Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
IEHC 246 ECLI:IE:HC:2006:246 KI-generiert

High Court dismisses judicial review application against Refugee Appeals Tribunal decision rejecting asylum claim.

Geschäftsnummer IEHC 246
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Irland (IE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The applicant sought judicial review to overturn the Refugee Appeals Tribunal's refusal of his asylum claim. He argued the Tribunal erred in law and fact by disregarding his subjective fears and treating his failure to seek asylum in India as irrelevant. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was reasonable based on the evidence and did not require interference.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Refugee Act 1996; Illegal Immigrants (Trafficking) Act 2000: The High Court will not interfere with a decision of the Refugee Appeals Tribunal if it is reasonably arrived at on the material before it, even if the court might have reached a different conclusion.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Refugee Appeals Tribunal Judicial Review Well-founded Fear State Protection Reasonable Decision Asylum Claim High Court

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
Illegal Immigrants (Trafficking) Act 2000 Section 5
IN THE MATTER OF THE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS (TRAFFICKING) ACT 2000 SECTION 5 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE REFUGEE ACT
Refugee Act 1996
REFUGEE ACT, 1996
s. 2 of the Refugee Act, 1996
relation to s. 2 of the Refugee Act, 1996 (“The Convention Reason”).

Zitierte Rechtsprechung

KI-generiert
Rasheed Ali v. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform and the Refugee Appeals Tribunal

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

Neutral Citation Number [2006] IEHC 246

THE HIGH COURT

JUDICIAL REVIEW

[2004 No. 739 J.R.]

IN THE MATTER OF THE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS (TRAFFICKING) ACT 2000 SECTION 5 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE REFUGEE ACT

1996 (AS AMENDED)

BETWEEN

MIKE ERO

APPLICANT

AND

THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE, EQUALITY AND LAW REFORM AND THE REFUGEE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

RESPONDENTS

Judgment of Mr. Justice de Valera delivered the 4th day of July 2006.

1. By a decision dated the 15th July, 2004, Elizabeth O’Brien BL a member of the Refugee Appeals Tribunal affirmed the decision of the

Refugee Appeals Commissioner dated the 18th May, 2004, recommending that the applicant should not be declared a refugee.

2. On the 17th August, 2004, the applicant sought leave to apply for judicial relief on a number of grounds fully set out in the notice

of motion.

3. On the 12th April, 2005, the applicant was granted leave by the High Court on the grounds set forth in that order.

4. This matter came before me on the 13th December, 2005 and, in addition to the oral hearing written submissions have been

submitted by both the respondents and the applicant – in the latter case a second set of written submissions declared to be in

relation to s. 2 of the Refugee Act, 1996 (“The Convention Reason”).

5. The applicant submits that he is entitled to the relief he seeks under four headings as follows:

1. That the second respondent refused the applicant as a refugee due to his failure to seek State protection and so erred

in law.

2. The second named respondent has erred in fact and has taken into account an irrelevant and immaterial consideration

namely that the applicant did not provide any evidence of a failure of State protection. The second named respondent

has further acted contrary to the principles of natural and constitutional justice and fair procedures in failing to consider

the evidence proffered by the applicant in his interview and in his form to notice of appeal. The aforesaid constitutes a

failure to examine the subjective fears of the applicant in relation to his belief that State protection might not reasonably

have been forthcoming.

3. The second named respondent has erred in law and acted contrary to fair procedures and natural and constitutional

justice in failing to examine the applicant’s subjective fears and reasons for not seeking State protection with particular

reference to the situation on the ground in his country of origin, as evidenced by objective country of origin information.

4. The second named respondent has erred in law in using the adequacy or otherwise of the applicant’s explanation for

not seeking asylum in India or the fact that he did not claim asylum in India as a reason to reject or “bar” the applicant’s

legitimate claim to asylum in the manner in which she did.

6. The member of the Refugee Appeals Tribunal who heard and decided on the appeal on the 15th July, 2004, clearly and

demonstrably gave the most serious consideration to the applicant’s case. Her decision extends to 13 pages and contains a

comprehensive overview of all relevant matters under the headings:

Introduction

Grounds of Appeal

The Appellant’s Evidence

Well-founded Fear of Prosecution

Burden and Standard of Proof

Assessment of the Applicant’s Evidence

Decision

7. And under each of these headings discusses in a detailed and careful manner, and at considerable length, the applicant’s situation.

8. The applicant’s case centres in essence on two issues, these are:

(a) The alleged inability of the local Nigerian police to protect the applicant and,

(b) The Tribunal’s finding that the applicant’s failure to seek asylum in India (where he lived for nine months) indicated

that he did not suffer a genuine and well founded fear of prosecution.

9. I have been directed by the respondent to the decision of Peart J. in Rasheed Ali v. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law

Reform and the Refugee Appeals Tribunal (Unreported, High Court, 26th May, 2004) where the learned judge held, inter alia, that

where the Tribunal reached a decision reasonably on facts before it then the (High) Court could not reasonably overturn it even when

the Court might not have reached the same conclusion on the same facts. Peart J. said:

“I do not have to agree with the decision arrived at by the Tribunal, or decide that I might have arrived at a different

conclusion. If there is material or information available to the Tribunal on which it could base its decision… then the

decision is a valid one on that ground.”

10. The learned judge also stated, and this is of particular relevance in the applicant’s case:

“… on the material before the Tribunal it could conclude that the applicant had not demonstrated that the protection of

the State was not, or would not have been available to him… there was no evidence that he had been refused help.”

11. I am satisfied that the applicant’s rather vague and unsatisfactory contention that he would not have the appropriate protection

from the police was a matter that the Tribunal member could reasonably take into account and decide upon in the manner in which

she did. There is no failure or departure from principle or want of fair procedure and she was entitled to reach the decision as

recorded on the 15th July, 2004.

12. I am also satisfied that the reasoning disclosed by the Tribunal member in relation to the applicant’s stay in India before coming to

Ireland is justified both on the facts and on the applicable law (as stated in her decision) and the conclusion thus reached is not one

with which I should interfere.

13. I therefore refuse this application.