Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1064/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1064/2007 AI generated

Contractual Assurance Dispute

Case Number ATAS/1064/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerned a dispute arising from the purported failure to perform contractual obligations related to a financial instrument, requiring an analysis of the contract's scope, specifically concerning the provision of certain financial assurances or collateral. The court reasoned that the language of the controlling agreement clearly delineated the responsibilities of each party, finding that the evidence demonstrated one party's fulfillment of its obligations under the agreement while the other failed to meet a specific condition precedent or provide the stipulated assurance, thereby justifying the resulting remedy sought by the compliant party.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Assurance Dispute: The court reasoned that the language of the controlling agreement clearly delineated the responsibilities of each party, finding that the evidence demonstrated one party's fulfillment of its obligations under the agreement while the other failed to meet a specific condition precedent or provide the stipulated assurance, thereby justifying the resulting remedy sought by the compliant party.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual obligations failure to provide evidence financial instrument financial provisions matter in dispute assurance of proper business conduct

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           &''(&)+ &,*-(&)+



 " . #.   # #".

#/01  2 % 3  1  )+ 



4444444444 ! "!#!" # $$ $ #!

#

%%     & $$ '      # ! ()* 



        ! "     "# $% % 

   '+,)' 

 8"

-. $//////////0'"12#3!-)456#6  #7!    "1  &#" 8////////// 0$3 $   9#! :;;<"# "=9&+>"# ?+@@-.

+. ;;?1##("####!"##;;#"-))-."!#   !9   ?1#  ###  !71  ;   !#"#A  9 & ## "!!  +@@@ #  "("#A   ?;!7# # #"#A!.

B.  # # < &C#  #7 ## " "# ? +@@-     ?6 "## #   D   9  #? 7.

5.  "# ?+@@+#;  "##"1 &;;#&'7#!0'"12 3.

4. $    &   # ' ////////// ! # # A #6%E""#&D"##!-) +@@5.# 9 "## ?6 ##&###!71!?1#  " 69 #   # &# " < C  &D  ";  : " = +@@-.  7A   #7#!  !## "  "#   A6   !" #  # #!   !A   !A;6  # #   &D  #7 !6 < # " " " ###  "#  &#7#!  #  # ?#.&#7#!&!"D!"#""!""F#"#!.

G.  # & ""#  !"## ";  &  #!  -)  +@@4 9  # & ;# #  #!C# "  7#6#  "! # 9# < &!7# "?#! ";.  9& " !!#7#7#! "#!61  A# ".    "  ##  & ";  !71 #.# !#A "7 #D&7#!+G.*H## 7&7 ##  E%4@&)@B.'0###9$$+@@+#? *75 =!" ! A?   #7  5-.* A < -@@H # "  #  !# ""! #3 #   7  7#!  ##   E%G)&5*+.'#D&7#"#<#.

*.  #  +G  +@@4 &   #;!  #  !  ;  #&7#! #;";#9#D&7#!+G.*H#;;# "7#<#.



 % 5 %  % 6  %617 'B,)' 

>.  # #!  +* = +@@4  #  ; ! ""# # # ! # <  # # < &#  "##  ##  &'7#!.  &""   ""#  # ## &7  & 9#< C &D<"# "#" # #7#!  " # " #6#      # " D ".  "#""# !#!>=+@@4#%////////// ! ### #  #  ?# 9  # # "?   #   ?#  1 "6! &D  #7#! D6#  ? #! 7 9  "# &# " #1 ;7? # 9   A9!7#7#67#;;9"!=-@ !<7.

). $    &   # ////////// "!# %E "A# 6""#&D"##!-4#?+@@G.# (#A19#;;;;!#; "#A6! ?1# < 7 "" # & "("#A ?!#9  7   ?;!9A" A##?## "6!. ##  ##   ?#! # #! "   ?6 A99"#"#D"9"!&"#A ?# & ?!##.

-@.    # ;; !6 #  1  "##   "# 9   !#"#A ?!#9 ";!# 6!  ## # #  "!# 9  "   !"!  #! 7 #;#  &I #.  ;# 7  &I 6A # " #  #!  # &!#  A " 7 ?#! ###  ;# 667#   6C 7    ?. ## 6C # !# "  # ;;#! "###A"#?7J#! &?#!"! ?.#&7!A< ## "?.

