Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/1021/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/1021/2004 AI generated

Offer Revocation Preceding Settlement Acceptance Validity

Case Number ATAS/1021/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case addresses whether a claimant who accepted a settlement offer prior to the expiration of a formal procedural deadline, but after the opposing party had communicated an intention to withdraw that offer, is entitled to the payment under the terms of the settlement. The court reasoned that because the acceptance was communicated after the offeror had clearly manifested an intent to revoke, the offer was legally terminated before acceptance, rendering the purported acceptance ineffective and preventing the formation of a binding contract based on the settlement proposal.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Offer Revocation Preceding Settlement Acceptance Validity: The court reasoned that because the acceptance was communicated after the offeror had clearly manifested an intent to revoke, the offer was legally terminated before acceptance, rendering the purported acceptance ineffective and preventing the formation of a binding contract based on the settlement proposal.

Keywords

AI generated
acceptance of offer termination of a contract deadline for payment revocation of settlement permit settlement of dispute delivery of possession by agreement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used to reject the appeal as inadmissible, which is the main order.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs for the federal proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$%&#%''( #)'%)#%''(



 *+ + +  *+  

(,  -.   / -  %''( 



   0000000000 



11 + +  2   ! "#$ $$#" %$&%&$'()'

       

         !"

   &,*0&  

+ 1

12 %"$$%-.!#3,..-455$" $%!#6$&!)7 !" 8 4 % 9%# ::::::::::  !$ % %$ 8 4$%#$"%;<# !%"%$=>2 %"$$"$#$'" !  5$ = 4"  4"$ ! !"" 8 4$ % <  ,, !#3##!"'#$#,+!#3,..-2

,2 4$""5#""#$,,%"#3,..-5$'$=4"$ ?%#%$>=48;#-.'#3,..-2

-2  %"$$ % ,+ # ,../ 455$  % 4#!$ 6$&!) 4 7  %"" "#$$'3!%%$'" #$'=" >$5$!$$%%"$2

/2 %"#$@ 55% $3%"/#$,../4" $>"2 ) =4"$$?%#%$$ %#!$$2 5$'$=4"$!33"!"%" 4!$'#$%4!%"=4%'$!" !!5$!!$$2 !!"=44'$##$ #=#;#$$&$%A8%$$%"!%%'"2

02 "!%-!#3,../4 >%' =4"'$!$3$$"%5$!"!!2

(2 %  %$ % #!$ ! !  $3 % "  1 %"#3,../4"%""=4'$#$!""$%4 =4"$'$=4%'$!"!!5$ !!$$2  4 =4 %"#3 ,..- =4 '$ !!$ =4 $ ! ; $%5$2

B2 "" %"8> 2





+ * 

12 $ '$4 $$>%$$$67""#%$5$"$$"%) 1A,..- $3%$#!"%0>  %  !"$%   '$&!"$% 0 !!"  1( >   62 1 20( 72



*+,-*,../  &-*0&   C$84$%4"$%1(> ! $35"%" ,B>'$,../6 D1-.1.(7% $ '$%!"1-5"'$  %$!$$$$ !# $3% $ % $"    8 $ >  $$  % 4 % 4"$%'E> 2

,2  $3  %  $ F  $ $= % $ $' 8  $ 5"%"  4 ;<#  3$ $  4$%#$"%4$'3$$"& 60(72

C#!"!> %%4!)$$"3$2

-2 $5"%"!$ ""%%$%$%(3 ,...6 7 "  '$  1 >'$ ,..- F  #%$5$$ % #3 %$!$$ "  %  %#$ %  $2 C %$!$$4!!$=8 5%" $E!62121 72

5#"#E20(21(.21 %"$$!!$$ !$3 %  %  %"$ % -. > $'  $5$$ %  %"$$>82 #!%5$=%"$ ! %B)# >'G=B)#>!)G=$$'#=G="$ %$1,'$,../@/#$,../%"$$!!$$ $5$",+#,../'32

/2 C4$0,21 %"$$!'?="% >!'$%4!!$$!)%4=$%84E!$% %"$$%4%#%!"%2421.%4%!$ ""%%$%$%11!#3,..,6 7" '$ 1>'$,..-!"$=4!!$$%$$%$ ?#$'"2 %$?5#"!$$!!"$%H! ? 5#" # 4% !"'$ = 4 $  4!!$$ %!)&'3$ "!4!!!"" 2

 4!)  %"$$ % -. !#3 ,..- #$$ $# = 4!!$$%'$?5#"!"$!)% !"#$%455$  % 4#!$ %  %"$ % -. >2     5#" !!$$  ,, %"#3 ,..- # $ ! % %E #$ !)  %"$$2

 $3 % " !! =4 %"$ "   ! ? ! " 6$ /. 21 !!$3! $'%4$(.2, 72 55  "$" % %$ E$  = $  I $#   I  !$!?#!$!"$!%#!J#$$#$ E !$3$$" % $ %  #$) =  !$ ; ' $%=4=$43>%!"%%"5$$$'#"5



*+,-*,../  &/*0&   6$9$%#$$$5'1++1!21K172$$% %"$ ! !% ? %" % #$) E!$ 8 %$$ =  #%$$""#!?;"5%4 $%%"$5$E"  !  =4 %#% % $$ #$'" $%$=   % 4#!?;# $ "" !"" %  %$E > 8 #! % $ H 4#!?;#"6$/121 72F4#$%$'$ ""E""%#?#%"$24 $&8%%$!$$$#!"$'E= $  ! ? %" " 6$!% % $" %#$$$' %  5"%"$L M(.*1++($%202/!2-(BN D11+KB$%2,N D 11,,0($%2,72 !$%%5#>= "'"# E%$$  $#!"'$$3 '  %; %  !;) %4$'$" % 4$""  4$#! 8 $ % 5@ $"$$3 6 2 O  ;P$Q$;3$ $;+)#"%2,...!2,,+72

 4!)   F &#?# '$ #   %"$$ % -. !#3 ,..-    =4 "$ !%" %'$  !" !#!5$!!$$24"$$%"$$"$E!$$ !$2

  # $'=" !    $ >$5$  $$ % %"$%42/12 2









RRR











*+,-*,../  &0*0&   *  1  *+ + +  *+  

 -343   5  633 3  2" )7%  

  43 

12 @$N

 43

,2 >N

-2 $=!"% $N

/2 5#  !$ %  =4 !' 5#    !" ? %  %"$ % -. > %)  $5$$ ! !$ ##%" %"  $3 5"%" %  C;P$Q;5=$ ( (../     $ E#!$2  %"$  ! ? ! "2  #"#$ %$J 7 $%$= E#=%"$$%"$3$$!%%"$$ ="N 37 E! ! = #$5 $ $# !'$ %#%   %"$$N 7 !  $    %  !"2 C$  #"#$  $ !  $ ""# "#""   7 37  7 $&%  $35"%"%!!#$)=4$ %'%"$'32#"#$%#$#S % !' =$  >$ $$ =  %"$$ ="  4'!! % =""E!"%$"621-,1.(1.K72   55$J  "$%J   T$%  9  $               

 !$5#% !" ?$5$"E!$C"$%4 8 4"#$! 55



*+,-*,../