Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
Orhan Mehmet Emin v. Argyris Charalambous Komodromos and another (1970) JSC 1234 KI-generiert

Supreme Court allows appeal and orders retrial when trial judge fails to find facts on oral contract credibility.

Geschäftsnummer Orhan Mehmet Emin v. Argyris Charalambous Komodromos and another (1970) JSC 1234
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Zypern (CY)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Teilweise gutgeheissen (Partially Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal because the trial judge failed to make a finding on the essential issue of the oral contract's terms. The appellant argued the judge should have determined the contract from the evidence, while the respondents contended the judge's omission was a procedural error. The court held that determining an oral contract relies on witness credibility, a function reserved for the trial judge, necessitating a retrial before a different judge.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Civil Code; Contract Law: Where the trial court fails to make findings on the terms of an oral contract dependent on witness credibility, the appellate court will not substitute its own view and will order a retrial before a different judge.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
oral contract formation witness credibility assessment trial court findings appellate jurisdiction limits retrial procedure Mangelnde Umsetzung der wettbewerbswidrigen Vereinbarungen Anspruch auf einen Entscheid fehlende Unterschrift
KI-generiert

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

[*1234] 1970 October 30

(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHTDES, JJ.)

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Orhan Mehmet Emin,

Appellant-Defendant,

v.

Argyris Charalambous Komodromos and another,

Respondent s-Plaintiffs,

(Civil Appeal No. 24.872).

Contract - Oral contract - No finding by trial Court as to what was the contract - Court of Appeal will not make a finding on this issue especially when it depends on the credibility of witnesses - Retrial ordered.

Practice - Retrial - When ordered.

Retrial - See under "Practice".

C. Myrianthis, for the Appellant.

N. Mavronicolas, for the Respondents.

JUDGMENT

The judgment of the Court was delivered by:

VASSILIADES, P.: Counsel for the appellant opened his case before us this morning with the complaint that the trial Judge failed to make a finding on the main issue in this action, namely what was the contract between the parties. The pleadings show clearly that the plaintiff (respondent in the appeal) alleged one contract and the defendant (appellant) in his pleading alleged a different contract. The result of the action must, obviously, depend on the contract between the parties. On this fundamental issue, [*1235] the trial Judge made no finding; and yet the determination of an action depends on the findings of the trial Court on the issues arising from the pleadings,

Counsel for the appellant asked us to proceed with the hearing of the appeal and make a finding on this issue from the evidence on the record. He suggested that we can take the evidence as it stands; and, if necessary, draw also inferences from the established facts, as they have been found by the trial Judge,

We take the view that this is not the proper course to follow in the matter before us. It is for the trial Court to find the contract between the parties; especially when that issue appears to depend on the credibility of witnesses, this being a verbal contract.

We must allow this appeal and order a new trial before a different Judge (in view of the fact that matters of credibility have been considered in the abortive trial).

As regards costs, we think that the costs in the District Court should be costs in cause. The costs in the appeal to be also costs in cause, but in no case against the appellant.

Appeal allowed;

retrial ordered;

order for costs as above.