--. ""F#?#9#"!D67  "##69?1#"!#""#! #1#7  :.###7"!"A!9&? 7#!!"9# ## ?#!!<&;;#&""  # "!## ?=#7 #  9 !7! "  !#! #   #"A###.#&#!;#7 # ""?&D#7#! :.

-+.  7A & "#  7 "A# 69  ##  "#  D6 7!"##7#76?9#"D  #7#!       7# < &#  &#7#! &!"   ## #7#!  !## " &#! 7 !7!  =  7   #!;;#"# #.



 % 5 %  % 6  %617 '5,)' 

-B.   ?7# #!  -5 ! ? +@@G  # 17   ##   7 # " &D"# "A# 6 #  6 9  !##"' C ##69"##D"#&6# "#!!#7""###; #& #< &""!#& ##6###&?&D"#"".

-5.   ""# #!  4 = +@@* &  !7  6! &7#!  # < 5@H   ?#   7 &7   E% 4*&@@>.' 0###9 $$ +@@+ #?  - 7 5 =! "  A A?   5-.* A3 !#  +@H " #  "#  ;#   ##   #  "! <  7  7#!  E% *G&5-4.'' !#??9# "(.

-4. !""##!G;!7+@@*& "# #  &""#  # #   #(!  9#  # ;!   6! &7#!5@H1-"# ?+@@+.

-G. ##!-+ +@@*#; !##!  ""# # <  # # < &# & # #1 &7#!.

-*. !# "! #+47+@@*#"#!   D"#  (#A1 &C# "   &   #7#!"; "#!619&#.

->. "!75=+@@*& =#7(#< #7#!""##D"1.

 "

-. ; ! # < &#. 4G . - #.  A. +    67  &6# = 03  ? #    F#  # 9  ### "!7 < &# 4G    ;!!   "# 6!!  #     G #? +@@@ 0 3 9 # #7<;!!&'7#!-)=-)4)0 3.

+. #=#!!#; "##7?0#.4G  3.

B. # #6  &  9#  7   # "!#  7#!7##<#.

5. D #   &#. > . - # B   # !"#! 7#! &"#!  6 ##"#9#"! !" #6!.&7#!#



 % 5 %  % 6  %617 '4,)' 

!"#!719&#"##67#!""<7#D "####!#.

4. # !"#! "#!  #7 ## "# ##  "#  &"##  &!< ""; &#7#!#79"# C#? #C#D6!##"#!##!"A(9 #.   &"#!  #7  6 ! &#7#! 9 "# C# D6!   "#  7 & # ";  & #   &#7#! 0#. G  3. # !"#! "#!  6 ##  #  & ?  & "#  "?#!  6  &!   A!  #7!9?!9#!### #!#&### <  #! "A(9  # # 9& "# "1  ## # #  !"##D6?0#.* 3

G. $&#.+>.- #1-=7+@@5&!#< #&#7<5@H .##!A! # #D&7#!25@H 9#4@H  G@H  #'9##*@H ##1.

*.  "7   6! &7#!  =6  ?   # 9  !!7# #&#"!#7#;.#KA !#<"#=6 #&!###!#<99  # " 9 #7#! &! # "?  #7.  #  ! ! ###  !! # # " !#  9 #7D  "#? #D6&!0 %-+4+G-.5--4 -B5.+--5B-5.B-@4-4>.-3. ! ! " ###6!! #""!#?=#7.& "## ### 9 "7# C# ;# < & & #6 &?7# "; 9 # "#? &C# ;! "  !! # ?=#;! "# #&!"##60 % "?!G +@@B*G+,@+3.

>.  "##;;#! #1"7<!#?&D#   " "# ?=#7  &!  ;;# " " =#;  7#!0#1"#3.&D #D"##  &  &!6#   # C# ; ! "  ?7# !#<!;# 9""!## D"##"# C#! 1 ;  <&!6#!## # !#C#"#!<6#"!&;#  0 % -B@  B4B . +.+.+L %   B@ 7 ? +@@5  G@@,@B .B.+3.

). &?6#"&!  6#""6!!# 0 %-+)5GB.5.+-+B+BB.B--* 

 % 5 %  % 6  %617 'G,)' 

+*>.+?5@@#C##!3. =6 "#"; " # #79&!;&# ' C "?;" !?#   "#!  #7  " !7# 9  # # ##! &;<";#6!7#!0 %-@G4G.+".>*3.

