Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
Ordinanza — n. 8465/2024 — snpen KI-generiert

Cassation Court dismisses appeal for inadmissibility due to lack of new evidence and attempt to re-evaluate facts.

Geschäftsnummer Ordinanza — n. 8465/2024 — snpen
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Italien (IT)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Nichteintreten / Unzulässig (Inadmissible)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The Court of Cassation declared the appeal by Berisha Patrik inadmissible, ordering him to pay court costs and a fine. The appellant argued that the lower court failed to conduct a unified evaluation of his community service periods, citing isolated incidents instead. The Court rejected this claim as manifestly unfounded, noting the trial judge had already provided a coherent and adequate response to all cited violations in the original decision. Consequently, the court ruled that the new arguments merely sought an alternative reading of existing evidence, which is not permitted at this stage.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 54 ord. pen.; The Court of Cassation holds that an appeal based on alleged violations of the unified evaluation of past community service periods is inadmissible if the lower court's reasoning already comprehensively addressed the cited violations without requiring a new factual assessment.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
inadmissibility appeal unified evaluation periods community service release re-evaluation of facts court costs and fine Nachfürsorge Eingliederungserfolg strafrechtliche Rehabilitation

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
Art. 54 ord. pen.
Rilevato che con il ricorso e con la memoria contenuta nella pec pervenuta il 2/2/24 si deduce la violazione di legge e il vizio di motivazione in relazione all'art. 54 ord.

Zitierte Rechtsprechung

KI-generiert
Sez. 3, n. 17395 del 24/01/2023, Chen Wenjian
Sez. 3, n. 17395 del 24/01/2023, Chen Wenjian, Rv.
Sez. 6, n. 5465 del 04/11/2020, F.
Sez. 2, n. 19411 del 12/03/2019, Furlan
2021, F., Rv 280601; Sez. 2, n. 19411 del 12/03/2019, Furlan, Rv.
Sez. 2, n. 7986 del 18/11/2016, La Gumina
KI-generiert
Sentenza — n. 17505/2022 — snpen
Italian Court dismisses appeal against early release denial due to severe drug violation negating reintegration progress.
Sentenza — n. 10311/2022 — snpen
Cassation court dismisses appeal against prison release denial due to disciplinary misconduct affecting the rehabilitation period.
Ordinanza — n. 41041/2023 — snpen
Italian Court dismisses appeal against therapeutic probation denial due to high social danger and lack of evidence.
Ordinanza — n. 23877/2026 — snpen
Italian court dismisses appeal on early release, ruling prior disciplinary sanctions prove lack of reintegration.
Ordinanza — n. 17331/2026 — snpen
Italian court dismisses appeal against early release denial due to post-period driving violations showing poor rehabilitation. The court ruled that such conduct reflects a formal adherence to treatment, negating prior good behavior. Consequently, the appeal was declared inadmissible, and the appellant was ordered to pay court costs and a fine. This decision reinforces the principle that violations indicating a refusal of reintegration can negatively impact earlier semesters in early release evaluations. The court emphasized that the Tribunal of Surveillance correctly applied the principle of fractional assessment of the condemned's behavior for the purpose of granting the benefit. The decision clarifies that a violation manifesting a lack of adherence to the reeducation work and an explicit refusal of reintegration of the detainee can have a negative reflection on the judgment regarding preceding or subsequent semesters. The court held that the appeal contradicts the reasoning of the Tribunal of Surveillance by proposing a different reading of the factual elements placed as the basis of the decision, thus soliciting an alternative evaluation not permitted in the realm of legality. The court declared the appeal inadmissible and condemned the appellant to pay the procedural expenses and the sum of three thousand euros in favor of the fine fund. The key legal issue concerns the application of the principle of fractional assessment of the condemned's behavior for the purpose of granting the benefit of early release. The court established that a violation manifesting a lack of adherence to the reeducation work and an explicit refusal of reintegration of the detainee can have a negative reflection on the judgment regarding preceding or subsequent semesters. The court held that the appeal contradicts the reasoning of the Tribunal of Surveillance by proposing a different reading of the factual elements placed as the basis of the decision, thus soliciting an alternative evaluation not permitted in the realm of legality. The court declared the appeal inadmissible and condemned the appellant to pay the procedural expenses and the sum of three thousand euros in favor of the fine fund. The key legal issue concerns the application of the principle of fractional assessment of the condemned's behavior for the purpose of granting the benefit of early release. The court established that a violation manifesting a lack of adherence to the reeducation work and an explicit refusal of reintegration of the detainee can have a negative reflection on the judgment regarding preceding or subsequent semesters. The court held that the appeal contradicts the reasoning of the Tribunal of Surveillance by proposing a different reading of the factual elements placed as the basis of the decision, thus soliciting an alternative evaluation not permitted in the realm of legality. The court declared the appeal inadmissible and condemned the appellant to pay the procedural expenses and the sum of three thousand euros in favor of the fine fund.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

a seguente ORDINANZA sul ricorso proposto da: BERISHA PATRIK nato il 02/04/1987 avverso l'ordinanza del 12/10/2023 del TRIB. SORVEGLIANZA di BOLOGNAdato avviso alle parti; udita la relazione svolta dal Consigliere MARCO MARIA MONACO; NN, Rilevato che, con il provvedimento impugnato, il Tribunale di Sorveglianza di Bologna, ha rigettato il reclamo proposto da Berisha Patrik avverso l'ordinanza con la quale il Magistrato di Sorveglianza ha respinto la domanda di liberazione anticipata in relazione ai periodi 2/12/2018- 1/6/2020, 22/10/2020-24/10/2020 e 15/4/2021-15/10/2022;

Rilevato che con il ricorso e con la memoria contenuta nella pec pervenuta il 2/2/24 si deduce la violazione di legge e il vizio di motivazione in relazione all'art. 54 ord. pen. poiché il Tribunale non avrebbe proceduto a una valutazione unitaria del periodo passato in comunità e si fonderebbe su episodi isolati; Rilevato che la doglianza è manifestamente infondata in quanto il giudice della sorveglianza, con l'analitico riferimento alle numerose violazioni che si sono succedute nel tempo ha fornito adeguata e coerente risposta alle medesime censure formulate nell'impugnazione (cfr. compiutamente pag. 2 del procedimento impugnato), ora reiterate;

Ritenuto pertanto che il ricorso è inammissibile in quanto le censure ora esposte dalla difesa sono tese a sollecitare una diversa e alternativa lettura degli elementi acquisiti che non è consentita in questa sede (cfr. Sez. 3, n. 17395 del 24/01/2023, Chen Wenjian, Rv. 284556 - 01; Sez. 6, n. 5465 del 04/11/2020, dep. 2021, F., Rv 280601; Sez. 2, n. 19411 del 12/03/2019, Furlan, Rv. 276062: Sez. 2, n. 7986 del 18/11/2016, dep. 2017, La Gumina, Rv 269217); Ritenuto inoltre di non dover provvedere quanto alla richiesta contenuta in calce alla pec di notifica del presente provvedimento in quanto tale adempimento non è previsto dal codice di rito;

Considerato che alla inammissibilità del ricorso segue la condanna dell2 ricorrente al pagamento delle spese processuali, nonché - valutato il contenuto del ricorso e in mancanza di elementi atti a escludere la colpa nella determinazione della causa di inammissibilità - al versamento della somma, ritenuta congrua, di euro tremila in favore della cassa delle ammende.

P.Q.M.

;€. Dichiara inammissibile il ricorso e condanna /1. ricorrente al pagamento delle spese processuali e della somma di euro tremila in favore della cassa delle ammende.