Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1023/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1023/2007 AI generated

Statutory Fee Applicability on Asset Transfer Substance Over Form

Case Number ATAS/1023/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The action arose from a dispute concerning the applicability of specific statutory provisions regarding the payment of a particular charge or fee upon the transfer of certain assets, where the court had to determine whether the transaction met the statutory threshold for triggering the obligation. The court reasoned that the statutory language, focusing on the nature and effect of the transfer rather than merely its form, indicated that the transaction, despite its structure, constituted a transfer within the scope of the relevant legislation, thus affirming the imposition of the charge based on the legislative intent to capture such economic realities.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Fee Applicability on Asset Transfer Substance Over Form: The court reasoned that the statutory language, focusing on the nature and effect of the transfer rather than merely its form, indicated that the transaction, despite its structure, constituted a transfer within the scope of the relevant legislation, thus affirming the imposition of the charge based on the legislative intent to capture such economic realities.

Keywords

AI generated
transfer of assets payment of fee scope of the legislation statutory purchase right financial legislation exchange transaction

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was applied to rule on the court costs of the proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



           %&'&%())& *%+)(,%())&

!*

 *  * ! !  !

-  ( $ (. /-  ())& 

   !"#$% &'( ''( )!(   *!(+(', -  ./ '!



('

   ,, - /012"34 &( ( ! "#55"#"" 



               ! " #$   $

   /#6%/  

! ! 0 *

8 /&'9''(:*( ' (;<=( &'>  (!&'!)&' ?.*@A ! /'B"? ( #$$%4

* ('( *&  (&' ' (  !(!  ('  ,  , ,,  ,8 /&'9, :(''("'C(#$$% B" ? ( #$$D !(( &'! ! .  ''( * (') ! &'  ')  (  ('/*&9  ,/."'A!)' '#$$DB"? (#$$D ( &(D 4

''(!&!"' C(#$$D*  (!;<= &'9*   ,, - 8 /&'9* ( !:4

&'!  "EC(#$$D* ( ! A'!''(.**) ( &' (F  (!;<=4

  ''(  A'! && (    !  !=F '&&( ) ' !(! ' !() '( !@*'/;<=&(1 4

&'!  #5?) '#$$7* ( !'?(!&& ( A( '  '' '  ,'!(' ( *(( @ *!  8 /&'9 , : '! F    ;<=  "% &(G' #$$% F (' . H&' &(' &!' ( ( (  )' '' (@*  (! A(!('' *F ( * ( ) (! AA( )   @ ( ( H4 . * ( ! (( ( .''(*) ('! (!(') !.'(D (&) (9' ?( A '*&!' 1 *( ) (!AA( )4

   ''  #3 A!)' ' #$$7  ''( ((  & (  )  !'(. '&'>!(( @( (  ( '( )@ '!     ( (   1   /   (  != '.  / ( 9 ' '& 4 .* ( @ *(    !   ( @ *('    (!*'/;<=& "'C(#$$D4

'!&7'#$$7* ( ! ( 4

 &' ''I(  (  #$ ' #$$7  ' G  !  ((! .  ''I(#7A!)' '#$$7'(*!((A (!( (((& ( GG*&9(((('') (A (*G?(*&&&'9  ' GA!!'8 /&'9 0:(&* (?.*@' ( ((& (4

 &' ''I(  "7 C( #$$7  0  !  ?=(  ' G  ! '& (4



67376#$$7  /B6%/   *    AA(  !'! .  ('( &! &' *(( )  &'  ;<=  &'!( ( &  '(!' ( . * ('(  (')  )( . /  (==!&'') (  ('(.* *2) (&' *&2'4.&'!( (  (((*G( '& (.'( (( (((  '!!'(  . *((   )' (  F ='  A' (' * (') *&&'( (G &@&'(( *  .*@ ')'!  ('&'(  * &'((   (')   '( . (( &!'  *(((  &) (I('&'  !'( ( ('*( ) (! @( ( 4

 &' '  "# &(G' #$$7  ' G  !  '!  '&'   * (   .! @  ''( &   *''I(  0 ( * A'! .*@ !A(  ''. *    #3 &(G'   ' ( ='! @ ?='4

 &' '' '  "E &(G' #$$7  ''(   .! * '&&'(' @ ?( '(.!(!='!@?='J

 !* !  *

 ' G(&!((( 9'8'(J%DJ"(J;J3:4

''(')G@A'8'(J%D(D$ :4

 ( =&'('' (''(@*  (!;<=@&(' "'C(#$$D4

 * '&&'  '9= !=  )(K L'!  ' ( @ L  (!  ;<=((L (& &'( (& 8'(J3J" (J :J('!&(!&  . L(&&'( @'&&'((')  (. ;';@F''( ) (!@& (&8'(J"$J" :J' (@ L  (!  ;<= && .   (  '( ) @  &!'   ( ( ('! !.L'!( G!'!8'(J3J"(J :J F ('  *'(J "B J "   ('  ) =' 9  "' ? ( #$$B   .    (! /'&'!)@(AA(8'(J5JB:F'!'(1   ( ) (! @( ( '& ( ( '( )@ &!' ( ( 4

'' ', &'!) (.  (K H  ( A ( *'(JE"*''*'/;<= 8 :   (( F '!  &  %$  *=((   G' *  (!(@(F;<=!)!9) A'!



67376#$$7  /E6%/   ; ('('((') (&' ')&'A   ' (J  )(  &'!) (  )'( *  ' (  & (  ( (  &'((.G!!A   'A' (('/ &'((   (')   ((( ' &( '!   &  (&' ' G)( !J &'9 F (  )' !;=  '' ' )  (' (! =) ) ) (@&'' ' )(J

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

 &'  '   ''I(  "7 C( #$$7 (' (( *   (( & ( GG*&9 0 !'!.9'.'(! /' '( A @  &!'   ( (   &'  ;<= *) ( AA( )( (') !&'') (  ('.'(&!'  A!' '@1    '&  ( &   (  &'!) &' *'(J "B J "   ( . & &'( (A (.&' ('> '(.( (  (!(! !=(! ( '&(&!' (') AA( A4

A'( ' G'!A!''@(''I(('.''(/ .   (') ! &'  , '( D   /  &( ?( A ' * &!'   1 *( ) (!AA( )(*&' (F  (!*'/ ;<=4

* '' (I(''?(!J









67376#$$7  /%6%/    ! * 0 ! *  * ! !  !

$

  12-

"J !'''')GJ

$ 12

#J '?((J

BJ  (.&'!'(='( (J

EJ A'  &'(    .L &)( A'' '' ('  &'!( ''I(   !   B$ ?' 9  ( A (  &'9  ' G A!!' 8,;M 1';A. DD$$E  :&') ''( 9'' ( &G A'!(F'(J3# A!!'' ' GA!!'"7 ?  #$$% 8 0:4  ! '  ''  (  .'    ( A ( 2&')(&'(' =('''(( '4  ( I(' '!  ' G A!!' &' )  &(  &' )  !(' . F  (   *'(J E#  0J  &'!( ''I( (  & 9  &   ''( ).!2&') )(I('? (@*) J  ='AA 9'  &'! (       NO P   G,   

 &  A'  &'!( ''I( ( ( A ! F &'(     .L ,'!(' ( *((@*! &'='AA



67376#$$7