Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1069/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/1069/2004 AI generated

Contractual Rights, Statutory Minimums, and Financial Obligation Disputes

Case Number ATAS/1069/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involves disputes over various contractual rights and obligations, specifically concerning the application of statutory minimums and the interpretation of complex formulas within the agreements, with the court considering multiple reference points and calculations to determine the proper financial outcomes for the parties. The court reasoned by meticulously examining the language and structure of the underlying agreements, applying relevant statutory standards where applicable, and resolving ambiguities in the contractual terms based on established principles of contract interpretation to reach its final determinations on the disputed amounts.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contractual Rights, Statutory Minimums, and Financial Obligation Disputes: The court reasoned by meticulously examining the language and structure of the underlying agreements, applying relevant statutory standards where applicable, and resolving ambiguities in the contractual terms based on established principles of contract interpretation to reach its final determinations on the disputed amounts.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual rights and obligations reference agreement commercial dispute scope of statutory duty contracting party proceedings relating to a contract

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

The court rules on the allocation of costs for the legal aid granted to the appellant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               &''(&)+ &,*'-&)+



! "! .  !. .

'/  .0  $ )* 1  )+ 



$ 2222222222 ! "#$%&&   ! &!$''$$



! 

33. .  4!.5 ' $!$& ()*+,-



                !" #$%

   41.504  

 3

56 7$ 8888888888  !$! !%$&5)/2! $-&9$:+ ; $<=5)>36(? & @$'A6$- $5)>*$B- & A $&!&C8888888888D $9 +,-6@@!& ' $  E  ' ! -$ ' "!  $ C8888888888 D $ 9   / -F  5))1  $ '"  %$  $!6  '! ' * E-$  5))3  9   ''&$$'"$!$!' !! -?!!!" &!!-  $!  & ' <   F! !  & $ - @@! &! !$@  12 '&F  5))G6 " &  &!& $ $! + " 4<H% ' @&- $ 5))3+ I!5))0$$@@!& !$! $  + " !!' ,-'!F 5))0+@&- $ 5))/ $ F !'3JG>0@ 6 @&- $ 5))/+@&- $ 5))>$+- A'$'$!&'<H%6

16  '! ' 5G $ 5))3 $  '&&  '' '  !!$ ' " 4 $-$'$!&  $ '   %$  $!6 !! ''  &!& &  E-$  5))0  $ ' "!!$!' ' " & K$ @$!  $  &  '( !!''$'"< !$! 6

G6 '!'5>I!5))>L &@$!<! !%!F$@ !  '<-$' $!-& !'$!$F$' $!6&!&! $!&   !&(!<,K$"!$K& , '$'<-$$!  ' $!6

36  1 @&- $  5))) " &  '&&  '?$, '' '  !!$ ' " 4$-$'$!& !'! +  ! '  -  @$  $'"@ ! !$'<-$' $!6

06  '!'5>- $1222" &F$  !< ',!$F$4! %$' $! ? #H$!? $- $!$  ' ,- - $! !4& !$  $6  '  '  & $!  &!$! !! !  &! &%! +   <  K$ F$%$!  !$! + !$$    %$ + %< $$ K"F!!' <6

/6 9&'$! $!!  8888888888 &!F$  !+"!!!$' "@@$ ! ' " 4$-$'$!& :$4 , " =  '! ' 53 - $ 12256 '$%!$K&!! ,@ ! $-'<-$' $! !! ,@ ! '"?! &$!&'$!'& &!! ,!&(!<,  -$'"?! &$!&'$!'!$F$!'&$! 5)I!5))>  !%!!!4 !< ','<-$' $!5)- $1222$$K" &!! '"%$6  !$!  &!$!  $$!& !! ' ! -$ '$  1)  5))) ' &$'&! $&6"&!!'!&&!$!!!$$ !$4$  !!$!!$!'"!  ' !$-$!& @$6

