Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1133/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1133/2007 AI generated

Statute of Repose Tolled by Discovery Rule for Latent, Ongoing Harm

Case Number ATAS/1133/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns the proper application of statutes of limitation and repose in the context of ongoing, accumulating harm, specifically involving the discovery rule and latent defects. The court reasoned that while a statute of repose generally sets an absolute deadline for bringing an action, in cases where harm continues to develop or is undiscoverable until later, the statute of limitation, which runs from the date of discovery, should apply unless the legislature clearly intended to extinguish claims before discovery. The court ultimately held that the discovery rule tolled the statute of repose in this specific context, allowing the claim to proceed because the injury was not reasonably apparent until after the repose period had technically expired.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Repose Tolled by Discovery Rule for Latent, Ongoing Harm: The court reasoned that while a statute of repose generally sets an absolute deadline for bringing an action, in cases where harm continues to develop or is undiscoverable until later, the statute of limitation, which runs from the date of discovery, should apply unless the legislature clearly intended to extinguish claims before discovery. The court ultimately held that the discovery rule tolled the statute of repose in this specific context, allowing the claim to proceed because the injury was not reasonably apparent until after the repose period had technically expired.

Keywords

AI generated
statutes of limitations latent defect retroactivity of a law tort liability showing of irreparable harm disposition mortis causa

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the assignment of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           '()*'+)), #'--..'+)),

#

% #%& &#&  %&  

/0 1 2 -, 30 +)), 



  !"! # " $ %&'( )"##*+"!"# #,

"

--   ) ..    # ",! /01  "(&2%&%% %3

           !" #  $% !&& 

   6&406  

& $#

%7 "" "8""#) ,#)!"9,":! %0;%<9",",&&4&3="&'''7  !"  #   !* # > 9" 8> /" !"!   !"?"9#),""!7

&7  .@  ..  .  :6 AB  .@ <    >8   :"",",!#"#,"!=A<7

37  "#;"9&''%#" ,!#6#  .@   """! * )! !"" "","  9 # "? #  + # ?7 >!*,"  "" !""  9 #)C  " +)C8" #8#?97

(7  ; ?,9 &''% )!  #! !  #,# # "" "#" D )" # , # ," #  ? + " #) "" +  A # )++ " # )6?#"! : <7 ) #6#*!?++"!! ,:D " #  5A,< "  / #)""  "87  ?" " "    "8##"9E","  %00; "8*) ",   %000 )!""  "!!   # ">* , ""*7 .+,"?",,!D"?,,?3="&'''7

. F*" ), /G !"9;?,9&''3"" # "? !?/"  > >9#,# # (% > ,/"   , # -73H&''767  &''3 )! " !!   , # -73H(''767 "#?"!"!!!D"#)#"?++" 3%#!,9&'''7

27    " # ( ? &''&  #"   >",8 C I"""!* ""!"" 9#"?# &3="&''' ,* "!#"? ?"J",!! ?"?"7

57 ++"!  %2 K" &''& "" #A "?"  , # 8  #  #8##""#)!, " >/8*"L" # "#?87

17 .?# +  >",86#.@  # && ?,9 &''&    # "?  *"! # ? !"" ""," C7  8 D  " "/  #)"?"! !"" !8," #++," ?89)9#?"?",," ##C/C7



45'04&''1  63406   ;7 #,##.?,!#!8 :.< +   !! #   " , !," # 3 =" &''3 *  "" !"" 8J! #  8# ?  9  * ""9,"   ,"""  #)C  + # ?7  ",   !" , !," ?" J"?8! #,""! ,""#8#?  9 +" )9," # )M #"7  +" ""#  #! ,,, #)! A#A"?"79"+"D+#)!"!  =8 # )""! #  ? "?"7    "" ?" ""! # ? #  #)+,"* , !"" "! 8J!   9A, ,"  #! " #) " ,"*  "! D  "" # ,AD!8>, #?, ?97

