Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1076/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1076/2007 AI generated

Tax Assessment Appeals Affirmation

Case Number ATAS/1076/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court considered several appeals stemming from various prior rulings related to tax assessments and liabilities, primarily concerning the valuation and taxation of certain assets and business activities across several tax years, with disputes arising over methods of calculation, applicable rates, and statutory interpretations of tax code provisions. The court reasoned that in each instance, the specific facts and the governing statutory language supported the determinations made by the lower tribunals or taxing authority, concluding that the applied tax assessments and penalties were legally sound based on the evidence presented and the proper construction of the relevant tax laws.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Assessment Appeals Affirmation: The court reasoned that in each instance, the specific facts and the governing statutory language supported the determinations made by the lower tribunals or taxing authority, concluding that the applied tax assessments and penalties were legally sound based on the evidence presented and the proper construction of the relevant tax laws.

Keywords

AI generated
tax assessments tax authority interpretation of laws assessment of evidence valuation of business assets tax liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           $%&'$'((& )$*(&+$'((&

 )

 )  )       

,  '

# - ./.  '((& 



 !"#$!%& & '"&  !("&  )&* + ,&

&

 *  *#&-. ,./01 &!"  !%&'"&  !("&  )& *  ,&

                 ! "#   #

   602156  

 0 )

17 86%-&9"1:;3.& "&""&" '&! (&&&' !& 1<%&!/055=%%  7   >( %&  !!&  && ?  < @  ! A 86%-  &&9  !%.   "% &   ,7

07 6B7&". &&&&B("&.  /C&!& "&& '" &  ." '/!& % &  >  && &  &7   & > & %%D  &"!&&(&%%," 7 >"&&   E  &  F  /    B ,&  ("%  >( ( &&B&/8D7%%& % % 1G%&!/055=97

<7 &/%&E (,%&&'%"&,.&(& &'"  && %&"  &' -  1< %&!/ 055=7   " ( &8/%/903%&!/055=B *  * 86%-(&!"97

G7  "  13 "!/ 055= (&!"  %&"  %  ,.  ( &! >"" %&&%- ;5H!&D> &("&&'&!&I%"B  .I& 8&7<:  ( &6%- &G: ( 6%- 97 (&!"%%&>  (&&%"% & '& %&%" &'!& B  /.  #&  &!!&  &&%,#>'(&%&.&7

;7 *&B(%%&D!"%&(&!"D!" "<1 E'05547

=7  ;!0554&&B(&  " &.B>(& "B(&!" '%&&" & ' &  "%7  D& ' &!& ( %& >( (#  %  %&%&BI E%  !J% I D"'&"&&'(&""&(&D!&%%"B%!&& &! B  .'&"7 !&&   %&%& B  I ' & B ( !&& !!  !%&!&    %'&" % &  (&&& >'%&&K (&%&& ->( &L& !  /""D  !%&!& !"& 8&7 G: 7 0    D9   "&  ">& & %%& '& B %&". &&  & % # !%  "% K D  (# & > >(  & %  &" & (& &&//(&""#& " " !!&&



234020554  6<2156   &  ' " % .&!%  >  &  & '" %!&7

47   "%  0 ' 0554 (&!" &  E&   & B  D!&   " &. ' &  "%7 %&  I&  "& &!!" &!&%-D&&>(D.&    !L! >    "% (&!" %%  E%  D" "&'B" & %&&%%&%&BIB /.7   " & >  & ("&& .."  (&&  &&    & >  D&  ("&& ! &!&>!&   M  .I (&>(%'&& '&)&> >(I/."&DD&'!&7(&&&%&%& B  I  B  /. >  " &!&  !!.  !%&!& %%& !!   &  ( &7 & B (I%&  !%&!& !"&   %& L& &  !&D ( %& > & .!&%%)&%%!-D&('&%"&"'>"%&  %" %"K (&%&.B>% "D &"D-7

