Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1165/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1165/2007 AI generated

Insurance Coverage Dispute: Earth Movement Exclusion vs. Ensuing Water Damage Loss

Case Number ATAS/1165/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

This case primarily concerns disputes over insurance coverage where the central issue was whether damage from earth movement, specifically subsurface soil collapse, fell under an exclusion for earth movement or was covered under an ensuing loss provision for water damage caused by a broken pipe. The court reasoned that the earth movement exclusion was applicable to the initial subsidence caused by the soil movement itself, but since the damage was also determined to be an ensuing loss caused by the subsequent water escape from a broken pipe, the specific water damage constituted a separate covered peril, thus making the insurer liable for that portion of the loss despite the general exclusion for earth movement.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Coverage Dispute: Earth Movement Exclusion vs. Ensuing Water Damage Loss: The court reasoned that the earth movement exclusion was applicable to the initial subsidence caused by the soil movement itself, but since the damage was also determined to be an ensuing loss caused by the subsequent water escape from a broken pipe, the specific water damage constituted a separate covered peril, thus making the insurer liable for that portion of the loss despite the general exclusion for earth movement.

Keywords

AI generated
water damage insurance over-insurance earthquake insurance claim to insurance benefits insurance exclusion clause environmental liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order concerning the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



            !""  ##$%!""

&&

'( &)*(+ + + ' (&+ )

,-  .

 !% /0/-  !"" 



 !!!"  #$%& $ "%!  !!'% ($!%!  ) *

 !$ !!!"  +$

 %$

+     ' # % "/$  

+        # %,,-.) *

                

  304  

+ 1)

56 $ 78%  59 7&!$ 3..2  5:; (<$  $!<  #$!;$ !%#$  "!& $"  5149% !$"51-:='"%!%$!"% 5,/"&$!$511-6

36 (!//$1!# !%!/78%#$"!%" $!<#$!;$!% $ "  #$%8 #$  !%!"  & !$  #$"& > #$ /!  =! #$$$%$!86

:6 78%!& $%&"/!!%!/3$3..2%"%"%$!' //!  $!<"53$3..2# $?"%! #$%86

-6  $!<" !!%"$  @A!%!%%! @A #$"& > #!  !%$#"  !%!%%!  "/$   #$!%  !  !=$   %%  & !$  =! $%  $!8  !% %$  5,/"&$!$511-%3$3..26

46 '8!%  $ ! '% &"$" #$; $<%    #% !!&!B

C ='!%$&!"97!511::5 D%3..5# $E  FG ='!   $ "%" //!!" H  +     IF '   * G

C = %% $!;$  %$! '& !$  #$"& > @+$6 33.'1,:6.4A  $ H  +         '   H =$"%"//!!"H #%$3."<$3..5G=    $!8% / $! #$   +         '    #% %  '& !$   %  $!8 8%"  !%"$J% '"#$8 " $%  $!8 '";& H +$653.':9.6CG

C ='!  "8% %$&!" # $ ) ' % <$ H "<$ 3..5G ='  %!%!  ' #% "%" $% $   !$ $%%%#"$! G

C =  $ 3..3 H  &<$ 3..4  $  %$&!" # $ E5!'# %!"?!;#!!$ $&"%% %$ #/!<G

C =  $   %$ "%" //!!" H  +          I    5$ "<$ 3..4  :.

    012203..2 :04  

 &<$ 3..,G =   & !$ '"&!%   %  !& $ H +$64'2596:. % ='!  "%" %$/"$" $  # ! '%%% @ %$% 519111903-::-AG

C =$<% #%!!&!'$"%!  %!&!%"$%!&#! $6

,6   % % "%" %$! ? #$%!  %  3 % <$ 3..26  7$!!%!  $  !!=" ='H "/% ' <$&%!   $ #$%  $$J% $!% $$%%<6

26 '<' <7%! "!/!?""%"8$"H78$6

+ '&)

56 '$%634 !/""$$!<$#8#$"& >#$ /!  &!!$&!&%%!&!!%"52"<$511:@+A%$"&!8$ 5$7&!$3...$;8#$ "$!& $6 $= 7 !% % #K $$#$%%!  $%!H#$%8$@$%6533%53:  !&!C A 78!!& $ #"%%'$%62:65 !/""$$ #$"& > #$ /!   34 7! 5193 @A  !% H ;&  $!< % $ !#!5$ D%3..: !%#$;='//!$!  "%"%$!@$%65-3 A?"%$' //!#$%8$< " $"#$%!%! "%$!"#$78!& $6