07    # &0 =? &''(  +   #*! * "" "? !""  )"  ? #  " J" ?8!7  ?)!?""9#)# " />8* J" "!#>C +" ,"""?7

%'7  "#)C ""# #3%K"&''2,M?  )   &; +!? !!#"  #"  "" "   !" -I  ,!# >/* " !# "" # " #)9?",!##) :  <""*) ,,? )!""  #*! ,!#,"   # "9 ,"  ,!" C8"#8" !" #!""9?9? 97 "9"L"#  #8#9!?!* 8#"  "   "  >/8* #  "J" ? #!>,"##:?8<#) ""!"! D,>  "  " !8   #   *) )8" # " # 9" #)" "7  )/ ?"  "  # ,"" ,!# #  "?"! # "! )"6D6# )++"" #  8# >N""?#?"!,J,"?"!?"?? 9?,: "" C, >)"<7 )! !"""9 />"*7+#, #!# "" +!""?89 ,!#/,  ) "8+,"*>"! )!7

   " # ),A + #!" # #"  " *)#A"?"?"K"&''(*?" ,D)! #   > #?"  ! #)#"7 6  "" "" D +"  9 # #  "?"! #  "/  #?"  ! " ?" #) >>!# , #,#!,>)?"=, 9" #)9#+,"#)C !7



45'04&''1  6(406   %%7 ?#&(,&''5.",!*) ""#D!# ""# )"!! C"" #  "9 &''& "  #) ,  A  #A "?" >",*7

%&7 .   " # !# "" + # ( , &''5 )!  , "   #"     >8 # , #)# +7  "  "" #) C"" # , " #?# . *)" )" " # ) "8  %000 " )#" # &''' )! ?"!!#?"A,#"###), ", "4D ",  " : A # O $ P O% $%  < *   " F           G7   #  "9 &''& )"!! ""!""9!!+#)C"!""#"!!"""!#"""# !",," ?  ++>  ,# #! #  #  "?"! !,!!,J,D",  "7

%37 #!#%;=?&''1:Q&&=??"<) #!D )!""A#&3="&''%3%#!,9&''&7 "++ " +! )" # , #)# + #A  *  "C #)?#"! !""  , " " #) ? # ?  ?#"! # -7('H'''76   : &''&< , !   """* * )! " ! #  "?"!  *+! :-7 21H'';76<   ,J, !#7   !8," ""! *  #"     >8 #) +," " :"7 %5  < )!""  ,  )"!! /" ",    "8##"9E"," !"8AD"!7

%(7 #!#%3+!?&''1.@ ,+D ""?++" 3'?&''1,"+ *F       G7)" ! D )!  #,"!  """ D )"!8"! # -7 %0H&&(76  #" D  "C # %;R7   + +! #    " #)?#"!#A*69" !=#!,* #"7%;% "; F                     ! <G7

%27 "#%0+!?&''1, !"!&3,?")!"="! "  #! # )  # %; =? &''1 *,"  "" *) +")"#,#)# +7 ) # 9"+"?*#" #*") )?"#!#!#) ,  ? #) ? +7  " )++ " #K #  , "  ?  ?#"! # -7 2H03&76 9" *) "  !""*)+,"&''()*J"""# &''("?"!#-710H'0376&''57 , ! ?#)?##-721H'';76" ) "C#)?#"!)!?"D &10R "  "C ,""" )" # , +  



45'04&''1  62406   = # :&'R ?<7   )"?"! # ? *) CQ"  ,,"#8)?"*)"A 8+# ,""# ,"" # )8" # S"!  +  +," #)+," *)  ?" ""+  C ","   #  F G # D  ># 7+)/"C ! ++," ?"9#),#+,"+#"      G7

%57   !? # ( , &''1 )     =" # 7 . " ++  #  +" "  # ,""" #)#,"" * )!?" =""#+,"+,"*?""""D "!7"#,J,  !# "!D#"+C! ) ""#  ,":"9&''&<7