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

>6 " &  &!& $ +  !% '"F -!$  @$ ' 5/ '&F  1221  1G   122G  !  '"$!&% !$  @$ ' " 4 $-$'$!&:$4 ,  =6  !9 '5*- $122G? !  @$!@ &$$-!NO"&-!$'$!&  @$ ' 7$  8888888888 @@!& + 9  ! +  $F$$!&' &'! '$ $!&$K 69$!& &$' ' ! -$!&-&! >2$$!522P ,KK$'  & !$ + ' !$-$!& $'! $ &%,  ' ' !$-$!& &'!$  &%,   ?$% '  &$$ ! ' @$ !  $!$  $$! $6 :Q=  '- -  K " & "! F$ %%&6 &$ $ ! K"$ F'$+ &! +( !!$6 - !!!$!' @$'&! !$-$'"$ $'"   !!$! K"$  "!  &$!&6  $'  ! ! ! $'$FR6

)6 " &  @@!&   %!$ ' !% ' 13    1) E$ 122G6   !   ! 9  ' G E$ 122G ?  (!<, $-!N O:Q= $-&! '!! %!$@+!!$!$%&6" H!&  $ '"9  ! ' "   ! @$ & ! $  S! $F!?$%$FK7$ 8888888888!!- $!& &$''! -$'>2P$$: '!'>2P$$  $ != '  $ '!& :- $  '"$ $   , @ !$  !$K=6 $  $   ! 9  !   ! ' !% '"- $    K$ $ ! '"- $  + "&!F$ ?&6 " !  H!& 7$  8888888888"'"!$-$!& @$'$''$?:$ $! F$' '$!$ ! -$=!$'$!K"$-$!@$ '" $4!: $'"< $'$!''$K&" &'&!$ !&&< &'$:  8888888888= ,?T$$!!$

  .//0.1223  43.504   $4! "!    @$ &=6 !! $!!$  '$! +  $ ! $!' !!! $!+-   ' !<& $K! '$ 6  -$!'&E+9 "$%K " &-!' :'!$$!$ $!! ,<'$&=! @ $E + ! @$ '"F!!$'"! ' ! -$6 9$  '$  !'! + '$  K" $4! !  ?$ -$!  "E! " &,-!!<'"M! F<&'< '" !$  !&%&R6

526   !''$-$$' &'!!$ @$'*I!122G (<% 8888888888 ' "    &'& +   $ ' - -! $-$'$!& ' /0J2/3 @ 6 !  , $-$'$!& ' 32J531 @ 6 : , &'!$ ' 50P   !$  ! ' $$!!$ @!$= '"U $  !$!  '% & '"$-$'$!&'G>GP$@@$! - $ ' $!+ !6

556  '&$$'12I!122G"  E!&''' !!$'" & !$@K$!&'! -$"&-$!'!$-$!&'!&+>2P6  $ ' %$ -! !  , $-$'$!& '$$! + !$   '% & '"$-$'$!&'G>G2P$@@$! ' ' $!+ !6

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

5G6   '&$$   $!$ ' 51   1223 "  "! &@& & +  E $ '' $F@&'& ' :$4 , V =K  ,   - ' "!!$! +  !&  K " & "-$!   $ '"!$-$!& !$-$@$! &@&  +" KM!$ ! ! '$  :$4 , " 99=   @$?   !! ' - !<& $K  , $-$'$!&6  !  '    &!   &'!$ ' 50 P  E!$@$$!   !$  ! '  $$!!$ ? ! -? &% 6  -$! &%! ' -  K  $$!!$ '  <'$ -$! &!&  $  $'& !$ ' "&-!$'  K$ !$@-$!@$?&+>2P!?' '! ' " &6  "   '$@$!$ $%$@$!$- &!$! $! - 

