Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1172/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1172/2007 AI generated

Property Tax Assessment Statute Validity Challenge

Case Number ATAS/1172/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involved a dispute over the validity of several statutory sections pertaining to the assessment and taxation of property, with the challenger asserting that these sections violated constitutional requirements for uniformity and proper legislative procedure because the enactments contained amendments not clearly indicated in their titles or by reference, as required by the state constitution. The court upheld the challenged sections, reasoning that the title of the enacting legislation sufficiently provided notice of the subject matter being addressed, thereby satisfying the constitutional requirements related to the title's content, and further found that the referenced amendments, though perhaps not perfectly highlighted, were sufficiently germane to the overall subject to be deemed valid under the relevant procedural mandates.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Property Tax Assessment Statute Validity Challenge: The court upheld the challenged sections, reasoning that the title of the enacting legislation sufficiently provided notice of the subject matter being addressed, thereby satisfying the constitutional requirements related to the title's content, and further found that the referenced amendments, though perhaps not perfectly highlighted, were sufficiently germane to the overall subject to be deemed valid under the relevant procedural mandates.

Keywords

AI generated
validity of tax assessment legislative amendment property tax state property matter in dispute constitutional requirement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article regulates the decision on costs, which is explicitly imposed in order 1.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This article regulates the award of costs, which is explicitly imposed in order 1.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



             

! !"

# $%# "!  #" !"$

"&'(  )  * (          !" ) #$%& ' (   )      + ,,     )!"  -.%/)&01#0## #2   )   ,  ,,  ,,,+ ,,   //" ,+  ,*3!)))#4550     

    

   706&7  

 +$

#8   "  #.42 9:)  /; +!/-"  !!")"<)! + ) )1;"<#.$$=) >;;) +;)79) )?)3!"@3/)"8 ,   ")" /  3@ /  ,  ,,   ,,,   ,+  ,A7/B, C8

08  "/"00/)!D0552 ! /B +     + ,, 7    A7/B  C <) =  /  3@ +))/;) +!) </;8

28  &!055&, ))">+!") )  + ) )) )3">!) /D ! +")) @B <!DD >+ D))/ )/)" )<" 8 ;  /!)) +)/ ///!-< +7< )"  "!3/)</) )< /)",  "   !)" EB E>+ 2# E) 055& "   D + /)" )< #55F8

&8  #0)D055&,  "=+" )=) +< )" 0%F) !)"/)))=+)"@)" 1F8

18 9! " /))")" )#5)D0551/+;;)    A7/B  C8   ")" ))" > +" /<) ; < /)" )<  )<)"!)))/=)D)!!D /" @3 3G  @38     ")" //"  ;!)  9 !) !! @)  )! , @" = +   )! '7!)<=,8

48  "  #% ;"< 0554 +   ;!" +" >+ <) ) =   !)" EB +)))  0 H) 0551  2# ! 0554 ) = > <) "D)  ! = < /"D  !/)D)" !  ) @ <;!) +!/-" !! +"!))=@)!/8

%8  "  . ! 0554 ) ) !/:)   #% ;"< 0554 +  /B < "9!"    ))" > +" <) )3"   !)"EB +7 )E>+2#E)055&) B  )= !)"EB  +))) #H)055&2# !05548

$8  4E0554+";!"//)8)) "D)  ) 9  !)" EB )  # H) 055&  ") > I < <G /  "  )!/ " )  02 < 055&  ,  ) /  



6.206055%  726&7   /!)   !)" ) E+ /:  <J)I8  ) =  >  "D)   !)" +))) !!  02 < 055& = 3@ /    !/) +")D "!/)> <)?)!=, ;> !)) "E=/:)!/"8

+" B< /  >+ //  ) = + !)" EB /  /) >)!/B "/J)  ! 8 " )> + !)" EB +))) )  ")" H ?) <" B  00 E< 055&>)!/B "/J)  8

.8  " 00E<055%+ E)"+//)8

#58 +")E)"4!055%) ) "//)8 / @!) "E= "<//" //)8



 !$

#8 ;!"!)=K)814 K@)E AC D ) )!/"))/)) /")8

08 ) +)8%# /"  !))< #0/)!D#.$1 A C +))" /) +;;   >?)   +//    ) )  )) E > ) /)D +?) ;;)" / +  /" 8     >B)  ) ) D@)  /) )  "  <)//D8

28  +/B  )) E >   ,  ,,   ,,, + ,,   ,+  ,/)?)"/+  /")/" 8

E);/">) +//8



6.206055%  7&6&7  



 " ,!$+  $%# "!  #" !"$

) - -   '

#8 //,  ,,  ,,,+ ,,   ,+  ,8

08 !/)) ".  /'(  / ")!8      @;;B  " )     7 L M  

/;! /") ));"9/)/@;;



6.206055%