Legislator European & Swiss Legal Corpus
Încheierea nr. 4048/2013 Dismissed AI-structured

Încheierea nr. 4048/2013 — Dismissal of case transfer request as moot due to prior final resolution of the underlying dispute

Case Number Încheierea nr. 4048/2013 (ICCJ_99862)
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Jurisdiction Romania — Case Law (RO)

Decision Summary (Facts, Holding & Outcome)

AI-structured

The High Court of Cassation and Justice dismissed the petition for the transfer of the case, ruling that the application had become moot and leaving the original jurisdiction in force. The dispute involved a request to transfer Case No. 31531/299/2011 from the Bucharest Court of Appeal to another court; however, the respondent and the Public Ministry argued for dismissal because the electronic court registry indicated the underlying case had already been resolved on July 1, 2013. The court relied on the procedural doctrine that a motion for transfer (strămutare) is without object if the underlying proceedings have been finally decided, thereby rendering the request for reassignment unnecessary.

Headnote / Official Regeste

AI-structured
The High Court of Cassation and Justice dismissed the petition for the transfer of the case, ruling that the application had become moot and leaving the original jurisdiction in force. The dispute involved a request to transfer Case No. 31531/299/2011 from the Bucharest Court of Appeal to another court; however, the respondent and the Public Ministry argued for dismissal because the electronic court registry indicated the underlying case had already been resolved on July 1, 2013. The court relied on the procedural doctrine that a motion for transfer (strămutare) is without object if the underlying proceedings have been finally decided, thereby rendering the request for reassignment unnecessary.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment — Încheierea nr. 4048/2013

Procedura de citare este legal îndeplinită.

Se referă de magistratul asistent asupra faptului că, potrivit programului de evidentă informatizată a instanțelor, dosarul a cărui strămutare se solicită a fost soluționat la 1 iulie 2013.

Intimatul solicită respingerea cererii de strămutare.

Reprezentanta Ministerului Public solicită respingerea cererii de strămutare, ca rămasă fără obiect.

Analizând cererea,

ÎN NUMELE LEGII

D I S P U N E

Respinge cererea formulată de petentul M.G. privind strămutarea pricinii care face obiectul Dosarului nr. 31531/299/2011 al Tribunalului București.

Fără cale de atac.

Pronunțată în ședință publică, astăzi 26 septembrie 2013.