Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ECLI:BE:CASS:2022:CONC.20221024.3F.3 ECLI:BE:CASS:2022:CONC.20221024.3F.3 AI generated

Court of Cassation clarifies that a defect exists if a characteristic makes damage possible in certain circumstances.

Case Number ECLI:BE:CASS:2022:CONC.20221024.3F.3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Belgium (BE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Cassation upheld the lower court's finding that a defect exists when an abnormal characteristic creates a risk of damage. The applicant argued that the property's condition constituted a vice under Article 1384 of the Civil Code, while the opposing party contested the severity of the anomaly. The court affirmed that judicial fact-finding is valid provided it aligns with the legal definition of a defect enabling potential harm.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Article 1384, al. 1er du Code Civil: A defect is established when a characteristic abnormality renders the thing susceptible to causing damage in certain circumstances, and the judge's factual appreciation must not violate this legal notion.

Keywords

AI generated
defect of the thing non-contractual liability obligation to repair abnormal characteristic risk of damage judicial fact-finding Civil Code Article 1384

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Article 1384, al. 1er of the Civil Code of 21 March 1804
Thésaurus Cassation: RESPONSABILITE HORS CONTRAT - OBLIGATION DE REPARER - Choses Mots libres: Vice de la chose - Notion Bases légales: ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 1384, al.
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Fiche 1 Une chose est affectée d'un vice lorsqu'elle présente une caractéristique anormale qui la rend, en certaines circonstances, susceptible de causer un dommage (1). (1) Voir les concl. du MP. Thésaurus Cassation: RESPONSABILITE HORS CONTRAT - OBLIGATION DE REPARER - Choses Mots libres: Vice de la chose - Notion Bases légales: ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 1384, al. 1er - 30 Lien ELI No pub 1804032150

Fiche 2 Le juge apprécie en fait l'existence d'un vice de la chose, pour autant qu'il ne viole pas la notion légale de vice (1). (1) Voir les concl. du MP. Thésaurus Cassation: RESPONSABILITE HORS CONTRAT - OBLIGATION DE REPARER - Choses Mots libres: Vice de la chose - Contrôle par la Cour de cassation Bases légales: ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 1384, al. 1er - 30 Lien ELI No pub 1804032150