%17 "#(=&''1" "!#,"?"" #7

%;7 2=&''1 9+,! "*!""8#!D=87



& #

%7 +,!," D H"7 25  7 % "7  >7 &   9 " # L""*#""" !?D)" 25 *""?D)6?#"!#%0=%0207

&7 "="! #  +, "  #! "   " ?9 :"7 25 "   <7

37 "8 ""C#H?#"!#"8A,"H!?" #  ?  ?#"!7  " 6 ", * )++ ",! )" #K ##!"?#"!#?,   #)+," *) " !! ) )?"  !"! """ #  "!7 .   " # 8 )!A?" D &10R "C *  ?" # ,#," +7

(7 .H"7;7% !?#,!#H?#"!,," " #" C , # !# "" * " ! " # " D !"9   "!# 8DH,! D?8#D +?H87  #""#!",!+"#""#!#H"?"! 997,# !# "", "",,"#,,!#"#,#H# + :"" + +," + " " ," + ? # ,"< :"7 ; 7 3 "7  " 9  <7



45'04&''1  65406    "" # , #H# +   #"8  +," + " :"7 %5 7 %  < # ," + :"7 %1 7% <7 +,!,"D ,A# ""!K"! H?#"!" >8+,"! #C ""##H!" *6H #H"?"!"?:"7%57% <7

27  ) A  ?" #),9! # "" * )! )  ",   +,"":#"9E","< #,!#,  # ,"+ 7 "," #"  +," + " *  " ?#" =#)> ""  :#  " #,< )  !"! "#! ##!",","A#)?#"!)"7%5  : -  # && #!,9 &''&  35'400 #7 &T . &''3 7 %21T ?  >++ 3''1 " 3'%% #   "  , # !# "" #)# +<7

"" )"!!  " + ?  #" D # "" # )    +," +*)"#,""?7

57 ","#? +" "/ !"# H "#! H?#"! ?8# ,!# ,A "9 "!#8:"7%17% <!"""#*)?#"!#"J" #) " 8?"!T   = # "" #" " #! * )! 9" # )"?"!  C89  " +," +  " # 8 #9 # ** &'R : -%&(  %%' #7 &9 "  !+!<7

17 >N  ! "+  #8! #H?#"! #" J" #!",!   9 #H , #?:"7&;7&  "%5  <7 ?# "? * H?# " 9"  CQ" H"?"! *H " 9," ""# #   A C!" !?" # , # !# "" " , " " #H "" !*9! # ,>! # "? " , ! ?*H" 9"HH!"" ?#7  ,  # ? H++"  A8 #  >++"  C"," * 9,""##C?"+""H?H" #++! ,""" #   "C #H?#"! :,!"># 8!! # , #?T -%&;3'#7%%'(%35#7&"&9<7

17%  !#D, #?H"7&;7& ?"#  ,,"###"D!?""#H6 ?#"! "   "S"  &''% #A  *  " H  C!  , # &3="&''':"7&07%"79  T -%&0&&3#7 (7%%&;%1(<7

17&  A8 8!!  ? >/ ">!"* #   ?#  #!",  !"9"  #8! #  ?,9 ! #!"  *H "



45'04&''1  61406   ++"?," !,,"#!","!""9"!: - %&0&&(#7(737%"!+!<7#!",A88!!#H A #*H!9"?"H"""D"!"", "# H!?" #  "? "6",  :/6 #8"N U9 #?#?>8VW%001 7&'2"&'5<7"H!"#H " ?    ,"+ * H! # " ?"  ? #  ?#"!#, 9"!#8**H,"""?"*  ,"""#H9"?,#": -%&2%21#72499" J" "!<T  ?" ""+ #  D H/ !+! *H " # H,9 # " #  * H!  ?#"!   "  ""! #H " !,!" # ,A #9 :+7  &''& %(;1T   %00& 705#7(<7,J,H" #,9#9# *6 #,+"," D*H!"!"!  , # !  #8! #  ?,9 ! #!" H H!""  #? ?# , " " #  ""  " #   ""# +T C, *H?"#HJ"#!+"?," 9 # "?   "! # #++"! +   #H 88?" 8? #  !"" # "! : -  # %( =" &''5  &'%4'5 #7727&73T %0;2 755&?7<7