  .//0.1223  40.504    '"&1222$K"&!$!+ !$ '!!'!K"$-$! &!& $!& ' ! -$ ' >2 P '  !$-$!& '!&6 ,   "&K '&! $!     $ ' - &!$! "& 12226   &'! +  $'%$- $F1222"F!$! !? '"$-$'$!& ' G>5) P K$ "- $!  ' $! +  ! :$   $-$'$!& &!$&1222"$'$$'$ +!$N /GJ>/)@ 6T$ '"$-$'" 991222NG)J3*G@ 6=6  -<" & -$! ' $! +  ! !$,  '"$-$'$!&    & $' ' 5> I! 5)))  G5 E$! 12226 "        @$ &  '&$$ ' 12 I! 122G @!' !!$ & $'!& $ G5E$!12226

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

506  &-$'0$1223"  E!'   &@& !+ '&$$!?$,''$ 6

5/6   $ 'G2E$1223 $F'&''& 8888888888 '$ K '!  !$!  &!$!  $!& !! ' ! -$ '  !$-$!&'!&6

5*6   $ 'G2E$1223&%!$''&+"  KF$ -$!! (&+" & !!$, '"$-$'$!&'5>I!5)))G5E$! 12226

5>6    $  ' 5> ! 5) E$! 1223    8888888888  &' K  !$! &!$!$!&!!'! -$'!$-$!&'!&:$!$ '! -$$-$F$$!&'-  &%$, ! F% T' ! '< %''&! $ &%$ '!&'!'"&< '"&<@'%='$@$'"&1225+ $'><  E 6

  .//0.1223  4/.504   F!$'!& $'"!&(!<,-$!$*$1221K$-$!%' &  $$!& !! ' ! -$ '!  $6  $%!   $!K F,'$'! F,''K"$"-$! ! $!&6

5)6 "  &''!'11E$!1223K" &-$!$'"$'! I!5))>-$!' $!+  ! !$, '"$-$'$!&'$$'"I!5))) $!'&$' '"&'" !61)'$ " 4$-$'$!&6 $-$!F$ !< ','<-$' $!- $1222-$! & !$ $$ $!  ' !$-$!&'!& ,!!& !$6  $!$ ' " !6 >> 6 5 ' ,%! ' " 4$-$'$!&  ! !$, -$!&!&$$!&+G$ ,!!& !$$!',5 I!12226

126 '!'5>I!1223 $F'& K$'  ! !$@$! ' $  ' "!  $ C8888888888 D $ 9  $$ K  $ '  ! $!$'&E 6

156   $ 'ME $''&+"  KF' $ -$! !  $  -! $-$'$!& ' 3J3*0 @ 6   $   K  ! $'$-$' 9'" &!$$!K'$ : )$ $ ' "! $!$ $$, =  $!! !  1/JG12 @ 6 ! GGJ2G* @ 6 $'$!&'- $6

116 E 5>I!1223 $F &$! %& 8888888888K!+ $!&'! -$'!$!6

1G6   $ 'G5I!1223 8888888888?$K&K" & ,  !< ', ' 5> - $ 1222 -$! 'I  <   '&< % ,! ' F  & & '! G $ $  < % -$! &!&  % $-! %!& "F'!'(!$'&F 12226 -$G$  ," !< ',$!!$"&!$! &'$!!F6

136    $  ' > !F  1223 "   $'$K&   -$  '"U -$!  !! ' $  -! $-$'$!& !6 9   F ' -  -! ' !$'$-$'"@@$ $-$!+'% &'"$-$'$!&'20P6

106  '! ' 1> !F  1223   !  ! $  $F ' &  ! $!$ ' &E   @$< ' $   -! '  !$ ! $ +" !!!'&!'<H%6"-$!F!$  !$@$! '$  ,'"!  $C8888888888D $9 $K$'!$ &$! K "'$$! !$@$'&$- $!'$, & $'!& $ + 5))36

  .//0.1223  4*.504   1/6   $ '*!F !55-F 1223 $F'&$! & "!  $ C8888888888D $9 ,69  &!& % '&+ E% 6



 

