '  5' ' 9' '35'   9& &  ' ? ' '  9  C ,   5  !' ' C '65 !' 'C&4  9'9 '& & :& !   H  &  P& ?  !'! 9& 7!  9&''   6  4  &&'5 '7 &?6'7'' &5&< &7 & 'CA$6$$$&4  &&'  9 ' 9&  & ?6 !   6 ' !'! & ?' C  99& 9&'' 9!' &4&&'5 '&&?&? '& &'  & '   ?  5  9&9& !'! 5 :& & 6 & 9'   > '& 5 &  & ' 5&<  6E' 9 ?  9&9& !'! 9  !& 



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

"%4 &&'5 '!>'7 &?6   6E ' D  '   9  9& ' & :    '   9&''  9!' & ? : &  & '  &  &' ''  ' 9&& '4 5 &&'9&9'&'  ''C?'' '! 'C?9&''  ' ! ''&!'D 4

"14 7 '! C  9&& 6 ' !   &!9  #   #$$%  5 &!  9 ' 4

"B4  & D&!9&' 9&9&' ? 6''2 7D& #$$%4 R ''    & D  E9 ?! C  &&' ?  9&  9   &' ''  7 ' -'& E !   9& & '9 ' ?6 9&& '  '   '&  &   6D >'   &' '&   ? 6  E & 'D5 ' ' ,&>'&9&4)&?  !'!>&!C@>&4

)  '

"4 5&!' C 6&'4 .2 4 " '4  ,4 A   & D '  & J' ' ?''' 9&!7CS&'  .2 5!!&&9&' >!!&& '& 8 ;  2 'D& #$$$ ?  ' &' 7 C    5!!& &  9&'' 



01220#$$%  3%0""3   9!' &CS&37  &7 7'' 7  '!"B&"B2. 8 ;L  J'    99 '   6&'4 .2 4 # '4    '''  9&!7 C 6&'4 /A     ' &  9&''  ' 9!' &C6&37  '&7 7''C6&3 7  '! #.'D&"B218 ;4

)9!'9&@>&S9:'  !'D 4

'&@'!! '5&9&!79& &&'&7D8&'4.2  L &'4 B     ' &  9&''  5!!& 9!' & C 6&37   ' &7 7' ' C 6&3 7  '!  "/ 'D& "BB.  (L&'4/A ;4

#4   !   &  #1 @7 & #$$/ 5 &! 9& !   & 99 '   # 5!7& & #$$% 6    &!  ''  9&''  9!' &  C  &&'  '' 9'   7& 6 D  D  &9&9& !'!&&'9 "BB# 99&C6  & 6?-'  . @  #$$A4   !  99&   9&''  9!' &  ?6&' '' )(&.26A"#4&&' ' 69&'?'''9&& '6'&9&'?7& D  D  &   ' 9 -'& 9&    !&'  9 ?6     99&' & '5 '9D   &'?65&, )(&%.6$$$7& '  -'&99 ?!4

A4 E'& '& 'E9&'' 9!' &9&?  9&< 7'  &'  S&3 7  '! 9& '' ?  !9 & '9!& &E&7!'& '8&'4#4" '# L &'4 # 4 " '4 D   ' /  ;4  ''   9&''  9!' & 5!!&9:&&9  C9&'!9&?  E:&7!'& '8A4" ;4&!>''    &&!> ' 9&'' 9!' &'854&'4A/'.4"'4 ;4 9&''  9!' & '  5'   ''  &7 '  !94

;  75!!&&7!'& '9&'''9& ' 5&'D  :&' D  :&8&'4A4"'4D ;? T : 5&' ''   & O  !9 #.S$$$ 5&4 9&  9&  8&'4 A 4 " '4   ;  &' 9  ' '& 9&''  9!&  ? F 9& &'S )'S 8&'4A4"'4 ;'&&' 9&'5&''F'& 'S'  8&'4A4"'4> ;4

5&''!7!&:>!> ' &S 9Q'' &'  '     8&'4 "% 4 "  6& 5!!& &  9&''  9!' & C 6&37   &7 7' ' 7  '!  ". @7 & "B%" 8 3 )0 ;;4 &?S D  &' 9 S,D ''   &?!&'