37    1= ' 0554  &  &" ('&  >L&7  &&D!!&'&".& -> "&  &-&!/.N7

:7  /  "  %" " B ( &  %&  &  00 ! 05547 &."& "">&O?*>&E( >'%F &&&" !'% &!%&" &'> "&!7 &&'&"7E(!%!&"&"'%D &&7*>&E( >>(!(&%'B(%&& >&& ("&/!&& (%%%7*(.& &>E(%D"" B (&  7  %%&" % !  8%- 4 ,."9E(&&'.!%%"&&!'&8' ! "&%-;97*>&E( >!(L&'"&!(L& ." ' 7  % %&". ! D!! % >( L&   !%&A7

    D!" ' F   & B && %'7  ! & (&!" -&&">&"%.!&D>((% (&"L&%&& . %&&%.7*> /  "('& >L&' & (!%# &7

157    = E 0554  &  %   & %-6'/I (  (&&D.&% 7

117   (  (>L&  1: E 0554  !%&/  (!%#  &D!"'%#"(& !%""> &



234020554  6G2156   (&% " &","& &&& >&  ("&& % %" B  E7   % & %   F  (&!"7

107    !%&  ! & >  ' &&  & I6 & "/&& >& >&"%.7& > ""&" " I%&%"&%-!%&%&>L&7

1<7   "&  1; P& 0554  & %   7 "/!&  %& B & ( &   &-7  -' >  / % %D&!&  ","&    '!&      !&" E- &!&  !  (!%# %>  &/ (& % " %    %&7  %% &&D (L& .." B "&"  && !! %F  &&   %"& %"  B  !%#7 *  D   -' >  &  ("&/!& "&& /E&'!&  . >  . "&& & % &&  % %"&> (%& '/E&D& '&%&".D!! ' &.'%"B&&>(&'& & "&& %%&" I & & &'   &7   &"! D!& %  >  & & &" &'!& ! "" %B(I%& &- &&"!..&&&"7 && ".!& >  !%&!& & "&"   &  ( &!&D>(.("&& "EB! (!BD'&> & .'&>("&&  " "B/>>(>> &7

1G7   "&  15 %&!/ 0554 (&!" ( %%& B E&   >& '/&" (%%B( & &"!&"& &   D   E&   ' &  "%7 *  D   %% >  !%&!& !"&  & L& & %>(B  !!&  &  ( & %"' &"!&  & >( & % '!//>B"  !%&!& &7( &   &- %)& &   ! J  &-  ">&    (&'& &&%&&>&-"&"& B I % &  &  %%  &7 *(.&   &"  &(&'"& ."'(.>&'&,M( %   & %"  & > (& /  !%&!& >  ","  I&%'>" !!.7

1;7 %- &!   "& I %& % %  15 %&!/ 0554  "&". "BE.7







234020554  6;2156     )

17 D!"!& B (&7 ;= 7 1 &7  ,7 ;    .'  (.& E  89  / &    )&  & >  &&& %"' B Q& ;=    D" "   %& .""  &     = &/ 0555 8 9 > & &'BD" "Q6 & 05!1:318 97

*!%"&%E.  Q%-&"&/7

07 D" "%&.""  &  =&/ 05558 9&&"'.1E'055<&)&! D& !/ %&".  ! 7* %!&"%& '> &(%%> &L&&,"B!- %%>-.%%/&'.!!&J D&E >!& "&!&&% &8 $1<50<5 7171K <<; 7170K $10:G 7170K $104G=4 7110=1<=  7G/&"D"97-. %" >&B(%%>& "' -E &"'.8 $114:< 7=/110<=5  7GK  1::3R<4%7<1= 7</97 Q%%>   Q%-7

<7 &E&" D!& "%"'%&'/8&7;=B =5 97*%',>& '&>&"%  & &!!& (   &"L& % .  %&&    (& =5 &7 /      %"   !&&' 86%-  9 &  (&;: >(&!"&&7

(&"L& .  %&& "&!&  >&" %  '&  E && &L&I!"%% "& (&7 15< &7   8/."K $ 1<5  <:5 7  7 070 &  "D"  E% &  &97

E%  -!!&"L& . %&&&&&"L&%&> E >B ! ! D&(&  "&&>"> %& D '  % &&& % && -7 (&"L& .  %&&&(&&"%&>>( ! %%&&  &   (& &!   D& ("'&  %"E   & "!> "!&"&> "&&>"&7 (&"L& &L& &&&K%&% &&'  %%&DD!!&"&&' "K&(&% >(& &&&> !- &!" &8 $104< 71/10;<G0  7G&"D"K $  0<'!/0551 =42055197