56   $ %-$   " %$!$ E'$$$  :=  &!& '$@$& !  $!$!& ',5 I!122G $F!' $&'0 E%'! &$'!!-$4 &$'!0&!!5/E%  : !65!6 !0/ =6

9$!+"!$'"&!$'5/E%   $F@&'&  1* E-$  1223 : V 5G2  52/=   ' $ %-$  '!&  5G @&- $   '$$!$ ! $!$   %!  !!!  $F ! '   $ ' $&%     + ! $ E% !$!$   ' "!!!'"&!$'-?E% 6

16 @ &!+J !60/65!6<61'$%-$ " %$!$ E'$$$ := $F!' $S!$! $K'!!!$ &-+" !60/  K$! !$-+$  " 4$-$'$!&'5)E$5)0)6

 9&! E% ''",!', &!F$6

G6  $F'&!!! K  $! E!&'@ ! '&$ &%? ! -F @ &! ?  !6 /) '  $ @&'&    " 4$-$'$!& ' 5) E$ 5)0) : = ! >3 '  $ @&'&    " 4-$$! -$-!'12'&F 5)3/: 9=6

36  $ @&'&      !$ %&&  ' ' $! '   $ ' /!F 1222: =!! &-$% 5 E-$ 122G!! S& '$@$!$ ' F  '$$!$ '  '$ ' " 4 $-$'$!&6&%$!$-$% EK"G5'&F 1221' !!@$ '&! $!  ",6  @@! '" ,  E $ '  &%$!$ $F'<%!' ,%'' $! !K$&!$!-$%   ' &$!$'"&!!'@$!K$'$!M!  &$&E $'$K!K$ '&KE $'$K: V5103/*$'65T51/5//$'63F= @$! K"! $!&'  !M! &+  ' ' '" &' '  '' $!'$$! !$@&!! $ ?K$  !  '$! EK" ! '  '&$$ '$$! !$- $!$%$ : V 515  G// $'6 5F=6  '$$!$ '     ! ' $!& '   ! -$% EK"G5'&F 12216

  .//0.1223  4>.504   06 ? !  ' J !6 3   J$-$'$!& !  '$$!$ '  $!& ' %$  &&  !  ' % ' & K$ &! 'J !!$! +  !& <($K! -!'J$@$ $!&%&$!'J'$'J $'!6

($' &$ KE $ '!$'"$-$'$!&' ' $!' $!!$&$K!&'$T!  &K &$K FE!$- ' "$$!& @!$ K"$ $ !'"&- : V5521*0$'63T52012*$'61=6 K" $'"$!$-$!&'" &'&&$K@!'&@!$($ '@'  '&'" ' &'$' U !!! '"&-   $!& ' ! -$ ' "$!& & ' ' !$-$!& $F! ?$%$F: V5505GG$'61T52050>$'65=6

 -$  '% &'"$-$'$!&"'$$! !$:E%"$(   =F$''!K&'$&-!!$'"!  &$$! '$-! $ @ $ 6  !W< ' &'$ $! +  !   E%!   "&!! ' !& ! + $'$K  ' K   !   K !$-$!& " & ! $F ' ! -$ 6  !   '& &'$ !$!!  &&! !$   '&! $  K ! -?  !   $F!?$% '" &: V5101/5$'63T5505G3$'6 1T553G53$'6GT52050>$'65=6

" &  ' $! +  ! !$,  "$ ! $-$' + // 1.GP  $ +  '$4 !"$!$-$'+02P$+K !' !"$!$-$' +32P$: !61>65 =6&$F$-$'$!&'32P $- ' $!+'$4 !6: !61>65F$ =6 ?! '" !61) ' $!+ !'" !61> '$ !H!+'!',KN =" & &!$$!&'%$' F'32P$ F= " &   &!&  (  $$!& ' ! -$ ' 32P  $ '!&$! !$!F:65=6 /6  "  "      !  ' $! +  ! !$,  '"$-$'$!&'5>I!5)))G5E$!12226" & K$ !'$4 ! '"$-$'$!&',5 I!1222!!! $'%$@@!&  " 6

"%$!', ''&! $ '% &'"$-$'$!&'  !6

-!  $ -$! ' !!  K   !   &!&  $$!& !! ' ! -$ '$  5> I! 5))> '! '  $'!  "  EK"$'"- $1222! 8888888888EK"+'&F 12226 "   F    && ' "F -!$ ' 1* - $ 1222 ' #H$!? $- $!$  ' ,-  K  $! & !$  ! &!& $ !