01220#$$%  310""3   C9&9& 9&'' 9!' & & 9&   9' C  7& 7! 8&'4 "% 4 /  3 )0 ;4  7& 7! 6 D '&9&&7&55  7&& 'LD &!'D F6' ' 87 & ,4 #""$   &' 7  6( ) &'  9&''  9!' & C 6 )0  U V;4 )  @& 9& 9& 7& 7! 6 D  6&'4"% 4/ 3 )0 6 '9& E7'D  & '&'  ?   !&'    '  & 8 (   9D !  .$0$$&15!7& &#$$" 4#;4

&     9&''  9!' &   9&  9'  &:> >!!&  &7 !'& ' D'  &  6!  7  9&!!''6!''5&'"&@7 &6!9&?9&''  '&7 L9'!>''&& !&' 9!& & ?5& :&'E' 5 8&'4#A4"'# 3 )0 ;4

)' !' D  &7 ''  5&  6'&'   D=' ' '  '!&-',F9',! &@?6C&&&'D&'6 D8&'4AD 4A'4D ;

D;   ?  &  9&''  9!' & ' S&'4 /   9&!7 '?S'& 'E9&'' 9&'&7!'& ' S'' ' 9  &7    ' S    8 39&:I  ); 99 D  ''   9&''  9!' & &&9' C   55!& '&   ) '  &7 !'& '  &?!&' 8&'4 ". 4 "  ;4

 &7 !'& '    S&'4 . 4 "   9& ''  9& '   5&' '' D  :& ?S D  :& 8'4 D;  , ' :   5&'''9&:!' S''#.6$$$5&49&9& 8'4;&'S&37  '&7 7''S&3 7  '!    ?   '! @& :&  S&3 7  '! 8'4 ;  &' 9 ''&9&'' 9!&  ?8'45;'9&'' 9!' & 5!!&8'4;4

)' !' D  &7 ''  5&  6'&'   D=' ' '  '!&-',F9',! &@?6C&&&'D&'6 D

)6> '   5&' D  :& 6&'4 % 4 " '4    9&!  ? ' '' !&!!!'5&' D?? '&     '' 4 )   D!!5   &  9&''  9!' &   '& 9& 9&       9&''  9!' & ' 9&9& !' & 6 D ?  &' 6,D ''  C 6   9&      7&  6 D 9!& & C )(& %.6$$$ '&   !&'  C ' '&  5&'4 &  D  &7' 9 6,D ''  9&  9 E '!&!



01220#$$%  3B0""3     D  '! ,&  '  C 6!'&>&  7& C 9&&   !&' '7&7!64%4

/4  7 ' C  '& &:> ' @& 9& ' ! ? 6' C @' ' '&?6  9&  !&' 7&7!6 D9&9& !'!  &&'C7 &)(&B#6"#$&&9'C)(&A.$6$$$5&<  7&'  "BBA4 6'7 ?&&' 7?& '5&< 469&'5 ' ?  & ' 55&  9 D  '! 6?!& &  D  9&  '& 9&  99&  9  & '  9&9& !'! ' D!!5   6?!&&4  '&   &O& '& 5 '&!5!&C' & ' 7  3  7'9&  9-'&9& 5' & '854 ("#" "#% 4#0'&&-' '!;4!?&&'? '!  9&9& !' &  699&''    (& 7     & ' 6  9& @&  ?' -    6 939&  &  &3 6 &  5 &4  7&   D  D  & 5 '  9&'  '!>&'   5&' ' C  ' '& '-'&9& 9'9&'' 9!' &4

6' !>'  7  ?  &&' :> ?6 7& ' D!!5  &   !'   )(& %.6$$$ 9&!7 9&    '' 5!!& ? '   & O '' !'   699 ? ?    D!!5   &  9&''  9!' &   '& 9& 9&       9&''  9!' &'9&9& !' &6 D? &'6,D '' C6 9&   4 &  &&' 6' 99 ?! C !'&& ?6  5<6'   'D  D  &&!7 ''9'4