36  '$%633+@ &%$&!8$#!5$7&!$3...A  !& $  #$%%!    $%! =! $%  $!8  % #$%8"  / $"% ?$%653353:5-5%5-3 G$%6:H4 +'##!=% #$ 8! %%H%$/"$$@65A6 $(= 7 !%#$%%!   $%!H#$%8$ $$# H!//"$%$#$%%!  $%!8%"  & !$  !<$ #8 ?!%% "&%%   %  !& $ %  #$%%!  $%!8%"& !$!<$#8?!%%"&%%  % ! $!8@/6$%63-+A6 $ 7 % H  #$%%!    $%! % H '& !$  !<$ #8 ?!%%   %    !   $!8  !%"$J%    %  !& $ @ + 539  3:.G +531---A6

 K#;  78  #$!;$ !%  $ "  #$%8 #$  !%!"  #$%%!    $%! =! $%  $!8 #$  $6  % #$%!% %K#$%$!85,/"&$!$511-K%$#$%% 3$3..2%H=78%!& $%&?"% !$6

    012203..2 -04  

:6     % #$ !%  #$%%!  =! #%  $!8 #$  $ %53,'.19/$6:. @53.':9.L4'2596:.A!%"$J%>%"7H"%" "#$!%!%%! #$"& >"/$ $%='! !%H  ?C"#  +$6,:'.-1654@53,'.196:.B3A6

-6 / $"% H  7$!#$ #!  7 $ "%$!% # $  #$%8 7=' %%$/$%#$%%!  $%! $ 7 !% !& $"<""/!!!$%%#$%%! $ !%H!%"$J% #% !$$  %%C!6 !%"$J% %"%?!!"8 '$%653 ' $ $#$"& >#$ /! &!!$&!&%%!&!!%"  59 &$! 519- @ 3A     %? $"8%!$ ! !C! % #"$!$ @ + #<!":,0.3597!%3..:A6

46 =! $/$!"#K$%62:63#$"!= %  !&%#$"& !$#$ "$!#$#!%#$!!#8$%!%6K$%6 91* 6 5    ! $  #$ "$ !!%$%!&  53 #%<$ 5194 @ A #$"& !% =% H ! =  #$ "$ % 8$%!% # $  #$%!6 %/ !  "< $ %  " % #&% J%$ ! H  ($8   #$%! =! 8!%  !;$%""$!$ %" !8"8;$%"6//%!!= $!</""$  $ K !  # !<!!%"  !!%$  8$%!%"    $ $ %""$!$  !%$7%" H  "8;$ %  #$!!# 8""$  #$ "$ #$"& # $ % %<$($ !@ +53,545 !6-<A6

 $!</""$$"8%$##"=K!>!/!$ !//"$ %$ K #$%  %!   %!%" #$  !  /$!  #$ "$H($8K#$%!=!8!%#$"8;$%" !;$%""$!$ K$%69463%6 !/""$$K$C&!!%$&!&% @ A @%% $%6 ,5 %6     ! /""$ $  #$%! 8""$  $ ![ &!8$#!5$7&!$3..:]%K%$#$%  $ !% ? "#   K$%6 94 6 3 %6 /   [%% $%6 ,5 %6 8  ]$ !%=!K##$"! $!%;$"& ##"7%K %!  "#H#$%!8!%%!$@$%!=3..3#6,5A6

K#; $!<" !;$=!K %$ !"#7%!/! # K%%!%  $ C =! ' 7!  " !% ?   $!8%=!!"%!%$"C7%!/!$&(=K! !% " #!%K" %6//%#!&!%"% = < $%!  %  %$!%  $!< H   <$ "$( =! % "%" "&!%" !  $ K"%!%  / $" H   <!8%!   $!8$  %  &! %!  % K!$ #!<  $$J%   K   K$%6 246 K" % $/!?"K $$H5'.../$6



    012203..2 404  

&  2 )1  &)*(+ + + ' (&+ )



30/4/ ,, 5  6//  /   7 8 #$! 9

56 &!%+     ' H%$/"$$ #%   !$      ,:'.-1 /$6 54 !! =  !%"$J%  #% !$ !"$%;:$3..27=' % %$/$% #$;   +              /&$ #%

36 K> %%=< !6

:6  !$H&$$" %+$65'...CC6

-6 / $  #$%!   =K #&% / $$ $ $  %$  #$"% $$J%   "!  :. 7 $ ;   %!/!%!  #$;  $!< /""$ @(M!N$( /=!,,..-  A#$& !$ $%!;$$ !% #<! / $"%?$%693 !/""$$ $!</""$52 7! 3..4 @ +AG  " !$  $ $  !% !!=$   !   %!/ %  >#$&%# $%$!8%$$ $%  %!$G! !% J%$ $"  $!< /""$ #$ & ! # %  #$ & ! "%$ != ?  !%!   '$%6 -3  +6  #$"% $$J% %  #!;  # !   $ $%!& ="  >#$& !&%J%$7 !%H'& !6  8$//!;$  $"!%B             !++ O$!  O 

 #! / $#$"%$$J%% %!/!"?#$%!!!=KHK//!/""$ $ !#$8$//

    012203..2