234020554  6=2156    (%- &  !& &"L& B  %"    (!%# %&%D&!&!!6!L! !%/&"> " (&!"&"!&;5H '"&%7

G7 >&&.&  "&!(&BE&&&>(&!"" & %&& ;5H%%& &<: &G: 7

;7  %% && (/  > (6 & & & (  %&& ( &%D%D8&7=71 97   &  &  && &&& !!./   & '& %&"  % ,! %   I&" I&  > !%!&  &"%,#>!& %#,>>&)!&8&7G  K $ 10:G5G 70711000<0 71&"D"97

 & B  %&& "& (  & " %% (/  & ("'"!& !!./ &- &&(&&&B&"  &"&7 &&I.&!%>(# ( !&&> &"'"!& & !!.&%% & &&>( &%' !L!!-7*'("'"!&"&(&&&B &" & " %  %%&  &" & &  >&  D& > ( !&&    ","&  E. I!   D & &!&   .!& (  !"  8 $ 10:  131  7 <71 G5=  7 G7<71 11:  <<4  7 1 113  03:  7 1/ &  "D"97    &"  ">& &  ',  >&  & >( %%&& B ( !&&& E. &,7&"& ">&  (%-   , &(I%" 'D& "" "&&%%B&)DD& . >(&% &'   "&& %&  DF ."" D'" %  & & 8 $ 10:131 7<70G5; 707010;G=1 7;&"D"97

=7 (%-(&!"&&%6BE&&&6/.& %&7 D& &&D .   %/&" " %  ".&  "   %&&    . I&  & (&% &"!" 8&7 <:  97

(&G:"0 %"'&" &! !&" %&&  %-   ( &  %D ' &!!&    ?%&%&BIB/.B!>("&"&"/"% %&.&  >(  %&  %& B  I  B  /.  >( '& B% "DA8&797

I&/.D&& >'&!%." % !L" .>/&&&7(.&  (&%.>> D. B (&7 1<< * & > ( "D  E%  8 $ 15=  0;5  7 < 15G  ;4  7 0/97 !!  / D" " ( E." B %



234020554  642156   %#%&%&BIB/. && %& !&> (&""% %&B '"&/& '! "EB ( (& .."  (&& >   "'&!& %"" " & >  "" !/->>(%&'B &  '7  > %&% B  %& '& >  !!&  &  '%%!& &!&&!&>!& M  .I  (8 $:::K 1:4= 0=4%705=97(&%" >("&!%&!&D&D%%>((& "&!& ' >&B(. I&%>!&D(&""%%&B %& ( " %(D&>('7*& "DD&>(" %'&  '& )&  > >( I   /. "& DD&'!&8 $<=12:3 15!055597

" & %&& (&7G:70&7 %%>(& !%&!& ("> &L&>D" %&%&BI /.& !!.'I& &"7E.   &"  '&  "&! "&%&'!&  %&&  "&& > (& % &  &  > ! (&&&   (" %%)& !!   &  ( & 8* 1::;   0: %7 3;97  & ".   ' %, ( I D!&  && &  %'& L&  ""  "% !!&( (&8 $ 1:=G%74;97&D E%  &&>E. (&%"%(%%"&>D& E.%" (I (/&&7("&&&D ("&& D& &% > %%"&E >>(DD&%B &>D & %%%&&8 $ 11144 7;:401<97

47 (&    %% >(  >   %'  E.    D   " D %& &      D& > D& (L& "&/  !- "D&/ %%& !!  % '!// (&6B6  > %"&&  ."  '!/ %"% "&7   DD&  % >( D& % L&  "" !& !!  ,#%&,- %/7 ! &  ""!&  D& "."  './  E. &   ","& & I >  %&  % %// 8 $ 10=  <=5  7 ;/ 10;  1:;  7 0 &  "D"K D7 $1<5<0G 7<70&<7<97 (I&6&6% &  %%>( !&&E. '&&&  &D' ("8 $10=<00 7;97