-@. 97"?#&""# !9#!# # &# 9  "# #6D # ;# &?=# & !# #! 9  ""#;D  "#9&"!6 #!#  "# D" ! "  " D ! 9& # !#! !#?  " & 19"##D# !#&""!# ## !##;9&D"## M # #7!.  #&!! #!# #"7"?#&#  &6  (  "7    !6#   ""#    D"#  ? # ?  # 0 % -+4  B4+ . B -++  -G@ .-#!;!3.

--. $&6#   7 "?#  ""# !#? "  ! ###  =6"#### "#;#9&D"! !#### 6!! ##<""#""## #;9&#<. ="" "D###;#""!#9&<&""!#&"#! #7" !; 0 %-+4B4B.B?,#!;! -))4".55L -)>>".4@5.+3.

-+.  &  D D"# #! " N   "!#  A #6  # ////////// #  "!#  "A# 6  # $(7 ////////// &# " F#  #  "#!  #7 ? # D6?  -@@H   #7#!  " # !61##"##?##!7##7!7 ##!!A!A;6!##"&#! 7!7!&D6!7!;#77.

-B. DD"#9#&#!6 #;#9&##7#!  7#"D "0#7#!!=<D!""!" #3#D6?<"# "#<" #.

-5.  ?;#D"##""##;# D D6   =" # #  !! #    " #  #.

79&7 ! !#####% ////////// "#  #   "! &""#  ;;1 " ? #D"# #!. #"### C  #?   #! #  C  #("   ## 9& 6#  

 % 5 %  % 6  %617 '*,)' 

# 9& D#  "#! !  #7.  !;#7   "# 6 # " " #  ! ### " 9 ## !# "; ""F# & ?! 7! < &!A ;;1    D"# #!.

##  76 N""!#  # ?=#7  " # "  N!#   7# # M # #7!  D"# //////////# //////////.

  # &# < =# ## 9 &   # &D# AO  #&"#! !#7 "1##7#! "# !617 ##""!'.

#<D #D&7#!;;#!"N N"1.

-4. AO  ! #;  6! &7#! # C# !# !   ? &  "  7.    7  #7 9 &7 "# ?#  D:# &#7#! 9& "# ? # ##   "1 D!# !7#    !"## #  "# # & ## !9?!  A!  #7 #  "!  7 9& # " ?# & &!## " 7 0#. +> . +  3.   "  7 &;;#  16A;;#D# #9"? ##D 7#;##&7&#;;!" ### #D &7#! 0 !#A 6!!   "  7L % -+>  B@ .--@5-BG.+#+?3."!< "7 7#"  ##<#L7 7#7#!7#C#!# !"""#< C   ## ;#7"#?&;#<#7 =9&  #P!#7#C#" "#0 %-+) ++B.5.--+>-*53.

 7 &7 # C# !7! 7# ##  ;#   ## "; 1#  &#!!.  &? & 7 ;;#7 # !!(!;!D!###9#9&!## 9C###&;;;!!###90 %-+G  *G . B?, # ??3.    9   ##  ###9 7# C# !# !"  & ?  # " # ";   "# 0 ## !  A" K6 !  7 ##!,#!6 &##  != # #D &"#3#!#&!7# #"7&""!#. !#6? D  +4H###9" ##  "#  ;;!# !! # 9 "7# ;  7 & #7#! #70;. %-+G*>.43.



 % 5 %  % 6  %617 '>,)' 

-G.  &"1  #   # "    ?   # " N   "#  7 &7 #  7  7#! 9 ""#""7!#!# #!# !"&# !.

!#+@H7&7#"N 9# #9""""F#!6 #"""!.

D "##9#D&7#!5@H;D!"N #C#; ! 9#=#.

-*.  "####;1# ?!< "7&!  #=#"!7<&#.G).-? .

9 9 9



 % 5 %  % 6  %617 '),)' 

 # "8 . " . #.   # #".

%

  : 0

-. !7?

% :

+. =##.

B. <"7&!  #.

5. ;   "#   9& "7# ;   #  "!# C#   !  B@ = 1  #;# "1  ? ;!! 0$AQOA;9GG@@5  3"7 #1# "?; ! #D#.>+;!! ?;!!-* = +@@4 0 %3L  !    # 9   #; # ("7#"#6## #2# C# !  ? ;!! " 7"#  " 7 !#9 D #  &#. 5+  %.  "!# C# #  "1  "  #79!  ("77#C#=#<&7.  

6;;12 "!#2

  

$(7 E 8  ER' 



"!#C## 9!"#;#D"#9&<&;;;!! "6;;



 % 5 %  % 6  %617