Legislator Case Law & Legislation
720.18.202.39 • KG BL 720.18.202.39 AI generated

Recusal of Expert Institution and Appointed Expert Denied Due to Lack of Demonstrated Bias

Case Number 720.18.202.39
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Basel-Landschaft (CH-BL)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs Borne by appellant

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court addressed a request to recuse an expert assessment institution and its appointed expert, based on the insured's assertion that the selection process via a specific platform was flawed and that the appointed expert had previously ruled against him. The court found that the insured failed to demonstrate that the institution or the expert were biased or that the selection process through the platform was inherently problematic. Since no concrete evidence of prejudice was presented and the platform's use was permissible, the recusal request was denied.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Recusal of Expert Institution and Appointed Expert Denied Due to Lack of Demonstrated Bias: The court found that the insured failed to demonstrate that the institution or the expert were biased or that the selection process through the platform was inherently problematic. Since no concrete evidence of prejudice was presented and the platform's use was permissible, the recusal request was denied.

Keywords

AI generated
selection of expert assessment of evidence untimely recusal request judicial bias legitimate suspicion of bias expert witness compensation Gutachten
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Entscheid des Kantonsgerichts Basel-Landschaft, Abteilung Sozialversicherungsrecht

vom 13. Februar 2019 (720 18 202 / 39) ____________________________________________________________________

Invalidenversicherung

Wahl der Gutachterstelle über die Plattform SuisseMED@P; Ausstandsbegehren gegen Institution und Gutachter

Besetzung Präsidentin Eva Meuli, Gerichtsschreiberin Christina Markiewicz

Parteien A.____, Beschwerdeführer, vertreten durch Dr. Michael Kull, Advokat, Marktplatz 18, 4001 Basel

gegen

IV-Stelle Basel-Landschaft, Hauptstrasse 109, 4102 Binningen, Beschwerdegegnerin

Betreff Gutachten

A. Der 1971 geborene A.____ bezog ab 1. März 2003 zunächst eine halbe und mit Wirkung ab 1. Januar 2004 eine Dreiviertelsrente. Am 12. Februar 2012 leitete die IV-Stelle Basel- Landschaft ein Revisionsverfahren von Amtes wegen ein. Gestützt auf das Gutachten der Ärztlichen Begutachtungsinstitut GmbH (ABI) vom 19. März 2013 hob die IV-Stelle die Invalidenrente bei einem IV-Grad von 8 % mit Verfügung vom 23. September 2013 auf. Am 18. Dezember 2013 meldete sich A.____ bei der IV-Stelle erneut zum Bezug einer Invalidenrente an. Die IV- Stelle kam zum Schluss, dass eine erhebliche Veränderung des Gesundheitszustandes mit den