.4 )6> '   9&& 9'    ' -'& &@'! !>'4  &99& ? 6&'4#% 9&'' 9!' & H'',! 7'-'& &' '!9&D!!5   &9&,!& ' &49&& 9'  5!!&  #$ !D& "B/2 & S&37   ' &7 7' 8 ); ' 99 D 9& >  C  &' ''   ' 9&''  ' C   D!&'   6D >' &' '&4 9 '  ' ?5 >&C6&'4#/ 4#43;4 E'&6&'4/%4# )& '&&' '' 9&& ' 9&  ! C 9'&  ' O     9'     5 ' 9'&9& ?9&:9 '&'L  & '&&' '' J'6'9 D9&? 9! 9&!7 '  !   9&& 9'  9 >  !  ' !'& '4  - &:>'9&!79&!> ' '8&'4#1 ;4

)@& 9&! 9&& 9' 87!& '!9!&9' I54 (""#  "12;   6&'4 /% 4 #  )   C & & ? &? 6  '&'  ' 5&!  ''   &' ?  ' !'& ' &''' 9&'& C6E ' 9&  9'!'6& '6E >&&' '' 9&'' C6!>& 69&!'& !4&? 9' 9 6' &



01220#$$%  3"$0""3   & '6E >&&' '' 9&''  55 '9?6 ''    5 ' ?  9&& ' !7'' &!&  ' & '  ?  & ' '!'D ?'C9&  9 ?'C!'8 (""#"1"  4 / """  "%  4 AL   "B1B 94.B2  4 /D;4  '&  5'  !&&&!&' '' &! ?'>D4 7' &&  !    &' ''   5' ?   ''  &' 7&! H'9 -'&!'& !8 (""""B 4.;4

69:! 9&& 9' 9&'?&99&'6?-'55'!9& 6   '!  . @  #$$A4   6  ?  55' ?  &&' & ' 5&!6  6E 'D  D  &'!& &'4 '& &  '&     9&''  9!' &  . 9'D& "BB/ '& &'?&&' &!C&6E ' D 9 ?6&!95<!>' 7C?' 7 & 9! ' D  D  &4'!>' 9&'?6C'C'& 6   '!'! 5&!6E 'D ? 9& &'''!9& 6  '6'9!'D 9&9 :455'&&':>3-? &?69&!C6    !'!&!9?D 7 '-'&!  7!& 'D9&9& !' &4 6D 6 '&' !9&6   9& 6!'D &?@&  ?'&&'9'-'& !&! '4

24 R'&??' &' 7C5 'C6  9&&&''   ''    6!9?  @'  6E '   D  D  & &  6 9&'   &  6E     &  9 9&! !'6ED5 &&'46  & 7 '! 7&@'&&C'&9&!&& 6&'!@C 5&!9&&&'9&37' & D!4





01220#$$%  3""0""3  

  /' .  ' ) )')  )  

 

  0,*

"4 !&&&&7D4

 0,

#4 &@''4

A4 7 ' 6   C '&9&& 6 '&'  &' 7 C    &    &&''C&&!  C@'4

/4  '?9&!&'>&' '4

.4  '?9&? '& 'E9&'' 9!' &5!!&9&'  ?S97'5&&&&'&9&!'&&-'! A$@& :  ' 5 '  9&:  & D 5!!& 8),W T&,5?  2 2$$/   ;9&7 &&' :&& '9D 5&!'E &'4 1#      5!!& &  & D 5!!&  "% @  #$$. 8 (;L  ! &  &&  '  ?&    ' 5 ' F  9&7 ' 9&'&   >'&  &&'    ' &L   ' -'& &!  & D5!!&9&7 9'9&7 !'& ?E ' 6&'4/#  (4  9&!' &&-' '  9 :  9   &&' 7?!  F9&7 7'-'&@ 'C67 4  >&55 :&  9&! '         XY Z D)   

9 5&9&!'&&-''' 5 !E9&'   ?SCS55 5!!& & 9&>&55



01220#$$%