  .//0.1223  4).504   @&F $! !'&'$$K$@$!! 3 $'- ," !< ',-!  $'! -$6&'$ $ " '!  ?$&  !$! !   !! K!$   8888888888 -<K$$-$!   !!+M' '&! $ - &$$'!'@$'"$$!&'! -$6 $F '& $  !! $+-$6-$!', '!!  K " &   &!&  $$!& !! ' ! -$ ' 5> I! 5))>  G5 '&F 1222:'!'"F'!'=6

9" !6>>' ,%! " 4$-$'$!&'5*E-$ 5)/5: = $  $!& ' %$ '"  & "&$  $ (  $ ' $'&   K  <%!  $ !!   !$ '  ' $! ?  !!$ ', K" ! "!!'  K  ' $! ?  !!$  $!$ ' !  X % & $'6   - ' M  K" ! <%! '&! $!  ' & G $ '&E+  $! !$ !F !  K" $!$  <$ $! +  $' 6 $!$'! !$$(', $'"! (   !  !!$, '"$-$'$!&'5 I!5))): ,'&$' ' " !61) =G5 1225:G$ , - !'$!&!!' ! -$=!G5E$! ! " 6

" ,    :  ! '"- $ ! ' E$ 122G= ! " '  &'$ ! $!! &$$!  <$  %$  !<&'$K   8888888888 :  ! ' -F  1225= " &  &!  $!& !! ' ! -$ -  '!'>2P''!$-$!&'!&!!!'$$!!$ @!$ :!$-$!& &'!$  &%,   ?$% '  &$$ ! ' @$ !  $!$  $$! $= ' ' ! -? ! K ? '"- $  '"$  $   , @ !$  !$K6 9    8888888888 %&& $! ! '"-$ K  !$!  &!  $$!& !! ' ! -$   "$ ! K !$-$!&6 9 -$ ! '$!   '?  !  @$ F& !!   ' !% $$ K   $ ' '?$, &'$ ! $!! &$$! K$  ! $!&   !  !   F,'<-$' $!'$!'M! & !&6

 '$!  ? ! '   !    8888888888 $! K   !   &!  ' $!& ' ! -$ '   @$ $$!$ ' A$$!& &$''!$-$!&&%, 6 '&! $  '% &'"$-$'$!&$@' ' &' + $' --!!  ,$-$'$!&6

*6  -$! $!! ' '&! $  "&-! ' $! '  ! +  !  ,G5 12256

<X &!$@'% &'"$-$'$!&'$!M! '&! $& F'"  $ ' -6     - ' ! -$ K "$-$'  $!

  .//0.1223  452.504   F!$   ? A! "!$-$!& K" ! $F! !!'  ' $  , ?&!$ &-! '   ' &'!!$ ! ! ! '" $!!$ &K$$F &' <&'! -$! & -K"$ $!F!$ "$ "&!$!$-$': !61>61 =6 $' -"@@! ,% %&&   <$@@ ! $ ?!! K $F  !! '  '? - !   @ !! " - "!   '$@@&   !!! '    !? '"$-$'$!&6     U  -  -! M!  <$@@ &?!!$'$-!M! !$&'" ,&&!'   !$$   , K$ "   !    -   ?$!$- $$F!6