E.D &%%"& %' D%'&.&I> &%"  (DD&' > & D& %"&&  ."  '!/ %"% "& & > (& ! %/&  %& % ! D && %%"&  & %D ( !& (& %' 8%%"& &%"  %'K



234020554  632156   R*  S&.'D,   *M',. %7 010 T G;5K RUV2+W  S&.'D,   S&.,&%D.    0" 7%7<:T111&%7114T<05KX 'S&.,&%D.0 " 7%704GKD7 $100G=: 7G10000< 7<105/00:  70/11:<GG 7<&"D"97&!- %"  '% & (L&& (&70:70 &78*0551T15%703  7 G/9  E%     (!%  (&7 G  &7 "&& &E '/8 $10G:G 7G/1001=0 71 &(L&&"97

37  (%-   & !%& %>( &&  %-6'/I  E. (&&> &%% %7(#% D &B !   & (& B'&-  &&7 &&&&6&6'. &%D""B(&  . %"& >  %% "&& ! '& > I >(  %%&"7  /  " & &&D (' > &&  %& L& &'&.&!%"!& !J,.% ( &.!!&''7%% (>(%"  ' DD"&  E&  & (  &  D&   E%  %"D"B>(" "%! >(.&">E >I%&'%'&L& 6!!&6% & "DI&"8 $101G4 7 0 &  "D"K    055G T  ;1; %7 G05  7 170 T  ;13 %7 G<=  7G70&T;1:%7GG5 7<70K*0555%7051 70 K $  %/" <5 "!/055G:425G97

:7 * / ""!&D.&  /&!"B& >&%&%"BI (&G:"0 &  E% %"&"7

 DD&  & &  "%&& (.7   % !& % &&> "&&'"&>(!&&/%>(B I%   ,."  % % ( ". 8D7 "&6%&  1G75:75=97  &&&>D& &/%'&Y'%&"B&  ("&/!& &  &%   D &   & &&  %""!& %>  & '&  !&D    >( ( % B  % > >( &7  ( % %" B D &'  % &  " " (&'6!L!7",. (& 6>>(& '. 6 &  &  "/""!& %  &  (. > B  !!&6B '& %&& >&&"  &  && &  &'&   E &(.%%"&&6%!6"8D7 !&%%&  !L! &97("% &'& >" (>(.'&B &!!& "&%"!&Z ! & ''  6&  %  /&&Z 8D7 "&  1G75:75=97  D&  &(&%" M  .I '& (



234020554  6:2156   &'& &>(%'& '&)&>>(I /."&DD&'!&7

 & '> &&D 6  &    %"& %"  >!& 6 >(  . % '    B  %  "D  > I&  " & %&&7D&'>!%&!&&.I&>( & ">& (I. ("!%&!&&&&B>&& - "'"!&7%& '  /&&D!%&!& &(%"&".I! "/ &7  & ('&  DD& %  !  .&  "&"  &  && 6 !L!  & &  !"& 6& (  %& & > %  !%&!&(&'' BD!!>&"&"&"6 %!!&&, (6B6%(.! ! .%7(&('&%'>"&.!& !!& D&> '!//>&("&&%!&'& !!&7

& B  &" &  !%&!&  & &  !!.  & "' &   (&  & B (&  (.  & (&%"&"/"%  7 >& ' & % (P& "&" (& % %&&  (%- %> (  B &  "&" I ( %&&>&" &L&I!" %& ' &7

157 ">&(&!""&&D "B"  ;5H%&&%- &I&&&!!!%"'%7%&L&>E&"7











234020554  6152156  

   ) 0  )  )       

#

  1.,

17 "'/7

# 1.

07 E&&7

<7 >%" &.&&7

G7 D!  %&   >Q %'& D!  &  %"& L&   "  <5 E -  &D& %-  / D" " 8*,SM,D>==55G  9%' !&-  & %/D!"!&I&730 D" " /D" " 14 E 055; 8 $9K  !"!   &  >   !&D & !# %'&%&.& & ! &K & L&  "  / D" " % ' %&  % ' "&> I  &  (&7 G0  $7  %"& L& &  %-  %  &'>"!!!# %' '&L&E&B('7  .DD-  %" &         XN V /*   

%D! %"&L&&&D"I%&>QBQDDD" " &"%/>%.DD



234020554