Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
IEHC 639 ECLI:IE:HC:2013:639 KI-generiert

High Court allows ex parte injunction to restrain asset dissipation pending English divorce proceedings under EU regulations.

Geschäftsnummer IEHC 639
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Irland (IE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The High Court granted an ex parte order restraining the respondent from dissipating or disposing of assets pending divorce proceedings in England. The applicant argued that the English High Court's freezing order required immediate protection in Ireland to prevent asset dissipation, while the respondent contended the matter should await the English judgment. The court decided to allow the injunction because EU regulations permit provisional measures in urgent cases even when another Member State has jurisdiction over the substance, and the inherent jurisdiction supported relief to preserve assets.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Article 20 of Council Regulation EC No 2201/2003; Article 31 of Council Regulation EC No 44/2001: Courts of a Member State may take provisional or protective measures in urgent cases regarding persons or assets in that State, even if another Member State has jurisdiction over the substance of the matter.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
ex parte injunction asset dissipation divorce proceedings EU Regulation 2201/2003 provisional measures jurisdiction recognition freezing order

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
Article 29.3 of the Constitution
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 29.3 OF THE CONSTITUTION AND IN THE MATTER OF THE JURISDICTION AND ENFORCEMENTS OF
Jurisdiction and Enforcement of Judgments Act 1998
Article 20 of Council Regulation EC No 2201/2003
JUDGMENTS ACT 1998 AND IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 20 OF COUNCIL REGULATION EC NUMBER 2201/2003 AND OR IN THE
Article 31 of Council Regulation EC No 44/2001
MATTER OF ARTICLE 31 OF COUNCIL REGULATION EC NUMBER 44/2001
Order 42A of the Rules of the Superior Courts (Jurisdiction, Recognition Enforcement and Service of Proceedings) 2005
Order 42A of the Rules of the Superior Courts (Jurisdiction, Recognition Enforcement and Service of Proceedings) 2005 at rule 1
section 35 of the Family Law Act 1995
section 35 of the Family Law Act 1995 and section 37 of the Family Law (Divorce) Act 1996 but does not preclude the applicant from

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

Neutral Citation: [2013] IEHC 639

THE HIGH COURT

[2012 No.53 F.J.]

IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 29.3 OF THE CONSTITUTION AND IN THE MATTER OF THE JURISDICTION AND ENFORCEMENTS OF

JUDGMENTS ACT 1998 AND IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 20 OF COUNCIL REGULATION EC NUMBER 2201/2003 AND OR IN THE

MATTER OF ARTICLE 31 OF COUNCIL REGULATION EC NUMBER 44/2001

BETWEEN

M.M.

APPLICANT

AND

J.D.

RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT of White Michael J delivered this 26th day of July, 2013

1. The proceedings before this court are an originating notice of motion seeking orders restraining the respondent from dissipating,

disposing or removing from this jurisdiction, charging or otherwise dealing with his assets pending the determination of divorce

proceedings in England.

2. The applicant married the respondent in Northern Ireland in 2005.

3. The applicant avers that she met the respondent in Dublin when on holiday in 1997 and commenced a relationship with him. She

began to reside in a property in Dublin with the respondent from October 1998. The parties separated at the end of September 2011.

The applicant moved to England to reside and commenced divorce proceedings in that jurisdiction based on her habitual residence in

England and Wales for a period of one year prior to the petition dated the 1st of October, 2012.

4. The High Court of Justice Family Division in England on 12th of October, 2012 granted an order forbidding the respondent from

disposing or transferring out of the jurisdiction, charging or otherwise dealing in any way with the property or in the event of a sale or

otherwise disposal, not to dispose of the nett proceeds of sale of the said property or any part thereof.

5. Subsequent to the order of the English High Court an application was made to this Court ex parte. By order of this Court of 15th of

October, 2012 the respondent was restrained until after the 19th of October, 2012 from dissipating, disposing of or removing from the

jurisdiction, charging or otherwise dealing with his assets pending the determination of the proceedings referred to in the title hereof.

6. There was also a specific order restraining the respondent from dissipating, disposing of, or charging or otherwise dealing with his

interest in the property or in the event that the said property has been sold or otherwise disposed of, the proceeds of sale therefrom

or any other property interest pending the determination of the proceedings referred to in the title hereof.

7. By further order of the 19th of October, 2012 this Court accepted an undertaking from the respondent in the terms of the order of

the 15th October.

8. The applicant gave an undertaking as to damages.

9. By further order of this court of the 7th of December, 2012 the orders were continued but without prejudice to the respondent's

challenge to the jurisdiction of the court to grant such orders.

10. It is common case between the parties that the respondent was married before to F.C. and a divorce was granted to him on the

5th of May, 1994 in England. That divorce is not entitled to recognition in the Republic of Ireland because of the respondent's

domicile.

11. It falls to this Court to decide the jurisdiction to grant the order sought and to interpret article 20 of Council Regulation

E.C./2201/2003 of 27 November, 2003 concerning jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in matrimonial

matters and the matters of parental responsibility, O.J. L 338/1 23.12.2003.

12. Article 20 states:-

"Provisional, including protective, measures.

1. In urgent cases the provisions of this Regulation shall not prevent the courts of a Member State from taking such

provisional, including protective, measures in respect of persons or assets in that State as may be available under the law

of that Member State, even if, under this Regulation, the court of another Member State has jurisdiction as to the

substance of the matter.

2. The measures referred to in paragraph 1 shall cease to apply when the court of the Member State having jurisdiction

under this regulation as to the substance of the matter has taken the measures it considers appropriate."

13. Paragraph 16 of the preamble to the regulation states:-

"This Regulation should not prevent the courts of a Member State from taking provisional, including protective, measures

in urgent cases with regard to persons or property situated in that State."

14. Article 1 of the regulation states:-

"This Regulation shall apply whatever the nature of the court or tribunal, in civil matters relating to a divorce, legal

separation or marriage annulment".

15. Order 42A of the Rules of the Superior Courts (Jurisdiction, Recognition Enforcement and Service of Proceedings) 2005 at rule 1

states:-

"An application for provisional, including protective, measures under Article 31 of Regulation No. 44/2001 or Section 13 of

the 1998 Act (including an Application for provisional (including protective) measures under the Lugano Convention by

virtue of sections 13 and 20 of the 1998 Act) or of a kind referred to in Article 20 of Regulation No. 2201/2003 shall be

made ex parte to the High Court."

16. The standard rules of statutory interpretation apply.

17. The words "as may be available under the law of that member state" do not refer to ancillary relief subsequent to divorce or

judicial separation but refer to the law on ''taking such provisional, including protective, measures in respect of assets in that state."

18. The fact that the original divorce is not recognised in the State would preclude the applicant from relying on the provisions of

section 35 of the Family Law Act 1995 and section 37 of the Family Law (Divorce) Act 1996 but does not preclude the applicant from

relying on the inherent jurisdiction of the Court to grant injunctive relief preventing disposal of assets in the State pending the

resolution of the substantive proceedings in England.

19. The regulations and the English High Court order provide sufficient comity to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court.

20. This court notes that the respondent may in fact have already disposed of his interest in the property and any proceeds of the

disposal.

21. The English High Court order confined itself to that asset and made no order preventing the dissipation of any other assets.

22. Before proceeding to make any orders it is appropriate for this Court to hear submissions on the principles governing injunctive

relief, and the nature of the relief sought.