  &' + $' -$-$!' ! '$'' $!+ !T --!$-$'$!&'$-!M!  '&! $&    ! +  M ! !  '$@$!$ '  - !$F '"$@   ' $! +  !  - EK" ! U  '&$$! ''$-!M!  $!: V51)111!51>5*3=6 "&' &@&  '"&5)))K$ K'&F!'' $!+ !6

 ,%%&&  K" &? !$-$!&$@!'!! K%$ @@!$-! &$&&K$-!+ !!$'! -$ '!6

 "   '$  !$! ' <$@@  '$-   !  -  !!KA'  !69( $&!&C8888888888D $9   K$! -$&'5)>*+5))1!!K$$ " $' K!$$  '"(   !!! ' '&! $   $  '  !6 "$! !$" $'"F!$ ' $%!$ !$& ,' !! !  $ - $FF!  @$$!6 "  -$! !  $  -! $-$'$!& ' 3J3*0 @ 6   $  -$    K F " 4 $'!K!+ !%$ &F5))G'02J2/3@ 6G2$! '3J5*1@ 6

'! $  ! ' ! $'$-$' 9 '  ! K"$   A  5)>*1*J/>3@ 6:$'$!&'- $= )$5)>>G2JG/0 @ 6:$'$!&'- $= )$5)>)1>J50>@ 6:$'$!& ' - $=  )$5))21/JG12@ 6:$'$!&'-  $= )$5))51*J3)1@ 6:$'$!&'- $=  52$!5))1GGJ2G*@ 6:$'$!&'- $=  55$6  $  $& :@6  M! ' V   F$&     110.2G=  &!!'!!'G/J)51@ 65)>*32J3>/@ 6/05)>>G*J033@ 6 5)>)G0J2)G@ 6G05))2G1J))2@ 6325))5!G/J232@ 6G05))16

 " !61065 ! &!& -'! -$'" !61>61    -   &F   K  !$!$  $!  A 

  .//0.1223  455.504   - ! '   96  -$! '  $!$ ' !  !$ ' !$   -!$& &!$&+"&5)))6

"%$!', ' &' +"&-!$' - ,$-$'$!&6

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

 -'$! M!  &'$!'12P !$ !''$$!$' '!'" &K$  &! -'31J)G/@ 6)06

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

  .//0.1223  451.504   J'$$! !$6  E% '   $  !  !$@  !$! F!$!  &$!$+'J'$$! !$: V51/>5$'6/=6

!!'EW%'  !:&5)/2=4K$  &!&&! $!$@4!'@$F$$!!$@!$K$!&!& $!  ? !' 7 '!?' '! !:>2P=!K$  8888888888"! S!M''$$!$' '!$-$! ' &' +F!!!' -'"$-$''50P?$K$ !@ +$ ! " ! '-E $ '@&'&  !$, 6"F!$!', + -'"$-$''G/J3)/@ 6326

9$" ,'+ $' --!! ,$-$'$!&M @$  ' (    & 5)>* + 5))1 $  !! "&   @- F + " & $! "& 5)>> :32J3>/ @ 6 /0 &!$& + "& 5))) $!0GJ>3*@ 610=F!$!+!?'"$-$'$!&'G111P:Y:0GJ>3*@ 6104 G/J3)/@ 632=?522ZN0GJ>3*@ 610[G111P=$@@$! - $ ' $!+ !4'+'G5 12256

 ! + -  K"$ " -  ! ! $ " !$!  %$ -! $-$'$!& $ ' "!$ ! $  + " !! ' ,- @@!& ' !F 5))0+@&- $ 5))/ $ F !'3JG>0@ 6 @@! '$($' !$ %$'01J/1G@ 6:3JG>0@ 6?51= K$ , $' -F!$!+!?'"$-$'$!&'G2/GP K$"- ' $!+ !6

