Police data access request dismissed as shielding third-party privacy is impossible without losing all relevant information.
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe Council of State upheld the lower court's dismissal of the appellant's request for access to police registration data. The police chief refused access citing the need to protect third-party rights under Article 27 of the Police Data Act, arguing that redaction would render the data useless. The court agreed, noting that while the appellant's right to know is not unlimited, complete shielding of third-party privacy in this case would eliminate all relevant information, making the request inadmissible.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArticle 27, first paragraph, sub-item d of the Police Data Act; Article 8:29 of the General Administrative Law Act: The right to access police data is not absolute and may be restricted when shielding third-party privacy is necessary, provided that redaction does not result in the loss of all relevant information.