Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ECLI:BE:CASS:2019:CONC.20190411.1 ECLI:BE:CASS:2019:CONC.20190411.1 AI generated

Revocation of donation for ingratitude is ineffective against a third party holding a prior legal mortgage.

Case Number ECLI:BE:CASS:2019:CONC.20190411.1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Belgium (BE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Cassation dismissed the request to revoke a donation for ingratitude, ruling that the revocation is ineffective against a third party who holds a legal mortgage on the donated property. The donor argued for revocation due to ingratitude, but the third party's mortgage inscription predated the revocation request. The court held that the revocation cannot impair rights already acquired by bona fide third parties with prior security interests.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Articles 918, paragraph 1, and 30 of the Civil Code of 21 March 1804: The revocation of a donation for ingratitude has no effect against a third party who holds a legal mortgage on the donated object if the mortgage inscription predates the request for revocation.

Keywords

AI generated
donation revocation legal mortgage third party rights cause of ingratitude prior inscription bona fide acquisition Civil Code 1804

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Articles 918, paragraph 1, and 30 of the Civil Code of 21 March 1804
ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 918, al.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Fiches 1 - 2

La révocation pour cause d'ingratitude est sans effet à l'égard

d'un tiers qui dispose d'une hypothèque légale sur l'objet

de la donation dont l'inscription est antérieure à celle de la

demande de révocation (1). (1) Voy. les concl. du MP.

Thésaurus Cassation:

DONATIONS ET TESTAMENTS

Mots libres:

Donation - Révocation - Effets - Droits des tiers - Hypothèque - Hypothèque

légale

Bases légales:

ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 918, al. 1er - 30

Lien ELI No pub 1804032150

Thésaurus Cassation:

HYPOTHEQUE

Mots libres:

Hypothèque légale - Immeuble acquis par donation - Révocation - Effets

Bases légales:

ancien Code Civil - 21-03-1804 - Art. 918, al. 1er - 30

Lien ELI No pub 1804032150

Annotations

Publications:

Revue de Jurisprudence de Liège, Mons et Bruxelles [JLMB] - 2019, n°

35, p. 1647-1654. - MOREAU, Pierre; Note'Le sort de l'hypothèque

légale grevant l'immeuble donné en cas de révocation de la donation

pour cause d'ingratitude'