>6 ! ! @$" !65*65 " &' $! ! '  -  @$ $  $-$'$!& ' &$   !!$ $!&' %$! $$ !!- $FM!  -% '&  &$ & ' $,  !F6 9! $'& &   ! '@ !$'!$&+' &K$!F$  $ '   $-$'$!&  , <,-! '" @ !$  @$ $$!$   ,  '&F! ' "? $ '" !$-$!&  !$-  @ !$  &F   $!$     &$   $F!   $!& ' %$ : !6 / 6 5 ' ,%!   " 4$-$'$!& ' 5* E-$  5)/5=6  @!   K "$-$'$!& $! '"  !$ % -$!&T   E $ ' !! '$!$ ! '&  K " & F$! ' "!$-$!&   ?$%$F  !  @ !$  @$   ! ' %$ ' F   ! ' KK12P: V513552$'65F! &@& =6

  "    ! 4 '!  '% & '"$-$'$!& ! '"-$  G2P 4  @@!& '? !% ' < ! $ $     122G6   ' ' !%? !!!&K"$-$!!<& $K!M!  &'!&'$ $! &$K '!$-$!&$!$E $!$ !$ ! '< %!'&!@ &K!! %&6&!$ '!&&!$!

  .//0.1223  45G.504   ! & $+"&!F$ , ' &'!!$'G+51$!$   ,   ' &'!!$ ' 5> $6  '! &!$! !! ' /2P $!! $!!!$' >2+522P ,%& $' '"'!!$: " &"-$!! -$&'$52=$$K" , '!!$'!'! -$:<$ %$K!$F$$!&'"%  EF=6<','" !&!$! $ " & !$$!K"$-$!! -$ K!$ $'"< $'$! ' '$K & !!$! '&!$      8888888888 :  !   D 9 %>=6

 - '  $'& !$  $F ' & !$ K   ! !!W%&'33'$!-$ F&&@$$ ' ' ! $'$$!!$@!$ !'%& $''"$!$-$!&$ % &@$!K"$$', $-$'+02P6   &$&    ? !  @$ :&!$  '!& + "&!! ' !& '  !N ! & $+"&!F$ , ' &'!!$'G+51$!$   ,   ' &'!!$ ' 5> $= '- $! -$  $'  " & +  &$!&%  '!'! -$$' $ (!'F-!&6  $F$%K"+'&@!'!$-!$'$!  ' !@$6

-'K$ &,' $F'&!!K  !' $!+  !!$, '"$-$'$!&'5 I!5)))G5 1225!+'  ' ! $  !!! ' ! -   ! ' ! -$ + 522P -  '! <'522P:$$>2P=69   ' !$! '$'6

'!  '&    M!   '& + "#9       &!!  !: V51/55=6

  .//0.1223  453.504  

 . 3  "! .  !. .

617   8  9   4% ,') #:

  7 

56 &    -FT

$ 7

16 "'! !$!''$'& !T

G6 $!K  !' $!+ !!$, '"$-$'$!&'5 I!5)))G5  1225!+' ' !T

36 $!K &' !% !$!T

06 @    !$ '  KJ -! @     !    &!  M! '  '&$ ' G2 E  ',  !$@$!$   $ '& ' &  $F @&'&  '   9<\$X <@K$ / /223     ! $ ?$ 6  '&$  ! M!   %&6  &$  '$! N = $'$K  ?!!K'&$$  !'&$ F!$ $!''&$$ !!K&T F= ?    K !$@ $ !$ -$  ''  !! !  '&$$T =  !   $%!    '   &!!6 9$  &$   !$!   ! $ &&! && &  !!  = F= ! = $4'  $F@&'& '  !  !$,    KJ$ '- '&  $ -F6&$ '  !$  ( '  - K$  ! E$! $$ K  '&$$ !!K& ! J- ' K&!&?&'$&  !: !65G152/!52>=6  % @@$, N   &$'!N   (9 & $7     &!$ 4E $!N  

  .//0.1223  450.504   V &'& $K 9   $@ ' &! M!!!$@$&? !$$$K"+"@@$@&'&  ' $ % @@

  .//0.1223