Court awards state costs for retrial appeal where appellant's defense did not contribute to necessity.
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe Court of Criminal Appeal awarded state costs for the appeal and subsequent retrial for both appellants. While Dermot Laide qualified for legal aid but lacked a certificate, the court found the defense did not contribute to the necessity of the proceedings. Consequently, justice required the State to bear the full financial burden of the appeal and retrial.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generierts.4 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993; The Court of Criminal Appeal may order state payment of appeal and retrial costs where the necessity was not contributed to by the defence, even if the appellant qualified for legal aid but lacked a certificate.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVolltext
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL
59/04 & 65/04
McCracken J
Murphy J
Peart J
Between:
The People at the suit of the Director of Public Prosecutions
Respondent
AND
Dermot Laide and Desmond Ryan
Appellants
Judgment of the Court delivered on the 7th day of July 2005 by McCracken J. (Costs)
_______________________________________________________
The Court has already announced its decision to award the costs of the appeal to the Appellant Desmond Ryan.
In relation to the Appellant Dermot Laide, s.4 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993 provides that where a person is ordered
to be retried for an offence and a legal aid certificate does not apply, the Court of Criminal Appeal may order that the costs
of the appeal and of the new trial, in whole or in part, be paid by the State, unless the Court is of opinion that the necessity
for the appeal and the new trial has been contributed to by the defence. The Court is satisfied in the present case that the
necessity for the appeal and new trial had not been contributed to by the defence.
The Court recognises the complexities of this case, and in particular of the appeal, and, notwithstanding that the Appellant
Dermot Laide qualified for legal aid, but did not at the time of the appeal hold a certificate to that effect, and
notwithstanding that his conviction on the charge of violent disorder was upheld, in its discretion feels that justice requires
that the costs of the appeal and of the retrial should be paid in whole by the State.