Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ECLI:BE:CASS:2020:CONC.20200819.VAC.1 ECLI:BE:CASS:2020:CONC.20200819.VAC.1 AI generated

Belgian court rules pandemic cannot justify denying suspended sentence time credit to prisoners.

Case Number ECLI:BE:CASS:2020:CONC.20200819.VAC.1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Belgium (BE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Cassation upheld the conviction that prisoners granted a suspended sentence execution break must receive credit for that time. The government argued the COVID-19 pandemic necessitated keeping inmates in isolation to prevent virus spread, but the court rejected this as a valid justification. The decision establishes that the objective and reasonable justification required for suspending sentence execution cannot be met by the pandemic alone.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Constitutional Articles 10 and 11; Royal Decree No. 3 of 9 April 2020, Article 6, Section 1: The necessity of combating the spread of COVID-19 cannot justify depriving prisoners of suspended sentence execution breaks of the time credit for that interruption.

Keywords

AI generated
suspended sentence execution time credit imputation COVID-19 pandemic justification proportionality principle prison isolation measures

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Constitutional Articles 10 and 11
La Constitution coordonnée 1994 - 17-02-1994 - Art. 10 et 11 - 30
Royal Decree No. 3 of 9 April 2020, Article 6, Section 1
n° 3 du 9 avril 2020 - 3 - 09-04-2020 - Art. 6, § 1er et 2 - 02

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Fiches 1 - 2

Les nécessités de la lutte contre la propagation de la covid 19 na sauraient

justifier que les condamnés à qui est octroyée l'interruption

de l'exécution de la peine dont ils doivent respecter les conditions,

soient privés de l'imputation de la durée de cette interruption

sur l'exécution de leur peine (1). (1) Voir les concl. du MP.

Thésaurus Cassation:

APPLICATION DES PEINES

Mots libres:

A.R. n° 3 du 9 avril 2020, article 6, § 1er - Interruption de l’exécution

de la peine - Effet suspensif - Justification objective et raisonnable

par rapport au but en aux effets de la mesure - Application

Bases légales:

La Constitution coordonnée 1994 - 17-02-1994 - Art. 10 et 11 - 30

Lien ELI No pub 1994021048

A.R. n° 3 du 9 avril 2020 - 3 - 09-04-2020 - Art. 6, § 1er et 2 - 02

Lien ELI No pub 2020030582

Thésaurus Cassation:

LOIS. DECRETS. ORDONNANCES. ARRETES - LEGALITE DES ARRETES ET REGLEMENTS

Mots libres:

A.R. n° 3 du 9 avril 2020, article 6, § 1er - Interruption de l’exécution

de la peine - Effet suspensif - Justification objective et raisonnable

par rapport au but en aux effets de la mesure - Application

Bases légales:

La Constitution coordonnée 1994 - 17-02-1994 - Art. 10 et 11 - 30

Lien ELI No pub 1994021048

A.R. n° 3 du 9 avril 2020 - 3 - 09-04-2020 - Art. 6, § 1er et 2 - 02

Lien ELI No pub 2020030582

Annotations

Publications:

Nieuw Juridisch Weekblad [NJW] - 2021, nr. 435, p. 71-73. - DE SMEDT,

Jente; VILAIN, Ruben; Noot'Onderbreking strafuitvoering in Corona-KB

schendt gelijkheidsbeginsel'