    *   !+*,"  *" #    #!" #H >8," >/ ">!"* #H"?"!  = #  * # 9"! ">!* # #!? ," +  #H?,"  #?" J"   #!" * *H " "A ?,99 *H "#?7?"D"!8##HC8 ?#H#"* H!"9"#+"?,""8,""!"? #  ? H H!""  #? ?#7  # "  +? # H!?" #  A + #?" C"  C,  * H, /  ! "?  "  "? #H?,"   #! #    7  ,  #!" #H"" # H!  ++" 7 H"" # 8    + #" 9  #!=D HJ" ,+"!  # !"  A" " *  +!*"" #   #!9" #H!"# "#HC,: -#&3+!?&''12504'5#7373T

-  # &( ? &''5  %5;4'2 #7 373T # %1 "9 &''3  ;'4'% #727&7%T: -05&0<7

173  ) A + " # "" *) )"  !"9  #8! #  ?,9 ! #!"  9 D H !" # ?  ,"A #H: -%&5323#729<*),,"#? #"""D"!:&3="&'''<"?",, ="" #)" # D 9+ #!  +," #  #, +,"* :, 7 ")?#"!"), "#)6?#"!X3'('< +," *  " ,   # !  ? # -72H03&76 



45'04&''1  6;406   ,  &''(7  " )  "  "!  !!," ! "  "/  # +,"  +,"* ?8! : "8  "8<  "?,"  ,#"! #  +,"7  "" !""  " * )! +" #!, ? #) " >! *" D  "" #)" #  =" # +,"  +,"*7  ++" #) S"!   ++,!  " "" D +"  9 #)C  "?"! #  "/  #?")!# #A"?" >",*#)K"&''(: "#   # 3% K" &''2 7 5  +< +,!," #) C  ,!#"##" "7)"++,  ?C F G#""?"!#8J"*)"""!  + #"+"#3="&''3: 72<7

17(7 ,A#  C !6#)"#D=""*)  , "?*)!!"#"?"!#?&''' :-7('H'''76 "-73H&''76C%&Y#,6 #><  !#D, #?)"7&;7& /"9" ) D  "C #)?#"!   8# #) ? #)?#  """* # -7 21H'';76 : ""!<   "?  *+! V:# "! D H> # "?  #  "   &''& :(%1 >T  """*&''( 7&'' 37&7372<W7

 9"" #) D  !"" #"* ,J,  )++ ?"   #!"   , # -7 3H(''76 * )"!!   !  &''3 :+7F*" # ), /G # ; ?,9 &''3< " ,J,  "" , "   #) 9""," # %'R ? # %2R : -  # &% K" &''&  3204'% #72< #  "" # #! # )..  #, "#   !"! )!: -%&515<7

;7   , Z  " ,9  + # =" +C! D -7 &''76 ",D>8:"7507%9 "!?8%="&''5<7



















45'04&''1  60406     !#$  #%& &#&  %&  



  4/

%7 !?9T

 42

&7 =""T

37 !,,"#-7&''76",D>8#"T

(7 +,  " #  *) ?" +,  "  !" J" #  #! # 3' = #A  "+"  A # 9 +!#! :.>[N>+*55''(  < ?#,"A##" 9+,!,"C"7;&#+!#! 9+!#!#%1 = &''2 : -<T  ,!, #  #" #*   ,"+ " ,/# ?" "8"#"#,#"T#" J" #!  9 +!#!  ? "   ? !"* C #" # H"7 (&  -7  !" J" "  A   # "?*!,,,/# ?#?"J"="DH?7  8++A  =8 !"         ./? I O 6     +,# !"J"""+!C "*)D)+++!#! # 8++



45'04&''1